Loved everything we ordered. Cannot wait to return next time I am in town! Ordered a few pizzas, wings, and salads - service was prompt and we were in/out quickly! read more

Surprisingly great considering lower ratings! Delicious pizza, the most fun and friendly server we've had in a long time, and great spot in town for sitting outside and people watching. Our server Juan was awesome, and we had come in as a large group of 9 and he jumped right into helping get a table setup and having a group of chatty Italians all trying to talk to him. Pizzas were tasty- we got the Popeye and the godfather. Manicotti was enjoyed as well as the mozzarella salad/antipasto, which came with huge pieces of mozzarella. Meatballs were not for me, more on the big/mushy side, but I think they're also used with pasta/sauce so makes sense. I'm more about a seared meatball, so just a preference! They are technically cash only but have an atm as well as take cards with a fee. Worth a visit while in Woodstock! read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

Nice pizza place in Woodstock out of a cottage-esque building! Came here for a quick slice before going to a music show and it did the job! Not too many specialty slices to choose from but the slices we did get were pretty good. No wow factor but hit the spot. We did come at a relatively busy time so I could understand the In-and-out attitude but the service was a little unorganized and the workers weren't the most welcoming but it's a no-fuss stop if you're around and are craving some pizza! I heard good things about the rest of their menu as well and would consider coming back to try! read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

Like I said, it's cardboard in a box of cardboard. And! They have the audacity to be "cash only" . With pizza looking this grimped out I'd take any form of payment. read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

I'll admit that I may not be the target audience for this down-to-earth pizza spot - I prefer artisanal, elevated experiences. But there are plenty of folks who enjoy a nostalgic guilty pleasure, and for that, this spot delivers. Our ready-made slices were quick to warm up, and we were handed them on paper plates that were immediately soaked through with oil. The glistening grease and takeout-vibe stood in contrast to the dining area in the back, which had checkered tablecloths and sit-down tables offering the small-town take on a "nice dinner out". There's also a 3.99% convenience fee for credit card payments. read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Slices - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

So I have to admit, the people are not the most friendly people, but the pizza is the best around the Woodstock area. Also a plus if the gluten free pizza! read more

This is a spot beloved by many locals for a very long time. If you are looking for gourmet bougie pizza, then one look at their menu and website should clearly show this isn't the place, so shame on those writing bad reviews for that reason- do basic research before you go out, folks! The cheese slices are revered by many people from the city to the boonies and are one of the best you can find anywhere in the area. They also have reliably good Italian American food. I personally like the "spa chicken burger," which is a ground chicken burger, but I also really enjoy the mushroom pizza. The bar is an extremely popular local watering hole where you can catch up on all of the local news and gossip and generally be extremely entertained by the fantastic long-standing staff. It's a family run place, which goes a long way, and they have a great beer selection both on tap and in cans and bottles. They also have a full bar. They do fun trivia nights and have live music regularly. The prices are also unbelievable in this day and age and allow almost everyone to be able to actually go out to lunch or dinner and get a decent meal without breaking the bank. Even when they get fancy beers, despite my own urging, they refuse to raise the prices because they want everyone to be able to continue going there. Case in point, their lunch special literally cannot be beat and feeds a big chunk of the community on a regular basis. Lastly, despite the many recent reviews claiming they only take cash, they definitely take credit cards. Sure they were late adopters, but they have been doing so for at least a year or two. I use a credit card there frequently. They do charge a fee, but so does pretty much everyone else on the planet at this point. This place is a gem and an important fixture in our wonderful town. read more

Asked for a pepperoni pizza well done and it was super solid!! Recommend this place to anyone in the Woodstock area looking for pizza read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

I was very surprised by this pizza place, we were looking for a slice after a long drive and it was a good decision, at first we saw them in the counter and they didn't look that big or that appealing but once they hit up it was definitely worth it! There is a parking lot which makes it easier to grab pizza on the rode, attention was fast and the slices are great! They have a nice set up outside for nice weather where you can just enjoy your pizza ! read more

See all

Catskill Mountain Pizza Company Woodstock, NY: Let me count the ways to justify my love in rational terms by expressing my desire to explain my heart on an intellectual level. Meat, cheese, and bread are all that is required for the dopamine plunge that is necessary to unlock my love. 10% off with the VIP Card www.ulstereateriesunfiltered.com read more

See all

It was a great place to get lunch! We got a margarita pizza and the Sicilian garlic bread and they were both delicious! Really friendly staff too! read more

Horrible pizza and pretty bad service. It's hard to understand how a pizza restaurant that doesnt known how to make pizza can stay in business especially in a tourist spot in New York. Unbelievable. This place is an embarrassment and should be ashamed. Anyone who thinks this pizza is any good doesnt know good pizza. read more

