Another wonderful experience at this wonderful restaurant! Stopped in midday to get out of the heat wave for their "Happy Hour" at the bar with Lindsay, an absolute sweetheart! Excellent food, great prices, super staff! The steak was cooked to perfection, tender and tasty, served with seasoned fries! The cauliflower bites were their usual outstanding! Fried Calamari and the Caesar salad was very good too! Overall, a great experience and highly recommend this place to everyone! You won't be disappointed! read more

Prominence restaurant - Fried Calamari w/Marinara - Steakhouses Near Me - Windham, New York

See all

Great experience from start to finish. Food was excellent and service friendly. You can tell management really cares. Definitely recommend. read more

Came back here for my father in laws B day. Still so nice. We were early but welcomed to have a drink at the bar. Had two drinks then sat at our table. Lovely staff and food was delicious. Looking forward to our next stop. Def a great spot to eat and enjoy a nice meal and conversation. The bartenders are very friendly and lovely. read more

See all

Now that Prominence has been open for a while, it seems like a new place from our last experience. It's quite popular now, gets filled up (especially on weekends), so we typically opt for dinning at the bar (which I actually prefer - it can be quite social). The service has been quite good and everything seems much better organized and running like a well-oiled machine. The food portions are quite large. My wife and I can share a main dish and still have leftover. However, the food is just ok. not bad, not bad at all, but nothing inspired. I'm sure a lot of families that come here appreciate the portion sizes, but I'd like to see some higher quality food offerings. The bartenders are great and I have no issues at all with the drinks - they're quite well balanced and tasty. So, overall, I'd say it is an solid option among the other restaurants in the area, though somewhat standard fare. read more

Greeted quickly and the waiter was very nice. One of the owners stopped at our table to check on our satisfaction. Extensive drink list. Known for their seafood brought in fresh from New Jersey. Ambiance was airy and open, but not noteworthy. She had a shrimp cocktail with 7 shrimp that she loved. I had the spaghetti and meatballs. We didn't love the sauce. High end meals with high end prices. Caters to a finer palette for sure. read more

I got the branzino fish - it tasted previously frozen and soggy. The sauce was too watery, only the vegetables were good. My husband got the chicken parmesan which was too thin, dry, over cooked and the sauce was too sweet. He only ate two bites and gave up. Based on our dishes he didn't even want to try anything else. My daughter (12 yrs) got spaghetti and meatballs, we asked for the kids meal twice and they still brought her an adult size meal which she didn't eat half of. Salads with the meal were plain and uninspired. Would never go there again. read more

Excellent Italian in the area! Penne a la vodka was delicious and the earthy mushroom pasta also had great flavor. Finally the bolognese was delicious as well. Price was a little high but overall the meal was great. read more

This place got that old school vibe, linen tables, live music, waiters all friendly and attentive...and the food is tremendous.

What a lovely restaurant .... We sat at the bar last night and greeted and served by lovely and friendly bartenders . Let me tell you they know how to make cocktails and how to host customers. Owner was a nice gentleman and he visited us and asked us how was everything. Delicious food very representable dishes yummy dessert read more

See all

As usual, we had an amazing meal at Prominence. The food, service and atmosphere is perfect. Thank you!

Food always excellent and fresh Service always friendly and kind Ambiance always buoyant and bubbly read more

We came here for a group dinner for 15 as part of a girls trip / bachelorette party. Food was great! Ambiance was fun and the staff were extremely friendly. Would definitely recommend especially for groups!! read more

On May 25th, 2025, I hosted my sisters Bridal Shower at Prominence. To say it was incredible is an understatement. The atmosphere, food, service and drinks were just amazing. I had the sangria and OMG was it FABULOUS. The chicken francaise was moist, the penne Ala vodka was the best on the mtn top and the family style appetizers were delicious. We had rice balls, eggplant rollitini, a smoked meats and cheese platter and meatballs. We definitely did not leave hungry. Thank you to the Prominence crew for making my sisters special day as perfect as ever. read more

See all

All the stars go to the Food! The food is very good here~ we started with the oyster champagne and they were outstanding. Our salads and entrees were excellent as well. But the service is so slow it will keep me from going back again anytime soon. read more

Good service, very friendly staff. The food from eggplant rollatini, caesar salads, calamari and complimentary zucchini straws were excellent. The portions for the pasta dishes were so generous! This was excellent Italian food and I'm from NYC! They were kind enough to let us bring a cake in for a birthday we were celebrating. Highly recommended! read more

See all

Another amazing meal! Called while we were en route and was able to get a reservation! Our waiter was fabulous, splitting an adult size salmon entree for our children. I had the mussels in white wine sauce and it was delicious! He could sense that my kids were tired and he made sure we were in and out in an hour. The owner Don stopped by the table to see how we liked our meal. Wonderful restaurant and cannot wait to come back! read more

Prominence restaurant - Veal chop Parm - Steakhouses Near Me - Windham, New York

This has been a favorite place for my husband and I since they opened and we have had visited here over a dozen times. Food is exceptional with large portions. Ambience is interesting and the friendly inviting service is beyond reproach. A welcome hello from Don and Miguel are always a highlight, and we enjoy speaking to them. Large portions so prepare to have some take-home leftovers for another tasty dinner. read more

