Cheesesteak a la Rocco (with onion pepper and mushroom) was excellent! Great roll and large portion.

December 26, 2025 - looking for good pizza and more well Rocco's Pizza is the place for you. Casual dinning with combination of cafeteria style service. Totally recommend... cheese pizza Italian wedding soup Garlic knots Conveniently located in a large plaza with ample parking. Several Tesla supercharge located in the Plaza too. read more

See all

The crunch of the crust was to die for! SO good and just the right amount of sauce. It was quick friendly and the facilities were clean and spacious! read more

Rocco's Pizzeria - Pizza box - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

Yum. Stopped for a few slices. One Sicilian with mushrooms. And tried their chicken Marsala slice. Pretty, pretty good. And, for dessert, had the straciatelli soup! A pleasant surprise for a Sunday night driving from Albany to NYC. read more

Rocco's Pizzeria - Stracciatelle Soup - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

I ordered a personal pizza,small Calzone and Eggplant parm dinner. All is delicious and great portion for the dinner, with a beautiful spring mix salad as well as bread. I was given extra sauce with Calzone and didn't even ask. Huge plus for me! The pizza is my favorite in town and their prices are great compared to others in the area. I highly recommend read more

See all

Can't even go there anymore because they can't cook and I had chicken and pizza tasted blend no seasoning they need to make regular food not lazy. If a food critic comes or famous people they will not like it here read more

Rocco's Pizza New Paltz : Stopped by to talk to Rocco. Always a good time catching up with an old school Italian Brooklynite, accent and all. Pizza is solid. Calzone was packed with ricotta and grandma slice had alot of fresh mozz. Give it a try. I like reheated slices because they get a delicate crisp on the bottom you don't usually get from a slice pie. read more

See all

I had Rocco's cater a small event at my house and everything was delicious. I had all types of guests coming to eat, vegan, vegetarian and meat eaters. Rocco's had everything I needed. The food was ready at the time I requested. They were very easy to deal with! read more

Stopped by here since it was nearby and the food was amazing! We had the eggplant roll and spinach roll. also ordered 2 slices to go. Haven't had such good food since being in the Bronx. I will be back whenever I'm in New Paltz! read more

Always solid. My ex loved the Sicilian and I always tried something different each time. Sausage and pepper rolls are great. Service is always fast and friendly. It's a pizza shop, it can only be so cozy. They offer outdoor seating and a great selection of food and drinks. read more

Luka is a really good pie maker. Always funny and his customer service is near perfect . The lady that's there on occasion always is so serious and needs to lighten up. It's a really nice spot just wish it were open a little later on weekends. Food is fantastic. Probably the best in the area.I recommend this pizza shop to all that will listen . read more

This past Friday, we ordered fried calamari to go from Rocco's. Very disappointing, as the calamari was rubbery and impossible to chew! The breading was also undercooked, not crisp as it should've been. Too bad, we had high hopes for finding a local place. read more

Great Pizza. Great Italian fare. Good home cooked food. Reasonably priced. Rocko, Susanne, Nick, Duncan and other staff are great. Highly recommended throughout the area. Have never been disappointed. You will be pleased. Good food for all. read more

So disappointed in Rocco's been going there for years.. yesterday I ordered escarole and bean soup in chicken broth and was served something that looked like tomato soup with 3 spoonfuls of beans and escarole for 9dollars plus tip when I complained the woman behind the counter was was rude and nasty.. told me I must have had the wrong place ..and told to go somewhere else. Unbelievable. The place was empty at lunch time. And I can see why.. customer service is so important to a business. I guess they don't care how they treat people ..too bad for them..do unto others has you want done to you..never going back there read more

The best pizza in New Paltz. The service is quick and friendly! The last 2 times we were here it was the absolute best pizza we've had in a long time read more

The food and service is nice and looks like a great place there is some music in the background and there is no out bursts read more

Rocco's Pizzeria - Some items on the menu - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

The guy cooking gave us the wrong order and would not change it. The pizza is bland and tasteless - we ordered margherita and it came without tomatoes! Avoid this place. read more

Have had excellent pizza here in past. Garlic knots aa good as you can get. But a real pleasant surprise was i asked if they have any sauce they sell. I took out an order of bolognese sauce. Home made and Incredibly delicious! Love the Sicilian and grandma slices. (And the beautiful owner should be in movies). read more

SUCH GOOD PIZZA. We loved it. Especially the pepperoni one, soo good. Very flavorful. The cheese pizza had a little less flavor but still good. read more

Rocco's Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

Worst pizza ever! Very bland, garlic knots were very cold, and wings were overcooked and very tiny and no service. Staff was rude and yelled "Yo" when the pizza was done! Was very upset. And left a tip unknowingly having to serve ourselves and clean up our own mess. Will not be returning! Rather go across the street to Pasquale's! read more

