Pizza Star

Made a return for dinner! We grabbed some salads, including the chicken pesto and caprese salads…read moreand a side of garlic knots and it was amazing! The salads were really good and fresh, loved the grilled and breaded chicken and the Caesar dressing they have is also really good. The garlic knots are not to be missed!! So delicious! They changed up the orientation of the store which made seating feel a bit tight but otherwise service was great as usual.

Excellent pizza! I had a slice of Sicilian and a plain. The Sicilian had a great, airy dough, nice…read moredollops of tasty tomato sauce and the perfect amount of cheese. It had a crispy crust and great texture. The plain slice was equally stellar. Thin, crispy crust and great cheese/sauce ratio. Yelp did not disappoint! Easy parking in municipal lot a few shops down. Easy on/off the NY Thruway. A great stopping point to stretch your legs and grab a bite while traveling.

See all

Village Pizza & Restaurant

3.5(53 reviews)

1.0 mi

Great food great service. Nice atmosphere. Definitely recommend . Go for the sausage and pepper…read moreparm sub. And the caprese salad is the best.

Passed the slice test. Their classic cheese slice is an excellent balance of light cheese, sweet…read moresauce, and thin, crispy bread, though a little heavier than the Slices slice nearby. Two fine pizzerias in Saugerties, though Village Pizza is the more traditional pizzeria experience of the two.

Menu

Village Pizza by Duchess Azure

See all

Tuscan 5 Cheese Slice

Tosco's Pizzeria

4.1(10 reviews)

1.8 mi

Delicious pizza and very friendly staff. Wide variety of…read morepizzas. Relatively new venue. Try it on 9W, Saugerties, NY.

I ordered a large chicken pesto pizza at their website for delivery. I also ordered the calamari…read moreand tiramasu. The calamari is not good. Too chewy, didn't seem to be prepared right. I know it was most likely frozen, not much can be done about that. Definitely not enjoyable. Did not finish eating it. After trying the tiramisu I found it was partially frozen and needed to be thawed before finishing. The pizza was good. I probably won't be ordering from Tosco's again anytime soon. It's a shame.

Chicken parm sub

See all

D’Elia’s Pizza

3.8(12 reviews)

0.1 mi

This Big Mac grandma slice from D'Elias Pizzeria, in Saugerties, was . With dill pickles and mac…read moresauce.

I am always pleased with the quality of food and service at D'Elia's! Dani (owner) is friendly,…read moreaccommodating, and professional. Highly recommend.

Pizza

Wood Fired Pizza

See all

You have to come in and try it

The Stone Pony Deli

4.3(24 reviews)

2.2 mi

The Stone Pony is great but the retail location is not open. It's catering now so don't see it on…read moreYelp as "Open" and think you can grab a bite.

Breakfast 3/5 stars…read more Stopped by to give their breakfast sandwich a shot. Ordered a bacon, egg and cheese and a breakfast at burrito. The sandwich comes on a hard roll that was actually soft and tasty. The sandwich was mostly bread, though. The burrito was warm and had egg, salsa, cheese and sour cream. It did the job and was hefty. IWe tried the house made roast beef and that was juicy and fresh! The deviled eggs were fresh and had a mild mustard flavor. They carry a full deli case of boars head meats and cold salads. I would come back and give their pizzas and sandwiches a shot, but for now, I was underwhelmed by the breakfast and would likely visit another local cafe or restaurant in the future. I'll add that the staff was very friendly and that weighs in on my over all impression. They also had a few places to sit outside if you came for lunch or on a warm morning.

See all

Brickyard Pizza

3.3(31 reviews)

2.0 mi

The salad was onions and croutons. I ordered penne, à la…read morevodka. The noodles are ziti noodles. They are the mushiest noodles I've ever eaten. And the sauce does not taste like vodka sauce at all. The staff was kind.

