Today I tried the second location of the Nunzi's. When I parked I couldn't really tell if they were open. Compared to the farmingdale location the ambiance of this one is giving forgotten step sister aside from the back table(pictured on the website)they did up very nicely. We sat at the bar and the bartender was very sweet and managed a basically full bar attending to every guest with care. We ordered the Italian nachos which we loved and the Picasso. The nachos had a generous amount of crumbled sausage cheese and bruschetta as well as some spicy peppers. We really enjoyed the nachos. The Picasso was a nice size, but the sandwich lacked a little seasoning and needed a little more balsamic. It felt kind of dry. For cocktails we got the strawberry lemon drop, it tasted a little medicinal and the cucumber lime spritz type drink(I can't recall the exact name). This one was very good. An overall very mixed experience but I want to give it another shot even if only for the nachos read more

See all

Great food, wonderful people, and exceptional hospitality keep us coming back. My family and I have dined at Nunzi's By The Water several times over the years, in both the summer and winter, and every visit has been consistently outstanding. The food is always delicious, the atmosphere is welcoming. In fact, our experiences were so positive that when it came time to celebrate my daughter's college graduation, there was no question where we wanted to host the dinner. We chose Nunzi's for a celebration with 20 guests, and they exceeded our expectations from start to finish. Owner Al was incredibly helpful throughout the planning process, offering thoughtful menu recommendations and helping us create a memorable experience for our family and friends. Also careful to note any food allergies, and accommodate dietary considerations like gluten free and vegan. While his suggestions were excellent, truthfully, everything we've ordered at Nunzi's over the years has been fabulous. The quality of the food is consistently top-notch, portions are generous, and the pricing is very reasonable for the overall experience. The service deserves special recognition. The staff is attentive, friendly, and efficient, making sure everyone's needs were met without ever feeling intrusive. They also have just the right amount of playful sass and personality to keep you smiling throughout the evening, which adds to the restaurant's charm. Whether you're looking for a family dinner, a girls' night out, a romantic date night, or a venue for a private event or special celebration, I highly recommend Nunzi's By The Water. read more

Awful experience. Walked out. Customers and Employees smoking in front of entrance. Drinks were terrible, and baked clams which were supposed to be chopped were whole, large, very chewy and fishy. Left after that. Not good at all. read more

Been here multiple times. I love all of the food. The people there are great also. The Caesar salad is one of my favorites in town. Highly recommend! read more

See all

I went here on Saturday nite around 5:40 pm. We were told immediately the restaurant was closing for a private party and 7. We felt that would be ok. About 15 minutes later a party of 5 came in. They had reservations for 6 pm and they were seated. Five minutes later they were told they would need to eat and leave by 7. They were really really angry. I like the ambiance of this restaurant. The lights are low, there are tablecloths on the tables and cloth napkins. I wish they would have served a bread basket before dinner. We ordered the Italian egg rolls. I absolutely loved them! They are garlicky with a hint of spice, possible from the hot sausage. The mozzarella was melted and goooey. The roll itself was crispy and delicious. I would definitely order these next time I return. I had the swordfish and it was drizzled with some sort of peppercorn sauce. That sauce was peppery and delicious and I wished there was more. Unfortunately I felt the fish was overcooked - a little too tough for me. But the sauce almost made up for it. It was served with mashed potatoes, which were good, and broccoli rabe, which was cooked perfectly with garlic and oil. The spicy rigatoni alla vodka was delicious. The heat was just right and the portion was plentiful. Delicious! I will definitely go back here. read more

Nunzi's by the Water - Italian Near Me - Freeport, New York

See all

Been to nunzis serval times good food and nice happy hour. Pizza oven outside had calamari app personal pizza and eggplant and arugula sandwich very good read more

They say 1st impressions are lasting and for Nunzi's they made a great 1st impression. We were meeting friends for dinner and I received a call that they were going to be a few minutes late. The hostess was very understanding when we arrived and understood that traffic has been an issue. We decided to sit at the bar to wait. The bartender, Mike, was very friendly and professional. In addition, he made a good Old Fashion. When we were seated at the table the waiter was great explained the menu, and made suggestions, which I agreed with. The branzino was excellent. We had the oysters which were fresh and fantastic. All the food was cooked to perfection and the service was great. I have to mention Rebecca the busser, she had a great sense of humor and did a great job. It was a wonderful meal. Next time I hope to sit outside. read more

