Peppers Grill at Utica Square is a standout. The food is what really sets this place apart. Everything came out fresh, well-prepared, and full of flavor. It's clear they put real care into the menu rather than just going through the motions. Great spot in a great location, and I'll definitely be back. read more

We come here a lot, and it is always great! The food is awesome. We got queso and it was amazing. I ordered a burger, and the food was quick to come out and it was good. Our server was super nice. The place has a great atmosphere, and never disappoints. I definitely recommend it! read more

Pepper's Grill - Burger and fries - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

We completely found this place by accident when we were in the Tulsa area looking for someplace to have lunch, but let me tell you I am glad we found it! It is not the fanciest place you will go to nor is it the most upscale what it is, is really good people serving really good food! There were four of us in our party, and we all got something different. I got fajitas another person got a chicken salad sandwich, and another person got a Chile Relleno. It was one of those situations where, as each of us took our first bite of our food. We looked at everyone else, and kind of smiled and nodded our heads approvingly. The service was really good too. Our server could not have been more friendly and more accommodating for us. Well, this place was not on our agenda this trip. I can assure you that on future visit for any of the four of us it will be a place we will definitely come too. read more

See all

Food was Bland. Came out hot, but without much flavor. I would not recommend. Service was great and atmosphere was great. My son was sick and the waiters were very kind to him. read more

See all

Staff has an attitude problem! There was an issue with our check, when we questioned it, the short haired woman wearing a plaid shirt got an attitude with us. When I talked to her in the same tone, she got angry, stomped around, raised her voice, made a scene in the restaurant, and got the manager. I have been going to this restaurant for over 30 years, and I will never return for the way I was treated! read more

Grubby was my first impression. Doors, chairs, walls, vinegar & oil cruets. Appears nothing has been really cleaned or refreshed for Years! Sticky table. I had the lunch chicken salad and was quite surprised. The grilled chicken was cut So Small that it was hard to get on the fork. White lettuce, no egg. Another person at the table had french fries and shared. They were Very good. Waitress was very nice and attentive. I will not go again. read more

An amazing Tulsa standby with excellent food excellent service and excellent ambience. The chicken fajitas are to die for.

Blandest food ever. The salsa is just tomato water. The burgers had zero seasoning. The chili and mac & cheese are gross. Service was good. Location alone cannot carry a restaurant. read more

Two out of five stars reason why they change the menu they condensed it from being a giant menu to a smaller menu. They got rid of their famous chicken fried steak, which was the heart and soul. So I had to go ahead and order fajitas and which also the server then messed up my order they don't carry Pepsi products anymore. It's nothing but Coca-Cola products not a big fan of Coke. No pun intended second of all the waiter server. Whatever you wanna call them did not listen to instructions. I asked for like I mentioned up top the fajitas for one which was supposed to be included with steak and chicken, but I've mentioned I want shrimp with it. He just gives me nothing but a tray of shrimp peppers, and onions and ice Just it's not rocket science to follow instructions. read more

Tosha, Chris and the whole staff is so amazing. They have the best fries in town and always make me feel like family when I come to visit.

I cannot remember the last time I was at Pepper Grill, but I was really impressed with the fish tacos and the fajitas that my boyfriend got. My group came in with about 20 people and our waitress was fantastic and taking care of us. She made sure we all had plenty of water chips and all of our meals came out at the same time. If you're in Utica Square, I need a quickie meal ranging from burgers to tacos. This is your place. read more

My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed our visit. The salsa is very tasty without being spicy. We loved the many options and were very satisfied with what we ordered. The ambiance was nice; dark and cozy. Our server was prompt and friendly. We'll definitely be back to try something different. read more

Pepper's Grill - Nov 2023 - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Finally, tried peppers after talking about going forever!! My husband and I ate outside this evening because it was soo nice out! The music and environment was chill and our waitress was very attentive. They have a huge variety of food from pasta, burgers, and Mexican to spuds and steaks! My husband enjoyed their burrito and loved the beans! I only had a bowl of potato soup but it was very delicious! The chips and salsa was average salsa, of course. read more