My partner has ordered delivery from here before, and she has always been very happy. Today I…read morepicked up food for us. The lady who helped me was friendly and helpful. It doesn't look like much on the inside. They do not have any inside seating, but there are two tables on the outside if you want to eat There. This is primarily at a to go spot. However, one thing that is cool, they actually have a working "space invaders" machine in a corner of the shop. My partner wanted a meatball slice, but they didn't have it that day, so, the lady offered to put meatballs on a garlic and mushroom slice. It was a big slice, too! My partner liked it very much. She said it was delicious. For dessert, she had a slice of the Godiva chocolate cake, or as we like to jokingly call it, the Godiva, death by chocolate cake. I haven't had it yet, but she says it is so rich and so very delicious! I wasn't very hungry today, so I just had the garlic knot meatball sliders. Excellent! You can definitely smell and taste the garlic, the garlic knots, themselves are tender, and the meatball in the middle is tender and very tasty. They also come with a good amount of cheese. There was a marinara sauce/gravy for dipping, that was also excellent. It was just an appetizer, but it filled me up. I ordered from them again, and I had the mushroom/meatball pizza that my partner had yesterday. It was delicious! For dessert, I had the fried dough, basically deep fried dough balls covered with powdered sugar. No, not diet food, but they are delicious. The price was very reasonable, and they even offer a military/veterans discount. There is a 4% "upcharge", to cover their costs if you are paying with plastic instead of cash. Not a big deal to us. We will definitely order from here again. Thank you!

See all

Vegan meatball and vegan sausage with daiya cheese

Miss Lucy's Kitchen

4.3(428 reviews)

1.0 mi

Amazing amazing amazing, loved everything about Miss Lucy's and wish we could've gone back for…read moreanother visit while in town! Definitely make a reservation beforehand as it was busy! Menu had lots of variety and the dessert specials were to die for. Everything was delicious - highly recommend the calamari appetizer and the complimentary bread was fantastic. I just about licked my dinner plate clean (get the duck breast)! Friends loved the fried chicken and the salmon. Wine list was great and service was wonderful.

We were eager to check out Miss Lucy's as one of the more popular spots in Saugerties. Thankfully…read moreit wasn't too annoying to get a reservation and we found the spot to be busy and popular among locals and tourists alike. Walking in we were seated promptly though we immediately noticed that the interior was extremely dark. Not a big deal but worth flagging for older folks who might have a hard time reading. Our server was friendly and relatively attentive and walked us through the menu. We started off with some classics including their bread and butter (which was tasty and delicious) and ordered their P.E.I Mussels ($19) along with their Fried Brussels Sprouts ($15) to share. The portions were quite large for everything (great if you're in a larger party) but we immediately noticed that the mussels they served seemed a bit off. Many of them were not opened all the way (a sign that they might not be the freshest or recently passed) and had a bit of a fishy taste to them. We ended up not finishing them and flagged them to our waiter. The other items, including the 14oz Ribeye ($43) and baby back ribs ($28) were better, though a bit one-note. The bay back ribs in particular were extremely saucy and the corn bread was dry and a bit tough to eat. I had to use a knife to split it apart as it kept crumbling every time I used a fork. Regardless, it seems like a popular spot for a reason and perhaps we just went during more of an off-night. I'd still recommend checking it out but avoiding the mussels if you go.

Dinning room

His Fried Chkn

See all

Dinning room

Two Brothers Deli & Pizza

3.3(75 reviews)

1.1 mi

Great pizza. Those are heavy boxes, so you get a lot for the dollar. All the staff is pleasant and…read moreplenty of free parking. Nice dining room. Recommended

Awesome pizza! Only downside is because it's so good I end up eating more of it! I placed an order…read morefor pickup for a large pie and it took about 20 mins. Service upon pickup was nice and quick. Parking is a breeze and it's right off 32 making it such an easy pass through on your way somewhere! Plenty of seating inside and the atmosphere is comfortable.

Counter and menu

When I called to complain she said she made my sub and it was impeccable. Seriously????

