I can understand why some reviewers have found fault here: pizza in the glass case did not look particularly appetizing, and, since we were ordering more slices than they had on any of the trays in the case, we asked them to make a new pie for us, which they did. That pie, plain pizza, was as good as any pizza that people rave about coming out of a New York City pizza place. Lots of cheese, very good sauce, the crust was just the right thickness & we enjoyed every bite. We loved all the Yankees baseball paraphernalia on the walls, the newspaper clipping collage honoring the town's local sports players and, well, the pizza. Not much ambiance here, inside or out, there are a couple of small tables outside (it's pretty warm & stuffy inside) & we would come here again. read more

See all

Great tasting pizza, friendly service, and a hometown feeling inside make this a great spot to stop in at! read more

Bennys Pizzeria - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Stone Ridge, New York

The place has been my childhood pizza stop. Benny pizza every Friday. Now that I'm older have ordered here many times disappointed. Last time was a month ago I ordered. the person that took the order place the order paper and put it with the credit cards receipt. I stood there for an hour and then she comes and says your order was just place now because the paper was with the credit card receipts. Not a I'm sorry madam but I missed placed your order, and as soon as u walk in they asked what name your order is so they know who's waiting. I was so disappointed and mad and the owner's daughter was there not a word from her I'm sorry . This has happen before(like forgot to make something that we ordered. The pizza is cheap cheese so greasy that a few times immediately get sick from all the grease.this pizza place can do better.the prices is outages! read more

Our favorite pizza! No one does BBQ chicken pizza like Bennys! The best owner and team as well! read more

Bennys Pizzeria - BBQ Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stone Ridge, New York

I always find myself gravitating back to Benny's. Other places in the area do put up good competition and I like to spread my business around, however when it comes to certain menu items it has to be Benny's! I'm talking about their Margherita pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, fried calamari and garlic knots. Ohhh and great tomato sauce and others I know agree on the sauce being very good. It is a tiny place, always kept immaculate, but I prefer to do take out as it gets crowded. The menu has variety and portions are generous. Some reviewers mention service issues, I never had problems, but a little unpolished. read more

The best "original" pizza in the area. I've tried many in the area and this is by far the best. Will definitely go back.

Tonight my team and I made a large order, and for the THIRD time in recent weeks, did not receive part of the order. And when I say large, it was almost $120. We called the shop and the young lady literally told me "I don't work here a lot" after telling her what happened. She then proceeds to tell me that she forgot to write the items we were missing down. Luckily my partner saved food from lunch and was able to still eat. Add to this the microwaved "grilled" chicken, burnt slices, soggy garlic bread, disgusting store-grade meatballs, needless to say we will not be returning. This place receives LESS THAN one star for their lack of professionalism, lack of quality, and over all disregard for customer satisfaction. HIGHLY DO NOT RECOMMEND. read more

Absolutely amazing pizzeria 10/10 service, food, and atmosphere while in vacation with family this was the best way to start on the ride up. Legit New York pizza read more

Bennys Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Stone Ridge, New York

Excellent Pizza!!! Wow. I had the basil pizza accompanied by the broccoli pizza. I also tried a garlic bread knot. Pizza was ready in minutes and was super fresh. Great service, nice outdoor seating with umbrellas. Ingredients all fresh and you can tell they take a lot of pride in their craft. They have plenty of soft drinks to choose from too. The ambiance is chill and comfortable inside. Overall a 5 star experience. read more

Owner is an asshole and stuck up, food is barely average and for their prices i think its not worth it. Dont even bother

As you can see from the owner's response to my original poor review of this place, he would rather threaten physical violence towards me and others, then respectfully answer, address and improve upon his subpar (lousy) food and overpriced menu. I you read any number of the bad reviews; this seems to be his M.O. His standard reply to the many negative reviews ??? "Tell it to my face" so childish and unprofessional. I think his reply speaks volumes about him as an owner, his product line and a lack of concern or caring for his customers. By the way, I live and work in the area and my neighbors and co-workers all agree with me.. They laughed when I told them I went there. A number of people on this forum have complained about being intentionally overcharged. Perhaps that is why he has no pricing on his website menu ???? Benny's (and its owner) is certainly not the kind of place I wish to patronize. Too many other better, more welcoming and reasonably priced places close by. Not being cruel or unfair, just writing a review and expressing an honest opinion. Thanks.. read more

