Holy crap. Just ate here and it has got to be top 5 pizza places we've tried (and we've eaten at a bunch across NYC and New Haven) Menu is concise but we ate the margarita and it was unbelievable. Sauce was perfectly balanced, dough was right amount of crisp and soft. Can't go wrong with wood fired pizza but they've nailed the balance here. Highly highly recommend! read more

Great Neapolitan style pies in a charming setting. I appreciated the simple menu. Poes came out fast. Had the Margherita pie and a pie with gran padano cheese, sauce and pepperoni to share with two adults and two kids. It was enough food to be satisfied snd not overdo it. I wish they had more appetizer options though. read more

Pizzeria Posto - Sauce, gran padano and pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

See all

Had a most delicious Margherita pizza pie here today. In addition to the outstanding pizza, it was a delight to be served by Jade B. She was very pleasant and attentive throughout our dining experience. Will definitely return to dine here again. In fact, I could easily eat their Margherita pizza daily! read more

Pizzeria Posto - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Clean spacious and bright interior.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Friendly service. Simple menu, they just focus on salads, pizza and drinks. I enjoyed my local beer from Poughkeepsie. Our mixed greens salad was excellent. We ordered a Margherita pizza with half a side of sausage. It was about the right amount for myself and my daughter to share. It was pretty good, thin crust, good dough. Could have had bit more char on the crust and base to help hold everything together as it was a bit too wet. I saw a reviewer here say it was as good or better than new haven pizza but having grown up in the next town over from new haven, I will say that this is better than average pizza but not really close to new haven-level. Go here if you are in the mood for pizza and are nearby. read more

Pizzeria Posto - Za - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

We took a drive to gorgeous Rhinebeck for a nice walk and decided to try Posto since the reviews were really good. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The pizzeria is nestled at the end of a cobblestone path with many small shops around it. It also has outdoor sitting.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We were seated immediately and we were offered the best crusted bread with some oil to deep. The kids and my mom wanted more! We ordered the Mediterranean salad ($17) the Cesar ($17) and three margaritas (26). It was 5 of us and we devoured the salads. They were delicious and perfectly seasoned. The pizzas were probably one of the best I had! The sauce was sweet, the cheese was a combination of fresh and grated mozzarella which I liked that since it covered the whole pie. The dough was the highlight of the pizza. Crusty and chewy at the same time!! read more

Pizzeria Posto - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

See all

Such a delightful dinner experience! My wife and I arrived in Rhinebeck arriving flying across the country and this was where we stopped in for dinner. The staff was friendly, the Margherita pizza was delicious (incredible dough, crust, and sauce) and we had to try the baba Louie after seeing it in other reviews. Loved every bite! read more

Pizzeria Posto - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

See all

Simply the best pizza in the Hudson Valley made by a true Pizzaiolo. If you think you know another one better, compare their pies with just crust, sauce and garlic. Your guy doesn't have that pie? That's because it's too hard to make well. read more

This is by far the best pizza in a fifty mile radius. My wife and I eat here regularly we share the marinara pizza with extra garlic, the Cesar salad and I have a glass of wine with the meal. The service is great [[HIGHLIGHT]]the food terrific ambiance is what you make it.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Try it you will love it. read more

Delicious pizza straight from the wood fired oven. Crust is just the right balance of crisp and chewy. Quality is fantastic but a lot of the pizza selections are very similar, not too much variety. The Nutella calzone makes for a great dessert. read more

Pizzeria Posto - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Delicious, very friendly staff, beautiful location.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Dave Portnoys video made me take the ride up from central Connecticut- Definitely will return- read more

Pizzeria Posto - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

Portnoy undersold this place. This is a mid to high 9 at minimum! Super fast and courteous service. Plenty of seating indoors and outside in a courtyard. Speaking of courtyard, this place is off the main street, when you see an overhang between two buildings that says "Courtyard", make your way through to pizza greatness. Talked to the chef/owner for a bit, great convo about Pizza spots we have all tried across the NY / NJ area (always great to calibrate with Pizza wizards)! Learned a lot about their style too- wood fired but not your double zero, soft and chewy dough/crust that ends up making people leave it behind (side note, in my mind if you don't eat the whole slice, it was not a great pie). Back to the topic: they use American flour so it has a little bite but also can get crispy and hold itself together. I personally love a tiny bit of char on my crust and not on the cheese- this place delivers! Great people, great food. And we walked way bellies full, souls nourished AND with some recommendations back in NJ where we live- how's that for a culinary experience? read more