See all

Annarella Ristorante

4.6(235 reviews)

1.9 mi

•$$$

Ima keep ranting about this part of New York. This area really don't got a lot of good flavor. And…read morewhat I mean by that, like the cooking just ain't cooking for most of these spots. And idk what it is, it could be just the local folks don't got that much flavor in their taste buds and they the anti-City folk type so most of the businesses just lack in that field. With that said... this was a pretty decent Italian spot I will say WITH that consideration in mind. I did have the ravioli with slow cooked carne inside and that was delicious. My wife got the lasagna and... it was iiiitte. Family next to us were raving about it and like they were nice and we were being polite. But like let's be real here - it tasted like Stouffer's. Not that it's a knock, but at that point, you paying for the atmosphere. Which I will say the indoors is nice. You can have a nice date night or family outing here. There's a bar and plenty of parking. The service was on point and very accommodating with our new born. Who we were chopping it up with our waiter, and found out the owner's name is also the same as our kid so that was fun talking with them on. The garlic bread - idk if it's supposed to come cold, but it had like tomato sauce on it, it was like the complimentary bread with some extra shit on it. But I wasn't feeling that, but my inner Italian side just kept dipping it in my red, and it was all good. I'm glad we came here but probably won't be back if given the chance. But we looked around, and it seemed like to be the only viable Italian restaurant in the area so, if given under the same conditions, we would be back lol. I just went back and forth there like 3 times. Is that non-Ai enough of a review for you Yelp? After they flagged me for actually structuring and editing my reviews like in old school English class. Now yelp is promoting "Yelp Assistant" even though it's Ai. Gtfo here lmao

For our wedding anniversary, we traveled across the river to Annarellas Ristorante on 276 Malden…read moreTurnpike in Saugerties We arrived early as we were traveling about an hour away and we're aware there were many detours as the Malden Bridge is undergoing repairs. I'd read about Annarellas prior to this, and based on glowing reviews chose this to mark 50 years together, 39 as husband and wife...long engagement! We were not disappointed. We were seated promptly by our lovely hostess, and Shaun immediately came over to recite specials and to take our orders. He was attentive and we knew we were in good hands! We started with the Dr. Fox Cocktail: Angostura bitters, Bulleit Rye, Apple Liqueur, Dry Curacao, and Sweet Vermouth, which was perfect. It was accompanied by a hummus trio to spread on the bread. There was also a delicious foccacio. Next we were served a perfect salad, delicately dressed, and what made the salad so delightful was that the lettuce was torn into manageable pieces. A pet peeve of mine is large lettuce leaves that are difficult to wrangle, and this was not the case here. There were also tiny bits of cauliflower that gave the salad a nice texture and crunch. I had the Stuffed Artichoke and my husband had Shrimp Gamberi on an Arugula salad. Both were substantial and beautifully seasoned. We had two glasses of an Argentine Tomero Malbec. It was a generous pour. For the main course, I had Polla al Limone (Lemon Chicken) over spinach. A simple dish done well. My husband had the Halibut special, a classic Mediterranean baked halibut with tomatoes, capers, and olives. So good that he finished it all...a rarity for him. (The halibut was pricey and it would be appreciated if the price was mentioned when the specials were gone over. Perhaps we should have asked.) We finished with a Sorbetto al Lampone, a tart raspberry sorbet in a dark chocolate shell and sliced. And as we left, our sweet hostess brought over Lucianno, the most adorable puppy, to send us off with puppy kisses! We definitely will be back...especially for the wild boar ragu over pappadelles. One nitpicking observation. The entrance to the restaurant was a tad shabby. We mistook it for the service entrance. It needs to be spruced up to match the superb food inside!

Inside

Homemade focaccia bread delicious

See all

Outside

Mirabella

3.7(82 reviews)

1.1 mi

Bella's is my absolute F A V O R I T E! Staff is incredibly friendly, attentive, and generous…read more Nothing beats a spot at the bar, especially after a long day at the horse show! Owner's wife is also hot (respectfully).

