Have been going to the Nautilus for years. The food is always good and service impeccable.

This isn't so much as a resteraunt review since we never got a chance to dine in but a learning experience to whoever is in charge. Pulling into the valet seemed very regular until the valet guy saw us (2 African american couples) and asked if we had reservations. Initially we thought nothing of it and let him know that we didn't. He then proceeded to go inside to check if there was space available "we assume". Valet then came out and basically said "I'm sorry there's an hour wait *and in the same breath* I can help you back out. I looked over through the driver seat window and asked how do u know we don't want to wait? Valet proceeded to tell us that we should try another resteraunt on the strip. I want to also add that we drove over 45 min +traffic to get to this resteraunt. Again I am not writing this review to be accusatory because we don't know if the actions of the valet reflect from inside the venue. But I do want individuals to understand why this was wrong. read more

Had dinner here with a friend on a Monday night at it was quite delicious! We arrived at around 8pm and there was a 15 minute wait for the dining room but no wait for the bar so we decided to dine at the the bar. The restaurant is intimate and cozy. It's shaped like you're dining on a boat and feels like it minus the waves. The bartender greeted us and cleaned our area right away. He informed us all of the specials including the restaurant week appetizer, entree, and dessert for $28.95 ending on April 30th. I ended up ordering the Soy Marinated Grilled Skirt Steak with sautéed onions, a baked potato, and Caesar salad and a glass of Korbel. And the bread he brought out was great! The meal was great! I'm such a saucey person but the steak was so flavorful that it didn't need any A1. The server was also attentive throughout the meal. I did notice that there were no tvs at the bar. There was one to the right of the bar but it wasn't on. I had great company so it wasn't a problem, just an observation. I would definitely return and recommend. read more

Nautilus Cafe - Soy Marinated Grilled Skirt Steak - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

Excellent food and friendly service. The best restaurant on the Mile by far!

Hands down the best Seafood in Nassau County! Great service and prices as well. Steak/Prime Rib amazing as well. read more

Six of us came here after a long day at the hospital. Small place with valet parking. Wine list does not have vintage years so you don't know what you are actually are selecting. Bartender needs to go back to bartending school to learn how to make a properly mixed drink. The menu prices reflect the Nautical Mile tourist trap area. Breadbasket: banana bread was leaden and rolls past their prime. The flatbread is delicious. Appetizers: $12.95 Baked clams were basically shells with breading. Crab cakes needed seasoning let alone a bit more crab. Oysters were decent and the mussels needed better sauce. Mains: All entrees come with salads. 2lb Lobsters were excellent and cooked perfectly but very pricey at $65. The wholesale price is about $8-9lb - Complete ripoff especially when all you get is the lobster and a small salad. Salmon tasted frozen. A nice size portion of Tuna (at $38) was seared to perfection but lacked the promised Asian flavors. Shrimp were pedestrian. Sauce with the Bronzino was very good. Sides: the fries and onion ring medley was small and a bit greasy. Very, very small vegetable sides. The $9 spinach needed spice and the $9 charred cauliflower had burnt pieces and undercooked pieces. Wholesale heads of spinach and cauliflower are barely about $2 each and you basically get about 25 cents worth of produce for almost $10. Desserts were ok Servers were excellent and their efforts raised my rating to 3 stars. They still charge $3.50 for a seltzer. read more

The food and service is always great and consistent. We had chose off the special Tuesday menu, which included an appetizer, entree, and dessert for $39.95. We ordered the veal chop (cooked to perfect) appetizers ordered were scallops and lobster bisque, (also perfect). The bread basket had a very nice selection with a freshly baked banana bread,which was the star! Dessert chosen was carrot cake and chocolate mousse cake, which we enjoyed later at home. If you're looking for a delicious evening out, this is the place to go on Freeports Nautical Mile. read more

I've been eating here for 20 years! Never a bad meal, Chopped baked clams wow ! Prime rib wow ! Cold seafood platter wow ! Best spot in Freeport by far read more

My waitress was very nice. The ambience is nice but the food is average. The crab cake was the only thing that I really enjoyed. read more