Sadly, the food we ordered was inedible. Fried calamari was undercooked - tasted like it was just poured from the frozen food bag- and so chewy we had to throw it away. Try it yourself if you dare but don't say you weren't warned! I'm read more

My partner and I absolutely love Rocco's and insist on ordering anytime a pizzeria is in question. I honestly can't rave enough about their food and we love Luca and the sweetheart woman who works behind the counter. The chefs at Rocco's definitely know what's up and that's coming from downstaters who know good NY pizza. Whether its a slice (hot OR cold), a slider, a sub, a salad, or dinner, ordering from rocco's you know its going to be good and not insanely expensive. The cost per portion is so fair. Love the ambiance and personality of the place, being able to sit in or sit outside or run and get to-go, they're easy and open relatively later than some other places in New Paltz. read more

We were disgusted by the poor service and terrible attitude that we received from this pizza place. We ordered 2 salads and two large pizzas and paid nearly 80.00 after tip. It's overpriced. We ordered from our hotel room and the pizza was sent over in an acceptable amount of time, but there were no napkins and no forks, so I called back and let the same rude girl know. She blamed me. She said, "Well, the customer's usually let us know if they need napkins and forks..." It was a terrible experience and this is no way to treat customers who just paid $80.00 for a meal. Please don't get your pizza from them. They ruined our dinner and they don't deserve to be patronized for this kind of rudeness. Thank you for not buying from here. There's plenty of other pizza places that probably have better pizza and more reasonable prices without the terrible service. read more

i came here for the first time for lunch. they were very friendly at the counter and answered my questions without issue. I got a Italian combo cold cut and a meatball slider, i found the cold cut pretty good, they put a good amount of red wine vinegar which is rare since most place are cheap with it on the sandwich, paper thin red onions and lettuce was a nice touch, the provolone cheese tasted very fresh and a good balance of it and meat. the meatball slider was amazing, a cut in half meatball on top of fresh mozzarella and marinara sauce in a cut in half garlic knot. its simple but man it was good. i ordered a grandma slice since it looked really good, after finishing my first order. the marinara sauce was good and not drowned the slice, light on greens and a touch of pram cheese, am glad it thin crust and not a thick piece of dough like most specialty slices do. overall, i def try more in other visits to the area. read more

Rocco's Pizzeria - Italian combo and meatball slider - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

The food is excellent. The meatball slider is so good with excellent bread. The broccoli soup is ridiculously delicious. All the stars.

Great pizza and garlic knots. The margarita slice is a must try! My whole table was very satisfied

If the rating were on the pizza alone, it would be a 5. But don't come here expecting a pleasant attitude to go with your tasty pizza because you will not get it. I think when they interview people, one of the prerequisites must be: "Are you a sourpuss?" If so, you have a job. We've been to this place about 5 times now, and each time the pizza is excellent but the people behind the counter really need to take some lessons on being friendly and welcoming. If you don't need a nice demeanor, or a friendly attitude, then I would recommend the Grandma's pizza, you won't be disappointed with that. read more

Perfect pizza the gluten free is best I have ever had !!! Highly recommended this place has everything

Stop back today for some more pizza and shopping at Peter Harris. My friends and I enjoyed the antipasto salad which was by far one of the best I've ever had. I got another one to go. Will taste great with a chunk of Italian bread. Will make a perfect meal really nice people to and the restaurant is nice and clean. read more

See all

I feel the need to balance the negative marks on service. We ordered take out in person and couldn't be happier with the friendly service. Food was solid as well. read more

My favorite here is the Buffalo chicken or chicken Marsala slice! Rocco's is a great spot ! Try it if you haven't !

Pizza is good. Customer service is a hit or miss. Sometimes friendly. Sometimes nasty. The staff should be on the same page on how to answer a phone properly and address customers with respect. Not "yeah what do you want" Prices a bit high but nothing terrible. read more

