Two Brothers Pizza

The best crust pizza dough I have ever had. They staff were…read moreextremely attentive and polite. This is a must try restaurant if you're in the Rinebeck NY area.

Great wood fired pizzas! Thin crusts. I loved the margarita pizza with an add of fennel sausage…read more They had a great Caesar salad as well. Indoor and outdoor seating plus high chairs for the little ones. Great service as well. Will definitely return!

Ask the owner about the tiny pizza he made for this little guy

Margarita Pizza

See all

Entrance

Village Pizza of Rhinebeck

3.6(111 reviews)

5 stars for their lemonade since I didn't try anything else. Was having a craving for ice-cold…read morelemonade and wanted something as close to homemade as it gets! Five stars for the deliciously refreshing Tractor Beverage lemonade in a big slushie container by the register. Just the right amount of sweet and so much better than any lemonade you'd get at CVS. 5 stars!!!

I live much closer to this location now, and it has been a pretty solid go-to for pizza. I ordered…read morefrom Village Pizza recently for a birthday. They did manage to mess up my order and I had to go back to get an extra pie, which was very frustrating. The pizza is good. I've had better, I've had worse. The staff are pretty nice. The interior is a little dingy, but it's got character.

Mushroom and olive pizza

See all

Where the light is brightest, the shadows are deepest. ― Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

Four Brothers Pizza Inn

3.9(54 reviews)

2.2 mi

On our way home from a wake stopped in to a familiar place. Had a specialty pizza. Good pizza great…read morefriendly service. Price was right. We will take the trip over the bridge from Kingston again most definitely.

This is our go to place for pizza. They also have great Italian style food and fried chicken…read more Greek salad is also worth a mention. Portions are large and prices are fair. It is a clean, casual, friendly place where you can go for great food and service.

Penne alla Vodka with sausage and house-pulled fresh mozzarella

Brother's Special pizza

See all

Penne al Pesto with grilled chicken & housemade fresh mozzarella

Market St

3.7(226 reviews)

•$$$

Nice spot. I went with a group of thirteen people which is unusual for me. Young waiters did quite…read morea good job in serving the table which wasn't easy. Food was good. I had an Aperol Spritz which I enjoyed. Rigatoni bolognese was very good. It was very noisy at first but as other diners left it really mellowed out. The nice thing was our group stayed quite late and the restaurant emptied out but they graciously let us stay and not feel uncomfortable. Very classy.

Went to Market Street for a friend's birthday party. I'm the only vegan. No matter where I go, I…read morecan usually survive with spaghetti and marinara sauce, and an iceberg lettuce salad with a tomato wedge. So here I got an upgraded meal: penne pasta putanesca and an arugula salad with pears & pistachios. Nicely done. I'm grateful for at least a meal. Some restaurants, I cannot get a meal, I order 3 side dishes. The back room is nice for parties, a little quieter than the front. Service was perfect. That makes a big difference in the experience. The parking lot adjacent was full, but there is plenty of parking across the street and also on the other side. Bathroom was clean. The birthday girl enjoyed trout, and a small warm chocolate cake with ice cream, with a candle. Delicious! She had to ask the waitress, what is gluten free because the menu is not clearly labeled. I think there is room for improvement, that is easy and cheap. We got a bottle of wine , it was served in regular glasses, we had to request wine glasses for wine. My wife got Swordfish. Enjoyed some and brought home the rest. Asked Google if she could give it to the dog. Google said No! Don't feed your dog swordfish because of the High Mercury! If you can't feed it to the dog, people can't eat it either! So she threw it in the garbage. I think Market Street should re evaluate their menu choices. Also, Market Street could do better than inexpensive pasta for vegans and vegetarians, at this price point. Something with beans or soy meat, vegan Italian sausage, there is so much out there in 2025. We left the 1900's a long time ago. Even the CIA in neighboring Hyde Park is teaching vegan cooking. How about an upgrade? Please? Helpful?

Back room works well for parties

See all

Lucoli

4.3(74 reviews)

4.3 mi

Wow super treat to have a take out meal from Lucoli We call…read moreto check if they have gluten free Lucolis My favorite is Cavolo Artichokes red cabbage and tahini sauce gluten free vegan delight The teens love the pizzas a lot!! The crusts are just amazingly perfect And flat out fabulous salad We also order Verdura and add sausage or chicken Fresh different amazingly good

Pizza amazing! All fresh ingredients. Recommend 100% and wish it would open for lunch!read more

See all

Gigi Hudson Valley

3.3(254 reviews)

