Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mateo’s Pizza

    4.6 (19 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Mateo’s Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Mateo’s Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mateo’s Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    a basket of pizza rolls
    Tonya P.

    You never know when you see a pizza by the slice place, it is always rolling the dice. Might I suggest no hesitation! Head directly to Mateo's, I only ordered a Nonna's slice, square pizza with mozzarella, tomato, pesto. If a slice is good, you know a whole pie will be delicious. Friendly service, great pricing and good quality ingredients. It was a perfect slice, I might have to stop by again before I head out of the area, it is that good!

    Beef patty interior
    Mandie V.

    Couple things to note that make Mateo's different from other pizza places in the area - they encourage and USE an app/website/online ordering. And it appears they have an actual pizza oven?! Like, look at the blistering and char on the pizza and wings and beef patty!! Everything was good. Nothing was exceptional, nothing was gross. Because this was our first visit, we got a pepperoni pizza - the standard by which all pizza is measured. I saw a few things on their menu that you can't get elsewhere, always appreciate that. THEY HAVE BEEF PATTIES. As far as I know up here, they're relegated to the DrugMarts and wannabe bodegas....this was good! I would've preferred it with some cheese and hot sauce, but I'll be damned if I'm paying $1 for them to add a slice of cheese. I'll do it myself! I rounded up to 4 stars because our pizza was straight up cold. My husband said (he picked it up) that he thinks they waited to drop the wings until closer to pick up time, which is a nice idea. It was good cold, so I bet it would be really good warm. We'll definitely be back.

    Thanks Tony!!! Love the girls!!
    Jill B.

    Such incredible food and HUGE portions!!! The prices are great! And the service awesome!!! The owner is the best!!

    a slice of pizza on a red tray

    See all

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Allie M.
    289
    44
    10

    1 year ago

    Pizza, caesar and fried ravioli were delish. Food came out fast. Employees were kind and efficient!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of C ..
    0
    13
    0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Tonya P.
    1847
    691
    12238

    2 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 2
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 1
    Love this 4
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Tom M.
    0
    70
    8

    1 year ago

    Good cheese pizza. Sauce tasty and nice crust. Meat lovers looked good. Heavy on toppings. Would try again

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 1
    Photo of H V.
    0
    14
    5

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Rob M.
    0
    29
    0

    2 years ago

    Ordered pizza there Sunday 10/13/2024. Place is bright, cheerful and clean . Very nice people, excellent service and excellent food.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jill B.
    70
    16
    1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Everything is delicious! We enjoy great food and excellent service every time. Great new spot in Cairo.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Best pizza I've ever had and customer service is always on point and it is the only place I get pizza from now.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of K R.
    0
    2
    0

    3 years ago

    Excellent! Ordered Margarita slice and a side salad, both were delicious! Best pizza in the area.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Mateo’s Pizza

    Review Highlights - Mateo’s Pizza

    Most importantly, the entire family who runs and works at Mateo's are so wonderful and very hard working people.

    Mentioned in 4 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 794 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Annarella Ristorante - Meatball side

    Annarella Ristorante

    (230 reviews)

    $$$

    For our wedding anniversary, we traveled across the river to Annarellas Ristorante on 276 Malden…read moreTurnpike in Saugerties We arrived early as we were traveling about an hour away and we're aware there were many detours as the Malden Bridge is undergoing repairs.  I'd read about Annarellas prior to this, and based on glowing reviews chose this to mark 50 years together, 39 as husband and wife...long engagement! We were not disappointed. We were seated promptly by our lovely hostess, and Shaun immediately came over to recite specials and to take our orders. He was attentive and we knew we were in good hands! We started with the Dr. Fox Cocktail: Angostura bitters, Bulleit Rye, Apple Liqueur, Dry Curacao, and Sweet Vermouth, which was perfect. It was accompanied by a hummus trio to spread on the bread. There was also a delicious foccacio. Next we were served a perfect salad, delicately dressed, and what made the salad so delightful was that the lettuce was torn into manageable pieces. A pet peeve of mine is large lettuce leaves that are difficult to wrangle, and this was not the case here. There were also tiny bits of cauliflower that gave the salad a nice texture and crunch.  I had the Stuffed Artichoke and my husband had Shrimp Gamberi on an Arugula salad. Both were substantial and beautifully seasoned. We had two glasses of an Argentine Tomero Malbec. It was a generous pour. For the main course, I had Polla al Limone (Lemon Chicken) over spinach. A simple dish done well. My husband had the Halibut special, a classic Mediterranean baked halibut with tomatoes, capers, and olives. So good that he finished it all...a rarity for him. (The halibut was pricey and it would be appreciated if the price was mentioned when the specials were gone over. Perhaps we should have asked.) We finished with a Sorbetto al Lampone, a tart raspberry sorbet in a dark chocolate shell and sliced.  And as we left, our sweet hostess brought over Lucianno, the most adorable puppy, to send us off with puppy kisses! We definitely will be back...especially for the wild boar ragu over pappadelles. One nitpicking observation. The entrance to the restaurant was a tad shabby. We mistook it for the service entrance. It needs to be spruced up to match the superb food inside!

