The Mill Rock hosted my intimate wedding and it was nothing short of perfect! Eddie and his family went above and beyond for our special day. The food, the atmosphere, everything was amazing! My family can't stop talking about the food and the just how beautiful the restaurant was. Thank you so much to all the staff @ Mill Rock you really made our wedding day all the more special because of how caring you guys were through the whole planning process up to the big day!! read more

I always enjoy a trip here, and there is usually a wait for a table. We've been lucky sometimes when we go later with a smaller party and the wait has been shorter. The only time I've not really enjoyed the dish was the Asian inspired tuna (yes, I agree, Asian inspire dish in Italian restaurant in a location where there is no fresh fish not my best decision). I love the chicken marsala, we usually get a pizza or an appetizer, and then the pastas and other entrees are always solid. And they have house wine by the carafe, 1/2 carafe, etc. This place is not to be missed read more

See all

The food was great, service was great (aside from the underhanded charge) and the atmosphere is great. My problem is with them telling us they have buttered noodles for kids and then charging us $28 a plate for them (at bill time)... each was more than the cost of either of our in menu plates.... Absolutely mind blowing to me. read more

Wonderfully wicked seafood is pretty good Very Fresh taste Sauce also nice Found today: I like mussels Friendly servants read more

Millrock Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

See all

Second time eating dinner here, food was amazing, service outstanding! Come early if you want a table. Not to be missed if you're in the area, you won't be disappointed. read more

By far the best restaurant in Windham .John and Justine are wonderful hosts. The seafood and spaghetti Melody is the best The steaks are equal to New York City Fair prices and excellent food read more

Millrock Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

The food here is good and the bartender super friendly. Drinks were okay. Funky smell in the dirty martini. Place gets packed so plan on a wait. We had the stuffed pasta which was very good and filling. read more

What a great restaurant! Came here for a date night with my husband and was so pleasantly surprised by the trifecta of delicious food, friendly service, and a charming ambiance. We asked to sit at the outdoor patio (might as well reduce COVID exposure while the weather's still decent!) and it was so cute back there with string lights and a recent renovation. They are also in the midst of finishing a really beautiful bar area as well. We ordered the Calamari to start and shared the Bucatini with Bolognese and Stuffed Rigatoni with Vodka Sauce. The pastas were especially fantastic and the portions were HUGE! Truly, I think we will have an entire meal for leftovers. Will definitely come back soon! Excited to try more on their menu and to support a great establishment. read more

Really solid Italian restaurant. During our short stay in Windham, we took out from here twice. Tried the smoked salmon and mushroom, fettuccini Bolognese, and chicken marsala. The pastas are legit, cooked all dente, with delicious sauce. And the portions are generous!! Chicken Marsala was a bit lighter in flavor but still delicious nonetheless. Give it a shot, you won't be disappointed. read more

We came for a Saturday night dinner and it was a 35-45 minute wait, luckily we weren't hungry yet. Quite a number of other people order glasses of wine to sip on while they waited. The staff was extremely friendly and courteous. We had the: - Calamari - good, fresh (so they weren't tough and chewy like some places) -special of the day: Stuffed trout with crab meat (which had peppers) - it was okay. would have been better if there wasn't bell peppers mixed in with the crab meat. The trout also has small bones, so be careful. -special of the day: Penne with shrimp and scallops - it was very good. The portion was large- couldn't finish it. There was plenty of shrimp and small scallops so that it was throughout my dish. -creme brulee - very good but way too little. The amount of custard was so thin, it was the same amount as the caramelized sugar... read more

Anyone who know my reviews on Yelp knows that I do not give 5-stars unless completely deserved. Millrock completely deserves all five. My wife, son and I arrived after our drive up for a ski weekend. We had heard that it gets crowded (and they do not take reservations), so we stopped in at around 5:30pm on a Friday night, checked in, and then left to drop off our stuff where we were staying. We returned roughly 40 minutes later, and their "45-minutes" estimated wait was just about spot on. Service was good ... they know how to handle crowds. However, the nice-casual atmosphere wasn't about service ... it was all about the outstanding food. We shared three dishes among us ... a pizza, the special stuffed veal chop and a smoked salmon and mushroom pasta. Let me tell you ... we couldn't decide which we loved more. The pizza was perfectly made with a nice semolina crust. The sauce had just the right balance of sweetness and tomato-tartness. The stuffed veal was wonderfully cooked ... nice and tender, with a chunk of asiago and a portobello inside. If there was anything they could have done better, it was to get the asiago to melt without over-cooking the medium-rare veal. The home-run of the three was the pasta. Unreal flavors with the right touch of cream to balance the saltiness of the smoked salmon. The mushroom flavors complemented the fish ... well OMG. We loved them. And with a $16 half carafe of house red, everything was just perfect. Desserts were a wonderful chocolate mousse, which was not too sweet (perfect) and a flourless chocolate cake that was basically all dark-chocolate ganache. Again ... not overly sweet, so the chocolates were front and center, rather than sugar. I had a decaf coffee, which was surprisingly strong. Our check for three was $136 inclusive of a generous gratuity, making the experience just great. I wish we could go back more frequently, but the 2+ hour drive makes Millrock out of reach unless we return to Windham for some more skiing. Seriously ... a wonderful experience. read more

love the pizza and pasta. Though the steak in a little rawer, really a good restaurant. Fudge cake is also re read more

