Millrock is such a special place. The staff is so sweet and really make you feel so welcome as soon as you get there. Inside is a vibe - moody and dark. The drinks are really good and the food was really delish. We got a pizza which was actually awesome and then chicken Marsala which was reallllly decadent. Overall, highly suggest. read more

Millrock Restaurant - "Just Right" before dinner - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

In town for my sisters wedding weekend which also happened to include my moms birthday. She couldn't stop bringing up the Millrock so we had to try it! The hostess was so kind, she kept wishing my mom a happy birthday and checking in on us throughout the meal. Our server seemed a little overwhelmed, but to be fair we were a party of 9. Near the end of our meal he seemed to recruit help from a couple other servers. The food was incredible! I of course had to get the penne vodka pasta. I was a bit bummed when they wouldn't let me add a protein to it, but it was still delish. Since it was the holiday season, I had to try the peppermint chocolate martini. I was worried it would be too chocolatey but it was perfectly balanced with a peppermint rim! read more

See all

Ok been here some times now and it's always amazing. Staff is dead on. And the place is so nice. Great date night or family dinner. No reservation so it's good to come early. The food is amazing and I will make this a go to spot for now on. read more

See all

Our waitress and food were great, be prepared though if you have a larger party there is a $750 spend minimum that is hidden on their website that they will not mention if you call and talk to them. Didn't tell us or mention it until we were ready to pay, very upsetting way to end dinner. read more

Beautiful space, but hospitality is lacking. Slow kitchen. Prioritize large parties and big checks over smaller parties. Overpriced. Drinks are watered down. Food is mediocre. They say they don't take reservations, but clearly do for larger parties. Act like well behaved children are a waste of space. Really sad...it has so much potential. read more

went here on a whim with my boyfriend. the food was amazing. the burrata starter was HUGE we basically had our entire fill on the appetizer. the hostess Kim was so friendly and gave us an amazing table turning a 4 top into a 2 top. thank you Kim! read more

I'm still trying to figure out my experience here. Everyone was friendly. The waitstaff was attentive if not flying through the dining room at a pretty impressive clip, you may never see the same waitstaff arrive at your table twice. Very busy, loud... I'm just so confused about the food I was served. I have to admit I was resting on my laurels and complacent, but I figured "chef knows best" in most cases. Anyhow I ordered the Pugliese, which was supposed to be "Cavatelli tossed with sautéed broccoli rabe, Italian sausage, shaved Parmigiano, garlic, and toasted breadcrumbs". It was missing Parmigiano, garlic, and toasted breadcrumbs. Had I checked the menu after I had tasted it, I'd have sent it back. What I received was cavatelli tossed with sautéed broccoli rabe, Italian sausage in a bowl with green pasta water. I just figured the dish sucked and the chef was a hack, turns out he's just forgetful which is kinda worse. This should have been caught at the service expo and never made it to me. Should have kept the menu so I could have done something in the moment, but the couple we were with seemed to be having good time and I really didn't want to rock the boat. I suppose it should be said that my partner's Scampi dish was incomplete as well (no garlic, lemon, salt, butter, or sear on the shrimp that I could see), but she said her shrimp was cooked well enough to not mention it. The scampi pasta had the same pasta water at the bottom of the bowl issue my Pugliese did, so she only ate the boiled shrimp. Neither saw a hot pan in retrospect. Are all these reviews real? Or am I just the first person to ever order and review this dish? Replace it. 36 dollars for pasta water italian sausage rabe and cavatelli is a scam. 3/4 of us took to go boxes, and not a single one of us went back to eat it. read more

Not good and pricey. My family ordered 2 pizzas for pickup. I wish they would have told me they were selling Tostinos... tiny little 10in pies with a smattering of cheese and a light drizzle of tomato juice. Just a disappointment. The staff seemed angry that I was picking up the pizzas. $19/pie! I looked at the bill and they'd added a 5% charge for a credit card. They didn't mention it, just thought that was okay. Nope. The place inside looks cute. So that's a positive. But the food? Small portions, medium quality ingredients (sauce from a jar and cheese from a zip lock bag) and honestly just not very well prepared. The middle of the pie was droopy and soggy while the edges were hard and flavorless. TL;DR: Not good at pizza. I don't suggest pickup. read more

Millrock Restaurant - Tiny baby pizzas for kiddos for only $19! - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

See all

After waiting 30 minutes for a table (they don't take reservations), we literally waited one hour for our dinners to arrive. The waitress never checked back... Eggplant parm. and chicken marsala were passable, nothing remarkable, and surely not worth the wait. read more

We hosted our rehearsal dinner at Millrock Restaurant and were really pleased with how it turned out! It's a family-run restaurant that was able to accommodate our group of about 40 people with ease. Eddie helped us plan a great menu that everyone loved. The chicken parm and stuffed pasta were big hits! The evening felt relaxed and welcoming. We would recommend Millrock for any group gathering or special occasion. read more