This place is absolutely phenomenal. As a New York City foodie who cares a lot about pizza quality this place really holds the bar above all else. Super fresh ingredients. No nonsense. Will be back. read more

10/10 food and service, love this place. Every time I come here the food and people are so amazing! Highly recommend the chicken bacon ranch pizza, absolutely loaded with toppings and delicious! read more

I love the pizza idk how you make the sauce sweet but it's so good I just rip the cheese off and slurp the sauce straight off every time bro and the garlic twists are FIRE common bennys W except for the actual guy ig -fire food critics read more

Wanted to find something new after an away Field Hockey game. Definitely found the spot!! Walked into an amazing family atmosphere of warmness and positivity. The place smelt amazing and the food had generous portions for our main meals. Our two kids were picky eaters and were eating off our plates. From creamy Alfredo sauce with the chicken fettuccine Alfredo to the perfect blend of ricotta and mozzarella on the baked zita. The homemade garlic knots were huge and out of this world!!! We got a pie to go and it had a nice blend of sauce to cheese ratio with a crisp to the crust. Bonus slice of the Chicken bacon ranch on the way out can compare to no one!! Definitely worth the hour trip for us to be returning soon for more amazing food. Best eating experience of 2023 with a great outdoor seating setup that even has bands come play. read more

Bennys Pizzeria - Fun family atmosphere to spread out and enjoy your family time - Pizza Near Me - Stone Ridge, New York

See all

I give Benny's one Star not because of the food but the staff and owner have the customer service personality of dirt. The food is ok, however the last 3 times I have called there the attitude of the female and then male I spoke to on phone is nothing short of rude and off putting. The price of most of their items is a little more than average but would be worth paying as Stone Ridge does not have much to offer in variety of restaurants. I can certainly say after the last phone encounter with these individuals I definitely won't be inclined to use them and certainly will not be recommending to anyone as an option. read more

Great pizza at a great price. Salads were HUGE and so tasty. Service was unbelievable - everyone was so friendly and food came out fast. Outdoor seating was also so cute and great for a group. We left so full and they insisted we try some of their cannolis. They were worth it to say the least. We will be making the trip back! read more

Bennys Pizzeria - Outdoor seating - Pizza Near Me - Stone Ridge, New York

High priced and additional fees for credit card....The food was ok and there was very little seating

Pizza is average but what is crazy is that the website doesnt tell you what the prices are. Ordered a lg pie and wings and it was $42. Food was ok but $42?!?!?! read more

Best pizza ever!!!! Service is good. The young girl there doesn't smile at all but I guess is nice.

Benny's just catered our Christmas Eve dinner. It was fantastic!!! The customer service was excellent when I picked the food up. Everyone raved about the food. Thank you! read more

Amazing pizza! Highly recommend! Thier garlic knots are fantastic too.

Ordered the Bountiful Vegetarian Nachos. The worst nachos I've ever had. Never in my life have I had Nachos made with Cheese Whiz!! The menu says "with melted cheese", not with fake cheese or Cheese Whiz. And it was $18.00!! in a to-go pan with foil on the top which was falling off. All the fake cheese was on the top, nothing on the bottom. Besides the fake cheese, the topping was canned olives, chopped/unripe tomatoes and chopped onions. The most unappetizing and most expensive order I've ever had. I guess they figure they are the only game in town and can do what they want. Re their pizza: I ordered 3 large pies with meat. I got the bill: $90.00!!! $30 per pie? It wasn't made with gold! read more

I was visiting my son in Stone Ridge, N.Y. He took me to Benny's. I ordered a slice of cheese. It was the BEST slice of cheese that I have had in 50 years!!!!! I moved out of N.Y. 50 years ago. I can't wait to go back. Maybe end of October. read more

