It's so, so, so, hard to open a second location. Will the magic spread from the first to the second? Will people show up? Will the donuts be as good in a new oven? Luckily, the answers here are all YES. The (no longer new) new location is conveniently located pretty much right on the drive from our house to my best friend's house and it has a drivethrough, which makes it pretty much illegal to NOT stop by when I'm going for a visit. I was not sure how I would do with a drivethrough, since so much of my Neil's vibe is taking in the smells and sights of the donut wall. Luckily, I had a brief moment to actually read the menu and put together an order and I could not believe the speed with which my order was ready. I'm still loyal to the OG spot, since it's right around the corner, but this is a wonderful second spot where I see myself frequenting in the future! read more

Oh baby have we been waiting for this new Neil's location to open up! Middletown is only 15 minutes away and we were shaking waiting for them to open. We've only been to their original Wallingford location once before, so we were eager to be back! We got here around 8am on a Saturday and just to be safe, called ahead to order our donuts and coffee. On this particular morning, calling ahead wasn't necessary but I'm glad they have the option! We ordered 6 donuts and I can't even describe how fresh they were. I favored their yeast raised donut, which was crispy yet soft - incredible! Their holiday special was a frosted berry donut and it was my favorite! Their pumpkin donut was another special that was delicious! It was a cake donut that was obviously 10x better than the one I've had at "Smunkin Smonuts" hehe. Their coffee is typical of any donut shop - not bad but not mind-blowing either. They have some great flavored coffees which are always fun but a little too sweet. This location also has a drive-thru, which is great! I can't wait for us to come here on a monthly basis whenever we pass-thru Middletown! read more

See all

This place is so popular! Their donuts and coffee were great but don't sleep on their muffins! We tried blueberry and cranberry and they were delicious. The staff was so friendly and attentive. The long line moved really fast and we didn't have to wait too long on our breakfast sandwiches. Will be back!! read more

Welcome to Middletown, Neil's Donuts!! We've been waiting for you! This was a long time coming, we've seen the signs. We've waited patiently. We've waited not so patiently!! Then one day, the soft opening was here! I raced in to get my hands on some. Predictably, the supply was low. But the staff hustled and we were shortly on our way. Three short weeks later, the donuts are more plentiful. The staff is still hustling, and there's rarely a long wait, even though they're always busy. I'm not a huge donut fan in general, but Neil's makes the type of donuts that I do love. Nice and fresh, crispy not mushy. My favorites so far are chocolate (cake) glazed, and Bavarian cream. They also have muffins, coffee and breakfast sandwiches. I love their breakfast sandwiches - you can get on a roll, bagel or croissant. We don't have a lot of places to get a breakfast sandwich on this side of town, so I'm thankful for the addition. And there's even a drive through for those who don't want to go in. If you haven't been yet, check it out! There is something for everyone, and the staff are all so friendly and helpful. Don't forget to tip! read more

See all

This place is amazing! Their donuts are on point folks! Light and fluffy when they're supposed to be and Cakey when they're supposed to be. My favorite is the Boston Cream. Dear Lorrrrd it's like heaven. Lots of cream and chocolate ( no skimping here) just don't buy them all on me! They have a huge variety and some I haven't tried yet but I will get there eventually! Check them out. You will thank me. read more

How have I never been here before?! These guys bring donuts to the next level. So many choices it's hard to choose. I swear I went through a should box just because I wanted to try as many as possible. And now it's time for a trip back. Can't wait!! read more

Delicious donuts but long lines. Make sure to give yourself time to pick out the best stuff.

Amazing donuts at this place. If you are looking for the best donuts around.Come to his place to have choice, super fresh right out of the oven and be confused from some many choices.This is the place to go! read more

I love everything at Neil's! I've been going to there Wallingford location for years and now they have one in Middletown. Luckily my fat self is far enough away from both to not go their daily but when I am near one I have to stop. Their donuts are incredible! I have never had a better donut anywhere, Samoa is my favorite. I was around early enough to grab one of their cheddar jalapeño bagels on this trip , they sell out quick. They are delicious! Please check them out you won't be disappointed! read more

Neil’s Donuts - Candy Cane coffee - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

As a reward for a good cardiology visit [you read that right], I stopped for donut purchase. This turned out to be a donut for me, donut for neighbor and a donut for lunch. Two raspberry glazed jelly donuts and a cider donut. The raspberry had enough calories to let me skip Thanksgiving dinner tomorrow [won't] and the cider beauty is waiting for me on the kitchen counter. Alas, alack and hope there is no heart attack! read more

Neil’s Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

Another wrong order. Sad day. Wont be going here anymore. The staff working drive through just arent as good as they use to be. Very disappointing. read more

