Only experiences with Muldoon pizza is via carry out and delivery, have never dined in. They have a good pepperoni pizza but when we've ordered other pizzas they aren't near as good. Run a little expensive verses other pizza places nearby. read more

First off, yes, i am that person who likes pineapple on their pizza and Muldoon Pizza didn't disappoint. Been ordering from them since moving to East side in 1998. Delivery is fast and free. 30 min and had combo pizza delivered for 17 bucks. Not bad at all. I also love their antipasto salad, it's enough for 3/4 ppl easily. read more

Muldoon Pizza - House special (combo) with pineapple - Pizza Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

Not as others reviewed it, just about worst pizza I've ever had! I would get a Costco Pizza or Frozen Dijornos instead!

Amazing experience in all ways. We called in for delivery. The host who answered notified us right away the delivery would take about an hour because they were super busy, and we could pick up in 20 minutes if we wanted. We still elected for delivery, and she was very pleasant and helpful. The delivery was right on time. The delivery driver was super humble and stated he was just "helping out delivering" to help get through the busy time. When I called to pay, it turns out it was the owner helping out with delivering. We were very impressed. And to round things out, the pizza was absolutely amazing. Real mozzarella cheese, great sauce, and the perfect amount of topping. We got both a thin crust and regular crust - Both were amazing. We will be going back for sure and will be glad to support this company! read more

Best pizza I've had in a while. The crust has the perfect amount of crunch, and then the perfect amount of give. The cheese has flavor, which is rare for most pizza places. The price is great, especially for Alaska. It's been a long time since I've looked down at a slice of pizza and though "aw man, it's almost over". Do yourself a favor and order a pie. read more

I love supporting mom and pop businesses! The food here is consistently good; and all things considering, I'd recommend anyone to eat here. Personally, I prefer the pizza over their pastas. They make their side salads with ham, pepperoni, mushrooms, tomatoes, and real mozzarella; I always get one to complement my meal. The service is something straight out of a comedy skit though. It's like dinner and a show. The waitress is pleasant, but seemingly forgetful. Glasses can run dry, and you may be asked if you ordered another pizza while she's holding one in her hand. She routinely delivers my salad to the table with tomatoes, regardless of my request to not have them. She loses the ticket she wrote your order on and will accidentally spill sauce on your card. You really can't help but to giggle at the hilarity; because in the end, we're all human. Give this place a shot. I'm pretty sure you won't be disappointed. read more

Our FAVORITE pizza place!! The pizza is super good and price comparable to Papa Murphy. But don't forget about their fried chicken. My daughter loves it so much she begged me to stop by the other day after school and she offered to pay with her allowance. Today we stopped by because my husband is craving the chicken. The owner saw my girl come in with me and told her that since she loves the fried chicken so much, she can keep her allowance! He bought our chicken! We already LOVE this place, but now they have a permanent place in our chicken/pizza hearts!! read more

Muldoon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

Terrific pizza. Great service. Good value, reasonably priced. Lowest bottled beer prices I have seen in AK. read more

Muldoon Pizza - Good salad before the pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

This place is by far one of the best pizza places in Alaska! 10/10 would recommend!! Not only are they amazing they are extremely consistent with the quality of the food. If you haven't had the opportunity to try them yet you should!! Crust is cooked perfect every time with an awesome amount of crunch! The cheese is amazing as well!! read more

-Based on a experience last year- I thought for certain I had reviewed this place previously. This establishment has been around for a long time. You can tell right away because of the 1960's-70's original decor, complete with years of smoke stain, dirt, and grease build up. It looks exactly the same as it did when I first ate there as a kid. Growing up, we were very poor and it was a real treat for us to eat at Muldoon Pizza back then. I can still remember the heavenly aroma wafting among the cigarette smoke. I probably would have forgotten about that, but this place still has that lingering sensation of Yuk. Among the beat up old tables and duct tape benches hung one of those old oil drip lamp things. It had been years since I saw one of those, and this one was just nasty.... not unlike the ceiling, walls, and floor. Actually, I guess it fit right in, never mind. Enough about the fond memories of old. Lets talk about the pizza, or rather the round thing they serve that is suppose to be pizza. The Pizza was part brunt, part pale, and drab. The cheese was .... does coagulated work well as a description? At any rate, it was obviously imitation, and the sauce.... well ... Flavor is apparently not available on/or near these Pizza's of Muldoon. To be honest, I never finished my piece of za. I would recommend that the owners, managers, employee's... anyone. Start from the top down and clean. read more