    The wild boar ragout was the best part of the meal, I would definitely recommend trying it and skip…read morethe stuffed hot Italian peppers. Usually I like to pick what dishes are considered popular on Beli but I really wanted to try them, they're just too hot and not very satisfying to kick off your palate. The bread was okay, a little (very) messy and the hummus trio was cute but not necessary or particularly tasty. The pollo al limone and gamberoni e fagioli were good, a little dry but not a deal breaker. Service was nice, the place is pretty casual so I would recommend for a regular casual date night, it's not fine dining--the experience was nice but not luxurious. What I mean is it's cozy and inviting, not elegant and stuffy. Cheers!

    Via Cassia - Summer seasonal pasta

    Via Cassia

    (36 reviews)

    We were excited to try Via Cassia during our visit to Hudson over the MLK holiday weekend, and it…read moredidn't disappoint. We arrived right on time for our 7 P.M. reservation, to a room that was warm and buzzy. We chatted briefly with Meigan, one of the owners, who was absolutely lovely, before being seated promptly. I ordered the gricia, which was divine (mine never turns out this well!), and my husband had the squid ink pasta with scallops, which he loved. We then shared the flat iron steak, which was cooked perfectly. We also enjoyed a few glasses of a Tuscan blend, which was just the thing to complement our meal. All in all, it was the perfect Saturday date night dinner, in a cozy, romantic setting. We trudged through the snow, back to our hotel, happy and full. We'll definitely return.

    Had a lovely meal at Via Cassia, which welcomed us with open arms at the end of a long workday. We…read morehad walked by Via Cassia a number of times before dining here, oftentimes seeing folks enjoying Aperol spritzes at the outdoor tables having what seemed to be a relaxed and joyous time, which made for a very compelling advertisement. While it was too hot to sit outside when we dined here, we made sure to start with a couple of Aperol spritzes, which were delicious and exactly what the night called for. I wouldn't say the food was as mind blowing as many of the reviews have described it to be, but it was still very good, albeit a bit inconsistent. We'll of course need to return to sample more of the menu (particularly the pastas, which we did not try on this occasion). We came here at around 8:30pm on a Wednesday night. When I looked online, I saw reservations opens throughout the night, so I didn't end up making one, mainly because we weren't sure what time we'd make it out for dinner. As it turned out -- mostly like because it was Wednesday and many places in town are closed -- Via Cassia was packed and there was nothing open when we arrived. We ended up sitting maybe 15 minutes later so it didn't end up being much of an issue, and we made sure to put in an order of Aperol spritzes to sip on while we waited. Food-wise, we ended up going the protein and veggie route and forgoing the pastas. I usually don't give much attention to pastas at Italian restaurants because I'm gluten-free, but through my thorough review review, I saw that Via Cassia offers gluten-free pasta and that it is heralded as quite good. I happened to not be in the mood for pasta on this particular night but it seems like that is where Via Cassia shines, so I'll know better next time. What we had, as I mentioned, was still solid though. Eats, below: Black Tuscan Kale Salad w/ honey and black truffle vinaigrette and ricotta salata: A+ Far and away the best thing we had. I honestly could have had three of these instead of the two veggie sides we got, and that's a lot coming from me because I'm always out for the most variety possible. The lacinato kale was so fresh and delicious and held the magical and heavenly dressing in the perfect way. The ricotta on top made it that much more decadent (decadent for a salad, at least). Grilled Quail w/ lemon yogurt and roasted corn: A- Always excited to see quail on a menu. The amount of protein was a bit smaller than we were expecting and while cooked very well, it was definitely underseasoned. However, the corn, yogurt and all other accompaniments were super flavorful and delicious, and when combined with the quail in one bite, it altogether worked very well. Halibut w/ cherry tomatoes, roasted summer squash, cucumber: B+ Similar to the quail, the halibut was fairly bland but the accompaniments were well-seasoned and flavorful, and paired nicely with the fish to make for a well-rounded and tasty bite. I appreciated the use of seasonal ingredients, as bright and colorful as they were fresh. Broccolini w/ black garlic mustard and pickled chilis: B Beginning to think someone had a bit too light of a touch on the salt or something on this particular night, because the broccolini was also lacking some flavor. All components were there and you'd expect with this preparation to have good flavor, but it wasn't quite there. Also very oily. Roasted Baby Carrots w/ honey and pink peppercorn vinaigrette: A- Oily again, but more flavor this time, making it somewhere between a B+ and A-. The vinaigrette itself was light and tasty -- the oiliness seemed to mostly come from what I imagine was involved in the roasting process. In any case, an easy fix, and these were otherwise very good, a hit for my partner in particular. We split the negroni (made with Malfy gin, which I hadn't heard of before) at the end of the night because we wanted to try it without drinking all that much. Highly recommend and splitting one will not feel even close to enough. Next time I'll be getting a whole one for myself, no sharing allowed.