Came here for lunch today and had their 2 slices and 1 soda special for $6. Pizza was excellent, slices are pretty big, staff is friendly, and seating is ample. I would come back here again. read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

Service-VERY UNFRIENDLY, bordering on rude! Food- was excellent! Major kudos to the chef cooking on 1/10/26!! I took a large party after a concert (I cleared it a day ahead that we would be coming) and was super grateful they took us in late. I also called our order in earlier in the day to streamline the process. However, from the phone call with the waitstaff AND manager to the in person experience they were wholly unfriendly and made zero effort to hide their annoyance at our presence. read more

really good pizzas. gluten free crust was pretty good. perfect pizza takeout experience. read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

The pizza was way over done and inedible. See picture. It's not difficult to look at what you're serving before giving it to the customer. I can't recommend. read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

The food here is amazing, been coming here since 2005 . My only serious concern is how hard it is to actually pay for the food. Its baffling that in 2025 this business is still cash only..this in itself would be ok if there was an easily accessible atm in the store, however the past 5 times over the last year i have gone there they have been out of commission forcing me to walk to cvs down the road. Honestly it is the primary reason for not going there weekly. I hope they fix this soon because the quality of the pizza is unrivaled in this area. read more

As a local I've eaten here many times. However, it's gone downhill and the pizza is NOT the same size as it used to be and no flavor. I ordered a pizza to go and asked for jalapeño and mushroom. I got BANANA PEPPERS,,,,,nasty. The price is higher than ever and quality is lower than ever. CASH only? read more

This is a solid 3-star pizza joint, as long as you adjust your expectations. Your standard slice, or cheese or pepperoni pie, is perfectly serviceable. Same for the burgers, wings, and salads. Pick "specialty" pizzas or add extra toppings and you are looking at gooey, soggy dough or missing key ingredients. Prices have gone up over the years, but so has everywhere else. I've been coming here long enough (mostly out of convenience) and have had some excellent food to awful food. Service is average to good, with occasional bad attitude but nothing egregious. Parking lot can be a nightmare (accident waiting to happen) so just be extra careful. read more

Cute and cozy place in the heart of Woodstock. Indoor and outdoor seating. Friendly staff, and there was signage to warn that service may be slow due to staffing issues. Service was on the slower side for a late afternoon on a weekday, but we weren't in a rush and it was lovely to sit outside. The Brooklyn style pizza can be ordered by the slice or whole pizza, and plenty of options for toppings. Delicious and large slices. We enjoyed the Classic which had sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and black olives. The combination calzone was a pleasant surprise and the star of the day. The ricotta was amazing! We also had fresh basil and garlic inside. Plenty of parking on the street or in their parking lot. Cash only! read more

See all

Good pizza & pasta! Exactly what you want out of a pizza place, thin NY slices with good topping options. Pasta & Caesar salad were good too. Prompt & friendly service. Definitely would go back! read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Cavatelli pasta with ragu & garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

See all

Came in to order some slices to go and loved the no-frills vibe of this place. There were ample choices of pizza slices available for purchase (even at around 9pm). The smell inside the pizzeria was delish and the flavor of the pizza itself matched that. The slides were huge and had the right ratio of sauce to cheese to toppings. The crust had a great bite and the price point couldn't be beat - around $3 for a gigantic slice! Staff were very friendly and worked quickly so that I was in and out in no time. read more

Best pizza I have ever placed in my mouth, my brother and I were in New York for a few days and we saw they had vegan pizza we went in and were nicely guided to our table I ordered the cheese and olive with tofu create your own pizza and my brother ordered the Nuevo vegetarian pizza, We had water brought to us immediately and pizzas brought short after, once we saw them they looked bigger than small pizzas should look and once we tasted them tears were cured upon that first bite, and it was a very calming place and my brother and I agreed Juanie was the best waiter we have every had and I would recommend this pizza place to any pizza lover. Have a great day read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

See all

Tucked away in beautiful "upstate" New York, this restaurant offered a number of unique pizzas and craft beers. After a long hike for several hours only miles up the road, we found an outdoor table, ordered a round of sour beers and ordered several pizzas (a total of 3 for three hungry men). The pizza margherita was simple but tasty. It contained fresh mozzarella, pecorino romano cheese, crushed tomatoes and sliced roma tomatoes which you can easily appreciate. The crust was regular style, not too thin nor thick. Also ordered a few beers. The restaurant has an interesting "hybrid" style: order at the register, eat outside (or inside) and pick your drink. The beer selection was awesome! Included a few unique IPAs (Southern Tier IPA, Peak Organic IPA) and Pilsners (Lagunitas, Glutenberg). A great spot that overall feels quite "local." read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Pizza margarita - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