I have never had a better donut . Try the vanilla butternut cream . My Gosh it is like a meal . There are plenty of people working so the service is very good . you know a place is good when they have to have roped off lines . read more

Neil's Donuts in Middletown CT was worth the hassle of the long drive through the back roads and eventually Interstates to get there. It was Mobbed at 8am when I arrived and I had to laugh upon entering as there were several Police officers in line too The young lady who waited on me was friendly, polite, cheerful and fast. The selection offered at Neil's was mind boggling and I could easily have ordered one of everything- that's how good it all looked. No disappointment here as I bought a large variety of Donuts and every single one has been amazing- Easily best donuts in CT and anywhere else I've tried. Worth the long wait but the wait staff moved everyone along and was super friendly! read more

Neil’s Donuts - Menu board - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

After my first purchase and seeing the prices per donut, it's a no brainer to come to Neil's instead to those "other" places that sell coffee and donuts ;) The taste surpasses the amount this dozen cost. Happy National Donut day y'all!! (From your local PD) read more

Neil’s Donuts - Dozen donuts. (Assorted) - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

I have yet to find a better donut spot, these are in a league of their own. Wonderful local business that puts out a killer product. So happy to have them here in Middletown. Keep up the great work! read more

This place is heavenly, and on the 8th day, Neil's was created. I can not tell you how many times I tried to photograph the dozens and dozens of boxes over the last three months. I failed on almost all attempts. The donuts never make it past 20 minutes in my possession. Truly the best donuts I have ever eaten. You have to get to Neil's earlier in the day to get the most selectional variety, like all donut shops. What blows me away about the service in this place. They are extremely patient with my persnickety palate and give terrific recommendations. I am willing to drive the hour it takes me to get there because the donuts are THAT fabulous. We have a few new local donut shops around here, but they pale in comparison to Neil's. Neil's is my happy place!! read more

Neil’s Donuts - Apple Cinnamon, Oreo Cream, Blueberry Crumb Cake, Maple Glazed (half-loved), Samoa, Apple Crumb Cake - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

I have catered from Neil's Donuts several times and their donuts are very high quality. I was able to quickly get a carafe of coffee and a box of donuts in each case and my clients loved the food. This place is head and shoulders above the rest in CT. Fantastic service. read more

These donuts were supposed to be fabulous...not true. People that like these donuts like the frosting that is full of shortening. As a matter of fact, it tastes like store bought frosting. The corn muffin is better at Costco. Don't go out of your way to eat these overhyped and overpriced donuts. read more

These donuts were so good! They also let you call ahead and order donuts to pick up, which was awesome! Can't wait to go back. read more

Neil’s Donuts - Apple Cider & Pumpkin Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Service has declined drastically in the last 3 months. For some reason it now takes 15-20 minutes for one egg sandwich to be made. The wait time has skyrocketed. Super disappointing especially given how efficient Neil's used to be read more

Used to drive all the way to Wallingford for my Neil's Donut fix. Great to have them here in my hometown. Boston Cremes are my favorites and they are perfect! Don't need anything else :-) Only complaint - they run out before I get there some days - but that's my fault, not Neil's. read more

I've been a fan on Neil's for some time so I'm glad I finally got around to checking out their newest location. And this location is awesome. It's bright, spacious and offers plenty of parking. The donuts, pastries, coffee and breakfast items are still some of the yummiest around. And the staff is always so helpful. This will be a great addition the the area. read more

Neil’s Donuts - Peanut Butter Crumb - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

This place is sooo dangerous. I can never eat a DD donut again. They are nothing compared to Neils Donuts. The Boston cream is my favorite. It is too good. The donuts are huge and deliciously sweet. We've tried most of your basic ones. They have something for everyone there. Their coffee rolls are HUGE. Prices are very reasonable for what you get. The drive thru can get pretty long - service inside is very quick so I recommend going inside if the drive thru line is long. read more

Neil’s Donuts - Large coffee roll - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

The donuts are absolutely beautiful and so good to eat. I would recommend this place to anyone that is a sweet treat lover.

We've been to the Middletown Neil's more than I care to admit to. My hub and I have our favorites but we've managed to try a few new options . I remember reading several years ago after discovering Neil's, that their glazed is a favorite. We tried one today and it was a great option; not over the top as some of the filled options can be. It was super fresh, just the right balance of sweet and very light ! It was reminiscent of a Krispy Kreme! read more

See all

I've had donuts from this location twice now and they were incredibly fresh and delicious!! I am partial to the powdered with buttercream filling (both chocolate and vanilla) and the coconut donuts. TheIr cake-like donuts are excellent as well. I'm hoping that the pumpkin flavor sticks around for a while! The drive thru at this location is great. So glad they expanded to Middletown!! read more

Neil’s Donuts - Powdered with chocolate cream filling - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