    Rip Van Winkle Brewing Company - Portobello panini. Yummy

    Rip Van Winkle Brewing Company

    (218 reviews)

    $$

    Finally was able to stop here on the way home from Hunter mountain and officially found our new go…read moreto spot for aprés ski. There is a huge parking lot located behind the brewery/restaurant with ample parking. We were seated immediately on a Saturday evening and brought menus and drinks. We ordered a few appetizers to start and if we were still hungry we were planning to order more. The chicken wings here are an absolute must. The chicken is tender and moist with a crisp exterior. The Cajun sauce was similar to buffalo but packed a better kick. We also ordered the Bavarian soft pretzels and garlic knots. The garlic knots were so light and fluffy and the marinara sauce was well seasoned and extra garlicky in flavor which we both enjoyed. The Bavarian pretzels were so good on their own they didn't even need the beer cheese or mustard dipping sauce. We were stuffed and did not have room for any more food. Can't wait to come back and check out the rest of the menu. Pricing is extremely reasonable as well.

    Definitely a new staple of mine! Rip is such a great space for lunch, dinner, or inbetween drinks…read morewhether after being on the mountain or during the week. So lively with easy dining and fast service. We got the blincess and one of their special chicken cutlet sandwiches with burrata, vodka sauce, prosciutto, pesto and it was absolutely delicious! Still thinking about that sandwich to this day. Would love to go back for one of their pizzas as well as they serve different styles! Ambiance was great, easy for large parties or small gatherings and the servers were super nice.

    Savona's

    Savona's

    (70 reviews)

    Love Savona's! We live in NJ but visit this area 2-3 times a year and always make sure we can dine…read moreat Savina's while we're here. Ambiance is lovely. Outdoor dining in the summer is perfect. Food is consistently delicious. For Valentines Day they had a regular menu and a special menu so you weren't forced into expensive food. The wait staff is great! Very attentive.

    While in Hudson for the weekend, we stopped into Savona's on our last day. We wanted to get some…read morelunch before hitting the road home. Didn't have a reservation but it was the middle of the afternoon so we were able to get a table right away. We were sat in a back room which is part of the dining room. It was a little small but it appeared that there was another dining area downstairs. Bernie was our server and super nice. She quickly came over with breadsticks which was a happy surprise! We ended up splitting the Gorgonzola Stuffed Figs -- small bits for sure, but good for sharing. We also ordered the baked clams oreganata which was my favorite. I typically don't go out of my way for a Cosmo but started out with Ceil's Pear Cosmo - it was SO good. For dessert, I ordered their Valentine's special which was a Chocolate Covered Strawberry Martini. This didn't hit the mark for me with the strawberry chunks. I wish I had ordered another pear Cosmo. Savona's was not the overall vibe I wanted for Valentine's Day dinner so I am glad we came here the day after for lunch. This would be a great place for a big family dinner! Wait staff including Bernie were all super friendly.

    Tabla Catskills - Everything was delicious.

    Tabla Catskills

    (96 reviews)

    Tabla was a quaint little place. Very small seating area on the main floor but seemed to host…read morelarger parties upstairs. The drinks were very balanced and sometimes felt too boozy (maybe I'm just sensitive). The food hit it out of the park! Everything was so flavorful. The staff wasn't super helpful or knowledgeable.. one of the dishes we had ordered had sausage in it and I asked if it was spicy or sweet sausage and she looked at me and said I think it's pork. It was a serious wait what moment ‍ like of course it's pork but is it spicy or sweet? It was sweet haha but we'll definitely go back if we're in the area again.

    BEWARE OF HIDDEN FEES!! I wish I could give zero stars. We…read morehad a group of 11 for my friend's birthday and the experience was a disaster from start to finish. The service was not good. Although our server was nice, she was often slow and not readily available. She and other runners/servers did not bring many things we ordered/asked for. 1 friend never got his side of pasta for his entire meal, another did not get his glass of wine when others who ordered at the same time as him got theirs. My girlfriend had to ask 3 times for a steak knife and we were constantly begging for basic items like drinks and ketchup. The predatory billing practices here are shocking: 20% Automatic Gratuity: ok, this is not unusual for large groups in many resistant, but clearly explained why the staff felt no need to actually serve and take care of us. 10% "Living Wage Fee": A mandatory tax on the customer because the owner refuses to pay their staff properly! Never experienced this fee firsthand only saw it online. An absolute joke to expect us to give an extra 10% to your staff because you're not paying a reasonable salary! $30 Cake Slicing Fee: We brought a birthday cake. They stored it and brought it out, but we ended up taking it home without them ever touching or slicing it. They still had the nerve to charge us $30 just for the "privilege" of having it in the building. When we spoke to the manager about the 10% surcharge, he acted like we were the problem and talked about how they are trying to make a living. We were all asking ourselves why he's not paying them a fair salary?? why is it our responsibility to pay even more, particularly for poor service! The food is fair at best and wildly overpriced. Definitely go anywhere else as this place is an overpriced tourist trap with lousy service!

    Mateo’s Pizza - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...