Just left the restaurant. Checked in and was told it would be a 20 min wait. Host said to just hang around at the barstool area and they'll call us up. We watched two separate couples walk in and get seated before us. Waited at the front to speak to a host, and all I see is the workers in the back realizing they seated two groups ahead of us that clearly walked in after us. AND they left me standing at the front with no one coming to check on us. read more

Not sure which location we went to this time but the service was fantastic, the food was excellent and we truly enjoyed ourselves. We ordered the Wall Street pizza with cauliflower crust and it was fantastic. perfectly crunchy crust and so delicious. We also ordered the Upstate Style Wings with bones and it was crunchy and so good. Overall NYPD did not disappoint and we will be back when we visit Arizona again. We love everything about it. THANK YOU NYPD read more

I like the food from this place but every time I order pick up from here they mess up the order. I really rarely order more than two items. A cheese pizza and a salad which was the case today as well. Cheese pizza was fine. Hard to mess that up but I'm sure they'll find a way some time. Antipasto salad with no tomatoes, no salami and add chicken, cucumbers, and kalamata olive and 2x balsamic dressings. How did the salad come? Well, they got the no salami right. Also there was no pepperoni, no chicken, no kalamata olives and no dressing. So I paid 10 bucks for lettuce, mushroom and a pepperoncini. Just don't understand how you can be that bad at making 2 items right. read more

The food was so tasty here! I ordered the bbq pizza and added pineapple. It came out within a reasonable time was delicious! The staff were super helpful, patient, and attentive during my dine. Definitely recommend! read more

We ordered a large pizza today. It was delicious, and everyone was very friendly. We highly recommend this place. read more

NYPD Pizza - Half ham and cheese, half all meat. - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

My son LOVES this restaurant. We have done many mommy & son dates here and we both really enjoy the experience. The service has always been amazing each time we visit. The food is delicious and the quality is always superb. My favorite topping on their pizza is absolutely ricotta. The salads are amazing. An amazing touch on the salads that I will say, the first couple of times that I've ordered salads, they served it with a cold bowl. I know this sounds crazy but it truly makes the salad taste better! I would recommend to do that for all salads served. The crust on the pizza is delicious and I love the way they top the pizza and cook it. I would definitely recommend to visit and would absolutely be back again! Delicious food! read more

NYPD Pizza - Chicken Cesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

Delicious pizza! Love the Brooklyn with fresh basil. Perfect crust. Happy with the beer selection on tap. We will be back! read more

NYPD Pizza - Delicious is in this photo! - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Went in this afternoon (3/6/25) for takeout. Was told 25-30 minutes, fine. Left & came back just under 30 minutes later and was told 5 more minutes. Fine. About 10 minutes later my dad, who is a senior, asks if it was almost ready, and the lady making pizza was so rude to him. He even said he was just asking in case the order was mistakenly given away to another customer. Zero customer service skills from this lady. When it finally came out the very nice blond cashier was very apologetic and opened the boxes for me asking if it was satisfactory. She was great. The lady in the kitchen area however needs some training on how to properly speak to a customer. We didn't care that it was taking longer than expected. Her attitude was the problem. We left feeling disrespected. Always liked this place as we are native New Yorkers. We won't be returning. read more

We ordered a Sicilian pizza and cheese garlic knots for takeout this evening. My husband got home and what was supposed to be a half pepperoni and mushroom and half cheese only, was half pepperoni and half mushroom. The girl who took the order on the phone, even repeated it back so it was not a misunderstanding. Also, invest in the little plastic things that prevent the box from hitting the pizza. Half the toppings came off and were stuck all over the top of the box. The garlic knots we barely cooked. The kicker was that when my husband called in to say that the pizza was incorrect, all the girl said was "oh sorry." Seriously? No offers to remake it correctly? Reimburse something? A future pizza? Nothing. Just a sorry and hangs up. read more

Best pizza and wings in the valley . Hands down !! 4 different wing sauces . Hell's Kitchen is my spicy favorite . Hand tossed pizza made from scratch , plentiful toppings , so good . It's a must if you love pizza ! read more

Margherita pizza is pretty awesome. Good crisp, minimal flop, nice flavor. Better than the cheese imo.