Imagine being a business that takes customers' money, willingly, and rather than being respectful to their customers with good business ethics, decided to be distasteful, have the worst attitude as a pizza business in New Paltz, NY and decided to ignorantly yell at his customers that paid $30 for his service! I would suggest to everyone, please ...pay your hard-earned money to people who actually respects as a customer who is taking the time to pay for their service (helping staff get paid weekly and to clock in at their job!) With no customers - Rocco's pizza would be out of business! 'And oh John is making sure to make many customers as you may see in prior reviews from others throughout the years - never wanting to go back to his business at Rocco's Pizza ever again . They have bad reviews on Door Dash, Yelp, Google, and the list goes on!! What a disappointment! So since John decided he rather get bad reviews than resolve matters kindly with his customers, "thank John"... for another bad review and MANY OTHER bad reviews from others as well. I saw... and the complaints are similar to mine too -- dating back for years!!! How do they manage to be a business for so long? We have no clue. It's shameful! John who made the pizza, he claimed he was the manager, decided to not hear customer's feedback politely and rudely yelled at us on the phone and hung up on us ---disgustingly twice... for simply sharing that the pizza was undercooked(raw ham) and etc. We paid for bacon (there was NO bacon added), only Marinara sauce, smeared with dried uncooked basil, barely any Pepporoni (it's a about a 8-10 slice pizza with only 4 Pepporoni's on it...), the crust was stale, and when requested--there was no Parmesan cheese nor Mozzarella cheese. Typically when ordering a pizza, all standard pizza comes with dough, sauce, and Mozzarella cheese. Grandma pizza was supposed to come with Mozzarella cheese and we got essentially no cheese at all (no Parmesan and no Mozzarella) and to be honest not a pizza! We spent $30 for an uncooked and undone pizza! This was a terrible experience. We are so disappointed on this service, we have went to Rocco's for years - never had an issue personally and John decided to dismiss customer courtesy, customer loyalty who've always happily bought pizza from this place, and he dismissed our respect by claiming that it was not his fault - and blaming US for using Door Dash- a company that his business partnered with....to blame Door Dash - when he was the one who made the pizza! Extremely awful and with his anger that he decided to not smartly put on his innocent customers who simply was not happy with our order, he would rather be inconsiderate, unwilling to simply make another pizza for us (we would had happily accepted that), ...he figured to curse us out instead -over pizza-..(how crazy can he be?) and run his customers away permanently. I would not recommended this business to no one ever again and going forward, will let others keep that in mind. My friends and family are even SUPER concerned right now that we don't even get food poisoning tonight! Thanks to John who literally told us that he does not care how he made the pizza, blame "Door Dash", and unwilling to fix his mistake like other stable-minded business people do! Maybe he should take a business course? How to run a polite, sanitary, and freshly cooked food business 101?? We don't know! Because running a food business and making sure customers are treated respectfully and in a courteous manner? It's definitely not for John! We even have Italians in our family and they were shocked on how poor this pizza was made and this guy's nasty attitude! There was a reason why I got a refund, thankfully. He in-FACT had attitude and in-FACT a undercooked and stale pizza! John got in his feelings than be business cordial and it was a complete waste of money unfortunately. Do not, I repeat - do not buy from this pizzeria. From one genuine Italian family to the rest, "abbi cura di te e non riceverai più assistenza da noi." (Take care and you will not get service from us again). read more

I rarely give out 5 stars but their grandma pizza is AMAZING!! Actually the three slices (one grandma, one margarita, one regular) were delicious but my SO and I fought over the grandma. We will be back for more!! read more

Such a shame. Was such a good eatery before owners changed. Pizza is still okay , but the food obviously comes frozen and not freshly made( my eggplant was lukewarm and freezer burnt ) tasteless soggy freezer burnt chemically laden crap. A frozen stouffers from shoprite would have been better and certainly more cost effective. A shame to call this place a " restaurant " lacking pride of ownership for sure! read more

Do not go there!!!!!! They are Rude and Obnoxious!!!!!!!! The Pizza And Food Is At Best Mediocre!!!!!! Not Even Worth The Astronomical Money They Are Charging!!!!!! Go Across The Street To Pasquales!!!!! Ton better!!!!!! Friendlier People And Total Experience!!!!!! And Totally Better Tasting Food And Ambience!!!!!!!! read more

We had 2 large pies. Pie # 1 had mushrooms & peppers other half had pepperoni &bacon. Pie #2 chicken bacon ranch other half buffalo chicken. These pies where loaded up with toppings. Pie was amazing!! read more

Rocco's has really great pizza. Coming from Long Island, I am a hard judge on two things; pizza and bagels. They exceeded my expectations on pizza one of the first times I had been here, and not much has changed since. I have always been a fan of Rocco's salads and sides as well including their eggplant rolls. I have never seen or had an eggplant roll anywhere else but Rocco's and they are a must try. Tuesday's are typically "pasta night" though I have not been here since they opened the restaurant side so I am not sure they still do that. When they did, you got a salad, garlic knots, and your choice of pasta dish for about 10 bucks or so. The salad was as you'd expect, but get the house balsamic dressing and you'll thank me. The garlic knots were here and there, sometimes covered in garlic and dripping oil, sometimes perfectly browned and soft. The pasta was always amazing. They had about 22 choices on the menu and I'm pretty sure I have tried atleast half. Do yourself a favor and try the pasta- any dish will do. They also serve gluten free pasta and pies which is a rarity in the area. Definitely a good local spot for some classic Italian eats. read more

Pizza was adequate. Attitude was poor. Simple question got a sarcastic response. Asked if the air conditioning was not working because it was hot in there, Rocko's response was do you want to come work back here. read more

Stopped for a quick dinner with my boyfriend. He ordered a pepperoni pinwheel. When he got to the middle it was all raw dough. He took it up to the counter and showed them... they said "oh yeah it is raw" and didn't offer another one or to cook it more. Just walked away from him. Not coming back again read more

Rocco's Pizzeria - Raw dough in the pepperoni pinwheel - Pizza Near Me - New Paltz, New York