See all

Memorable Cuisine, Atmosphere and Superb Service! Were we impressed! Our server, Jessie(ph) made us feel as though we were his only customers. He was very attentive, knowledgeable, professional and provided us with excellent recommendations when asked. They offer a good selection of menu items along with specials of the day. We shared the shrimp cocktails and squash soup to start...delectable! I had the Halibut dressed with a creamy wine buttery garlic sauce accompanied by sliced mushrooms and lobster meat...yummy! We ended with the mud pie and apple pie a la mode for desert, both are must haves if you visit. We enjoyed a fine meal, well prepared and served, in a charming, intimate setting, fairly priced. I highly recommend the Nautilus Cafe (Reservations need and proper attire) Honorable mention to the hostess. She is professional, accommodating and just great! read more

Love the food and service here. all the fish entrees are amazing and the Prime Rib is second to none. We've been coming here for over 20 years and we'll come for another 20! read more

We have been going to the Nautilus Cafe for years. The entrees are well prepared, fresh and delicious every time. Brian in the kitchen is an expert at delivering tasty cuisine. Don't miss their Shrimp Oreganata. No little scrawny shrimp here. The thick swordfish is a family favorite. Don't forget to order some french fries. The lobsters and steaks are fan favorites too. The service is fantastic and they aim to please. read more

First of all the parking lot is much too small and the parking is difficult. The service is good. There is no ambience to comment about and the restaurant was noisy. As an appetizer, I had crab bisque soup, which filled only half the bowl and was too thick. My main course was halibut, which was OK, but the portion was too small. There was a side dish for the table, some potatoes, but they were terrible, dry and tasteless. For dessert. I had a lava cake, but it was really just a chocolate cake with some ice cream on top, I'm not sure how this place is for lobsters ; maybe it's better, but I won't go here again. read more

It's always a pleasure to eat at Nautilus. Great service and wonderful food, specially the lobsters! I'm a fan! Maria A. read more

I came here on a "cheat day" and omg the apple pie a la mode was just amazing! Service was good too. Highly recommend.

If you go to Freeport to eat seafood, locals often recommend going to Nautilus Cafe. I do not that recommend the soups, since they aren't anything special. However, the seafood is really great, especially the lobster and baked clams. The quality of the lobsters they have has never let me down. The fried soft-shelled crab is also very fresh and fried well with faint seasoning. It is savory, but does not dominate the natural taste of the crab. The scallops do not contain any chemicals, and is just cooked fresh. I sprinkled a little bit of pepper onto it and it tasted delicious. The mussels are very juicy. Their baked clams are chopped and made with various other ingredients like bread crumbs and herbs, and even a hint of cheese. The entrees come with either a soup or a salad. The raw Little Meck Clams are also very fresh and clean. Not only is the seafood good, but the bread platter they give you before the meal is baked very well. The bread is a five-star restaurant quality . It's hot, just like freshly baked bread. The top row of bread in the photo was all finished by me. I rarely eat bread due to being on a low carb diet, but their bread has made me break. -- at Nautilus Cafe. read more

See all

Looking for a wonderful meal in a warm friendly atmosphere? Our family has made the Nautilus our go-to restaurant these many twenty five or more years. I have a particular favorite, the ale battered shrimp. Any fish special is always a winner. Prime ribs, delicious. When, with friends, lunch is always a treat. read more

This is without a doubt the most constantly excellent restaurant on the Nautical mile. We have been dining here for years and I don't remember ever being disappointed. The consistency of excellence with the food and service is amazing. Over the years we have noticed a very low turn over with the staff. That speaks volumes. read more

This past week we returned back to the Nautilus Cafe. Lobster was full of delicious meat, Prime Rib was cooked to perfection as usual. Thank you Brian for doing the right thing after our so so experience NYE. So happy to see it was just a bad night and everything is consistently outstanding! Thanks Brian for taking great care of us!! See you again soon! read more