It's advertised on website as "by the water". No water. No view. Also mentions "waterfront" Not true. Service was abysmal, almost non existent and we were the only table occupied inside. I asked if there was a lunch menu. I was told no. So I ordered from what we were given. Later I found out there were " lunch specials" No water refills , extremely small portions , my husbands papadelle was good , my daughter's seafood platter was not. Overcooked shrimp and tough frozen calamari rings. My eggplant parmigiana was terrible. One bready soggy piece with skimpy mozzarella and a tiny side order of spaghetti. For the prices charged I expected more. read more

Has a lunch there and the place was clean and inviting. Has a nice menu and service was excellent. I'm thinking that being off season made it a bit slow. Food and presentation was excellent. read more

See all

Exactly what we were looking for, a hidden GEM! From friendly service to the warm intimate comfortable dining and the best authentic Italian I've ever had! We basically licked our plates clean! We started with the meatballs, I would highly recommend! All of our mains were perfect with homemade pasta! The waitress was very attentive, my husband loved the decor in the bathroom and was in awe of how clean everything was! This entire dining experience was *chefs kiss* perfect read more

Nunzi's by the Water - This was.... cannolis a bottle of whine and a delicious espresso martini - Italian Near Me - Freeport, New York

We had lunch today at Nunzi's. Everything was great! We shared a couple of apps and a salad. The food and cocktails were awesome we would definitely go back. read more

My friend and I stopped in for lunch on a Monday. The door was shut and the parking lot was empty but upon checking they were open! We were greeted by Kalyne who was super friendly and provided exceptional service. She makes a mean margarita! The cheesesteak sandwich and asparagus were excellent. Highly recommended if you're in the Freeport area! read more

See all

Service was great, food was great, nice place to go after going to the beach. They have outdoor seating read more

See all

perfect spot for a date, 10/10 food! Great view and nice employees! Love that they have options that arent just fish based!

The place looked lovely ... perfect for a birthday celebration with friends? Drinks were good. Food was just ok. Calamari was tough. Salads were nice! Pork chop was not fresh. Pappardelle was nothing to rave about. Monk fish had heavy salty cream sauce. Friends brought cake which took forever to be served on plates that sat in front of us for 10 minutes with table spoons... Server was a sweet courteous young man that needed much training from taking our order to asking if we needed anything including a drink. General Manager came by to make sure "everything is great!" and when we tried to express our dissatisfaction he quickly left our table without any attempt to make our experience better. He made it a point to go to the other 2 tables that had guests seated twice & ignore our existence. Great example of customer service for the staff! read more

Food was good and service was good. Reasonable prices. Outside eating was great and the live entertainment was great.

Nunzi's may actually be the best restaurant in Freeport. Now hear me out, the food is exceptional. For lunch I got one of the best burgers I've ever had in the area. Came here for the dinner the other night with family - the pork chop, the short ribs, and the seafood fra diavolo, everything was delicious. (More than likely will be back again tomorrow. They are that good here!) The team is awesome, Mike especially has been fantastic - makes great recommendations, personable, and all around fantastic service! I live 5 minutes away and will definitely be a regular here! read more

Nunzi's by the Water - The Smash Burger - Italian Near Me - Freeport, New York

Can't say enough great things about Nunzi's by the Water! We had an anniversary party for my parent's 50th anniversary. Even though a small restaurant, they were able to accommodate a table for 25. The food and service were great. The staff is very friendly. Food wise we tried a few different things, everyone really liked the Italian nachos and sausage and broccoli rabe egg rolls. The fried calamari was light and crispy. We opted for rigatoni ala vodka. The sauce is a little spicy and so good even people who don't like spice couldn't stop eating it. We really enjoyed ourselves. Definitely check it out. read more

We have been 2x. The 1st time was visiting a new town, try a new restaurant. We had great service and great food. So we came back. 2nd time we sat outside. We really enjoyed ourselves. It's now considered one of our favs. Don't be fooled by the name, it may be near the water, but you can't see the water. (I was hoping we could the 1st time). Make reservations. This place is good. read more

Terrible food and even worse ownership--never returningI had a horrible experience at this restaurant. We started with the calamari, which had absolutely no seasoning at all. It was the most bland calamari I have ever tasted.After that, we waited over an hour for our main courses. When the food finally arrived, the "roasted potatoes" described on the menu turned out to be regular tater tots. The swordfish was completely dry, and it came covered in a cream sauce that was never mentioned anywhere in the menu description.The worst part of the night was the management. We asked to speak with the manager and the owner, whom we had watched sitting at the bar the entire time we were there. Instead of coming over to address our issues, the owner stood right next to our table talking to our waiter, looking over at us, and loudly claiming that we were lying. The complete lack of professionalism and disrespect was shocking.The only saving grace was our waiter, who was amazing and the single positive part of the entire evening. Avoid this place. read more