I came in twice today, the first time was for 12 traditional wings, and pasta. The pasta was the complete wrong order from what I asked for. I then came in a second time after I saw that it was messed up and I waited 30 minutes for my food. So unfortunate, I don't even think i'll be returning back with what awful service this was. read more

So staying in a hotel not a lot of options for delivery . And pizza is always a good choice , it's a hit or miss mostly but we decided on NYPD Pizza and this was the best choice of all . From the time placing a call with Ryan helping us order to getting a call back asking how was it . Blowing away by customer service . Let me step back a second, when I order he was telling me all vegetarian options, do many to choose from but made a decision on Joeys Favorite, we ordered a med to start because basically that will just feed us , 2 people , he was kind enough to ask how many are we feeding , because the small would feed us , he said it's big ,, 14 inch is a small When it was delivered it really was a big small pizza , no joke ,we have leftovers , makes for a great midnight snack .. lol This was hot , tasty, and really , really good , great price and fast delivery, we had a few special requests, , like olives on the side , and add jalapeños , all made to perfection. Sorry no pictures only because we eat it so quickly , will have to go back and order again and get pictures. I would highly recommend this pizza place . read more

We stopped for a late night meal/snack. Although they were near closing and almost empty we got the warmest welcome and best service. I ordered a bowl of tomato basil soup, and boy was I surprised with the presentation- very pretty with three toast points. It was yummy. My friends ordered slices of pizza, and a wicked looking ice cream dessert. They were quite pleased, and quite full. This is not my stomping grounds, but if I find myself on this side of town again, it will be a must-stop! read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

We just came back from our first trip to NYC and have been on the hunt for New York style pizza, and this is the closest we have come! Pizza was delicious, I love that you can order half and half specialty pizzas, and their fried zucchini was amazing, even with our order being take out!! Only disappointment was the fact that a half order of zucchini was 4 pieces (great!), but a whole order of fried mozzarella was only 3 pieces! $10 for 3 pieces? And the lids to the sauces were melted in the Styrofoam container and spilled/soaked into them. Otherwise everything was wonderful, and we have a new favorite pizza joint. read more

Waitress was rude. Clearly having a bad day and took it out on her tables in addition to ours. When we made our order we told her we wanted ranch and lots of it so she didn't have to come back and she said ok. We were close to being done and I finally decided to get up and get ranch. As I was getting it she ran up and got it then signaled me it for was for my table. No apologies. We were here celebrating a Birthday and he asked her for a slice of cake and a candle for his bday. She had zero response or customer service and could of at least said happy birthday - she stormed off and took 20 mins to get the cake. It's amazing how a waitress and her attitude can ruin a dinner .... A BIRTHDAY dinner no less !! read more

Usually we get a regular size. Today we decided to get two larges. Considering they are 50% more expensive you'd expect them to be a fair amount bigger. They are not. No difference at all. read more

NYPD Pizza - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

Best way to describe their pizza? It's like Really good frozen pizza. I ate it, but I won't be back. For what I paid, I could have gotten a pizza from Crust or Grimaldi's and gone to heaven. But no, I got talked into ordering from this place. Fool me once. read more

We placed an order online and it had been an hour with no update. I went to check the status and it said the restaurant had not confirmed the order yet. I call them and spoke with a customer service representative who stated the order was never confirmed and she will confirm it right away. However, she didn't give any explanation as to why the order was never confirmed and just hung up. I'm astonished by the customer service or therefore lack of. My husband and I are regulars and the last few times we have gone to this restaurant it seems to be going down hill. read more

I ordered delivery pizza 2 weeks ago from this location. Pricing wise, it was very, very expensive for what I got. The pizza was good, but for the price I'd rather go to Grimaldis. The breadsticks were less than mediocre. I had one bite and threw the rest away. I'm not sure if I'd return. The delivery guy gave me a box and a bag. About 5 minutes later he came back and asked for the bag to be switched because he gave the wrong one....that's a little sketchy. read more

Would have given a lower score, however, customer service by employees/manager was exceptional. Was allowed to use the $10 off ($20 or more) coupon that was sent by them in the mail. Unfortunately, it was the pizza's that fell short. First the Brooklyn Pizza was missing the basil and cold. And second, the My 'Za 8 inch did not look appetizing at all. Not at all! My 6 and 8 year old's were shocked at the way it looked and the cardboard taste it had. Think I'll pass on this location. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

See all

I have ordered from here before and tonight I ordered sausage pepperoni and basil for my family. It is a Joey's pizza. After two hours...I got a vegetarian pizza! I called the manager and it was going to take 45 additional minutes to get the correct pizza! Unreal! I don't mind waiting if you are busy but to deliver the absolute wrong pizza??? The manager asked if he showed me the pizza....are you kidding me ...of course not. Ridiculous service...beware! read more

I always enjoy coming here. The food is amazing and the service is even better!! I stopped in for lunch after a long bike ride and enjoyed a slice of pepperoni and 6 upstate wings from their lunch special menu. The slice was cooked beautifully and the were wings fried to perfection and the sauce is 5-star! Ally G was our server and did an amazing job! Everyone here works as a team and it was refreshing seeing one of their cooks even greeting people and helping the dining room. (I watch all that) Cool, calm and collected. Great place and I can't wait to come back again. read more

Great pizza! We've tried several pizzerias and this has been our favorite. Lots of toppings and tastes delicious!

