So yummy, we order all the time! Their pizzas aren't too thin or thick and the wings are to die for! Everyone is always nice when we come to pick up. You can tell it's family owned! You can dine in, but most people do take out. Try it! read more

Always consistently good, best wings, very good lasagna (I usually don't like ricotta cheese), very good thin crust pizza, I like the Italian sausage sandwich, service is good and dining in is good as well, usually get takeout every other week. read more

We love to support local joints. We love pizza in our family, this place wasn't for us. We did take out and prob won't be getting it again. The crust wasn't crisp, the sauce and cheese were over loaded. My kids enjoyed picking the pepperoni off so that was nice. read more

I love trying out pizza places sandwich's because I like a nice cheesey messy meatball sandwich and their Facebook page shows them making the meatballs in house so I had to try the meatball sandwich. As I drove over I realized that I have been to a pizza place in this spot before and they had a good thin crust pizza but why was my review not listed, aah it must be a new pizza place in this location and it was because it looked completely different on the inside, no more dining room and set up for takeout with a couple hi tables in front of the kitchen. The meatball sandwich was a little heftier than I expected and a decent size for $7.95, you can get a combo for $9.95 that comes with frys and slaw but I didn't get the combo. The meatball sandwich looked pretty good with mozzarella cheese oozing out of it and it came with a pickle spear. The meatball sandwich was tasty with tender meatballs in a red sauce that was not very sweet or runny on a very fresh/soft roll, I forgot to ask for my favorite which is put it on garlic bread. Overall was it the best meatball sandwich that I have have, na but it was not bad and it completely satisfied my craving for something in red sauce smothered in mozzarella cheese and I would probably stop back for the chicken Parmesan sandwich. read more

See all

Me and the bf had some errands to do this past Friday and I told him while we're out I will call and place an order for 2 chicken dinners. I heard word of mouth and also some reviews about the chicken here. I like they have a choice of French fries or mashed potatoes to go with your dinner. I went with the fries and my bf with mashed potatoes and gravy. We timed it just right when we picked up our food because they were just bagging it up. I have to say we were quite pleased with dinners. I'm a classic crinkle cut fry type of gal but it was nice to see a regular cut fries that were cooked perfectly. Crispy on the outside and soft potato inside. The chicken was pretty tasty as well. Chicken was crispy and juicy and the price was decent as well. We will definitely have it again and maybe next time order a pizza. read more

Nini's Pizzeria - A foam tray contains fried chicken pieces, French fries, a biscuit, and a chicken drumstick, typical of American fast food. - Pizza Near Me - Greenfield, Wisconsin

We ordered a pizza today. Cheese, sausage, mushroom and onion. It came on time. The cheese was almost non-existent. The onions and mushrooms were overpowering, and the crust was soggy. We also ordered Garlic bread which also had almost no taste and was kind of stale. We do enjoy the fried chicken but will pass on the pizza from now on. read more

We ordered the Nini's Special pizza, meat lasagna and chicken wings (hot) for delivery from their online site. The short review is these items were all just "OK" to us. I get the feeling that they are trying to do too much (larger menu) and should focus on fewer items and being better at those. Pizza was OK; not a ton of a flavor. Crust was on the thin side with just the slightest crisp in spots. This would be a solid pizza for the children - not someone who wants to be wow'd or craving a really good pizza. There are some frozen pizzas that I'd take over this. The meat lasagna was very cheesy. On the bland side. The website asked for a dressing selection, which made me think it came with a salad. But the dressing nor salad were delivered. Not sure if this was missed or a website mistake. Chicken wings (hot) were pretty decent. I liked these the most and thought it was good value. Would consider ordering these again. Everything came on time and hot. Will I be back? Probably not. read more

Solid pizza. The garlic dough balls are amazing. I haven't checked out much else, but the pizza is definitely worth a go. Also, the staff has always been super amazing to me. read more

At least twice a month we order there chicken, the past 2months something has been "off". It has been over cooked and now the last time it has no flavor and tasted of oil. Not sure what is going on, but it will be a while before we order again. Very disappointing read more

Our first clue to Nini's should have been when we called and asked them what their speciality is, and their response was fried meat. Apparently, their fried chicken was great?! Frankly, their fried chicken is not their claim to fame, in reality, the chicken was a claim to shame. The cheese curds were good. There was a reason they weren't proud of their pizza, as it was shameful itself. There was also a mixup with the delivery driver demanding I pay with cash, when we had already paid with a CC over the phone. Overall, Nini's was a disappointment. read more