Great addition to the mountain. The veal chop parm is the real deal. Highly recommend. Frequented the location twice and must say the food is high level. Also had the tomahawk steak , along with mussels fra diavolo appetizer. Both were very good. Service was attentive as well. read more

Prominence restaurant - Veal chop parm - Steakhouses Near Me - Windham, New York

Excellent restaurant. Food is brought in fresh daily. Very nice staff. Food and drinks are excellent overall. Owners always say hello. Always a positive experience. read more

Great new spot! Had the veal parm, some shrimp cream sauce pasta dish and calamari - all wonderful. Will be back again! read more

Food and service was great. Restaurant is very loud and the tables are very close together so be prepared to meet your neighbors at the next table whether you know them or not. read more

All of the above. The food was very good and so were the Bourbon Sours. The service very good and the Ambiance was very nice

Good food!! Not so good waitress. Service was meh. We did not feel welcomed by our waitress, she seemed agitated and was passive aggressive. The owner of the restaurant went around to greet everyone and was more welcoming than the waitress herself. Our group came up for a weekend and were looking into dinner options around the area. This restaurant seemed promising and located close to where we were staying. We were seated immediately and put in our order. Food was a slow to come out and our waitress Sam was almost nowhere to be found most of the time. We waited an hour before asking sam for an update on our order and she seemed agitated when we asked. She informed us there were two large parties ahead of us, which is fine. We would've appreciated an update on our order. We were okay with the waiting time but there was no update or acknowledgement on why the wait was so long even after we noticed a table that came later received their food earlier. The service was not good from our waitress but everyone else was super sweet. We saw lipstick on our napkin and we were missing plates and utensils. The food was great!! The penne alle vodka is a must try. We got calamari and the burrata for starters. Calamari was good, not too rubbery and lightly battered. The burrata has sardines in it and it made it a deeper flavor. For entrees, we ordered the chicken parm, chicken Marsala, penne alle vodka, linguine and clams and rigatoni bolognese. All our entrees came with the house salad, which was really good. Overall, the food was great but the service not so much. read more

I went during happy hour - EXPENSIVE! The food was fine - I paid $30 for a tuna tartar appetizer - excellent. The rice balls were tasty but small sized. The staff was very very nice and attentive read more

We've been waiting to try Prominence for many months during the construction and it certainly did not disappoint after our recent dinner. Food: A+ Large delicious portions of excellent Steaks, Veal, Chicken, Pastas, Fresh Fish and so many other dishes and daily specials like Soft Shell Crabs and crab claws. The Veal Chop Parmesan and Filet Mignon were our favorites. Ambiance: A+ We ate at the huge square bar that's seats 28 people comfortably with 4 massive 63" TV's on each side to watch sports. There was also a live Piano/guitar player that had the whole bar crowd singing and dancing. The bar area also has a huge wood burning fire place which will be great for next Fall/Winter. The dining rooms also looked well appointed with nice industrial hanging lights and additional fire places in some of the dining rooms. I also noticed a huge outdoor patio off the bar which will be used for outdoor dining and a fire pit once the weather warms up. Service: A+ The restaurant was packed on a busy Saturday night and the 2 Lindsay's behind the bar were amazing bar tenders. They are true professionals at their craft. The owners also frequently checked on us and take a lot of pride in their new restaurant. You can tell they put a lot of attention into every detail of the restaurant design which is gorgeous and fits in well with the Windham NY area vibe. We will certainly be back many times to enjoy this spectacular new addition to the Windham dining and bar scene!! read more

See all

Delicious meal and excellent service! We will be back again and again! Wide variety on the menu. Spaghetti and meatballs were wonderful. Definitely try the tiramisu!! read more

Everything from making reservations, being greeted at the door, being seated, going over the specials was 5 stars. The food is better than any seafood restaurant ive been to. I Had the oysters with crab meat in a lobster sauce which was as good or better than Julia Childs cooking. The red snapper stuffed with crabmeat was a large portion as well as fine taste. The owners greeted us and made us feel welcome! Highly recommended! read more

Prominence restaurant - Oysters with crab meat and lobster sauce - Steakhouses Near Me - Windham, New York

See all

Well I have been to many restaurant's in many countries and in the US. I was appalled by the help mostly the waitress and waiters. We picked a night that they had the restaurant filled by a party and was still taking in walk-ins. They should have turned away people. That would have been better than waiting two hours for food. Along with eating outside with only two heaters and we were not seated by one. So besides being cold and asking for napkins as well as other utensils.. Along with having to wait for a glass of wine because they ran out of glasses.. One of the owners kept walking around to check on everyone and give explanations why they were backed up. What I would have done is started to get my hands dirty as a owner and help the staff get things right. Some tables got some free drinks along with desert very inconsistent. We got offered free glass of wine however it was not the same wine as what we were drinking. Oh and one waiter was the bread delivery and it seemed as though he was consistently walking around placing bread on the tables we received three without asking. Confusion. My suggestion would be to train your staff better in what they should be doing! Also turn away clients if you are out of one chef and have a large party going on. Your reviews will just keep getting worse. I had the meatball app with was very good!! Salad was great. Dinner was a 7 by nine I was to cold and ready to leave. I would give them one more shot to get it right & will give a review after that. When you pay good money for going out you like to expect more! I hate to have an experience like this. I want the best for any owners and enjoy going out to eat. Hopefully this gets read and they step up. read more

