Which is more important to me? Food or service? Well, I want both, and Pomodoro's delivers. On my recent visit I ordered fried calamari and boneless wings, both to go. The order took longer than expected and when I opened them at home, the calamari was room temp while the wings (wrapped in foil) were still hot. I reheated the calamari in the oven and ate the entire order -- delicious. The wings were what I wanted: hot, lots of chicken with little breading and great sauce. Employees have always been the best. read more

I usually love the pizza tonight something was wrong the pizza isn't cooked right there was like One pepperoni for each slice, the crust was so tough to chew felt like the cook didn't know how to make a basic Sicilian pizza correctly, So besides 25 dollars for the pie I have to rate this as please teach the cook the proper way to make a Sicilian this is a special pizza and needs to be cooked right Ty read more

I just ordered two chicken Parmesan heroes. I think they only use the one cutlet for a full sandwich and they chopped it up. The taste was good but no chicken. It was ridiculous. Very disappointed... $15 for a sandwich with hardly any chicken. read more

Extremely disappointed with one of the daily specials, the Reuben Panini. This was honestly one of the worst sandwiches I've ever been served at a restaurant. It barely qualified as a Reuben--there was almost no meat, barely any sauerkraut, almost no cheese, and it was mostly dry pressed bread. The presentation was equally poor, looking rushed and careless. For something advertised as a special, it was completely underwhelming and far below expectations. Definitely not worth the price, and not something I would order again. read more

See all

Two cold raw slices of pizza and a small Pepsi for $12 and the guy working the counter couldn't manage to pay attention long enough to finish ordering two items. Last time got a chicken parm sub that was barely passable as school cafeteria food. Hopefully I will be smart enough not to go back. read more

When we first moved up here, Pomodoro's was really a pretty good place to go get a good pizza. As well as a dinner visited there last night. Order a pizza and it was one of the worst pizzas I've had had there It all depends on who's making the pizza when they have a guy who knows what they're doing. It's good last night should've got my money back on that one. read more

Food is great , service is good. We've been going there for years, But do to health issues we have tried to get take outs from there. We haven't had much luck, the first time we ordered four dinners we got home and had only three, the second time we ordered four dinners that came with salad. I told the girl that answered the phone we wanted house dressing, I got home and had no salads at all. If you get takeouts be very careful and check everything read more

Delicious food. Pizza is amazing. Nicole is an outstanding waitress who is super attentive and very nice. I'm from downstate NY and always enjoyed the old Joey's Pizza next to Jamesway/Ames. Glad that Pomodoros has kept their delicious pizza recipe all these years. read more

Pomodoro's - Delicious penne ala vodka. - Pizza Near Me - Catskill, New York

Pizza was hit or miss Sandwiches were ok but on the soggy side that day. Like Paul's, I guess it depends on staffing. read more

Amanda was our server and she did an excellent job. The food was good... but the calamari was absolutely amazing. Possibly the best I have ever had. Worth going here just for that! The place was very busy - even considering it was 3:30 on a Thursday afternoon. Excellent smaller-portion lunch specials - VERY reasonably priced! I could eat that calamari again right now! read more

we arrived on a sunday afternoon to get some italian food. They have a special there for two dinners and appetizers for 39.99. I got the garlic chicken with penne and broccoli and my wife had the pasta with meatballs. Both dinners were delicious and we had to take the extra for another day. The waitress was quick to come over and take care of us.We also had soup and mozzarella sticks before our dinner.. Both soups were good.,I had the french onion and my wife had the pasta fagioli soup. We've eaten at several italian restaurants and they didn't compare to this one. read more

See all

Food was excellent, served quickly and piping hot. Pizza was amazing! Don't remember our waitresses name, but she did a great job.

GREAT ALL AROUND PLACE. Food was so delicious and savory. Don't get me started on the damn garlic knots. waitress was a smoke show. absolutely stunning. she even let me play with my teck deck (mini skateboard). would highly recommend. read more

My partner and I always enjoy coming here for their lunch specials. Our bill came to a total of $35 dollars and we got a lot of food! We started off our meal with a nice salad, and again, it's a lot! Try the house vinagrete, it's delicious. You can't go wrong. Their bread is amazing too. Very garlicky and buttery. Our pasta were delicious too. Our waitress, Lisa, was wonderful. Very down to earth, polite, funny and most importantly, caring! When I asked her name she said "Lisa like pizza". Absolutely loved her! read more

See all

Best Italian around. We live locally and love going here. We had them cater our wedding last weekend and our guests lived the food. Affordable and delicious catering. The eggplant, lasagna, penne ala vodka, and salads were our favorite! Thanks for making our wedding weekend delicious! read more

Eaten here fairly often and the food is decent, straight up American-Italian food in ample quantity. That said, do not get the calzone......a large ball of dough with adequate cheese but the filings you choose are virtually non existent. read more

Solid lunch spot in the Catskill area. Was visiting family in the area and we phoned in an order. When I got there was decently crowded which is a good sign during these Covid days. Ordered a salad and a few sandwiches, the Philly cheesesteak looked amazing but the flavor was just ok. The meatball parm and the Buffalo chicken sandwich was very good. Serve beer which is nice. People working were pleasant, plenty of room to park. Overall solid place. read more