Millrock Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

See all

We were trying to call the restaurant for a long time to order take out and no one was answering. We then went to the restaurant to pick up the pizzas and the hostesses were not friendly or helpful with us ordering pizzas for our friends. However, we ordered about 6 pizzas and Caesar salads which were all good. We also ordered a gluten free pizza. The restaurant is a semi upscale pizza place. Pizzas are a bit bigger than personal sized. read more

We had a wonderful dinner at this place. Both the food and the service were outstanding. We ordered pasta broccoli rabe with sausage, Marsala, and the stake. The Marsala was cooked with amazing wine and vinegar sauce. The stake was tender and the broccoli rabe was sautéed to perfection. Our waiter Paul was very kind and passionate to welcome us to the town and introduce us to the dishes. Definitely recommend! read more

See all

Millrock is by far the best restaurant in the area! I have eaten at many of the best Italian restaurants across the country and I can easily say that Millrock is my favorite! We had a large group and decided to do their catering so that we didn't take up a large portion of the restaurant. The process was really easy and they were extremely flexible. They reached out to us about a week before to confirm our order and everything was ready exactly when they told us. The fresh bread was out of this world. It was so fresh that it was still extremely soft the next day! The Caprese, Lobster Ravioli, Chicken Parmesan, Eggplant Parmesan, Penne Alla Vodka, and Fettucine Alfredo were AMAZING! I'm not exaggerating! The highest quality of food. Nothing was greasy, oily, or watery like some other places. If it's available the Lobster ravioli is a must-try! Big chunks of lobster inside with a delicious lemon sauce. Everyone in our group had a shocked reaction to how good it was. We will 100% be back over and over again! read more

See all

Millrock is fantastic. We love Justine and John and the entire staff. The food is always fantastic and now that they have a bar all I can say is yes, please read more

Recently visited the Mill Rock for our first dining experience since starting quarentine in March and it was the perfect spot. They have moved to outdoor dining which was very much appreciated. The parking lot has been transformed with tents to block the sun or in our case the rain. They easily have 20 tables outside of various sizes to accommodate various party sizes. They tables are distanced making for a comfortable experience. Now onto the food we had pizza which was great as well as pasta and a the lemon chicken which were all delicious. Everyone was really accommodating and checked in to make sure we were doing okay. They also had to go pizza kits and were doing pick up if you arent ready to outdoor dine yet. Thank you Mil Rock for everything. If you are passing through make sure to stop by and support this great local business. read more

The food is always delicious here. Excellent service and cozy atmosphere. Our favorite when we are in town.

This is food! Ah-MAZ-ing from walking in to leaving. The owners, Justine and John are so sweet and down to earth. They will make sure you are happy. The entire staff were focused on the service we received and that was very apparent. Portions are dinner and next day's lunch worthy but you will have a really hard time not eating it all way after your belly is full because it is that good and you just won't want your meal to end. You absolutely cannot go wrong here. So until everything opens up go right now and order take out... When it opens, make a reservation because I can very easily see them booking quickly, there's nothing to not like. Thank you for an amazing time Justine, John and staff. read more

My FAVORITE restaurant in town! We come to Windham a lot for work and always make sure to go here. They give you bread with olive oil to eat while you wait for your food (for free!). My favorite dish is the orecchiette with pesto, but the marinara is also soooo good! I know it sounds plain and simple, but it's the freshness that makes it taste so good. And we always get the house red wine, also tasty! read more

Delicious food at a quaint spot in Windham! This was our first visit to this restaurant and we were very impressed. We started with a simple tossed salad which had a nice light balsamic on it. My husband got the special which was a baked eggplant parm that looked so delicious I wish I weren't allergic to dairy. Speaking of allergies, the staff was very accommodating and I was basically able to pick anything I wanted off the menu and they made sure that there was no butter or cream included. I ended up getting the chicken with mushrooms over bucatini and it was totally delicious. The staff was incredibly nice and attentive too, despite the fact that they were pretty packed. The owner came over to check in on us as well and everyone made us feel very welcome. Would definitely return for a meal here the next time we visit the area. Keep up the good work! read more

Cool new vibe in back room. The Tap room still smells new. Bartender Mark was quite the character in a great way. But best of all, our food was out of this world. I had the shrimp. Hubby had the amazing veal chop. Everyone was so nice. Met some great folks that night. read more

Always a great experience and great food. Service is spot on. One of our favorite places.