Maybe my pizza standards are too high, maybe I got too excited when I saw that pizza stove, because the pizza really fell short of any expectations. Very average at best. The staff is very friendly and attentive. Lots of wine and drink options to choose from. Prices on the high end given the lack of flavor. Location is perfect if your coming off the mountain. Beautiful views from the dining room. read more

Millrock Restaurant - Garden Veggie Pizza - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

We visited Millrock this evening. The menu specials were amazing! All prepared with creativity and balance. Grilled artichokes on a red pepper purée, octopus on a bed of fava beans, Caesar salad, grilled clams (perfect), bread pudding for dessert! All just perfect! Great service and loved the ambiance and new decor. Beautiful art work on the walls! I will go back!! read more

Anticipated a great experience we were rushed from the moment we sat down. Uncomfortably rushed. Then rushed out. No one came to the rescue despite complaining 3 times. Food just wasn't that great. Off the list which is a disappointment considering it's a cool and place. Get it together and pay attention to your customers! read more

As soon as we walked in we were greeted .This was our first visit to the Millrock .The ambiance was warm and inviting .Our server was very friendly .She was helpful with the menu and told us all about the specials. We ordered several appetizers for the table. Our dinners were delicious and dessert was great also .Our server was very attentive .We had a great night with friends with fantastic food . read more

See all

This is hands down my favorite restaurant in Windham. The service is impeccable from start to finish, the owners always make their rounds to make sure you're enjoying your meal, and the space is so cozy and warm. We started with off drinks; I had "The Hugo" which was an Italian Spritzer with prosecco. It was very refreshing and paired perfectly with the meal. We didn't order an appetizer but their bread deserves recognition in this review! They serve their bread warm with a really high quality olive oil and fresh cracked black pepper. I could eat an entire loaf of this bread in one sitting. I usually have the bolognese which is one of the best versions I've ever had but tonight I had the Rigatoni Alla Vodka. To me, this is the perfect vodka sauce because it's more tomato based than cream based so it's a bit on the lighter side. I added chicken to it and it was grilled to perfection! I was able to try the Mussels Bianco and the Vegetable Medley salad as well which were both incredibly tasty. The broth for the mussels was so rich while also being light and the vegetables were grilled perfectly on the salad. My experiences I've had at Millrock just gets more and more elevated every time we go! read more

Millrock Restaurant - The Hugo - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

See all

Great food, amazing service! Place was busy for the long weekend but we never felt rushed. We came for dinner on Saturday and loved it so much that we came back again on Sunday. Between the four of us over the two days, we probably tried half of the entrees on the menu. Everything was yum! But let me rant about the service... as we were about to leave, I asked the owner who was hosting where I can pick up some fruit for breakfast tomorrow. She suggested a place down the road, which was helpful. Two minutes later, she came to our table with a box of blackberries, strawberries and an orange! She gave us food out of her own refrigerator!!! Talk about a proprietor who cares. read more

Millrock Restaurant - Gift from owner - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

Delicious. I had the penny, a vodka and my Beau had lobster ravioli... Don't know how we missed this place before read more

Pay attention to your bill. They hand write everything and will overcharge you $1-2 per item. When inquiring about it they only admitted to one overcharge. Otherwise the food is not bad. read more

Phenomenal service and staff, food was outstanding! Ambiance was perfect. Highly recommend!!!! read more

See all

Take out | Dinner | $20-30 WARNING: PUBIC AND PERSONAL HAIR FOUND IN OUR FOOD. If I can give this place a -1 rating I would. I have to say that I have never in my life experienced such a horrible take-out service. I honestly felt completely disrespected with the quality of the food and the over pricing. I spent $64.00 on 2 Shrimp Scampi and about $12.00 on "Roasted Veggies". Here were my issues: 1. The Shrimp Scampi had absolutely no flavor, the spaghetti pasta was extremely undercooked and the shrimp was badly overcooked and had noooooo flavor. When I bit into the pasta it tasted like I bit into Chalk. I literally took one small bite and had to throw both orders away. My little sister of 8 years old could of cooked it better. 2. The " Roasted Veggies": I asked them if they had Roasted veggies, the woman said yes.... when I returned back to my hotel 30 mins away, the Veggies were 3 small pieces of oily broccoli and about 9 pieces of green peas. But what was most disgusting about this order was that there was PUBIC HAIR in my food. It seems like they did that deliberately. My wife and I were speechless. We couldn't call back the restaurant because we had no phone service and I was not going to drive back 30 mins to return it. They would have been closed by the time I got back to Millrock the nastiest restaurant in Windham. 3. Packaging: The packaging had hair on it as well. My wife and I just wanted to have a nice Saturday dinner and we went to Millrock because we saw the great reviews on the food. But honestly, I feel this was done deliberately. We went into the establishment respectfully and even told the lady in the front (whom I think is either the manager or owner) that we looked forward to tasting the food because of the great reviews. This truly ruined the great Saturday we were having. I felt disrespected and will never ever return to this establishment. Note to Management: Treat your customers with respect at all time, even when it comes to take out food. We did not want to eat at the business because we rented a beautiful cabin and wanted a romantic dinner by ourselves. This order was a complete nightmare and thank God we didn't eat any of it. I had a fear that the dishes were poisoned due to the PUBIC HAIR and all the other hair within the packaging. You guys stole our money and lost our respect. We went in there kind and looking forward to eating your food. I wouldn't feed your food to my worst enemy or any animal. Horrible horrible horrible service. read more