THIS PLACE IS AMAZING!! Brandon showed us their Thursday deal for 10$ 14 inch pizza!! It was way yummy I recommend the Boston family it comes w sausage and pepperoni:) way worth a visit! read more

NYPD Pizza - Restaurant interior - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Service was great! The pizza was good, but the salad was not great. The lettuce seemed old (had a lot of brown spots).

My son worked here years ago. He loved working there and when he died in a car accident they brought all kinds of food and were very kind. I will forever be grateful to them for their kindness and the pizza is wonderful. I will always support wonderful humans and this place has them. Go check it out! read more

I have to say I was a lil skeptical about NY style pizza in the dessert, but this spot is on POINT!! I haven't had pizza crust so soft and not gummy since my last trip to NYC. Thanks guys, I'll be back #BoricuaAfroLatina #CaliGirlInTheDessert read more

Good but unremarkable pizza. Modern casual--Stand in line, order, pay, get a number. Staff was polite and service was prompt. Good value for the money. I'd go back. read more

Pizza was good. Service very friendly and quick. Worth a try if you have not been there. Menu has a wide variety of options don't forget the desserts. read more

Came for Mom's Day. Surprisingly they weren't too crowded. Yet we had a long wait. Not sure why at first. Turns out they lost our order ticket. Many apologies were forthcoming, and they made the effort to make it right. Good customer service. I take that seriously, and give credit when it's due. So the food arrived. The pizza was good, as it usually is. In the past I had been unimpressed with their non-pizza items. But our table ordered two of them, and a small portion was shared with me. The penne al vodka was very good, as was the meat lasagna. So it appears that they have made some improvements since the last time I had one of their pasta dishes. Which is good to see (taste). Perhaps they read feedback from customers and took it seriously. Kudos for that. Next time I may have to order something other than pizza! I'm good with rating 4 stars this time. read more

We have been going here for over 10 years. They have raised the prices so much, and reduced the portions of the toppings at the same time. The sauce for the spaghetti and meatballs changed and no longer tastes good. There are better places to go for good pizza in our area. Sad. read more

Pizza is ok. Service in the restaurant in Gilbert is average at best. Ordering for delivery takes WAY too long. Two hours for a so so pizza. Go to Rosatis instead!! read more

Really, no MEDIUM pizzas anymore?!? Stop trying to screw the consumer. It's ridiculous! F the customer, we need some more profits, and to waste more food in the process. read more

So I asked for a cheese pizza. And I received a sauce pizza with barely ANY CHEESE! This is the third time I received a sauce pizza instead of a CHEESE PIZZA! I even asked for extra cheese this time knowing they never put cheese on my pizza. Will never order here again. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Amber was amazing this evening she did everything to make us feel at home. She is a big reason why will be coming back. The food was great from the tossed antipasto salad to the Sicilian da works pizza. The restaurant was clean and inviting. Great job Amber and thanks again. read more

I recently had the baked ziti and also 6 piece garlic knot. Fantastic! The ziti is normally what I look for on a menu and I've been disappointed a few times, but this has been hands down awesome. I had some leftover for lunch today, but the knots in the oven for a few minutes, nuked the ziti and amazing. Was not let down. Highly recommend. I will be getting this again soon. Real soon. read more

My friend and I were waiting for my tires to be serviced at Discount Tires and hungry for lunch, this is perfect place to go and grab a pizza (easy walk). Service has always been good. We ordered a Large Pepperoni Pizza and a couple of Beers. The pizza came out hot and fresh and tasted very good. read more

NYPD Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gilbert, Arizona

Service is NON EXISTENT... Food is good, sometimes great!! Too bad the staff only talks to one another

lets start by saying my husband and I order pizza every Friday night for delivery whe ever we are in town without fail. we have to order two different pizzas because I am gluten-free and he is not. That said, pizza night is expensive! it's normally $60 which includes the pizza, delivery fee and tip. That's for 2 people. I love NYPDs Gluten-free pizza so much and willingly tolerate their long delivery times. This evening I thought I got lucky with a delivery time of up to 40 minute. When our pizza did not arrive after 50 minutes I called and found out my order was entered as pick up in error. I was given the choice of picking up pizza that had been sitting there or having cold pizza delivered, however delayed because of other delivery orders. i did not like the options presented and was given the option of speaking to the manager which I took. I explained the situation to Noah and he gave me the same options above and one additional option. He was clear that I would be charged the $5 delivery fee and when I challenged the fact they they were in error he stuck to the $5 fee. Not a lot of money but it's the principal IMO. I told Noah to go ahead and charge the fee but I would never order from them again. I thought maybe he would reconsider given the poor experience nut nope the fee was charged. So good bye Noah and NYPD pizza. read more