See all

This restaurant is phenomenal. Best Caesar Salad I've ever had. Margherita pie with Fennel Sausage was fantastic. I live in NJ and know great pizza when I experience it. Posto pizza is insane. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Also great service and nice dining area/ambiance.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Very friendly owner as well. He knows what he's doing. Trust me. 5 stars every day. read more

Our first time in Kingston and saw this on yelp! [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a cute place but not very spacious if you go during busy times.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Do not drink the tap water - it tasted horrible like sewage water. So we ordered a bottle of their aqua panna which tasted like water (nothing amazing just water - at least not like their tap). We also got a diet soda which comes in the tiny 8oz glass bottles; if you get a regular coke they come in the larger glass bottles but for diet it only comes in this small one. We got the arugula salad (9/10) - I don't usually like fruits in my salads but the apple slices were the perfect touch to lessen the sourness of the vinaigrette - it was a great salad and a good portion for the table with pizza or by itself for one; note it has goat cheese which I love but some may not. The Margherita pizza with pepperoni (10/10) is what I would go to order again for pizza; even without the pepperoni. We also got the Ponte vecchio (7/10) pizza which has no tomato sauce and mostly has ricotta instead - I didn't really like this as it was very heavy on the bacon and wasn't as clean tasting as the Margherita and was on the heavy side but for those who love bacon, it may be one to consider. Note that the pizzas are not a usual large size but is more for a single person (it is a little bigger than a usual individual pie size) if this was all they were eating. For a family of 5 where 3 were kids under 11yrs - 2 pies and the salad was just the perfect amount. read more

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]We enjoyed a quiet lunch at Pizzeria Posto.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] It is kind of hard to find if you're not familiar with Rhinebeck. It shows an address on Market St but you need to enter an alley to a little courtyard shopping area, not visible from the street. [[HIGHLIGHT]]If it were, I think the place would be full, that's how cozy and inviting the space is.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] My daughter and I shared the Mediterranean Salad, featuring roasted eggplant, tomatoes, greens and ricotta salita, a Margarita pizza and two glasses of red wine. Everything was made to order, and the salad in particular was fantastic and came with bread and olive oil. The pizza was just what we hoped. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I enjoyed watching pizzas being made in a brick oven in the dining room.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Afterwards we went two doors over to Bread Alone for a little bite of dessert and coffee. I believe they do have dessert at Pizzeria Posto, although it wasn't offered. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Delicious pizza in a really cute area.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Very small menu, but I highly recommend the Terra Bianca - their white pie with arugula on top. read more

Wow, what a great experience. Staff was attentive and friendly. Amazing brick oven pizza. Peronis available in the bottle read more

Pizzeria Posto - Vegan marinara vegetable pie well done - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

[[HIGHLIGHT]]In a very chill courtyard with ample free town parking.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We are greeted by the lovely wife of the chef, seated promptly, and a waiter is over filling our water glasses just as we settle in. We The Mama Mia and the Margherita as well as a spinach salad. The salad came first and was excellent- really fresh greens, dressed, but not over-dressed if you know what I mean. The pizzas arrived and I dug into the Mama Mia- oh the crust, the combination of sautéed sweet onion and some epic sausage. I was feeling it- that warm glow when you've taken a shot in the dark and hit. Now I'm from the Boston area, so kinda in enemy territory. I don't want to compliment anything from New York. Sorry, if you saw the Red Sox lose series after series against those arrogant Yankees you'd understand. Anyway that gives you some context for what I have to say next. By the way we have some serious old-school pizza in Boston, so I know what I'm talking about. To get back to the review, I tried the Margherita next. I was absolutely gobsmacked. It was like meeting an old old friend you'd lost touch with when you moved away. But my god, the sauce. I'm crying that I don't have some right frikkin' now. The crust- words fail me. The cheese, the pepperoni- this was the pizza of my childhood, but better- fresh ingredients, sauce made onsite fresh never canned. It was a sublime slice, and a look into the mind behind it. The owner/chef came over, checking on us. "Oh you're from Boston? That's alright, we won't hold it against ya." Will I go back? If you need to ask, you didn't read the review. read more

Easily the best pizza I have found in the Hudson Valley. We tried the margherita and the marinara + pepperoni, both were perfect. Also had a spinach salad w bacon and mushrooms, also very good. We'll be back. read more

Pizzeria Posto - Pizza Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

See all

The pizza oven and the pizzaiolos are true angels. Crust is perfect. Sauce is sweet and spicy. Toppings - balance to cheese and crust is on point. Went with a tried and true Margarita. Proves any pizza will be great. read more

Great pizza and wonderful salads in Rhinebeck. This is not Pizza Hut-- it's delicious high end pizza and large fresh salads worthy of some in Rome. The white pizza with mild onions and pistachios was so unique. Highly recommend. read more