See all

Friend and I came during a weekend trip from the city. Outdoor dining patio was spacious, and they ensured distancing between tables. As soon as we sat down, they brought a bowl of water for my pup. They also sat us in a sunnier area, so they made sure to move the shade for us so the sun wouldn't be in our faces. The food was excellent (and the portions were enormous). We shared the caprese, which was fresh and tasty. It felt like it had something missing - which I realized was balsamic vinaigrette. They brought us some upon request, and the caprese was now perfect. I had the spaghetti bolognese and my friend had the spaghetti puttanesca. The sauces for both were hearty, flavorful, and plentiful. I think I had enough for 1-2 more meals. We shared the chocolate mousse flute for dessert. Despite being extremely full at this point, I couldn't stop eating this. It was a very classic and delicious chocolate mousse, which is exactly what we wanted. The service was excellent throughout our meal. Given the quality and huge portions, the price was definitely worth it (I'm also a bit biased because I'm used to Manhattan prices, but I still appreciate). A great place for a nice and relaxed dinner. I would go back if I stay in the same area. read more

I used Millrock to cater my rehearsal dinner for my wedding and would make that choice over and over again. First, the food was absolutely phenomenal!! I am from the tristate area and being that most of the rehearsal dinner guests were from northern NJ and NYC area, we all have high expectations for Italian food. Millrock blew our expectations out of the water and everyone couldn't stop talking about how good everything was! Aside from the food, the second best part of Millrock is their staff. I worked with Eddie to create a custom catering menu and he was so easy to work with. He always answered all of my questions promptly and had no problem in changing the final menu multiple times (he dealt with a bride with true grace). I can't thank Millrock enough for their impeccable service/food & I am excited to eat at the restaurant in person when I am up in the Windham area next! read more

Friendly staff, hits and misses with the food. Went with the surf and turf special last night - this was about as poor as it gets. Nothing was seasoned - almost positive they just threw shrimp and steak on a pan straight out of the packaging. Poor excuse for surf and turf and at $45 mind you. Stuffed rigatoni - phenomenal. This dish is truly delicious. Would come back here time and time again just for this! Will try again. read more

An excellent restaurant with great service and good food. We were a party of six and we all enjoyed our meal very much. I had the chicken parm with pene. We also had pizza, calamari, and Caesar salad. Everything was fantastic! As a New Yorker, I was particularly impressed with the pizza. The portions were perfect. The chocolate fudge cake knocked it out of the park by the way. Thank you to our waitress Kelly and also Justina for checking in on us throughout the night! read more

See all

Had my daughter & new son in laws 18 guest intimate Wedding Celebration in the Bar Room at Millrock Restaurant on 11/2/24. Fantastic Ambiance, food & service. Comfortable seating, people could get up & down from hi top chairs with ease to talk to others around the table. Also option to use the patio with heaters with comfortable seating. Family style portions were generous & all servings were not rushed. Each dish was fresh & delicious. Eddie offered us to have a wedding playlist played on Bar speaker, personable touch including being able to dance to their wedding song. Best way to go during these hard financial times. Intimate wedding with family/close friends. Eddie, his parents & all servers could not be more down to earth & friendly ! read more

My wife and I went here for our last dinner while staying in Windham, and we felt very welcome when entering and talking to the staff. We'd not been here before, and I was wondering if we were walking into a cold, overpriced, snooty place; but that wasn't the case at all. We chose to sit outside in the back area, since the tables in the main room were occupied, and a heater was provided. Service was quick, friendly, and conversational, the low-light atmosphere was pleasant, and the food was delicious: my wife got a penne dish with salmon, while I got bolognese with orecchiette. I think we'll be back one day. read more