I ordered take out for a group of almost 50 people from Millrock Restaurant and the food was amazing. People had seconds and thirds. Everything was very tasty specially the Chicken parm, Lemon Chicken and eggplant parm (which was outstanding). Incredible Italian food! Customer service was also 10/10. Staff are super friendly and extremely helpful. read more

A large group of us (arrive early and put your name down ahead of time) visited Millrock in early fall. The small restaurant can be deceiving, because the many tables about can hold a large quantity of people. Service was attentive and helpful and didn't mind explaining the specials multiple times to our group. Our food was exceptional l, and we all left happy, full, and excited about our return next year. From the appetizers to the main entrees - millrock knows how to pack a punch. read more

See all

A nice spot in Windham. Because of our party's size, we have to be in the bar room. It was therefore a bit noise. The food was pretty good and reasonably priced. The wait staff did their best to work with our party and that was appreciated. Nevertheless, it has come across that the restaurant is short staffed. I will definitely revisit but may not have a big party with me. read more

Still dreaming of that shrimp pasta! So good! Must try and family friendly for my boys. We will be back.

The food isnt good, the cheese is stringy and tastes like plastic and the pizza tastes like cardboard. The wine tastes like it's watered down. We added caramelized onions to the pizza and it came out covered in onions and when we complained and asked for a new one the waiter seemed annoyed and didnt even apologize. A woman standing at the front who seems to be in management stands there giving people uncomfortable glares from the moment we walked in. Don't waste your money nor time. read more

Amazing service and food !!! I recommend white/ red mussels, pizza, rigatoni !!! The desserts were to die for!!!! The ambience was perfect ! First time here!! Recommend coming to check this place out read more

We Ski Windham every Winter.... Have never had a opportunity to visit. So mad we missed it each time. We were greeted by the Owners 11yr old Grand Daughter (Hostess) she was a breathe of Fresh Air....! Loved the vibe, our server and above all we had the most delicious dinner. Highly recommend dining here, you will not be disappointed. read more

Excellent Italian food. Excellent service. Dishes are huge. Can't be happier with a restaurant. Thank you very much. *Calamari is crispy on the outside and tender on the inside with tasty mildly spicy marinara sauce. *Seafood lovers dish with pasta is great with pasta and HUGE. WE ARE HOOKED. read more

Delicious wood fired pizzas and Italian food! Warm bread with olive oil to dip in served and an extensive wine list. You can see the open kitchen from the dining area and watch them making the pizzas! Lots of tables had ordered the steamed mussels so they must be good! read more

Millrock Restaurant - Seasonal vegetable pizza - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

See all

Many restaurants try to make dining an experience, but few succeed. The owners, John and Justine Gulino nailed it! Millrock has an inviting dining room with view of the kitchen and the eclectic brick oven from any table making you feel like you're part of the action. The staff is attentive, but not intrusive and cover for each other when needed. You will find both owners engaged and jumping into help. The menu will satisfy any palate. We started off with an order of Caprese and a small, thin crust pizza. Both were just the right size so not to fill you up. For the main course, my son had Veal Scallopini with spaghetti while I indulged in a Branzino fish stuffed with fennel, baked and served whole like back in the old country. If you're looking to cap of a great day of skiing with a relaxing and fulfilling dining experience, the Millrock Restaurant is a great choice. read more

Honestly I love the Millrock. It's a nice little Italian spot in the heart of Windham. I've been coming here for years and it never lets me down. Very nice atmosphere and even nicer staff. If you are in Windham and you are looking for Italian this is the place! read more

The Food and service was great. The restaurant was crowded and had a great atmosphere. The server was outstanding. A nice craft cocktail Manuel and some classic pasta dishes done very well. A great stop in Windham. read more

After over a year working remotely in Windham this restaurant repeatedly meets or exceeds my expectations, every time. The menu is incredibly diverse offering a lot of options for the picky eater and the portions are generous for any dish. The atmosphere is very welcoming and the staff is very friendly. I was also pleasantly surprised just about every dish from pizza to pasta can be made gluten free!! This is rare! Of all the places I have dined in the area so far this was the best. Don't miss the bar addition in the back if you are looking for a slightly more intimate atmosphere, it is great for a date night. read more

Owners son was so accommodating and attentive. Cute little place with delicious food. The penne vodka was delicious as was the veal parmesan and piccata. Definitely recommend this lovely restaurant. Update for this cute super sleepy town. read more

This is one of our favorite restaurants, but every time I order eggplant parm, it's served undercooked. I stopped ordering that and have been happy with everything I've ordered since. The addition of the bar/pub in the back of the building, along with outdoor seating was a stroke of genius and very well done. It is quite popular and it seems every time we go, there's someone we know who is also having dinner there. They are also very accommodating - we've had vegan friends that often have trouble ordering at some restaurants, but they have made some very tasty vegan dishes that our friend enjoyed very much. I don't believe they take reservations, but still very much recommended. read more

Best Italian food in the area! Fresh ingredients, amazing daily specials and friendly service. Get the stuffed rigatoni if its on the special menu. All pizzas are made to order. They have gluten free options, and are flexible to your special requests. No reservations, but worth the wait. A staple in Windham, New York. read more

See all

Ordered dinner for takeout here tonight. First of all both my husband and I called yesterday and left a message. Never got a call back. We did get a call back tonight and picked up takeout. We used a gift certificate our kids gave us for Christmas in 2018. The woman that gave us the order was nasty, questioned the validity of the gift certificate and why it was from 2018. Very rude. We took the order home and it was cold and subpar for the $50+ price tag. Will not go here again. We were insulted by her attitude about the gift certificate and the food was not worth $50. read more