Just went to Muldoon Pizza for the first time. After seeing the ads and reading the reviews, I knew it was going to be a great dinner. We ordered an appetizer of meatballs with sauce and the 16 inch House Special. As soon as the waitress walked away from taking our order, my wife sees something inside the Parmesan cheese shaker. Inside the shaker, running circles, was a 3/4 inch long cockroach! A freaking COCKROACH!! Living in the Parmesan cheese shaker! Needless to say, we didn't stick around for dinner. This happened 20 minutes ago, and I'm still totally repulsed. If the cheese on the table is infested, just imagine what the kitchen looks like. Never again read more

We had no idea what to have for dinner after doing some shopping yesterday afternoon. My sweetheart turned into this little strip mall Ive never been to before & takes me into this pizza place on the corner & my first reaction is WOW! Very retro, nothing fancy & it has a very comfortable atmosphere and feel to it. The menu is simple with a couple of pasta dishes, a salad or 2 and pizza. We had the house pizza. It had canadian bacon, pepperoni, olives & onions. It was SO good. It was no fancy Moosestooth/Beartstooth pizza but it was still so delicious I cant wait to go back or even order takeout from there. Pitchers of beer are only $9.75, glasses of wine are $2.50 and $2.75, not a huge beer list or wine list. Very simple, great prices & great customer service. My boyfriend told me it is one of the oldest restaurants in the Muldoon area. I am curious to know exactly how old this establishment is etc. Give it a try, you wont be disappointed. read more

Until recently, this was our default pizza place for delivery. Lately though, the quality has dropped off. Delivery times have gotten longer (almost 2 hrs one time) and the toppings don't match the order. I've never had an issue with dine-in pizza. The place looks dated but the service is good and they don't mess it up. Dine-in but avoid the sketchy delivery. read more

Purely awesome! The pizza was rockin and the crust was sooooo good. The server (girl) cut the straws for our kids cups, brought extra soda never let our cups empty. It was great. Our picky toddler even ate the kids ravioli (which was great and adult serving size!). The pizza was even awesome reheated in the oven. We gave a $30 tip and our compliments to the chef. We will be back and pass the word. read more

Muldoon Pizza - A super happy toddler at Muldoon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Anchorage, Alaska

*****MICE****** If it weren't for the server this review would be even worse. She was very nice, very apologetic. While dining in a mouse jumped on my leg!!! She said ."Oh you got assaulted! The meal is free." She went on to explain that the building is Infested and the other businesses refuse to bomb so they can't get rid of the mice. I wouldn't eat here if it were the last place on earth and I was starving! #call the health dept. read more

The pizza is greatly good and extra cheesy! They will accommodate and substitute non-dairy cheese if you bring your own in. The place is run down and old, but fairly kid friendly. Reminds me of the pizza parlors from childhood. The blond waitress is wonderful and funny! Been there forever, girl next door type. But the new gal! Ugh! Worst waitress ever! read more

If I had to choose between this pizza and Costco's pizza I'd most likely pick Costco. This pizza reminds me of grade school, cafeteria pizza only not rectangular in shape read more

First time I tried this place it wasn't bad but a bit lacking in flavor. The restaurant seems to be nice I just picked up an order rather than dining in. Everyone seemed very friendly. read more