What an incredible meal to celebrate my uncle's birthday! Everything we tried was insanely good. From the appetizers, to the pastas, to the entrees, and dessert. I definitely recommend their new Freeport location. It gives summer vibes with the live music and outdoor seating. My favorite appetizer was probably the homemade Arancini with black garlic truffle aioli. The steak and pastas were all so amazing and cooked perfectly. Don't forget to order dessert. The cannolis and the tiramisu were to die for. Thank you to Chef Bennett, Michael, Giavano, and Alfredo for the amazing service and hospitality. Appetizers: - Arancini - Fried Calamari - Grandma's Meatballs - Watermelon & Feta Salad - Charred Pulpo Pastas: - Spicy Rigatoni alla Vodka w/ shrimp - Linguine in White Clam Sauce - Lobster Pappardelle Entrees: - Grilled Porterhouse Steak - Grilled Calamari Desserts: - Tiramisu - Cannolis read more

See all

Ordered the chicken parm vodka. Geesh! was it amazing. My wife ordered the eggplant sandwich and she said it was just as great. The service was amazing as well but even if the service sucked the food would have made up for it. Our New favorite Italian restaurant on the south shore! read more

Nothing to write home about I gave it three tries and very overpriced and disappointing every time! Pasta dishes are basically 1/2 portions of what you get at better restaurants . Last trip there I got pasta with shrimp, the shrimp tasted stale and tasteless, app of calimmari with thi sauce was only litely drizzled in 1/2 the plate and tasted more like duck sauce and not spicy. My date food was so over- salted it was un- edible. ( eggplant parm), I had two glasses of wine, first one in a gkass, when I ordered second round , girl for some reason cam back with a mini carafe, which wound up , I believe was $2 more,go figure. The previous two times my experiences were just as disappointing . I'm done , never again. read more

I'm honestly kind of shocked at the positive reviews here My wife and I came here because it was a beautiful night and we wanted to be by the water. *this restaurant is not on the water, it's true to it's name: BY the water lol* Which was totally fine we still were able to sit outside on a nice night. But you have a view of the parking lot FYI. My wife ordered wings and the watermelon feta salad and I ordered the lobster pappardelle special with roasted tomatoes (I'm pregnant and took a look at the pictures before ordering because I wanted to see what I was in the mood for and yelp had 2 pictures of this pasta that looked great!) Our food came while my wife was sitting but I was by another table saying hi to a friend I ran into....I walked back to our table and BAM, before I sit down I see a black curly hair in my food. (My hair was up in a tight bun and I didn't even sit down yet, so it was 100% not mine) I told the server, she took it away immediately but I didn't want to re-order the same thing bc I was afraid they were just going to take it out and give it back to me AND also, the pasta looked NOTHING like the pictures. The pasta was swimming in a watery "sauce" I wish I took a picture of it. My wife's watermelon feta salad ALSO looked nothing like the pictures. Very mediocre. The wings were actually delicious - but if I want wings, I'll go to a bar yanno? No manager came over to apologize for the hair in the food. I don't know if it was an off night or what, but won't be coming back read more

Food is good. Service was a little slow due to there being only one server/bartender doing double duty. Went for a quick afternoon lunch. Sat outside which was nice. They have ample outdoor seating. Cocktails were not strong. So ended up sticking to wine for the balance of my drink orders. read more

See all

From the moment we stepped into the restaurant, we were greeted with smiles and great service. I apologize for not remembering the hostesses name.She is a great asset! The food and service was 5 star. I ordered the swordfish and it was mouth watering good!!! Thank you and your staff Chef Bennett!!!! Magic Mike (lol) you put up with the craziness of my party with professionalism and kindness. read more

See all

Amazing food! I had the lobster and shrimp pappardelle pasta. Dessert was homemade (Tiramasu). The food was delicious. I highly recommend this restaurant. Our waiter was great and the food was amazing. We will definitely be back. read more

First time trying Nunzi's and we had lunch. We were the only table inside, service was very good. The clams oreganata were very good although next time I'd ask if they can do them well done so they'd be a little crispier on top. The clams did have a great wine sauce and bread for dipping which we enjoyed. The Vietnamese ribs appetizer was tasty but small to share so I only got to try one small rib. These were served with a coconut rice cake which was crispy, sweet, and something different. We all enjoyed our sandwiches: philly cheesesteaks and prosciutto with mozz. Lunch prices seemed to be a little less than places on the Nautical mile. Will come back and try some dinner options. read more

