Been coming here for years! 3/1/26 was The Worse Pizza Ever AnyWhere! Yikes, Yuck!!! Hard Rubber Cheese, SUPER SALTY!!! Crust was Tough & It was Just Terrible!!! omg Never Again! Why??? Used to be good! GONE, GONE, GONE!!! TOO BAD, NOT ALL CHANGE IS GOOD! Should of kept things REAL! We tossed the Whole Pie right in the Trash! Not Good!!! Bye read more

Very good pizza, even by the slice. Owned by the same family for years and the pizza is still very good. Lots of variety and friendly folks. They are located right next to where the Catskill Mountain RR crosses Washington Ave - so your kids can watch when the train goes by! read more

Picnic Pizza - Yummy - buffalo and meat lovers slices - Pizza Near Me - Kingston, New York

See all

Excellent Pizza, owner is not really nice. Don't like places where they make you feel like they are doing you a favor. Pizza 9, Owner 4.5

Tasty cheesesteak sandwich, it's not Philadelphia, but best to be had around here imho.Pizza is ok too

One of the best pizza's I've ever had in my life. I chose onions, mushroom, extra cheese and garlic (I've searched high and low for someone to get those ingredients right!) The best pizza I previously had was as a child in north beach, SF- turns out I just had to go to NY a 100 years later to find the other best pizza. read more

We have gotten good pizza here before but ordered a veggie lovers 9/27 and it was a disaster. The veggies need to be roasted to remove the water. The choices were great - mushrooms, peppers, broccoli, onions, etc. - but they were all veggies with high water content. The crust and sauce were delicious, but by the time we got the pizza home, the box was soggy (had to hold with both forearms to prevent collapse), the pieces were stuck to the cardboard, and the dough in the middle 2/3 tasted totally uncooked. We trimmed off the outer crust and threw away the center. Mostly unsalvageable. Had to give the toddler cereal instead; she is a pizza lover and wouldn't eat it. read more

I should have turned around when the counter staff failed to even acknowledge that I was standing there. I placed an order for pick up, boneless wings, garlic knots and an Italian sub. Ready in 15 minutes which was great. Unfortunately the garlic knots were missing from the order and they wouldn't deliver them or credit back my card so I have to go back to get my money back or the rest of my order. The Buffalo wings were more BBQ than Buffalo but nice and crispy and the sub bread was chewy but packed pretty well with meat and cheese. Hopefully the new ownership can improve the food and the service. read more

See all

We ordered lunch for pick up. We got a lot of food. My partner ordered the lasagna, I ordered the shrimp Parmesan, and we also ordered a side order of breadsticks, not knowing that bread already came with our dishes. Our dishes also came with a side salad. The salad was fresh, and the Italian dressing was good. The breadsticks were buttery and delicious, and we liked the sauce that came with them. It had a nice tang to it. My partner said that her lasagna was delicious. For me, the shrimp Parmesan was a little bit less successful. The linguine that it came with was good. I liked the cheese on top and the sauce that came with it was good, but I wish there would've been more of it. Also, the shrimp themselves were very good but they were way over breaded. The only way I could taste the shrimp was eating the breading separately. I would order from here again, but I would not order the shrimp Parmesan. Maybe next time I would try the lasagna or something else. For all the food we got, the price was very reasonable. Thank you. read more

Walked in and placed a to go order tonight and waited a few minutes, the order was given to me and I left. Once I got home, I realize that we had gotten the wrong order. I called up the store and they were very helpful in getting me the rest of my order. We almost didn't realize because the fried mushrooms were great, and the pizza now that it's been delivered is also delicious. read more

Overall just bad, embarrassingly bad. This is a pizzeria trying to be a pizzeria. The pizza was a soupy, sloppy, greasy mess. The dough was paper thin and they seemed more interested in cooking it as fast as possible as opposed to cooking it right There are to many other pizzerias to be this bad. Hard pass read more

3 of us choose assorted slices which were a good choice and tasty. Quick fast and reasonably priced