Great food, wonderful service and chill vibes Caesar salad was awesome and I loved the lemon chicken!! My son loved the pizza and lemon sorbet! read more

recently visited this place again ordered pasta waited about 40 minutes still didn't arrive i finally motioned to the owner and complained ended walking out with out dinner they obviously have a kitchen problem then i went back 2 weeks later ordered salmon and a side of pasta tomato sauce both totally tasteless so this my last time at this joint i tried this place is used to be great when rocky was the owner/chef sorry guys! read more

Sorry to say seriously declined since we were here two years ago. Service excruciatingly slow. Pasta dishes have lost their snap everything is eh at best. What a pity. read more

This place is a chaotic, inhospitable mess. If you're quoted an hour wait, expect that it will likely be much longer - people linger at their tables for ages to listen to the live music in the backyard, but then the host doesn't communicate simple options like the ability to sit inside immediately. And don't expect apologies for any delays or miscommunications. I was holding back tears of hunger by the time we were seated 1 1/2 hrs after arrival - I got some empathy from 1 of our 2 servers, but no offer of free appetizer, round of drinks on the house, etc.? My husband and I have both worked in food service and were appalled - our only conclusion was that the owners must be penny-pinching, and didn't allow their staff to make easy calls like that to improve diners' experiences. I recommend going to Tabla or Mill Pond Inn instead, where you can make a reservation and you are treated like a human instead of a cash cow. read more

We came as a party of 5 on a Saturday 7pm and it was jammed packed!! We were provided an 45 min wait which we obliged. While waiting, they kindly provided complementary pizza slices to their guests who were waiting. When we arrived, we waited some more until we were seated around 8:15 and when 9pm rolled around, the manager walked over and offer complementary salad for the table. By 9:30, our meal finally came! Glad we waited because my pasta alla vodka was delish. The sauce was so creamy and I wish I could have finished the whole thing. It seemed like my friends also thought their dishes were delicious with the exception of one who thought the pasta was bland (perhaps it was her choice in veggie pasta?) 1 star loss due to the excessive backup of the kitchen but exceptional service to keep their guests happy!! read more

Millrock Restaurant - Rigatoni Alla Vodka - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

Local Favorite! Great pasta dishes, fried Calamari and real wood fired pizza. Service is best on the mountain!

Hands down the best Italian restaurant in the Windham/Hunter area. We come to mill rock once every couple of weeks, and it's the highlight of our weekend. This time (last night) the three of us (plus baby) ordered: The burrata- one of my faves The baked clams- small but delicious The white pizza with fresh arugula (from their garden) prosciutto and balsamic glaze- the guys LOVED this. Mains: Broccoli rabe, penne allá vodka and stuffed rigatoni vodka. All excelled but I think we all agreed our favorite main was the penne. Dessert: NY cheesecake and creme brûlée. DEFINITELY get the creme brûlée- you won't be disappointed. Service is family run and you can tell by how well they take care of each guest. Absolutely must go if you're in the area read more

Another great evening at Millrock. Had the stuffed rigatoni & my wife had the mussels. We sat outside & listened to Lex Grey. The combination of music, drinks & delicious food made for a perfect evening. read more

Millrock Restaurant - Lex Grey & my wife - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

Food was underwhelming. Not worth it for the price. Service was the same. Did not match the ambiance of the restaurant at all. Quite rude at times and no smiling at all. read more

Waiter Eddie is awesome Give us plenty advice on wine food etc. I had the weenie with clam sauce excellent. One young lady set us at our table very professional and attended to her every needs with bread water etc. My fiancé had this Alfredo penny over salmon oh my God it was so good I think there was mushrooms in it and artichokes. Plenty of food we had leftovers. read more

Millrock Restaurant - Salmon with mushrooms and Penny Alfredo - Italian Near Me - Windham, New York

See all

This was our first time at Millrock Restaurant, I had the Lobster Ravioli and my wife had the salmon, both were off the hook and the service was excellent, but they fill up quickly so get their early. We will definitely be back for more! read more

Millrock is now under new ownership. I wish we could all disregard my previous review from 8 years ago, but it's hilarious - and it serves as a beacon of just how much this place has changed for the best. This establishment is now a restaurant of fine dining, and the only one of which Windham has to offer in terms of Italian cuisine. Amazing staff with impeccable service, fantastic food, and an aura that's eager to please. 10/10 would recommend. read more

I used Millrock to cater my rehearsal dinner the night before my wedding at Windham Manor and it was absolutely amazing! The entire process was so smooth, and everybody was so helpful and kind from start to finish. The food was absolutely DELICIOUS and my guests were raving about it for the rest of the weekend. I would absolutely recommend Millrock for any catering needs or just for a nice dinner spot while in Windham. My husband and I will definitely plan to return to this restaurant when we visit Windham next time!! read more

Food and service always fabulous. The staff is so friendly and accommodating. We had stuffed shrimp and salad. We also enjoyed key lime pie and cheesecake with strawberry sauce read more