It was SUPER busy when we arrived, but service was really fast. The team working the counter were extremely efficient and did not mess around taking orders. The donuts are very light tasting- they're not heavy heavy themselves. The toppings is what makes them heavy. There were a lot of flavors to choose from as well, and many were flavors I've not seen before. I'm not the biggest donut fan, but it was fun trying some different flavors you wouldn't see at a chain breakfast joint. read more

Neil’s Donuts - 1/2 dozen - coconut frosted, blueberry, 2 peanut butter frosted, 1 maple French toast, 1 raspberry cream stuffed - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

I am obsessed with these donuts. I was always someone who strictly went to Dunkin but now, I treat myself to the high quality taste and texture of Neil's. The service is always smooth and fast. Drive through AND inside. I've never had an issue with incorrect orders either. They also take allergies seriously! The location and storefront are also really nice, it's always clean and there's never a traffic jam (at least when I go! which is any time of day really) read more

I just wanted to give you some feedback. While I love their donuts and coffee, the attitude of the people you have working behind the counter makes a WORLD of difference. I went to the Middletown location today to get iced coffee the person who waited on me was rude and did not listen to my order. When I clarified the order to ensure it was made correctly, she became irritated and gave me an attitude and was super rude to me when checking me out. While she did make the order again, it was obvious she intentionally did not make the order correctly as it was not what I had asked for...once again. After I was done paying, before I even had an opportunity to say "thank you", she said "you're welcome" in an incredibly snarky tone and walked away from the counter. I understand everyone has bad days, but customer service is everything. It's a shame they have someone like this working for them and representing their company. read more

Just got a glaze donut and cinnamon sugar donut both were really good and the staff was really nice

Best bagels that I have tasted in a very long time! Great service and very friendly people.Donuts are very innovative!

The best donuts around always fresh not greasy. Get there early because they go fast. Get the Strawberry frosted my wife says they're the best. I like the powdered sugar crullers they are just like the ones that we got in the old days read more

I've been going here for years and they seem to be getting worse.. today I've encountered something very unusual that rarely happens but it is very unappealing on my egg sandwich this morning. read more

Neil’s Donuts - Mold? Or what I do not know but unappealing. My stomach has started hurting. - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

I think my expectations were too high but I thought Neil's was a typical donut/breakfast sandwich place. I tried a glazed donut and the ham,egg, and cheese on a hard roll. I'm sure it's worth trying all the different types of donuts but I wanted to try something that I could compare with other donut places. I found the glaze a little too sugary but it was a good donut. The ham, egg and cheese on hard roll was nothing special. The lines were pretty long but servers were quick and really great. Worth it to grab a quick bite or maybe I'll bring a dozen donuts to a gathering. read more

If you are ever in the area here or Wallingford you have to get donuts here! They have the BEST homemade fresh donuts EVER! I'm still warming up to the coffee and breakfast sandwiches. They are ok, just not my favorite. But I have yet to try a donut from here that is not good! I will never go back to a chain donut place ever again! read more

I live closer to heir original location in Wallingford and they have the best donuts in CT. This was my 1st time to this location. I love the abundance of parking. The inside is set up in such a way you can see all the donuts while waiting in line. Seems less chaotic than the other location but the donuts are still as good. There's a few tables outdoors. read more

When my good buddy and fellow Yelp Elite @pastathedogctjp recommends @neilsdonutsct, I'm going to listen! #iykyk Neil's Donuts are legendary in these parts, and rightly so. Pillowy soft donuts in so many varieties, all freshly made. There are even several Vegan choices! I got 2 dozen assorted flavors and still did not get every flavor on the case! Concoctions like Samoa and French Toast with maple frosting and cinnamon sugar coating are what keep so many coming back for more. The line can be out the door on weekends. I am so glad I listened to @pastathedogctjp's tip to get there early because the line started forming at 7:30 am while I was at the counter ordering! They had lots of eager, friendly and helpful staff, however, to keep the line moving. A half hour drive for donuts early on a weekend morning sounds crazy, but it is so worth it once you take one bite into the soft sugar goodness! This may become a weekend tradition!!! read more

See all

We love Neil's Donuts!! The apple filled cinnamon sugar coated donut is out of this world delicious. read more

Neil’s Donuts - Donuts Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

I love Neils donuts! Not only are the donuts fluffy flavorful and delicious, the iced coffee is great too! I always like to try the seasonal flavors. They also offer seasonal donut flavors which leaves you something to look forward too! I've also tried the breakfast sandwiches and the best part is they add to eggs! The everything bagels are my favorite. Also if you like the convenience of a drive thru, go to the Middletown location! read more

See all

Voted best donuts and man does it hold up to its reputation! A must stop for that sweet tooth!