This is our go-to place for pizza. We love the retro atmosphere and the service is pretty great. We love places like the Moose's Tooth, but there's usually way too many people and you might have to wait a while to get seated. We usually go once a week now and are never disappointed. It's what you might think of when you imagine a small, local neighborhood pizzeria. We normally get the pepperoni pizza. If a place can make the basic pizza taste amazing, then that's a win in my book. If a place can't even get pepperoni right, then it's not a good pizza place. These folks get it right every time. read more

I think this is some of the best pizza in Anchorage and for sure the best on this side of town. My pizza's have always had a great amount of toppings, a ton of delicious cheese, and home-made crust. They have really reasonably priced pitchers and wine, but a slim selection. Delivery is free and the timing is reasonable, about 30ish minutes, with the exception of around 7pm when it's more like and hour, maybe more. I'm not a person who really cares about atmosphere, but for those who do: It was probably nice in the 70's... gold wallpaper and all, but now it's kinda funny. It's casual. OH! once they lost my order when I called for pick-up, so they upped the order to a large from a medium and threw in a beer. That's awesome. read more

OMG...let me tell you about 'the torpedo'! If you want an authentic Italian sandwich, look no more. Subway? No way. Muldoon Pizza kills it. Hands down the best. I want one right now! Fries are also awesome! Way to go, Muldoon Pizza!! read more

Muldoon Pizza is old school pizza at its best. Even the restaurant itself brings you back to the days when your parents took you out to Shakey's for pizza, sodas and video games. Picture Shakey's minus the arcades... Muldoon Pizza is very good, INEXPENSIVE and has consistently friendly service. Favorites: Canadian Bacon & Pineapple Super Special - be hungry Antipasto Salad - feeds 2 or 3 adults easy read more

If you enjoy waiting an hour and a half for your pizza to get to your house (which for us happens to be 3.8 miles away from the pizza place) then this most certainly is the place for you. Also if you enjoy rude people answering the phone it's a good chance you'll get what you're looking for here as well. We've ordered from here 4 times now, three times we've had rude people answer the phone and their delivery is ALWAYS slow. The pizza is okay, but not worth what we deal with. We won't be ordering from here again. read more

Pizza is delicious! I love the vegetarian. The delivery is fast and free. My husband likes the house pizza.

I've pick up a pizza and didn't wanted to go there anymore. The waitress seem ok but she looked like she was on drugs I could smell an odor on her. The floor was filthy and so was the men's room, after my husband used it. It also smelled like cigarettes. He also glanced at the kitchen crew and their pizza line through a small cubby hole, it wasn't in the greatest shape a little bit dirty and their deep frying station look like something out of a horror movie. We saw mouses running down the hallway! Be warned. Also when a friend asked us to join them we said HELL NO! We gave them no reason we just said go figure out themselves. We never contact our friends we don't really wanna know. Now the food, No Flavors on the spaghetti with meatballs, It taste dry. Didn't like the pizza neither we had better Stone baked Pizza and Uncle Joe's ! And our friend that dine in and say that a Kitchen personnel was smoking and when straight to make Pizza! No Hand washing Nothing. Ok read more

Every Monday night for football we order the muldoon special, basically a combo pizza, and wings. Never disappointed. There pizza was always good and the wings were always still hot. Will continue to order every football Monday. read more

I go to Muldoon pizza a few times every month and I became a regular there because the food is delicious, service is great, and the place is clean. One of my favorite restaurants. read more

To put simply; this place is the best, cheapest pizza that delivers. I know that sounds like a lot of qualifiers, but the pizza is delicious! One of the few places in Alaska you can get an 18 inch (extra large) period, and you can get that extra large for $20.00. And they deliver? Haha SOLD! Delivery is up-to-date with the latest technology if you use a card to pay. So forget all that none sense with giving your card number over the phone, they swipe your card at home; simple fast and easy. Friendly staff. This Pizzeria has a lot of history in East side Anchorage. Ask for your pizza to be "well done" to get the best results for your pizza. They make it perfectly. read more

Moved within delivery range recently, and thought we'd give this a try. So glad we did! We had the House Special thin crust XL pizza. Excellent balance of flavors, and really appreciated the thin cut Canadian bacon and fresh onions. All this for only $23. Will definitely be back! read more

Not impressed.. stopped in for dinner after reading the reviews. Food is reasonably priced, service was good, food not impressed.