Great food very appetizing cool bar, nice staff, friendly, smiling faces we enjoyed the pool table…read moreand television

Menu

See all

Drinks

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Mike J.

0

1

0

6 years ago

Went to get my pizza , 5 people standing in 6'by6' space pickup area , none of the food service workers wearing masks or gloves . The guy who waited on me was sniffling ! I wanted to just walk out but paid for my pizza against my better judgement! NEVER AGAIN ! No barrier between workers & customers at counter , worker came out into seating are walking past waiting are with no mask on sat down & proceeded to eat his lunch ! UNREAL ! & when I say no mask I mean NO MASK .. not on chin or hanging on ear .. NO MASK ! Or gloves ! I left ! SANITIZED & REPORTED THEM TO THE CORONA VIRUS HOTLINE FOR RESTAURANTS NOT IN COMPLIANCE ! HOPEFULLY THEY DIDN'T GET ME SICK !!! BEWARE !!! read more

mary e.

48

21

0

5 years ago

This place is disgusting!!! Don't waste your money! I had an antipasto. The meat wAs bad. The lettuce was wilted. It was soggy....my sausage roll was also soggy soggy soggy & it tasted like wet dog!! I had diarrhea after I ate that shit!! Yuk!! Threw my entire food up!! Frozen fake food! Cannot believe this place is still in businesses read more

Jean D.

0

5

0

3 months ago

Rude, unfriendly and unprofessional. Place reminds me the pizza place from do the right thing movie. Need i day more. Curly hair owner said" get the fuck out of here" as I was leaving the door because I didn't support his soccer team in the world cup. Unprofessional and rude. Place was 100% empty. Need i say more. read more

Kristen D.

0

7

0

1 year ago

Owner is very rude and obviously doesn't care about customers. Also has a bunch of Trump signs all over his walls. The food is decent, but I refuse to go there anymore. Johnny is running his business into the ground. My family has been going there over 20 years, but we all are not coming back now. read more

Jersey F.

0

1

0

9 years ago

If I could only give this place negative stars! Ugh, my friends and I are staying at Howard Johnsons down the road, We ate here and all got very sick. This place should be shut down by the health department. Shame on you.... read more

Alexandra P.

0

1

0

7 years ago

Let me start with this place has great pizza. However, one of the employees consistently and publicly shames my friends with fat comments. Always telling him that he shouldn't eat so much. He should be FIRED! read more

Andrew P.

0

14

6

7 years ago

Staff likes to demean women and make sexual jokes. Pizza is a 3 outta 10. Will not be going back

Pizza Star - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Saugerties, New York Restaurants near Pizza Star

BEST of Saugerties, New York Coffee near Pizza Star

BEST of Saugerties, New York Things to Do near Pizza Star

BEST of Saugerties, New York Breakfast near Pizza Star

BEST of Saugerties, New York Dinner near Pizza Star

BEST of Saugerties, New York Desserts near Pizza Star

BEST of Saugerties, New York Burgers near Pizza Star

BEST of Saugerties, New York Shopping near Pizza Star

BEST of Saugerties, New York Movie Theatre near Pizza Star

Best of Saugerties

Things to do in Saugerties

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Pizza Star also viewed

Slices of Saugerties

4.3

(187 reviews)

Made a return for dinner! We grabbed some salads, including the chicken pesto and caprese salads…read moreand a side of garlic knots and it was amazing! The salads were really good and fresh, loved the grilled and breaded chicken and the Caesar dressing they have is also really good. The garlic knots are not to be missed!! So delicious! They changed up the orientation of the store which made seating feel a bit tight but otherwise service was great as usual.