Excellent service and food. Crust was perfect and the fresh basil was a nice touch. Service was quick and the pizza arrived quickly. read more

Pizzeria Posto - Fantastic crust and fresh ingredients. - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

Pizzeria Posto is an excellent option for pizza or salad in the charming village of Rhinebeck. We had initially ordered pizza for take out since we wanted to try it out passing through the area, but wound up dining in since it was in such a charming plaza. The friendly staff were more than happy to accommodate us. The margherita pizza (4.5/5) was delicious. It was a neopolitan style pizza and the ingredients were highly quality. The crust was cooked to chewy perfection, with sauce made of san marzano tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella, with basil leaves for a little bit of flavor accent. Although I wasn't a huge fan of the basil leaves and this wasn't my favorite style of pizza, I was impressed with the great fresh ingredients/flavor such that I'd recommend Pizzeria Posto to others. The wood fired crust is simply delicious and at a quality level you'd be hard pressed to find outside of Italy. The owner/chef thanked us on the way out and seemed genuinely appreciative of our business, so I'm happy to round up and give them one of my rare 5-star pizza reviews. It's definitely worth a stop for a meal when in Rhinebeck. read more

See all

Usually we love the pizza, however our last visit was disappointing, the pizza was soggy and over sauced, with way too much cheese, and basil burnt. As many pizzas were being made, perhaps rushed. The salad was wonderful , served with lovely olive oil and bread. The checked arrived on the table with remaining dirty plates and pizza. Unpleasant for sure! Oh and by the way, we did not receive a pizza that looked anything like the pizza shown on their website . A far cry! read more

These are Neapolitan style pizzas. If you want pineapple or jalapenos or chicken on your pizza, this is not your spot. If you want a cauliflower crust, you're going to be disappointed. They have perfected a small collection of pies. The ingredients are fresh and high quality. North of New Rochelle and west of New Haven, you're going to have a hard time finding a better crust. The crunch, the char, the chew, the thinness, the flavor; perfect on both pies we ordered. And they have been that consistent every time we have visited. I wish they had a more robust wine selection and more engaged service. But I keep coming back to how consistently good their pizza is. If you're in the mood for a Neapolitan, there's simply nothing better in 100 miles. read more

Really enjoyed this place. Came here because of the yelp ratings and was not disappointed. We had a mixed salad to start, which had a very delicious Dijon vinaigrette dressing. And then we had a margarita pizza with pepperoni. The crust was quite delicious. I would recommend this place in a heartbeat. The server did a great job. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Worth every star from vibe to service to food.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I had a simple salad with vinaigrette and the pizza with sausage and smoked mozzarella. I added shrooms. This would be a weekly spot or more if I lived here! read more

Wow. As a born and raised local, I cannot believe that I have not heard of this pizzeria sooner. I heard of this place via word of mouth and a friend posting his meal on social media. I thought, that looks amazing. Well, going in person did not disappoint. The shop is in the heart of Rhinebeck, easy parking and conveniently located. Service was very friendly, and it is amazing to have seen the owner making the pizzas practically right in front of our table. Service was quick, and we received our order of three pies within about 5-10 minutes. I must say, these were the most beautiful pizza pies I've ever seen. Additionally, this was the best tasting pizza I have ever tried as well. I would absolutely recommend this pizzeria to all locals to try. read more

Pizzeria Posto - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

Horrible customer service. The waitress has an attitude and too busy on her phone. I drove 1 hour to have a great experience and was let down. Definitely not what I expected. read more

Was in Rhinebeck for the day, and we are always on the lookout for excellent pizza. Had good reviews already, so that was encouraging. [[HIGHLIGHT]]We were seated right near the pizza making station, and was a very chill relaxed vibe.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We met Patrick the owner shorty after and he was chatty and super nice, and knowledgable. We ordered a salad w grilled eggplant and greens. Great dressing. Then onto the Pizza, we orderd the margarita, and was immediately impressed by the look, and smell!!! The pie was expertly cooked, good char and crisp, but not burnt, the cheese was melted perfectly. Patrick mentioned they use 3 cheeses actually, and was one of the most flavorful Neo pies we have tried, and there has been many. Look forward to coming back, and trying more of the menu. GO! read more

I've been making my own Neapolitan pizza dough and pizza from scratch for several years in an Ooni oven. Their Margherita Pizza was fantastic. The dough was a little more crisp than the traditional Margherita and that had me on my first bite. Patrick was open to discussing his dough with me and even gave me a few tips. The fresh mozz was super creamy and the sauce complementary as opposed to masking the other flavors. We had a Mediterranea salad which was more than enough for three to share. Don't miss this spot if you're in Rhinebeck! read more