We got the chicken barbecue pizza tonight because my daughter was just dying to have it. She currently goes to college out of town in missed Benny's Pizza. I have to say, we weren't disappointed. Order the BBQ Chicken pizza if you want a filling, delightful treat. In the summer months you can sit outside, enjoy great food and relax. Benny and his staff greet everyone who enter like they're family. Thank you Benny for another excellent meal! My daughter goes back to school happy. read more

We love Benny's. Always our go to pizza spot in the area. Consistent and the garlic knots and wings are great too. Thank you Benny's!

went "30 minutes" before closing when online and the menu said it closed at 10pm. we came as a group of 10 and they said we couldn't even sit, we had to put the chairs down on our own And got no service. once we got home and ate the food, the food was almost inedible and instead of giving one of the meals garlic bread they gave us bread bun with nothing on it. will not be coming back. read more

Bennys Pizzeria - a sandwich wrapped in aluminum foil - Pizza Near Me - Stone Ridge, New York

This restaurant has great flavors but honestly deplorable textures for all of their foods. When you order pizza, you expect a crispy bottom and a soft cheesy top. Bennys gives you a soggy, oily bottom, and an even more oily top. If you order a panini, you expect a crispy sandwich right? Wrong. Bennys paninis taste like someone steamed them in warm water. And the bruschetta, I mean, it's hard to screw up bruschetta, but they've done it. The bread is soaked in oil and soft, yet again. The picture included is of the Mother Italy panini and this is just an example of how soggy the bread is. Like I said, great flavors and very creative and awesome ideas, but terrible textures. For someone like me, that is super important when it comes to bread and this makes it extremely hard for me to find the food redeemable. read more

Bennys Pizzeria - a hand holding a sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Stone Ridge, New York

Pizza from here really isn't great, it's convenient. Ordering was no easy chore as the individual who took the order seemingly found it difficult to understand words. While waiting an hour to get pizza delivered 13 minutes away, we get a call asking for the credit card expiration date. The pizza hadn't even left the shop. Spoke to the owner, no "sorry your pizza is late", I get, "Some people wait 2 hours." So, whenever I want pizza in this area I will skip Benny's and go to Picnic Pizza in Kingston. It'll take me a 1/2 to drive there, but at least I know I'll get decent pizza. read more

Very very average. Ordered a tuna fish sub and called ahead to ask if it was tuna salad. The employee on the phone didn't seem to know anything about the menu. He asked someone else and they confirmed it was tuna salad. I asked for it with cheese on it, toasted. No problem. I ordered a few other items as well. They said it would be ready in 25 min. We showed up 30 min later and still had to wait 10 minutes. The employees behind the counter didn't seem to know anything either. I asked for a cup of water and she just stared at me...seemingly mute. Arrived home and my sub had in toasted cheese on top of tuna- no mayo at all. Absolutely disgusting. Do not recommend this place at all. The incompetence is shocking. read more

This asshole doesn't deserve a review or his mediocre pizza but I just want to let anybody know who's ordering from here that there MO is go to the wrong house and call the wrong number and then refuse to bring u a pizza so you guys better answer the door. And if bennys reads this fuck you you suck and the only thing ppl like u for is your chicken bacon ranch but that's only bc 2 places deliver around here. read more

Benny, the owner doesn't wear a mask. The staff do, but not the owner. There are better places to get pizza that's so much better. Try Ollies just down the road. read more

If you like loads of toppings on your pizza like I do, go to Benny's. When I saw that Benny's wasn't getting enough love on Yelp, I had to share my review. They sell by the slice and there are usually many different kinds to choose from in the case. I highly recommend the White Broccoli with Ricotta, the Philly Cheesesteak, Buffalo Chicken, or BBQ Chicken slices. I've had the mushroom slice, too, and it's pretty good. The amount of chicken they fit on the pizza is absurd, really. I've never seen any other pizza joint with the amount of toppings they fit onto their slices. I'll try to post a picture so that you can get the full effect. My boyfriend usually sends me pictures of the slices when I'm out of town to torture me, so I'm sure I have one somewhere. Sometimes the White Broccoli with Ricotta is a little underdone, but I simply place it in my oven for a few minutes and it is 10x better when the crust is a little crisp because the ricotta can soften the crust up a little too much. I've never had a bad experience like some of the other reviewers and I can be pretty picky. read more