Pepper's Grill - Pork Adovada Burrito - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Well I didn't think it would be so soon after my last not so great visit from just a couple weeks ago, but I did come to Peppers again for another shot at having an experience like what I remember this place was like years ago. I added another star from my last review, mainly because of the service (especially compared to last time!!). For one, we were actually welcomed into the restaurant and weren't rushed to order literally on the spot. Plus, we found out that the winter hours they told us about last time were only for weekdays (and we went on a Sunday, so there was no reason for what happened last time in the first place...). Second, the server we had was sweet. Our chip bowl was filled quickly and so were our drinks. The food itself was not quite what I was hoping it would be, especially since (as I think I mentioned in my last review) I used to have pretty good experiences here. The chips were stale tasting and the salsa was more liquidy than I like, and didn't have a ton of flavor. However, I eventually asked if they had spicier salsa (something I do often) and they brought it to me quickly. It still didn't have TONS of flavor but it was better. I'd even go so far as to say I liked their spicier salsa better than some of the spicier salsas at other places! At some places where I've done this the spicier salsa just tastes more bitter. This was still the case here, but it was done better, maybe because the flavor was mild anyway. I ordered the Fajita burrito, and there are a few different choices you make with it. I went with chicken, white queso (instead of yellow), and refried beans (as opposed to fiesta beans). The queso on top was fine but I probably would have been just as fine without it, and wouldn't necessarily be tempted to order it on its own, like as an appetizer. Not bad (like it didn't ruin the dish by any means), just not anything exceptionally good. Something else I feel like I need to mention is that the onions inside the burrito were EXTREMELY sweet, which made them have an overall odd flavor for some reason. I had to try to pick them all out (and I'm not a picky eater). The rest of the burrito was pretty good though, other than that. I'm not saying I would never go back to Peppers but I do think I'll need to give it a decent amount of time before I return. It just seems like it's not what it used to be... I don't know if they got new owners/ management or something within the last handful of years, but I do hope they improve again and get back to where they were!!! read more

See all

This place is about 1/2 Tex-Mexican and about 1/2 everything else, including steak and seafood, salads, and pasta. Good for any occasion, any party. Our family stopped by on a Thursday evening and had quick and exceptional service by Jose. An amicable, comfortable restaurant on the edge of Utica Square across from St John's Medical Center, Pepper's provided generous portions at reasonable prices. read more

Pepper's Grill - Terrific salsa with the pre-meal chips. Just give me a straw! - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

me and my family sat for a while waiting for our server. we had 3 different people come back and forth. the dude who took our drink orders didn't I.D. the girl who took our food order had an attitude when we asked how long until we got our food. We decided that we were done and wanted to leave and we asked for our tickets and she didn't take the food off of our tickets. we told her we were only paying for what we ate and drank and she had an attitude. It was ridiculous. We will never go back there. We also waited for over an hour. read more

Always good. Best chili relleno I've found anywhere. Long drive for me but I'll go back when I can.

So, once again I revisited a place that I have not been in years (years, I tell you). It was my best friend's birthday and she wanted to meet here. It is ironic that this is a place we used to haunt quite frequently some years ago (and the one in south Tulsa). The thin chips and the salsa were as good as I remembered. I have to say, however, that Pepper's is looking a little worse for wear on the inside. Update much? We both got lunch salads and were warned they were small. Indeed they were. Don't get me wrong, they were the perfect size for lunch (especially after all the chips) BUT I'm not sure they measured up to the price paid. I will say that the jerked chicken salad came with roasted vegetables which was a bit odd but worked quite well (especially with a bit of ranch dressing). It wasn't a bad experience, just not as good as I remembered back in the day. I kind of wonder how they keep that expensive real estate at Utica Square. read more

Pepper's Grill - New American Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Catering from Pepper's was awesome! Tasha and the staff are very accommodating, always provide timely service and have terrific food! Over the past four years, our organization has catered multiple meals and has never been disappointed! read more

If I could give this place 100 stars I would! We brought close to 100 high school wrestlers, coaches and chaperones for a tournament and Pepper's catered lunches and dinners for the entire week! They were on time and even set up our dinners in the evenings! Foood was fresh and filling! Their catered taco bar was a HUGE hit with the kids! The cheesecake chimis are to die for! We had a few kiddos with allergies and they were happy to accommodate! We will be using them any time we wrestle in Tulsa! Pepper's for the win! read more

These guys are nice enough and the decor is okay. Restrooms are tiny, but clean. Wish the bar area had short tables, I like it better to the right than to the left, the seats in the booths are too soft. The chips and salsa are not great, but okay. I got ground beef enchiladas and they were good. I just can't forget that this used to be Swensen's Ice Cream, back in the good old days. read more

I honestly don't remember what food we ordered so it must have been uneventful. BUT, the Long Island Iced Tea was on point and that is super hard to find. Will go back for drinks for sure. read more

Went as part of a group of 30 for lunch. Servers were polite and efficient. Ordered the Chicken and Spinach Florentine Quesadilla which came with rice, beans, guacamole and sour cream. The quesadilla was the most disgusting item I have ever been served in a restaurant. Whatever the seasoning was on the chicken it was intolerable with the spinach. I ate the R&B and called it a day. Wow! Someone in management needs a thorough review of their menu. read more

We had a group of 100 wrestlers and these guys did an amazing job!!! Price was right, food was delicious, and service was above and beyond. Definitely recommend! read more

My mom and I went to lunch at Pepper's yesterday, and I just wanted to complement Joel the bartender. He went out of his way when I tripped on some uneven surface outside and sprained my ankle. He and one of the other managers raced outside to help me, and they didn't have to bc it wasn't even part of Pepper's property. It was so kind of them to help me out and I will never forget it. Aside from that, Pepper's is one of my favorite restaurants and the food is always delicious. Thanks Joel and other awesome manager! read more

I love this place for chips drinks and tacos. Great prices and Keyara is the best bartender because she takes care of her peoples. I will be back! read more

Favorite in Utica Square ! Our go to place . Margaritas are top shelf . Always super service , Thanks for being there !!