I'm always looking for lunch specials when I'm out of the office during the week. I found such a deal last Monday at the Nautilus Cafe on the Nautical Mile in Freeport. The Nautilus is the best restaurant on the mile, hands down, and they offer a 22USD Prix-Fix lunch which includes a starter, a main and a desert. I started with the Mussels Marinara, followed by a Shrimp & Crabmeat Roll with French Fries and Oreo Ice Cream. Michael had the soup of the day (New England Clam Chowder), Blackened Salmon with Tomato-Avocado Salsa and Chocolate Mousse Cake. Mike's platter also came with a side of Mashed Potatoes and Broccoli. Let's not forget the basket of gratis Banana Bread! It was as good as everyone said it was in prior reviews! Every dish was outstanding! We're not talking small portions either, these dishes were appropriately sized. The crabmeat in my sandwich was the real deal, mixed with medium shrimp and mayonnaise on a buttered and toasted roll. Mike's salmon was moist and well seasoned, and his soup was creamy and clammy. (his words - not mine - that, when translated means, full of clams). We got there early and it was filled to capacity when we left. Service was a tad slow, but neither of us minded very much because the waiter, hostess and busser were all very sweet. I can't wait to play hooky again and return for another fabulous lunch! read more

See all

The bread basket consist of banana bread and everything crusted crackers. The 22.00 Prix-Fixe lunch was a great deal. Choice of 3 appetizers (mussels in saffron butter, chilled asparagus, soup), 3 main courses (Parmesan Crust Bronzino, Chipotle Lime Glaze Salmon, Prime Rib) and 2 of dessert (Cheesecake or Oreo ice cream). Portions were large and it comes with a shareable sides (mash potatoes and vegetables.) We ordered some oysters and they were full of sand which was disappointing. Will be back to try the rest of the menu. read more

Nautilus Cafe - Salmon, Bronzino, cheesecake, mussels, oreo ice cream and banana bread basket. - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

Its about time!!! Freeports nautical mile, if you read some of my reviews has a terrible track record. Over-rated, over priced in many cases, and a huge disappointment...until today! Nautilus is by far the best place on the Nautical Mile. With only 15 tables, and an chef who IS the owner, you get quality with every portion of your meal. The food was excellent, ambiance is nice and the drinks were perfect! They also have great specials, the person I was with got a lunch meal that included fried oysters with wasabi mayo (and they were fresh oysters, not the frozen ones), a lobster tail with skirt steak, broccoli and mashed potatoes and a nice sized expresso cheescake dessert for 20 bucks!!! Portions were shockingly sized, and best part was everything was cooked and prepared perfectly. I got crabcakes and coconut shrimp and both were excellent. Crab cakes were very fresh and although not the best i've had, no complaints here. The shrimp were the size of a medium lobster tail and were delicious. I can't wait to go back, seriously! (I don't give Four stars lightly!) FYI they also have half priced lobsters on Mondays and a great meal deal on Wed or Thurs...call to check and above all make sure you get a reservation as the place is very cozy. read more

we were celebrating my sister's birthday and she asked to go to the Nautilus because she wanted a "good piece of fish " and once again the Nautilus didn't disappoint and her husband, who doesn't eat fish, was more than satisfied with his steak. the young server we had was just breaking in and he did a fine job...unfortunately I didn't get his name. thanks again for a gre dining experience read more

Amazing food, prices very fair, excellent service. Thank you Chuck for making our anniversary extra special.

I'm a little embarrassed to say, but for years I thought the Nautilus Cafe was a diner. Boy was I surprised the day my wife and I realized that it was indeed an excellent seafood restaurant. The Nautilus doesn't serve "fast seafood" or have loud music like some of the more well known restaurants on the canal, but rather it's just plain old good food with great service from an attentive staff. Keep up the good work! read more

Wonderful food and service. The ambiance is very nautical with a nice view of the Woodcleft Canal. Have dined there many times over years and have never been disappointed. read more

I have been going to the Nautilus for probably 20 years and the food has always been consistent and delicious. Whether you eat at the bar or at a table the service is always fantastic the cocktails are spot on. The staff has been there for many years and is as friendly whether you're new or old customers. The Nautilus is usually my first spot when I am back in town for dinner. read more