Visiting from Denver and this was a classy but comfortable Italian place by the marina. Mike served me and was fantastic. I had the 1274 gin and juice cocktail, the short ribs with Paperdelle, and a cannoli. Everything was delicious. Would absolutely recommend. read more

Nunzi's by the Water - Bar area with 1274 cocktail. - Italian Near Me - Freeport, New York

This place is a hidden gem, I only say hidden because it is fairly new! It is such a welcoming environment and the food was delicious! I am truly looking forward to the summer and eating outside with music! I highly recommend! read more

See all

Really nice restaurant. Nice people and great food. I had the chicken parm which was delicious. My husband had the spicy rigatoni which he loved. read more

I had went out to eat with my daughter and my friend. I ordered pasta with vodka sauce and chicken. I think it was the spicy rigatoni. It was a little tiny bit overcooked, but overall it was delicious and I left no crumb on the plate. My daughter had the burger and it was really good. The fries were so crispy and that's my personal preference. I also ordered the pineapple daiquiri. It was all right I had better. The ambience was nice and quiet. It did have aesthetics to take you pictures. The servers were young they were so kind definitely would come back but as a date night next time! read more

Nunzi's by the Water - Spicy rigatoni with grilled chicken - Italian Near Me - Freeport, New York

This place is amazing! New spot we decided to check out this past Sunday Night. The Hostess and our server were very polite and accommodating, the owner was awesome checking in on us to make sure we were happy with everything. The food was fantastic, their meatballs taste like you are at Mom's house for Sunday dinner. Baked clams, the lobster roll, steak all top shelf. Atmosphere is great as well you can see they really put effort into the decor, inside or their outdoor patio and bar. Great New Spot, we will be back and spreading the word about Nunzi's by the Water!!! read more

We hosted our twin daughters' Sweet 16 Dinner at Nunzi's after a taste test and were impressed. Alfonse and his team provided excellent service for our 40 guests, making us feel welcomed like family. The ambiance and food were superb. Be sure to add this restaurant to your shortlist. read more

Excellent food! The oysters were amazing, so fresh. The service was great. Can't wait to come back on a nice night and enjoy the outside patio. read more

I should've attached photos of our food, but we were so taken back with the great appearance that we just dug right into the meal. The staff was extremely friendly and worked hard to make it a welcoming environment, which was a big plus. Now for the food. The starters were arancini balls and a chopped Italian salad (their take on an antipasto). Both were very fresh and flavorful. But truly the standouts for the evening were the Branzino and the Picasso sandwich. The Branzino is perfectly sautéed + crispy skin, and the caper sauce kicks it up beyond the usual flavor one would expect. The Picasso combines thinly fried eggplant and ricotta cheese (at the recommendation of the waitress) that was a savory and very memorable dish (one I will definitely order again). Even little touches like the fries were fresh, light and crispy. Again at their advice, selected the chocolate cheesecake. Instead of a dense thick dish, it was light, sweet and airy. A truly pleasant surprise. For a full meal, two apps, two entrées, dessert and two coffees for $125, this is a place worth visiting again. On the way out, shared our experience with the owner, Al, who was equally as welcoming as the rest of his staff. With so many places struggling with staff and food quality these days, this new spot is onto something really impressive. read more

I was very excited to try this restaurant since its other restaurant in Farmingdale had a great reputation. I had the spicy rigatoni a La vodka. It was great. For the appetizer I had the chicken wings. They were great. Our server Briana was great. read more

Wonderful new sibling to the original restaurant in Farmingdal. We tried this new local spot this evening and were welcomed by the hostess, and immediately seated on their cute outdoor dining area. The server was personable, and knowledgeable about the menu recommended a couple of cocktails to start our evening. The food and cocktails were expertly prepared and generous. My swordfish steak was at least a pound of perfectly grilled fish served with broccoli rabe and cheesy whipped potatoes. Our overall experience was wonderful! We look forward to returning to our new local spot. read more

BEST VODKA PARM EVER!!!!! nunzis is the best! friendly staff, super cute nautical theme inside. im obsessed with their vodka parm read more

Nunzi's by the Water - Vodka chicken parm - Italian Near Me - Freeport, New York

Great new restaurant by the water with live music. The food is delicious. The chef came out to our table and served us complimentary appetizers. That was very sweet. The fried calamari is very crispy. All the pastas are cooked Al Dante which I love. The steak temperature was perfect. It was a really nice cut of a meat. Our server was great but some of the employees looked like they needed more training. read more

See all