Bennys Pizzeria - Two Buffalo Chicken slices and a White Broccoli with Ricotta slice - Pizza Near Me - Stone Ridge, New York

Tonight was a special night for our family. We had a very special evening. Tonight we picked out the perfect tree...we found it in Stone Ridge. This has nothing to do with yelp or food until the crew proclaimed..."were starving", so I pulled into a pizza place called "Bennys Pizzeria"! Let me just say "a perfect ending to a perfect day. As soon as you get into the door we were met with hot apple cider, fresh cider donuts and cookies. The kids couldn't wait. The sign said help yourself and they did. It reminded me of how we use to visit house to house for the holidays back in the day. Did I mention this was all free, yes i said free? UNBELIEVABLE! Patrons inside say this is typical Bennys, he does this with candy apples, cannoli's, and chocolate covered strawberries, depending on the season. We finally made our way up to the counter to place our order. Now almost completely full on cider and donuts the kids ordered a chicken parmigiano sub to split. My wife and I ordered two slices and fried calamari. The order took a little while to get. When the chicken parm arrived I thought they were kidding, it was so huge we all could have shared it. The sauce was fresh and just the right color and the chicken was tender and juicy with a great crunch. Our pizza slices were incredible and also a dinner in themselves. The Calamari was tender and cooked to perfection. Looking forward to the next trip back to Stone Ridge, if for nothing but just to eat at Bennys. Thank you from one full satisfied family read more

Bennys Pizzeria - a slice of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Stone Ridge, New York

See all

Oh my God, just got my appetizers and they are amazing! We have not gotten our dinners yet because we are still eating appetizers but as soon as we get them I will post more. hopefully I can take some pictures because this food looks great! read more

See all

I'd give three and a half but rounding up to four .. I penne al vodka with chicken and a cheese pizza for delivery .. the delivery was quick enough (about standard) and the food came piping hot. The penne al vodka was good, but nothing memorable. The cheese pizza was good and had nice sauce, but it was way too cheesy for my liking. I liked how the sauce went almost to the whole crust. read more

Me and my boyfriend were staying in the area and decided to give Benny's a try. We ordered a pizza, wings and garlic knots and even after the 20 minute drive home everything was still delicious, hot and fresh. I wish we stayed longer because we would've definitely ordered from here again! Everyone in the restaurant was nice and helpful. You probably won't find anything better around here than this! read more

THE WORST PIZZA IVE EVER HAD!!!!!! the pizza is AWFUL. disgustingly greasy and soggy. it's a joke. benny himself is a joke. he is rude and STUPID. he has ZERO respect for his staff nor his paying customers. i am just in utter disbelief. i've actually noticed that benny doesn't do much of anything, other than complain and yell at the sweet and friendly girls working the front counter. they were the only enjoyable thing about this place. also, never forget that none of the staff members or benny himself wear a mask, and i know they are not vaccinated as i've overheard them discussing their political views and views about vaccinations and covid is general. read more

We ordered a hot combination sub with fries and coleslaw. This was half of our order. The other half was fine. The girl on the phone said 40 minutes. The boyfriend told them the sub is cold and is supposed to be hot. Even after the second attempt the sub was not hot. The cheese wasn't melted. The boyfriend was told to throw it in the oven at home. No coleslaw was added even though it was ordered. The fries are good. Not very happy. I'm at work. The food should be prepared as ordered or remade to meet the order. This was not my order. read more

I have been to Benny's many times over the last 20 years and have yet to have a negative experience. Their pizza is outstanding and loaded with toppings. The food is made fresh and is second to none. The staff is friendly and go out of their way to satisfy. There are at least two other pizzerias in the area, but none can compare. For those who left bad reviews, you live to complain and are unworthy to consume the delicacies they prepare and serve. read more

Bennys Pizzeria - What a beautiful and tasty calzone. Yum yum. - Pizza Near Me - Stone Ridge, New York