Kinda pricey for what we ordered but everything is pricey now inQ3-4 2026 (FDT) and it's no judgement against the pizzeria. Pizza was- as always- perfect! Also their Sicilian pie is amazing. Added mozzarella sticks which rocked tho the clamshell dishes melted into the food. The boneless wings were cold but yummy. Delivery was quick and easy- driver was awesome, friendly and attentive. They always provide a good dinner. read more

1/10/26 - ordered boneless wings, onion rings, and a large chef salad, with NO onions. Boneless wings is supposed to be 10 pieces, we got 9. Chef salad had a huge amount of onions which had to be removed. The person who took my order asked twice about the no onions. read more

Supper nice, accommodating, and Never been disappointed!!! Very good good even for gluten free

Tried it once or twice. I wasn't crazy about the pizza. My daughter loves it so we go on occasion. The sauce just doesn't do it for me and the pizza always seems to be over cheesed. I mean, it's pizza, so you know pizza is always pretty good, even when it's bad. And this pizza isn't bad. Just not as good as others that I regularly frequent. So I'm happy to indulge my daughter on occasion. :) read more

This is a go to pizza place in Kingston. Reliably fresh and delicious pizzas. The staff is super busy but they're always friendly. If you love garlic as much as we do, the white pizza never disappoints. read more

Good food at a great price. I was surprised when I got the spaghetti & meatball diner that the supplied salad was a salad, not just lettuce and a small piece of tomato. They also smothered the spaghetti and meatball with mozzarella and baked to melt it. For $11.95 you can't beat it. The garlic bread they gave with the meal wasn't worth the calories as my wife would say. I also ordered a side of meatballs for $5.25 and they baked them with mozzarella. That was dinner and lunch for the following day. Of course with dinner we I did have our own bottle of Italian Wine that paired well with the what 440 supplied. read more

Just called 3 times to try and place an order.I was put on hold all 3 times for over 4mins each. I'll take my business somewhere else then cause I could image how long it would for a pizza to be delivered probably a nightmare read more

My husband and I ordered the family size calzone. It was delicious, and definitely meant for a family. It took us three meals to finish it. I really liked their tomato sauce. Looking forward to going back again! The crispy crust was excellent. The staff are super nice. Not a lot of seating, most people get take out. Their Buffalo chicken pizza (blue cheese sauce on the side) seems really popular. We just went ham and mushroom for the calzone. Yum. read more

Very good service and the best eggplant parmigiana sub I've ever had. Their pizza is also top notch and my husband says their sausage & pepper parmigiana is great. Take out is always ready quickly. read more

I gave this place another chance. I am glad I did. Everything was fantastic. Sticky wings, Hot wings tossed in garlic parmesan and chicken bacon ranch pizza. I waited a while for delivery but it was worth it. I actually called them after finishing the meal to let them know how satisfied I was. Keep up the good work. read more

Been waiting over an hour and a half now, this pizza better be fantastic. 90+ minutes is completely unacceptable/ridiculous and this will be the last time I get delivery from this place. Pizza finally arrived but it took an hour and 40 minutes but it was worth it, probably because I'm starving but it's pretty good pizza. read more

I would be embarrassed to make a pizza with canned mushrooms and so much salted garlic that I could taste it after I took it off. If I were one of "those" people I would have asked for a refund. Disgusting read more

440 Pizzeria - Mushroom and garlic pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kingston, New York

We Love 440! Their pizza, wings and garlic knots are great. The owner is really nice. The meal deals are perfect for our family of four. Recently my brother, who moved 2 hrs north, asked me to bring him a 440 chicken, bacon, ranch pizza. Yup it's that good!!! read more

440 Pizzeria - Special delivery to Herkimer, large chicken, bacon, ranch! - Pizza Near Me - Kingston, New York

Incredible pizza!!!! Quick delivery and great service. The cheese was piled on and the crust is the perfect thickness, still firm, and slightly crisp. Toppings abundant with the perfect ratio and flawlessly executed portioning! WOW. read more

good pizza, delivery sucks. we live 5 minutes away and it's rare that we get our order in less than an hour and a half.

Sadly did not enjoy their pizza or garlic "knots". The pizza crust was just too underbaked as it made a soggy mess, and the so-called garlic? bread was just a ball of plain bread and a thin coat of some oil. As a first time customer, 440 is a no go for me. I would go to another pizza joint next time. It was too pricey and underwhelming for a local corner pizza. read more

The food used to be good but unfortunately last time I got it it was disgusting to the point I had to throw my whole dish out. I will Never order from here again nor would I recommend it. Breaks my heart cause it used to be my go to spot read more

Cool and respectful dude when I called to place a pick-up and friendly when I got there. Food was great!

The pizza here is solid. They are very consistent here. It will never be "hit or miss". The buffalo chicken is always a favorite but just the plan cheese is also really good too. The guys are awesome also. They love what they do. Go here and enjoy a slice or two. read more

Best pizza in Kingston and the buffalo chicken pizza is amazing. The wings are on point also.

Very inexpensive and reliably good pizza. Delivery is always on point - make sure you call them directly and ask for their daily specials! You won't be sorry you did read more

BEST PIZZA AROUND! get the buffalo chicken pizza!! You won't regret it! They're super polite, and never disappoint. I have friends who come back to Kingston for their pizza! read more

My favorite place to go for pizza. The owners & staff are so friendly. So courteous to the patrons. Great prices. You want the best, look no further. read more

The pizza is really good, but I haven't eaten there in a year and when I come back all of a sudden theirs bits of garlic in the pizza which I do not appreciate ew read more

Came back into town for a visit and to try all my usual spots and figured I'd give them a chance. Grew up in kingston on Sammie's pizza and this is just the same! Everybody knows this is the spot for buffalo chicken pizza! Not greasy and the prices are average -$18 for a large pie, $2.25/slice for cheese and $2.75/slice for specialty. Thanks for not changing! read more

My family and I enjoy 440 pizza. My only problem with them is when you call in a delivery they tell you your pie will be delivered in 45mins to an hour and we ALWAYS end up waiting for 2hrs until its delivered. Don't tell me 45-60 mins and you don't come for 2hrs! This is so often.. Just in case anyone was wondering. read more

Started great Quality 4 stars Put predisesor sami to shame Now same old same old Weak at best food falls short A while back stopped in paid for an order to be delivered to my kids 8:00 on a Friday night They got it at 11:00 burnt and cold wtf two stars is a gift read more

Very good pizza, generous amount of mozzarella.. good sauce, crispy.. and the wings are meaty and delicious with different variety of sauces.. This will be my go to place. read more

440 Pizzeria - menu page 1 - Pizza Near Me - Kingston, New York

See all

Good pizza, a little pricey for upstate ny... that's coming from a brooklynite. Yummy salads.

service, delivery great. their food is great! very reasonable prices. i recomend this place to everyone.

I don't mean to discredit other reviews, but this is literally the worst pizza I've ever had. I've had all kinds of shitty pizza, but this takes the cake...er, pie. Try it for yourself. Maybe a bad night. Also, it seems like their favorite saying is "yeah, gimme 5 minutes." As in, your pizza/slice, what have you, will be ready in 5 minutes. Don't be surprised to sit there for 20. read more

Whoever took my order over the phone was very rushed, did not know what was actually on the menu (I ordered something and he asked me if that was on the menu because he didn't see it) I was never asked my name. They didn't get my full address and I'm waiting for an hour and a half for my food. read more

Two slices and a soda for $6! I'll be going back. Good crisp thin crust. Staff greeted me when I walked in the door. Nothing that you will be posting pictures of on Facebook, but a great neighborhood pizzeria. read more