Great food and service. Piano man rocks!!!! friendly staff from the second you walk in to check in. Bar is always lively and the Lindsey's are the best!!! read more

Food and service was amazing. We met the owner and he was extremely friendly. Would highly recommend! read more

See all

Service was discriminating. Arrived 10 minutes before close and there were several people at the bar and at tables. Everyone turned around when we walked in. A woman behind the bar says can I help you guys? My husband asked if they were open. The woman turns to a heavy set bald man who was sitting at the bar and says "it's up to you, you make the call" the man looks us up and down and says "no Im sorry guys were closed". Despite there still being people behind them in tables with food and drinks at their tables. All we wanted was a drink and to buy 10 bottles of wine for a wedding the next morning and everything else was closed. It was extremely embarrassing and hurtful to be turned away. We were visiting from out of town but told all of our family and friends about the rude encounter and they will not be going to this establishment. read more

Went for the first time tonight. Food was delicious and service was excellent! A complimentary appetizer was sent to our table. Delicious egg plant and chicken parm! read more

Went there last night. Was greeted with a warm welcome. When we sat down at our table for 8 and ordered drink we were surprised to have complementary rice balls and meatballs brought to our table, that were fabulous. All the meals came with a salad. Our table ordered Fish, lamb chops and chicken dishes all were cooked perfectly and tasty. We were greeted after our dinner to see if everything was good and see if anyone had any suggestions. Highly recommend this restaurant and wish them good luck. read more

Can't wait! What a beautiful spot, terrific views, California bar with inviting stone fireplace. Preliminary menu looks great!

My family and I came in on Sunday 01/19/25, it was during the snowstorm and it was pretty busy but we were willing to patiently wait and it was understandable! However our experience was very unpleasant! Our server Devin was really the main issue! He messed our order up twice. My son ordered steak which came out overcooked and when it was mentioned our server did absolutely nothing to fix it! He proceeded to walk off three times while he was taking our order so no wonder it came out wrong! And then later on into our meal we seen him screaming in the face of the hostess!! I was appalled by the unprofessionalism and felt so frustrated for the young lady he was screaming at in the middle of the dining area which was filled with people! She was running around helping everyone, busing tables, and ev with the restaurant packed, she managed to get us seated in a timely manner and even moved things around to make us more comfortable! She was probably the best experience of our entire dinner! The food was pretty good and so was the atmosphere but our service from our waiter was appalling and I do hope there was some sort of consequences for treating another staff member the way he did! I do recommend eating here, but hopefully you don't end up with Devin as your server! read more

Another good addition to Windham. Sat at bar. Caesar salad and spaghetti and meatballs were good. Will certainly go back. They've done a really nice job renovating from Chalet Fondue. read more

Excellent food, service and ambiance, reasonably priced by today's standards. We'll be back!

Amazing food, service & ambiance! We tried different dishes, all cooked to perfection! The presentation was great, the flavor was mouthwatering. Right amount of seasoning. The staff was friendly, attentive & made us feel welcome. Best bartenders, Lindsey & Lindsey If you're in the area, do not miss this place! You're sure to make new friends! read more

See all

Date night! Had to try for first time due to great great reviews! Staff: Welcoming, polite and ready to accommodate without suffocating. Giving great service, attentive, knowing specials and giving recommendations. We ordered the calamari for our starter. It was served hot and perfectly cooked. Not rubbery and tasteless. Was fresh and could still taste the ocean! The marinara sauce was also delish! Ordered the 16oz sirloin medium rare. Came with a perfect char and actually medium rare! . The beefy tase was clear and there was enough char tase to make it perfect! Was tender and juicy. Ordered the chicken marsala. The chicken was juicy and tender. Not at all dry. The sauce however was not as expected. It was more like a beef based mushroom gravy. It had a sweet beefy tase with a mushroom undertone. There was no marsala taste. Marsala is supposed to be made with butter, garlic, shallots, marsala wine and mushrooms with a chicken stock. Even though the chicken was perfect the marsala sauce was not as expected. Experience: The over all Experience was wonderful. We ate outside on the patio on a beautiful night. One of the owners came to introduce himself and was very kind. The food and quality was very good. The price was reasonable and will definitely recommend. Will return again to try more! read more

This beautiful restaurant had a few hiccups when first opened, but now is in its stride. We sat at the bar, masterfully tended by Lindsay, and had the Linguine Porcini, which was expertly seasoned and delicious, and the Osso Bucco which was gigantic and perfectly cooked. The food is truly exceptional-so glad we have this treasure which was long in coming! At another visit we had the calamari which was also excellent. The service was swift and thoughtful. read more