•$$$

I was pleasantly surprised by my experience at Gigi's during a family trip to the Hudson Valley…read more The aggregated 3.5 star rating (at the time we visited) had me thinking "it's probably fine" but didn't expect much more. I got more! We were in the back room with a large 2 family party and everyone had a good experience. The staff was attentive and took great care of us. The star of the show for me was the Bianca "Skizza" - Skizzas are what they call their pizza-like experience....super thin dough, not quite NYC style in its taste and texture, but at least as thin with a unique overall texture and flavor to it. The kind of taste that sticks with you and makes you wonder "when can I have that again." I tend to get margherita or a basic tomato cheese situation to suss out any place offering pizza of any kind, but strayed from my comfort level and went for the Bianca which was truly a delicious experience. Gigi Rosemary Fig Jam, Pear, Arugula, Goat Cheese, Mozzarella, Truffle Oil created a super delicious and crave worthy experience. I finished the whole pie by myself with no issues. (Okay, maybe my wife had a slice, it's hard to remember...I just remember every bite being delicious.) There are other vegetarian options including pastas and a lentil soup. Plus a delicious looking "Barbina" salad, and the menu is helpfully labeled with which items are vegetarian. There was something for everyone at Gigi's and everyone in our 16 member+ party was happy to have eaten there.

My husband and I stopped by on a whim. It was beautiful out so we dined outside. I had the…read moreminestrone soup and we shared a margarita skizza. My husband had a shrimp dish and loved it! For dessert I had the lemon cake and he had the almond cake. All dishes were made with high quality ingredients and we could definitely tell. Our waiter was great and we look forward to returning very soon!

Harney and Sons Chamomile Tea

See all

Rustica Skizza

Savona's Trattoria

3.9(152 reviews)

3.3 mi

We love going to Savona's! As an Italian family, it's hard finding good Italian food in dutchess,…read morebut Savona's knocks it out of the park every time. Their stuffed artichokes taste like it came from my family's kitchen, their portions are huge, we leave with full bellies and smiles from a great time!

Lovely restaurant in Redding, Ct Sitting outside in a sunny…read moreafternoon on their patio, is a plus. Our waitress Susan was on point when she recommended the fried eggplant wrap, I loved it. The French fries were delish. My husband had the Shrimp Spring rolls delicious and copious for a starter. We will be back.

Mother's Day Margarita Special

Lunch bill

See all

Amazing bread!

Village Pizza III

4.1(61 reviews)

4.4 mi

New to the area and all our neighbors recommend Village Pizza as the best pizza around…read more Absolutely agree,good value,excellent pizza,friendly staff. We are fans!!

My friends and I decided to do a blind pizza tasting of 6 top rated pizza restaurants in Red Hook,…read moreRhinebeck, and Tivoli. Village Pizza was the winner!! And they came in on a day they had planned to be closed just to complete our order! Great work guys.

Got too excited and grabbed slices before taking this photo. Tastes even better than it looks, and that looks fine.

Our garbage pizza

See all

Large pizza with buffalo chicken, bacon, jalapeños, mushrooms and extra hot sauce. Absolutely glorious !

Sorry, Charlie

4.4(86 reviews)

3.9 mi

Phenomenal service -everyone is so nice!- really delicious and creatively made pizza pies!…read more I got the cowboy candy pie with vegan cheese and no sausage and everything down to the crust was perfection! Only wish I wasn't visiting from NYC, because I'd become a regular at such a fun, delicious place!

Cozy bar with a fun combination of classy wood/retro garage decor. I want one the shirts the…read moreservers wear! The Caesar salad was fresh and flavorful- a balanced blend of savory cheese and cashews with zingy dressing and fresh lemon. The caps and stems pizza was in what I would call a Detroit-style thin crust. The onions and mushrooms has a savory steakhouse flavor and the Parmesan garlic sauce was definitely garlicky but did not overpower the other toppings. The salad a pizza were enough for two with a solid amount left to take home. I have the raspberry Collins made with gin. I could taste fresh raspberry, and the soda did not drown out the gin flavor. Very nicely balanced. The service was quick and friendly. I would definitely recommend this to some looking for a bar with excellent food and drinks!

Menu & Bar

Close up of the pizza we had

See all

Old Fashioned

C J's - Children speghetti and meatballs

C J's

2.9(82 reviews)

1.6 mi

I've eaten here many times over several years and been happy with the food and the prices. Service…read moreis inconsistent -- if you're at the bar it's good but if you're in the other parts of the restaurant it's not as good. There's plenty of seating and good on-site parking. They need to improve their service.

Our waitress was great! The bathrooms are nice and clean. Unfortunately the food was unenjoyable…read morefor lack of better words. My chicken parm sandwich tasted like it was made with cheap frozen chicken patty's, sauce was okay. I didn't finished it and still got a bad stomach ache after. Wouldn't recommend the food. But staff is very welcoming!

Chicken Parmigiana sandwich

This was 'Thick and Chewy' crust?