Great quick bites at reasonanle price when in Kingston NY. We stop here for a light lunch. They about 4 group inside when we were there and continuous stream of customers in and out during the whole 1/2 hrs we are there They have more than 15 different pizza flavor to choose from for slices. We choose Eggplant tomatoes and chicken ranch which come with a medium size of drink. . I was skeptical as they put our chosen slices to their giant oven but They re-heat our slices to melty cheesy goodness. With addition of a dash of crushes red pepper and generous sprinkler of grated parmesan.they hit the spot! We will come back when we are in the area and we will recommend! read more

Me and my mother have been ordering from here for a while now with no major issues. Tonight I can honestly say we will no longer be returning. We ordered 3 large pies one being a pepperoni pie. That is what I have an issue with. The amount of pepperoni on the pie is ridiculous. I called them to ask them if they can put more on and the man said that's how they come now and hung up on me. So I called back and asked him why he hung up and he said we have more calls I just spent $62 here and this is how I was treated. He further began to say if I wanted more pepperoni I should've asked. And I told him he should let people know only 1.5 pepperoni came on each slice. I will not be returning not only because of the pepperoni but because they have no respect for customers at all. read more

Picnic Pizza - Pepperoni pizza... or lack there of - Pizza Near Me - Kingston, New York

I was a loyal customer for years.Y my first time ordering since they changed owners will be my last. The prices doubled and the quality is down the drain. My sub was awful (dry, no sauce, no flavor) and the spinach calzone had no spinach at all, just gobs of cheese. I'm really disappointed! read more

Picnic pizza is the best NY slice in Kingston NY. I usually get mushroom with extra cheese. All their slices are delicious. The service is kind and hospitable too! read more

We have been going to Picnic Pizza for years. Loved their Caesar salad as it had great dressing, shaved parm and nice croutons. Ordered today and all we got was yellow romaine lettuce, a package of Ken's dressing and no croutons. Also always request well done pizza as we love the brick oven finish. They have changed their sausage and the pizza was wet in the middle. Far from well done. After years of going here, never again. Very very disappointed. read more

Picnic Pizza - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Kingston, New York

See all

Giving this a 4-star rating because I've liked Picnic Pizza for years and it was my Dad's go-to place! Always hot and fresh, not too doughy, etc. However...I wanted to share some feedback with them and there is no way to do that without calling. Their website seems to be non-existent and their FB page doesn't accept Messages. So...I'm posting here just to let them know that I had the White Spinach pizza last night and there were two things wrong with it (IMO). First...it had red sauce on it, making it not white. And second, it had soooooo much raw garlic on it that I found it to be almost unedible. No one needs that much garlic. No amount of mouthwash or toothpaste could get rid of the taste so I woke up with the strong taste of garlic still in my mouth. Just knock the raw garlic down a bit (and don't use red sauce on a white pizza) and I'm sure it's fine. All of that being said, I still recommend the place and I'll go back. read more

Fast delicious large slices of authentic Italian pizza... This also means NO tomato sauce under the cheese layer (so FYI for your tomato sauce lovers). Food: Buffalo chicken pizza - 5/5 - deliciousness!!! Tomato basil pizza - 5/5 - great to accompany any meat pizza Service: Real Italians with their unique American accents and their style of service Ambience: Small dine in area; rustic Italian decor read more

See all

Excellent Pizza. Good, friendly and accommodating service. Their mushroom pizza is delicious.

Wow. I went a little crazy a couple nights ago and ordered a ton of stuff. Plain pizza. Delicious. Fried mushrooms. Amazing. Super Italian Mix Cold Sub. One of the best I've ever had. Cannoli. Scrumptious. I would highly recommend this place. read more

Best slice pizza in Kingston. Chicken Francese was really good as well, nice surprise

Ordered a large pizza with half sausage and pepperoni and the other half mushroom. One order of wings cooked well with mild sauce and extra blue cheese. it cost me 40 dollars and I received a small pie and the wings were not cooked well with a packed of Paul Newman blue cheese! I wouldn't mind paying 40 dollars if the quality was good. Also, I did not see the original owner, so i think it might have changed hands! I will not be back! read more

We stopped here on our way home from an upstate trip. Picnic Pizza has friendly staff and very reasonable prices. My Sicilian slices were excellent. My son also enjoyed his pizza. read more

Not impressed at all--we were looking at the different pizzas and were rushed like there was a line behind us-- there wasn't. They still forgot to heat one of our slices and the girl rudely said -- she didn't charge us for that one. Cheese was plastic like. And over all despite red pepper flakes and garlic salt had very little flavor read more

We had a simply delicious grandma pizza yesterday evening. No nonsense. Good food. We will definitely be back.