Excellent pizza! I had a slice of Sicilian and a plain. The Sicilian had a great, airy dough, nice…read moredollops of tasty tomato sauce and the perfect amount of cheese. It had a crispy crust and great texture. The plain slice was equally stellar. Thin, crispy crust and great cheese/sauce ratio. Yelp did not disappoint! Easy parking in municipal lot a few shops down. Easy on/off the NY Thruway. A great stopping point to stretch your legs and grab a bite while traveling.

Vincenzo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.3

(68 reviews)

I love this place. Whenever I am in the area on vacation, I always tell my wife whatever we do, I…read moreneed to be in Kingston in the afternoon one day so I can get pizza at Vincenzo's. Absolutely love it.

This felt like a one man shop! Walk right to the counter to place your order with the older…read moregentleman making the pizzas. If you choose to eat in, grab a table after placing your order and someone will bring pizza and drinks to you. They do not offer beer, so hubby was a little disappointed. Highly suggest calling ahead to place your order!! It took about 15 min for the pizza and a small 14" still left us with leftovers! Pizza was very good - definitely a wonderful find on our travels!

Picnic Pizza

3.5

(167 reviews)

One of the best pizza's I've ever had in my life. I chose…read moreonions, mushroom, extra cheese and garlic (I've searched high and low for someone to get those ingredients right!) The best pizza I previously had was as a child in north beach, SF- turns out I just had to go to NY a 100 years later to find the other best pizza.

Been coming here for years! 3/1/26 was The Worse Pizza Ever AnyWhere! Yikes, Yuck!!! Hard Rubber…read moreCheese, SUPER SALTY!!! Crust was Tough & It was Just Terrible!!! omg Never Again! Why??? Used to be good! GONE, GONE, GONE!!! TOO BAD, NOT ALL CHANGE IS GOOD! Should of kept things REAL! We tossed the Whole Pie right in the Trash! Not Good!!! Bye

Village Pizza III

4.1

(62 reviews)

New to the area and all our neighbors recommend Village Pizza as the best pizza around…read more Absolutely agree,good value,excellent pizza,friendly staff. We are fans!!

My friends and I decided to do a blind pizza tasting of 6 top rated pizza restaurants in Red Hook,…read moreRhinebeck, and Tivoli. Village Pizza was the winner!! And they came in on a day they had planned to be closed just to complete our order! Great work guys.

Mama's Pizza and Trattoria

3.6

(73 reviews)

staff and food exceptional easily accessible and friendly…read moreservice family owned by the staff and owner specials are great and pizza !

The food is amazing!!!! Service is definitely a little slow but when you consider that you're…read moregetting a pizza made from scratch, it feels worth the wait. Love you mama.

440 Pizzeria

3.5

(33 reviews)

Kinda pricey for what we ordered but everything is pricey now inQ3-4 2026 (FDT) and it's no…read morejudgement against the pizzeria. Pizza was- as always- perfect! Also their Sicilian pie is amazing. Added mozzarella sticks which rocked tho the clamshell dishes melted into the food. The boneless wings were cold but yummy. Delivery was quick and easy- driver was awesome, friendly and attentive. They always provide a good dinner.

1/10/26 - ordered boneless wings, onion rings, and a large chef salad, with NO onions…read more Boneless wings is supposed to be 10 pieces, we got 9. Chef salad had a huge amount of onions which had to be removed. The person who took my order asked twice about the no onions.

La Roma Pizza & Tacos

3.8

(34 reviews)

Taco Tuesday is the BEST deal around! And their pizza is AMAZING!! $3.00 tacos all day on…read moreTuesdays! Every Tuesday I get 2 Arrachera Taco's and 1 Pineapple Shrimp Taco! And a White slice with, broccoli, tomato, ricotta and fresh garlic!!

A recent Friday evening visit to LaRoma was the best- from the autumn pumpkins at the door to the…read moreTV screens displaying a roaring fire in both dining rooms- to the excellent live band softly playing their music. Excellent service, delicious food, you can't ask for a better place to relax & enjoy a meal.

Lucoli

4.3

(74 reviews)