See all

Though we are in the area often this was my first time dining at Catskill pizza. The place was clean the bathrooms were well kept and sanitized. And the customer service from the staff was a plus. Juan was Awesome he was behind the bar but came out greeted us and had great conversation, Don't remember asking our waitress her name. But she was super friendly and provided quality service. The pizza was so tasty and looked amazing when it arrived. The crust was not super thin but a perfect thickness. Each size has enough for your crowd are dinner date. The small medium and large has enough slices so that everyone can have seconds. A young man named Damien was also working that night. A bright young polite young man. I chatted with him about school and peer pressure. Not knowing his parents were present that evening. After she introduced her self. We all chatted. After meeting his mother you realize where this kid got his amazing energy and spirit from. I highly recommend this place for a cozy dinning experience and great conversation from some pretty awesome people. read more

See all

Driving through Woodstock and needed to pick up a quick dinner and a pinch. Almost didn't stop in due to some bad reviews but glad we ignored them. We got multiple slices and they were all top notch! Delicious, fresh ingredients and the dough was perfection. Too bad we live over 100 miles away or we would make this our go-to spot. read more

I've been eating here for as long as I can remember. I practically grew up with this place.. hell, three generations of my family went here. This restaurant is good in person but everytime me or my family has gotten takeout or delivery something always goes wrong. Around a week ago I got a chicken Caesar salad for pickup. I got it without croutons, but what I didn't think I'd get it without is every other vegetable that they used to put in the salad. Normally it comes with onions, peppers, tomatoes, etc. and this salad had nothing but limp lettuce, dressing, and chicken. I'm not the person to demand a refund or a meal comp, but I'm very disappointed and have given them one too many chances. read more

Great people, food, atmosphere, cozy bar and service. Expect nothing short of a nice experience.

Apparently this pizza place has some spectacular reviews from years past and, as a diverse group of individuals representing multiple areas of the country, we decided that pizza or pasta sounded like a grand way to end the evening. That we were wrong about that assumption was only the least of our experiences with Catskill Mountain Pizza. The parking situation with this restaurant is a joke. Trying to leave the parking lot is a danger to the oil pan of any vehicle smaller than a jacked-up monster truck full of backwater mountain strippers. In attempting to back into a parking spot, made nearly impossible by the lack of parking skills of the locals, we were polite enough to allow several vehicles to pass us by before starting our careful penetration into the space behind us. Suddenly a huge truck appeared out of the smell of mountain air and pot to block us in while the shriveled up woman behind the wheel berated our driver that we couldn't park next to the building itself--despite the lack of any intention to do so on our part. She appeared to be mentally deficient in reasoning skills to understand our explanation of trying to park in the open spot she was now blocking with her attitude and her truck. After negotiating the narrow space and finally making sure we wouldn't be a rage target by those parked adjacent to us, we made it inside. The bartender/waitress was attentive and helpful. Then we discovered that the crone of evil from the truck in the parking lot was an employee of Catskill Mountain Pizza! We were sure that she would be in the back spitting in our food. Worse, the food was inedible out of the kitchen. Not all of it, fortunately, but two of five meals (a Calzone and a Pizza Roll) were cold as ice. No joke. No exaggeration. Cold. As. Ice. It was only offset by the 80s soundtrack over the sound system that ironically was playing the Foreigner song of the same name. That should have been our warning. Of course, by the time Whitesnake's 'Heat of the Night' came on, the rest of the food was delivered and it was at least warm. The cold food was returned slightly heated up but finally edible. Barely. The rest of the food lacked in some way. The Chicken Picatta lacked flavor. The Manicoti (and the spaghetti dish) had a water puddle at the bottom of the dish. The bottled Ginger Beer was acceptable. By the time the bill came, they got that wrong too, but the waitress was wonderful to help us out and make sure that everything was right (with our bill, at least) by the end of the night. Overall, Catskill Mountain Pizza is to be avoided. While it is possible that this was an off night, the presence of a ghoul that roams the parking lot in an oversized truck accusingly pointing boney fingers at patrons before they can even get properly situated in the punchline of a parking lot turns this 2-star rating into a 1-star rating only because a negative 10-star rating isn't available. read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