See all

White clam sauce in fettuccine

Two Brothers Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Two Brothers Pizza also viewed

Mario's Pizza

4.0

(23 reviews)

We picked up 2 slices for lunch--Sicilian and a specialty buffalo chicken slice and it was…read moredelicious! My go-to is a Sicilian slice and this one was so pillowy and delicious! The sauce and cheese were great and everything was hot out of the oven. Service was quick at the counter and the cashiers were very nice. Lots of seating indoors too with some tables outside as well. Great place to stop in and I'd love to come back to try some of their other things.

Love Marios and Sue! Sue works so hard and gives so much to our community@ I love anything…read moreeggplant always delicious!

Angela Pizza

3.0

(91 reviews)

Great food at this place…read more We order subs from here most often, but we've also had spaghetti as well. I don't think I've ever had their pizza though. I've only ever eaten in once. I found the interior to be a little on the small side. It tends to get crowded in there at times and finding a parking space outside can also be tedious during those times as well. The lot isn't very big. I'd recommend you order your food for pickup and eat it within the comfort of your home, hotel room, wherever you may be. Prices are great and their turkey subs are huge and come with about handful of potato chips. My girlfriend and I can split a twelve inch sub from here and end up satisfied. Where else can you get by with a takeout dinner for two at about $10 total?

During pickup they forgot to give me calzone. Drove back from home and female clerk simply said OH…read morehere it is, here you go. Didnt deserve a sorry i guess? What a shame they have someone like that as the customer service face of a business. Ill say sorry to any others who were shorted during pickup.

Tony’s Pizzeria

4.1

(13 reviews)

Really like their pizza crust and sauce. Fresh ingredients and consistent preparation…read more Their cheesesteaks are spectacular. Fresh crusty bread, good combination/balance of ingredients. One of the best I've ever had and eaten them in Philly many times.

Great pizza and portions! Just take a look at those slices! Came here to pick up a quick lunch and…read moreit was great. I was helped promptly at the counter and they had a few specialty pies in the front to choose from. Great thin crust pizza. Toppings would slide off a bit but it was still good. Would love to try a Sicilian from here sometime. Couple of tables for indoor seating and easy parking right next door. Cute no fuss space.

Village Pizza of Rhinebeck

3.6

(111 reviews)

Antonio's Pizzeria Bridge Plz

3.7

(29 reviews)

Best calamari ever!…read more We had a wonderful time here. Seven people gathering together to catch up and n things while enjoying a meal. The food was excellent and nobody rushed us. We sat and talked for two hours. It's hard to find a restaurant that allows its patrons that kind of courtesy. Let bed the wings and cheesesteak sandwich. Portions are huge. We all left with leftovers. Did I mention that the calamari was wonderful? Yum. Will definitely be back.

I ordered take out and when I got home I realized the onion there burnt and actually black. They…read moreshould've thrown them away and not served them! I called for a refund but needed to keep calling around 5 times until it got resolved and then told not to come back. They have a habit of overcooking and burning everything especially the pizza! There are so many good pizza places around but this one is not it! Stay away if you want good food and more importantly, good service!

Catskill Mountain Pizza

3.4

(267 reviews)

Loved everything we ordered. Cannot wait to return next time I am in town!…read more Ordered a few pizzas, wings, and salads - service was prompt and we were in/out quickly!

Surprisingly great considering lower ratings! Delicious pizza, the most fun and friendly server…read morewe've had in a long time, and great spot in town for sitting outside and people watching. Our server Juan was awesome, and we had come in as a large group of 9 and he jumped right into helping get a table setup and having a group of chatty Italians all trying to talk to him. Pizzas were tasty- we got the Popeye and the godfather. Manicotti was enjoyed as well as the mozzarella salad/antipasto, which came with huge pieces of mozzarella. Meatballs were not for me, more on the big/mushy side, but I think they're also used with pasta/sauce so makes sense. I'm more about a seared meatball, so just a preference! They are technically cash only but have an atm as well as take cards with a fee. Worth a visit while in Woodstock!

Slices of Saugerties

4.3

(187 reviews)

Excellent pizza! I had a slice of Sicilian and a plain. The Sicilian had a great, airy dough, nice…read moredollops of tasty tomato sauce and the perfect amount of cheese. It had a crispy crust and great texture. The plain slice was equally stellar. Thin, crispy crust and great cheese/sauce ratio. Yelp did not disappoint! Easy parking in municipal lot a few shops down. Easy on/off the NY Thruway. A great stopping point to stretch your legs and grab a bite while traveling.

Made a return for dinner! We grabbed some salads, including the chicken pesto and caprese salads…read moreand a side of garlic knots and it was amazing! The salads were really good and fresh, loved the grilled and breaded chicken and the Caesar dressing they have is also really good. The garlic knots are not to be missed!! So delicious! They changed up the orientation of the store which made seating feel a bit tight but otherwise service was great as usual.

La Roma Pizza & Tacos

3.8

(34 reviews)