We have passed this place many times and have heard good things, so we decided to check it out. First and foremost, service was great. But our first impression was scary. The front door was filthy dirty from years of use. However, our hostess was prompt and friendly. The menu's were sticky from not being wiped clean. Our server was awesome, Kind, friendly and helpful. We ordered our drinks, water. One of our plastic cups had a deformed rim from being over heated. We chose the soup and half sandwich. The food was well prepared and plated. The food gets 5 stars, very good. The overall cleanliness gets a zero. Floors, walls cabinets, light switches and bathrooms were disgusting. You can write your name in the dust on the lamps over your booth . My thoughts of what the food prep areas must look like causes me to not return. What's amazing is this place serves an upscale clientele and nobody seems to care or notice the filthy surroundings of this place. I would highly suggest they hire a cleaning service to do the job the management obviously can not do! So disappointing. read more

My family and i have been coming here for years! Decent Tex mex and have a great selection of American food for a wonderful price. Conveniently located within Utica square - my go to is the chicken salad sandwich not too full of mayo and their wheat berry bread is wonderful and you can even get it toasted. Got the grilled chicken sandwich last time the chicken was fresh and tender only needed more honey mustard. My dad always gets the double bacon cheeseburger it's huge comes with a side and around 10 bucks. Their salads are big and flavorful also. I never seem to get Mexican food here which is odd my next and suggestion and by far favorite item there is their chocolate shakes hand spun like the old fashioned fountains and they come with the extra tin even. Beats braums by far in my opinion. Also every day of the week they offer wonderful specials that makes it even more affordable and on cinco de mayo they always offer cheap dollar margaritas. Check out their happy hour if you dig their drinks! read more

Came here for the first time and loved it!! We enjoyed our day and sat outside in the beautiful sunshine. The raspberry margaritas were outstanding and our server Samantha (Sam I Am) was the best ever! We told Sam we're only coming on the days she's working....no joke. We ordered salads to go yet devoured chips guacamole and salsa!! I'll definitely take pictures next time because we'll be coming back very soon! read more

In from out of town- nice location, comfy interior , super friendly waitress. Violated my own premise never to order fajitas outside of Texas - was a bit underwhelmed with those, but colleagues I was with enjoyed the burger and something else so definitely give this place a try-- but come to Texas for your Tex Mex.:) read more

Due to Covid, my husband & I hadn't eaten out in restaurants for 2 years, we sometimes did drive-thru or carry-out. This week we decided to venture out to eat in a restaurant, we chose Pepper's Grill at Utica Square. The food was good like it always was, it was nice to enjoy a good meal in a restaurant. read more

Very good even with a large group. Food was good and the service was efficient, accurate, and friendly.

Pepper's is pretty good! There are two locations that I'm aware of - this is the one in midtown by St. John in Utica Square. They serve Tex-Mex and American fare. I typically split a Mexican plate with my wife like enchiladas. We have to go easy on the chips and salsa because both are really good. This location is kind of an odd shape - we often sit in the bar seats by the windows. It's great people watching but an awkward place to sit. (Also, it's by the windows so wear a jacket if it's cold out!) The very last time I went I had a salad. It was OK - I liked the dressing, a spicy ranch, and there was a good amount of toppings mixed in. I got grilled chicken on top and that added a lot to it. It was a little overpriced. Overall, Pepper's is a great place for lunch or dinner. There's enough variety that everyone in your party can find something they enjoy. read more

Conveniently located near St John's Hospital & consistently great food, price & service make Peppers our "go to" place for lunch when in the area. read more

Menu same for ever! Tex-Mex with an OKIE twist...lol Nice surprise here in Utica Sq. Fairly clean for its age and the staff was friendly! Nice sidewalk patio if that's you thing! read more

I have been coming to Pepper for years! Its not the most authentic Mexican food but I always look forward to coming to this place and is typically my go to lunch spot during the horse shows. I usually order the quesadilla or the fajitas. read more

An OK restaurant for a quick Mexican dish- Fresh Salsa is tasty and fajitas are favorites. The restaurant needs to be terminally cleaned due to fleas... Not sure if an isolated incident with me, but was bit while eating indoors in both lower extremities... read more

I've never written a review for a restaurant before, but I had to this time. My son and I just ate there for lunch. He ordered a chicken sandwich with onion rings. The chicken was tough and couldn't eat it and the onions rings where cooked in OLD oil. I tasted one. They had a somewhat fishy taste. I told our waitress and she just said, ok, I'll tell them. We used to love Peppers, but, it certainly has gone down hill. read more

Honestly, I knew from the inch of dust on the lamp shade above the table and the puddle of who knows what under the table it wasn't going to be spectacular. But I definitely wasn't expecting ROTTEN FOOD. I ordered the chicken chimichanga and the chicken was totally RANCID. How it made it out of the kitchen is beyond me. The stench of AMMONIA from ROTTEN CHICKEN was so pungent it stung the nostrils. read more