Great food really great food great prices fantastic service. We eat there a lot ambiance is ok

I was a little skeptical about this spot, but thankfully we ended up here anyway! The French onion soup is phenomenal! The garlic chicken was great! They have an extensive menu all around. They have lots of entrees and desserts as well as beers, cocktails, and wines. I really liked this place. It's located in what seems to be a small shopping area, but it's so cute on the inside. If you're in the area I would definitely go here. Great service too. Our waitress Samantha was awesome and attentive. Very sweet girl. If I'm in the area I will definitely go back again! Good for groups, couples, or families. read more

See all

Nothing but great things to say about this place! I ate here with my mother and we were very satisfied. I ordered a caesar salad with pasta fagioli and she had the spaghetti with meatballs and a side salad. Food was excellent. The soup was perfect for a cold night! We ordered a carafe of wine too and it was so affordable! This place was recommended to us from someone in Leeds and now I'm recommending it to anyone looking for a warm Italian meal! Service was great and very professional! Thanks Pomodoros! read more

See all

In a town with a lot of Italian restaurants, they take the cake! Fresh Italian and great every time. The atmosphere is typical of the Italian restaurant. Wine in the archways, music that you can't understand (sorry I won't assume you don't speak Italian!), and all the smells of tomato's and cheese! The food here is great! One of my favorite places to get pizza in town. I've had many of the other dishes, and they're all great! Not quite like Grandma used to make (still makes rather) but still delicious! Fettuccini Alfredo or Chicken Sorrento are my two highly recommended dishes! With a side of French onion soup of course! Give it a try, you won't be disappointed! read more

Do not take your service animals into pomadoros in Catskill. They treat you and them like crap! Tell you you shouldn't be bringing them into the restaurant. Manager included. These people all tried to rush us through our food and were extremely rude from the moment we entered the establishment. This animal is a life saving animal that can not be separated from its owner because of the owners medical conditions. just let it be known, Our food was just under $40 and we left our waitress, who was extremely nice, a fifty and told her to keep the change. The hostess, the rudest of them all, kept trying to take my plate from me and she saw I was still eating. However, didn't understand why I was getting angry. The staff, including the manager, tried to then embarrass me and started a verbal altercation with me right in the dinning room and told me I shouldn't have brought my dog in and everything would have been fine. So please don't bring your service animals into pomadoros in Catskill because they discriminate against and humiliate the disabled Americans in this country. food was good though. 1 star for food and a good waitress, one good waitress! read more

Had a hankerin for pizza tonite. Stopped here at Pomadoro's and picked up a small pepperoni & onion just for me! Asked for it well done! After a ride home, I enjoyed this pie! it was hot, cooked perfectly and beautifully seasoned. One thing, at $2 per topping you needn't be so stingy on the onions!! read more

I was very impressed! Why? I ordered a couple slices of pizza with mushroom and garlic. They sautéed the mushrooms for me and really LOADED up the slice with both ingredients. I wasn't in the dining area, but I peeked in and it's pretty spacious. read more

See all

This restaurant has been opened for years. Some of their food items are tasty, such as the French onion soup! However, the quality of the soup and other items can be comparable to the local diner. Their Italian food is OK. The quality again, is comparable to local diners. The service has gotten worse over the course of Pomodoro's years with the community. If you're looking for a good sit down, this may not happen. They do deliver to locals. read more

Got take out here tonight. Ordered two slices and a large Caesar salad. Salad looks like they took the small and spread it out in the bottom of a large container. Taste is mediocre on both pizza and salad. Prob wouldn't go back. read more

Pomodoro's - Really small "large salad" - Pizza Near Me - Catskill, New York

See all

Ordered lunch here through my job and was excited to see all their awesome pizza combinations! Friend and I decided to share one of the pomodoro creation pies. We did half gourmet pulled pork and half contadina. Pizza was very good! Thin and crispy. Very New York style. The pulled pork was very good, but a little dry. The slice could've used some extra bbq sauce or something, but I would definitely get it again. It came with a delicious spicy blue cheese drizzle that made it all worth it. The contadina was amazing. Marinated artichoke hearts with roasted red peppers and eggplant was a great combination. It was wonderfully juicy and incredibly fresh. Very, very good. read more

Pomodoro's - Left half Contadina. Right half Pulled Pork - Pizza Near Me - Catskill, New York

Had the stuffed pizza and wings. The pizza was amazing. The wings Buffalo garlic parm were great and truly an original. Good service. The wait staff were friendly and helpful read more

The phone skills are poor Every time I call the place you on hold Tonight I was placed 3 times on hold in the middle of giving our order After the 3 Rd time I spoke up We finally got our food and it was cold We have had that there also Then we got soups that was Luke warm You need to take care of your customers first Too many young kids who don't give a dam kids who don't give a dam. read more