Great pie and some of the best wings I've had...ever! Had a mushroom, black olive and pepperoni pizza that was made to perfection. Great dough, excellent marinara and topping distribution. Not too saucy and a good size. Wings were some of the biggest I've had. Not too dry and not too juicy. Absolutely delicious! Worth every cent. I'll never go to another pizza joint when I'm in Milwaukee. No need, this IS the spot. read more

I drive by this place all the time but just recently discovered it based on a recommendation from a friend. We ordered pizza, garlic bread and the garlic butter dough buddies - I know, carb overload! The pizza was excellent! Thin crust with lots of toppings and very cheesy. The garlic bread was just meh. The star though was those garlic butter dough buddies. Soft, buttery, garlicky and so good! We will be back soon to start working our way through their large menu! Be sure to check out the Combo section on their website for some deals. read more

Pizza is OK. Good for kids and parties. If you are a pizza connoisseur. This isn't for you. It's a 62.

Very good pizza! You can tell it's hand made. Third time ordering from here, came across this place while search for some in the area, would recommend! read more

The pizza was perfection and loved the atmosphere for our family with small kids. The staff was so friendly and kind to our family. We are from Chicago but always make sure we stop by for pizza when we are in town. The garlic dough balls are AMAZING!! read more

The chicken was pretty good which is ONLY reason for any stars. The pizza has horrible crust that taste as if it has freezer burn. Weirdly chewy. Eggplant was oddly wet and the batter taste like nothing. Soggy and bland. 10/10 don't recommend to anybody. Don't trust the other reviews idk what they ate but it can't be the same thing. read more

Was that Pizza or a Cardboard Cutout? It looked like cheese sprayed on cardboard. It was flat out yellow. No stringy white cheese here, and no sauce. It was suppose to be a Meat Lovers of sausage, pepperoni, bacon, ground beef. There was a little something that looked like sausage. The other few chunks could have been bacon. There were red spots that must have been pepperoni. As far as the ground beef, "where is the beef." Did not make any difference though as there was no flavor. I threw it out! The Garlic Butter Dough Buddies were just as horrible. Sounded so good, but where was the butter. After one of those, I threw them out. The cannoli was no good either. It is a wonder they are in business. But a lot of people will eat anything, thinking it is food. For me, I threw away $35. read more

This place is amazing! The guy suggested the Deluxe 14" and this pizza is the real deal!

Ordered a pizza and cheese bread!! Both were excellent, highly recommend this hidden gem. Best pizza in greenfield!

First time trying Nini's tonight after seeing them on DoorDash, I ordered outside the DoorDash app from previous bad experiences. I'm not a huge fan a pizza so it takes a lot to impress me. The pizza was delicious & I'd definitely order from again. The garlic bread, although didn't lack on flavor it wasn't the best I've had, it was on the dry side. I'm interested in there pastas and chicken, so that'll be next. FYI run from being apart of DoorDash before your ratings are ruined! read more

Solid Meh. Ordered a combo with a sixteen inch pizza, 12 wingsx garlic bread and a two liter of soda for $28. Solid value. The garlic bread was almost burnt. The best thing I can say about the pizza is that is was, in fact, pizza. But nothing to right home about and the crust seemed premade. The wings were the best part of the meal, but I asked for garlic wings and got plain. read more

I have ordered pizza 2 times from NiNi's Sausage pepperoni onions and mushrooms The first time I observed very little sausage in my opinion however the pizza was very tasty and cooked perfectly, The second time I ordered the same with double sausage, I don't believe the sausage was doubled however there was more. Also tasty and cooked perfectly. Not sure there will be a 3 rd time read more

I'd rather eat frozen pizza. The crust is just a vessel for the flavorless toppings. Cheese lovers only distinct cheese was the feta because you could see it. The meat lovers was similar, you see it and the flavor is in the meat but nothing else. read more

10/10! Great overall experience! Awesome customer service, fast food prep and a delicious culinary experience! I will be visiting again!

The pizza is good, the garlic bread bites are good and the cannolis are the best. Very flavorful and filling. This is my new favorite pizza place to order from. read more

Pizza and chicken were good eats, But Watch out for the extra's you don't ask for on takeout orders. They over change us almost $5 on our order until we question why the bill was so much. They added extras which we did not order. The owner seemed not to care about over charge. Will Not Return !!!! read more

First time trying it, we got a 14 inch pizza. It was tasty!! The only reason we don't give it 5 stars is because the location is a little weird. Not a huge deal since we just picked it up. read more