My fiancé and I decided to dine at The Nautilus Cafe last night. We've been here several times over the last few years and the menu never changes. Since this is restaurant week for the Nautical mile, we decided to order off of that menu. It was a $26 prix fixe for 3 courses. I ordered the fried oysters for my appetizer and the lobster tail and crab cake for my entree. The oysters were good but my entree could have been better. They actually charged a $2 supplement for this choice. The lobster tail was very tiny and had a weird taste and the "Maryland crab cake tasted as if it had been frozen. My fiancé ordered the stuffed baked clams and the pistachio encrusted halibut. He enjoyed his food. The mango salsa that came with his entree was really good. I was disappointed because their regular menu is outstanding. The service was good. The ambience in this restaurant is terrible. They should look into remodeling the place. The lights are too bright and the chairs are too close together. It's either that or they have too many tables. read more

See all

We have lived in Baldwin Harbor for 24 years, since Super storm Sandy and The Schooner being closed The Nautilus Cafe was our go to place. The food, service and prices were great. After covid, the food portions were unacceptable and the prices were $$$. Sorry to say we will not be going there any more. A VERY DISAPPOINTED HARBOR CUSTOMER read more

Great service and food but $3.50 for a glass of seltzer is a bit much. We also ordered alcohol. Have to let everyone know the manager has agreed that the charge for seltzer was wrong and has changed the policy. we continue to go to this fine restaurant and are never disappointed! read more

Been going for years, what can I say, you can't go wrong! The food, the service, the view, FANTASTIC! My favorite, bronzino any way they make. read more

Wonderful restaurant Top notch food and service!!! Always consistent and a great dinner read more

Nautilus Cafe has been a favorite "go to" this summer. The food is deliciously prepared and the seafood the freshest on the nautical mile! Special thanks to waiter Jesse for his superb service. His attention to detail is unparalleled. read more

Have spent New Year's Eves here for quite a few years now. Never disappointed. Their soups are extremely good, as are their salads. Meat is prime and served perfectly as ordered. No matter how full I am, always save room for a piece of mud pie! The staff is knowledgeable and accommodating. Definitely a winner. read more

My family came to the Nautilus Cafe Saturday afternoon to have a meal before the Christmas Tree Lighting on the Nautical Mile. We all ordered off the Price Fixe Luncheon menu. Our meals were all delicious! We had lobster ravioli, fish with crab topping, & prime rib. Market fresh vegetables, great crusty rolls, beautiful presentation and fabulous service made our dining experience wonderful! Thank you to the chef/staff and our server! We look forward to return to dine here again! Merry Christmas! read more

Love this place! Great seafood! Best restaurant on the mile, the drinks are good and atmosphere is classy.

My favorite seafood restaurant in Freeport. The food is fresh and prepared in the classic culinary traditions, chilled salad plates, fresh made whipped cream. Food was fantastic. Service was excellent. I will return whenever I'm in Freeport. read more

went with my sister and her husband we had 3 excellent meals . i had the halibut it was off the charts. best seafood around leo read more

We just had a fantastic meal here. My wife and I don't dine inside and we were made to feel at home inside their outdoor dining tent. They provided more than enough heaters that we were able to dine without coats on. The service was fantastic as well as the food. At the end of the meal they insisted we order dessert and the whole wait staff came out to sing happy birthday to me. They also didn't charge for the dessert. Wholly recommend for an enjoyable dining experience read more

I would rate this restaurant a 3.5 if I could. This was my first time on the Nautical Mile and my first time at Nautilus Cafe. We started with a really delicious jumbo coconut shrimp which came with a really tasty Thai sauce. Our entrees weren't bad neither. The lobster roll could have had a bit more flavor but it was still satisfying. The marinated skirt steak was very good and the caramelized onions on top of it were a nice touch. The lobster tail itself wasn't too flavorful, but again, not too bad. I would definitely return if I were on the Mile again looking for something to eat. read more

Nautilus Cafe - Marinated Skirt Steak w/ Lobster Tail - Seafood Near Me - Freeport, New York

See all