Can't praise this place enough ! Although basic and somewhat pricey , their pies have such a delicious crust, that you'll remember and crave again and again!. (As we have been doing for at least the past 10 years.) read more

We got a margherita- our go to for judging a good pie. The simplistic nature of the pie really shows off if it's good or not. The outer crust had good char but the base crust was a bit soft. Sauce was tasty and basil was generous. Would have preferred fresh mozzarella vs shredded. All in all, a solid pie. read more

I was honestly skeptical when I ordered the Pistachio Pizza--no mozzarella, no tomato sauce? It sounded almost unthinkable. But what I got was an explosion of creativity and flavor. The pizza was exceptionally moist and inventive, with perfectly grilled pistachios paired with onions with herbs that simply melted in my mouth. This unexpected combination turned out to be one of the most memorable culinary surprises I've had in a long time. An absolute masterpiece! Thank you to the master cook!!! read more

Always out of this world. We have dined at Posto dozens of times since Patrick opened the doors. Always 5 stars for us....As I've written before, growing up and working in the 5 Boros, I've had the best pizza. Pizzeria Posto is the best Brick Oven pizza found anywhere. They will customize your favorite combinations and make it right on the spot. Can't wait to stop in on this Memorial Day Weekend. Matt Mad Dog Sweeney read more

Stopped by Patrick's place this past Friday while shopping the stores in Rhinebeck. Had a wonderful pie from the wood-fired oven and a delicious salad along with some wine. We wanted something light, so this looked like the place. The best way to know a place can make pizza is try the simplest pie and taste the flavors from the dough, cheese and sauce. We did the Grana Padano - basically a tomato pie with grated cheese. It was excellent - thin with a nice char on the bottom and a bit on the crust. Light and delicate with excellent flavor from the fresh tomato and cheese and it comes with a good 'crunch'. If you want a dozen toppings on your pie, go somewhere else. This is an authentic pie in the Roman / Napoli style ... Not meant to have everything under the sun laid on top - it just messes up a great pie. Spend a few $$ and enjoy a good pie - other than NYC, CT and a few places in Westchester County, you won't find pies like this. read more

I've been participating in a chat with some Yelp Albany friends on pizza. In the thread's original post, a website, newyorkupstate.com, compiled a list of their 25 best pizzerias in "upstate" New York, upstate being defined as any place north and west of Westchester and Rockland counties. The rankings were based on Yelp reviews. Pizzeria Posto was at the top of the list, and I immediately noticed it is the pizzeria on the list which is the shortest drive from where I live, yet I'd never been there. A last-minute change of dinner plans last night led us to Pizzeria Posto as our alternate choice. After last night, it won't be relegated to "alternate choice" any longer. The hype is real. It starts simply, with some bread and a really fruity olive oil. I think a good quality balsamic vinegar would have added to the taste, but I was quite content with the olive oil. Meals here will focus primarily on 3 things: salad, pizza, and wine (there are a few beers available too). For a really good experience, you should plan on having some of each (assuming you drink wine, of course), because all the choices really complement each other. The salads are as pleasing to look at as they are to eat. And then there's the pizza. The aroma of our Margherita pizza made it to the table before the pizza actually did, and I was ready to give it 7 stars just on that. In a word, "Wow!" The wine we chose, Rapitala Campo Reale Nero D'Avola, with its complex berry and clove flavors, put my taste buds in a positive feedback loop when alternating sips between it and the salad and pizza. Service was great, we were greeted not only by our waitress but the guys behind the counter making the pizzas, and we were checked on often. I may never find out just how good my meal at the other restaurant might have been, now that I've been here. read more

See all

While you might go there for their great oven fired pizza they have the best salad in town! read more

Pizzeria Posto - Salad dressing on the side - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

We were on vacation in New York (we are from California). We were looking for the best pizza in New York and we found it at Pizzeria Posto! read more

Pizzeria Posto - Pizza Near Me - Rhinebeck, New York

See all

The pizzas here are made to order so patience is definitely a virtue. The arugula salad was a great stater and a standout as was the olive oil that accompanied the bread bowl. The gentleman waiter could not have been sweeter or more accommodating and the atmosphere was a perfect relaxing summer evening. read more

A must visit every time we're in Upstate! The staff are all attentive and friendly! Everything tastes so fresh. The basil blew me away (that's how good everything is). You can see the oven the pizza is cooked in. My go to starters are the Caesar salad and capresse - easy to share with friends! We split the two amongst a group of 4. The balsamic on the capresse has a sweet robust, flavor. My favorite pizza is the margarita and marino! The margarita is a classic and the marino has a nice tangy kick with the olives. read more