Oh man, delicious pizza! Sausage, mushroom, thin crust....yum. Can't beat this place. Thanks for keeping your pizzas consistently great for the past 30+ years. Wish they'd open a place in south Anchorage...hint, hint....maybe old Pier 1 bldg? read more

Comon people! Its MULDOON PIZZA! We've all been coming here since we were little! Every visit, since the age of 6, I've been staring up at that red velvet and gold brothel wallpaper with the 'hanging on for dear life' dust bunnies begging my parents if I could come in one day to clean!! Its not the best pizza, i.e. crust n sauce, especially if youre Italian. And you wait an hour for it.. but its the thickest pizza with the most toppings you'll ever get on a pizza in this town. Their Greek Salad's have always been to die for. Every Italian meat, olive and on it topped with amazing oil and vinegar dressing. Muah! read more

The staff is always friendly. The pizza is good enough that I eat there about once a month. It's definitely convenient and my preference of pies on the east side of town. Easy quick service for both pick up and dining in. read more

I can't remember if a person or newspaper recommended Muldoon Pizza. Had I the ability to recall who or what, I would beg for an explanation for the recommendation. Beg, I tell you. It doesn't take much for a pizza to impress me. Round? Check. Cheese on top? Check. That's it. After trekking from west to east at Friday rush-hour, I was good and hungry and looking forward to eating at this hidden gem. Plenty of parking. No line to get in. Plenty of seating. Appallingly appealing seventies brothel decor. Remember those goddess Diana lamps that heat up and drip "rain" around her immortal form? Check. Red wallpaper with velvet floral burnouts? Check. Garage sale quality oil paintings? Check. On to the pizza. My companion said it was California style pizza since it wasn't Chicago or New York style. I have never heard of California style pizza, but if such a category exists, I'm glad I left the Golden State. Wouldn't want to live in a financially and pizza strapped state, right? The crust was flavorless but of adequate structure to hold the toppings. The melted cheese was an unsual consistency, leading me to question its authenticity as a 100% dairy product. Another oddity was the sauce. Where was it? There may have been a thin veneer, but it was undetectible, even after peeling the cheese from the crust to get a better look. Feeling like I should give it a second taste, I took the leftovers home and gave it the morning after cold pizza test. Nope. Not remotely better than the night before. Much worse cold. Maybe Muldoon Pizza's food, like its decor, harkens back to the brothel days of yore, where one isn't there for the food, if you know what I mean. At least at a brothel you get what you pay for. But a good pizza at Muldoon Pizza? Refund, please. read more

Most definitely the best pizza in town! They have the crispy, thin crust and it has that New York taste. I will be ordering from the again! Oh, did I mention their fried chicken is on point, sorry Lucky Wish Bone , but Muldoon's Pizzas is better. read more

We love their pizza! The salads are great too. Michelle is the best waitress. Very friendly. Knows our order as soon as we walk in. We are from New York and this is the closest to New York style pizza in town. read more

I usually don't write reviews but this was so bad I felt I needed to warn others. I skipped lunch and ordered pizza at 6pm. It didn't arrive until 8pm, which was much longer than the time I was given. The pizza was so bad I threw it out and dug through my freezer for leftovers. It was salty, cold, and tough. read more

My favorite pizza place in Anchorage. Great staff. Great pizza. Fun throw-back atmosphere. Met some people here for my birthday and they could not have been more accommodating. read more

Great food & great service. The owner misread our order & insisted on our meal being on the house. I tried to resist but he won out. That's what I call service! read more

Great pizza. Crispy crust, cheesy cheesy cheesy toppings and they have a simple variety of toppings you can get with your pizza. I enjoyed every bite of my pizza. Great price for the pizza too! about $15-18 for a large pizza to feed 4 people and they don't charge extra for delivery/pickup. Friendly service... would recommend and buy again and again! read more