Use to be ok pizza there, our often "no-time no budget spot". Got 2 pizzas and 2 bruschettas yesterday, paid $75 and couldn't eat it. Family of 5, not just me. It's hard to explain: crust was there and cheese was there, but it doesn't taste good anymore. Hope I just got unlucky, was a great spot! read more

I'm being fair and giving them an extra star just because the spinach pizza was fairly good. I was excited to visit this place since it came from a recommendation from a fellow Kingston resident as " the best pizza ever". Looked forward to it but instead was helped by a very rude owner; never even welcomed , and only spoken to when it was time to pay. Not even a thank you or have a good night. Customer service is a must and I would not return here ever based on how rude they are. Stay away if you actually want to feel welcomed! Plenty of other pizza establishments that I'm sure would be happy for you to spend your money with them. read more

Picnic Pizza - Worst customer service. - Pizza Near Me - Kingston, New York

See all

You craving a real deal NY pizza? This is the place to go! The wood fired oven really sets it apart from other and their pies are constant. I love their dough and the speciality slices are great for a lunch special. read more

I'm from out of town but who forgot to season or use the salt on the chicken roll I had?? Just my opinion: not seasoned, whole chicken breast....was too thick and the cheese should be replace very bland. Everything has to coexist. read more

Ordered three orders of mozzarella sticks with my pizza. Half were empty bc the cheese blew out in the fryer. Pizza tasted like the oven needed to be cleaned. I would only go here for slices for lunch when things are fresh. Owner is grumpy and ungrateful. Pizza sent me to the bathroom the next morning. Yuk. read more

Great chicken parm nice people very friendly good pizza too and going there for years very tasty food Joe is cool and so is John Vito is the Don lol enjoy reviews guys read more

Best find of the road trip! Well worth the very slight detour off 87 in Kingston. Five of us sampled the gourmet and regular pizzas offered. Large delicious slices served up by two friendly fellas. Don't let the inexpensive pricing fool you... there was nothing cheap about the quality of the food! If our travels bring us this way again, we would definitely dine here and try some of the dinner options. Thank you for a very pleasant and delicious experience. read more

Trash pizza. That's all I have to say but yelp makes you write reviews of a certain length. So I'll just repeat myself. Trash pizza. read more

Best pizza in Kingston, hands down (even if that isn't saying much). It's made in true Italian style and the marinara sauce, which is the foundation on which so many pizzas falter, is outstanding. Kudos to these guys for keeping standards high! read more

The pizza was Very good, the salad was average, and the pasta could pass for a bit above average. The people working there were very nice but tables weren't the cleanest. 4/5 stars seems like a very fair rating considering my visit. Most likely will come again. read more

Very disappointed. Recently I ordered a THIN CRUST, WELL DONE pie and it was neither !!! In fact the crust was thick, wet and "gooey" on the inside. Had to cook for 10 more minutes when I got home for it to be even remotely "well done" In fact, this was nothing more then a generic pie that. similar to something you get from Pizza Hut or Domino's. Lousy pie .... read more

Looking for a new pizza place that is more consistent. Every time we've ordered from this place it's different - seems like they're overwhelmed and just let the quality suffer. Took over an hour for delivery and pizza was soggy, greasy and chewy. read more

Love everything about this place amazing salads pizza garlic knots and my favorite joes tea. Recommend 10/10 read more

Picnic Pizza - Joes raspberry sweet tea - Pizza Near Me - Kingston, New York

Stopped in last week for pizza as i waited for my slices there was a bit if a political discussion going on. I made a comment that was interpreted as not agreeing. Whn the staff person with my order passed my slices to the owner to give to me he said i dont serve democrats. My last visit. He also commented on my earring . Sheesh read more

The pizza is fine but they have the absolute worst customer service. Every time I've been in there the ignore you forever until you're practically begging to place an order. Then they act like you're inconveniencing them. Typically that's a good sign that the pizza is good but it's just meh. They are also very openly homophobic/transphobic and conservative. Bad energy and not worth dealing with. read more