Fast delivery and willing to find you if your a guest at Carl's Rip Van Winkles Motor Lodge and cabins! Ordered two different nights and the food was consistently good and tasty both times. Their pepperoni rolls and mozzarella sticks are very good! Their deluxe pizza was good, crust a little thin and they cut a small pizza into quarters (makes for very large pieces)! It was very heavy on the veggies, which I enjoy but scant with any meat toppings. I was disappointed with the Mac and Cheese bites because I thought it was going to be a homemade appetizer but it was the typical triangle processed appetizer. Much better left over. Their delivery drivers are very friendly and courteous! read more

I've eaten here several times and the food has always been good. I've also done pizza take out and that has been hit or miss because they are the only pizzeria in the area open on Sundays. read more

Really don't go here any more. Food is "ok" but you don't go to a restaurant for ok food. My family finally had it with this place when they lost our order. We kept asking the waitress what was taking so long and were told kitchen is busy. Eventually made her follow up, when she returned to us she said our order was lost. No apology, just let's start again. It's frustrating to watch other customers who came in after you finish and leave. You can try this place but bring a flashlight to signal the server that you are still alive and hungry. read more

I would only eat fresh pizza not reheated here as don't think they put it I. Tenoevn long enough for health standards. Pizza was fine but bad luck with a reheated slice that was left on the side got me a little bummed. Don't think I will ever be back though I ate here a lot over the years. Customer Service is huge and I always contact before reviewing. read more

If your looking for decent quick meal Pomodoro's isn't a bad option . The staff is attentive and receptive to special requests . The menu is standard Italian restaurant affair with all the staples . The food is good but not incredible . read more

Yes, I agree with the last reviewer, Mandie. I've been going to Pomodoros all the while since it opened a couple of years ago. BUT I've been dining there for several years beyond that - back when it was "Joey's", located in the dying, all but deserted, out-dated strip mall, long before the area was overcome by the retail giants Walmart and Lowe's. In the good ole' days, the pizza at Joey's was THE BOMB!! Then the new shopping center and revitalized strip mall arrived and Joey's got a much needed facelift , morphing into what we now know as "Pomodoro's". For their first year and 1/2 as the new and improved "Joeys", the food was just as good as the old Joey's. The service was great, and the newly remodled restaurant was just lovely and very comfortable to dine in. You would walk in through the front door and think to yourself "THIS used to be Joey's?". What a difference in the decor (Joey's was a little run-down and very out-dated). BUT, the last 6-7 months have been a disappointment, overall. On our last two visits (mid-October and December 12), the service has really been "Eh". We've gotten the same waitress twice now (long, straight blonde hair) and she seems rather forgetful, which is not a lucrative attribute for an individual working in the food service industry! The pizza has gone from "Awesome!" to "Pretty good", and their chicken parm subs have been rather small quite unflavorful- not very satisfying at all. "Pommies" also got rid of their Budweiser on tap, supposedly because it "wasn't selling". (Huh? Bud doesn't sell?) That sure made my father annoyed all right - he wanted his Bud on tap, dammit!! read more

I give this place a three because yeah waitress is a great place is nice spacious but I would never of guessed that like their portions would be a lot plus their food needs a lot of work flavors kind of bland a little overpowering price is kind out there would go back maybe read more

Little bit of a disclaimer: when Pommies was Joey's, it was the BEST! That being said, when Pomodoros opened, the food was outstanding, fresh ingredients! I feel the quality has gone down and the prices up as of late. The atmosphere is really nice, great for sitting with friends and catching up, good for larger groups too! They have some great deals, but some stuff is just outrageously over priced. Not all Italian food, you can get burgers and sandwiches, full bar too! read more

Went here tonight after 2 other Italian places in catskill were closed, thought I'd give their food a try. No bread baskets but our entrees did come with a soup or a salad. I really enjoyed the salad and their house balsamic. It also came with a slice of buttered italian bread. They also have pretty much a full bar. I got their khalua mochatini, pretty good, strong. I got their eggplant parm dinner with a side of veggies. Big portion but I wasn't really a fan. Thinly sliced and breaded, but I found it mushy and kind of lacked in flavor. My boyfriend got Penne Vodka with chicken and I took a taste. Probably the worst I've had. I really wish their food was better because I enjoyed the atmosphere. read more

See all

The food is okay but comes at a great price: your sanity. Take out service is simply awful. Expect to wait an hour if they say 30 minutes, expect items not to be available after you order them and you'd best check to make sure everything is there before you drive all the way home and have to come back to this purgatory of eternal waiting. I was told I'd get a full refund by one person but ended up only getting refunded for the missing entree(a kid's meal, so about $8 on $50 order.) That's something, but not enough to ever get me to go back. My whole family was tired, cranky, hungry and frustrated. Kid had to have something else to eat as it was bedtime by the time I got back. Not the first experience like this there either. read more

The food is standard Italian American fare. Decent, but unimaginative. The service however is unparalleled in its horribleness. I have eaten in 3 times and taken out twice. Eating in is marginally better. There you can be ignored by apathetic wait staff. However take out is horrible. Both times I was told it would be "30 minutes", which means an hour. Both times entire entrees were missing from the order, though paid for. Both times, the staff was unapologetic for the delay and offered little explanation or compensation for the wait. read more