First let me say I have had many meals at CMP, both inside, take out and delivery. I have never felt that a food review was warranted, the entrees and pizza were always enjoyable and appreciated. Tonight we ordered a couple of entrees, Marsala & Chicken Parm. This was not a delivery order or dine in but a pick up. Honestly this was absolutely a "Catastrophe", both in quality of food and arrogance of the employee at the register. Let's start with a simple salad that comes with the $60+ 2 entree meal. As ordered 2 salads with blue cheese dressing, well the salad delivered was one large, not 2 individual, ok that's fine. The blue cheese dressing was devoid of flavor and had no blue cheese flavor, as if none was added to the recipe, if they use recipes. When inquiring to the host who took our order, I was told " you had no crumbles, that's such a catastrophe" I politely asked if someone could check to see if it was made correctly. The condensation was not appropriate. The entrees were far from adequate, a chicken parm was so dry and pounded thin it had no discernible chicken and the dish did not even include cheese on the parm? The Marsala had 4 slices of mushrooms and was had no hint of Marsala wine or flavor in the sauce? In the past these dishes have been our favorites, I probably would not have written about this experience, had it not been for such an arrogant response from CMP. I do hope you all have a better experience and the chef or owners can possibly check the quality of what's being made and served, plus stress to the front end help to be understanding instead of displaying arrogance your customers. read more

They lost my order. I paid and waited for 15 minutes before the young man told me no one made my pizza. Said it would be 10 more minutes. It is run by children so don't expect much. Oh and they only take cash and their ATM is always broke. read more

If you care about your health or just disgusted when food is handled like we are in a third world country don't eat there. Will upload the video don't watch if you think you will get offend read more

Super rude waitress! Bad wine, actually you can't call wine more like viniger. Serving whole pizza with metal utensils but paper plate? Can you cut the pizza on paper plate? I can't! There is nice place to bite around don't get upset eat there. read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Pizza on paper plate! - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

This is one pizza joint that lives up to that typical 'NY Style Pizza'. It's not artisan or Neapolitan style or from my super favorite- Patsy's in East Harlem- but Catskill Mountain, can save you if you're craving a slice in a pinch. We're usually in and out but Mountain has large enough space where you can sit closer to the entrance, off to the right of the shop if you want to linger where it's quieter, or sit outside when the weather's warm. Menu is typical with Garlic Knots, Sandwiches-and my favorite Stewart's Cream Soda- plus more. You get classic toppings here but their White and Regular slices, do the trick for me every time. Service is at times cut and dry...but I try real hard to kind of move past that and enjoy my meal. This is a 3-1/2 for me. But bonus point though- for holding it down in the heart of Woodstock. read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Texture~ [Decent For These Neck Of The Woods] - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

See all

Our fam's favorite pizza in Woodstock! We've been eating their pizza, chicken and everything they offer every Summer since 2014 :)

CMP provided ample outdoor seating which was lovely in September weather. They also offered some seating inside but not much. It was your typical pizza parlor that accepted cash only. But an on-site ATM was available. The pizza itself wasn't horrible but not great either. The best part of the whole experience was that one of the staff was very kind to our dog. She put out a water bowl for him and when she heard that he wasn't eating well on our trip, prepared a small meal of grilled chicken breast cubes, which he ate. All in all, if you're looking for cheap eats to tie you over until dinner this is a good choice. Another plus is they provide parking ! read more

My wife and I decided to spend the day in Woodstock. We love the small shops and numerous restaurants. We got tricked today . Most of the stores were closed. We learned many places close on Monday and Tuesday. So as we walked around we came upon this restaurant- one of few actually open. We were VERY pleasantly surprised. We were seated in the bar area where there were a bunch of obvious locals having pleasant conversations. The bar tender/waiter was very pleasant. He gave us menus- which contained many more choices than we expected. We studied and made our choices. I got a sausage hero and my wife ordered steamed clams - sautéed in garlic sauce. She had been talking about getting clams for over a week and was extremely happy this restaurant had them. Many such restaurants do not. We received our food and we were truly happy with our choices. The clams were prepared perfectly and the sausage hero was very tasty with enough spice to make them keep my attention. Both meals came with really fresh and tasty sesame Italian bread. This restaurant has basically no ambiance and is rather loud but the choices and food quality are so good it was easy to overlook the noise. We definitely recommend this restaurant for folks looking for plentiful choices and tasty food offerings. read more

What a neat spot in Woodstock! Only draw back is cash only, but they're very upfront about it and have an ATM in the building. Came here on a Friday night an dined in. I really love the old school pizza parlor feel, and really took me back to my childhood. They have a great selection of beers at a reasonable price, and the service was really great from getting our drinks, to getting our refills, and to packing up and paying. Decided on the supreme pizza, a real test of a place in my opinion. It was delicious! Crust, sauce and cheese ratio were perfect and the toppings were perfectly cooked and well distributed on the pizza. It was even delicious re-heating the next day! I would definitely recommend this place as a good local stop. read more

Catskill Mountain Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Woodstock, New York

See all

Delicious pizza, pasta, and chicken parm. The staff is very friendly and helpful. We wanted a pasta and chicken parm combo and they basically made a new dish for us. Cash only read more

We love the spelt pizza! Overall, unfortunately inconsistent. Dinners are sometimes great, sometimes a bit overcooked or slapped together.