Based solely on the crust, I'd rank Ollie's behind Pizzeria Posto, Nightschool, and Hilltown Pies. That still puts it in my Top 5 for the Hudson Valley. The crust is too doughy for me. I know they're not going for New York style, but Hilltown does a very similar wood-fired pie and their crust is significantly better. The ingredients on both of our pies were high quality. Neither was greasy. Their Famous Onion Pie, a ring of sesame seeds around the outer edge and calabrian chilies, ranks with the best signature pies any of their competitors are making. The place is loud. Feels like a college pizzeria took over a refurbished old barn. And it gets crowded quick. Get in early and try the onion pie. read more

Back again on a Friday at 5 pm Ordered 2 pizzas, meatballs, Diet Coke etc Fast friendly service Ollie's child shirt too Highly recommend read more

See all

Pizza is substantively better than competitors however this is offset by the staff. Have visited seven times and the bartender has an unwavering dour disposition. Surely they could find a more customer-friendly employee for this role. It is a critical point of contact and presently deeply flawed. Normally the staff who answer the phone for take-out are quite pleasant but we've encountered some really ill-equipped kids in this role that simply don't know what they're doing. After numerous negative on-site dining experiences that were suboptimal, the take-out process now appears to be faltering as well. Regrettably, while I once heartily recommended Ollie's I believe they now have systemic service quality issues which, while insidious, are not intractable. Hopefully, there will be some staff changes. read more

Recommend to us by our Inn Keeper. Great choice. Pizza was fantastic. the staff friendly and informative. Will go there again if ever in the area read more

EXCELLENT VEGAN PIZZA! Thin crust. Deelish! Fresh. I like extra oregano plus crushed red peppers. Ollie's Salad is so good I can't try anything else. Has shredded jalapeños and olives. The dressing is vegan, too. Nice restaurant inside. Big bar in the center. Staff was helpful and were nice people. Plenty of outdoor seating, weather permitting. Parking lot looked big, then filled up quickly. See the pictures! Great food. Reasonable price. Good service. I'll be back ... Helpful? read more

See all

From the people behind Eliza, Fletcher & Lu and one other, Ollie's Pizza in High Falls, NY, has paved the way for success- and it delivers. And they know it. Plus these folks say it loud and proud that they're the first born; not Eliza- their sister restaurant over in Kingston which we love. We moseyed through back roads to familiarize ourselves then noticed Ollie's without even planning it. Just then, I realized Ollie's is sitting on an antique+vintage black barn shop I visited several years back. Anyhow. I love a good ol' slice- but I've mentioned a bunch of times that I also love a Neapolitan-style pie. From air bubbles, thin- but not too thin triangle, chewy- but not gummy crust and charred marks- that are just perfect. Folks, if you're looking for a pie like that, this is a must-visit. From the gravel picnic-style area to inside, Ollie's P. gives off that little je ne sais quoi that you won't find anywhere else- especially in these sticks. My White Pie with 3 cheeses and caramelized onions was so good- everything worked together for a flavorful bite after bite and hubs devoured his Margherita with pepperoni add-on. They also offer cacio e pepe arancini, roasted broccolini, salads, sandwiches, etc- if you prefer something other than pizza. My pro tip would be to order a pizza- I mean....you're here already and honestly, you won't regret it. Service was phenomenal and so was my Shirley Temple. read more

See all

We were greeted with a smiling face as the hostess welcomed us to the establishment. We brought our dog with us and we're a little nervous, but the tables are very spaced out that each customer has their own area. We started our service off with the glazed, hot honey wings, followed by a Caesar salad and the white pie pizza with pepperoni. I included photos of all the food except the pizza because we got too hungry and I forgot to take a picture of it, lol. Overall great service and a dog friendly establishment! They have water bowls for the dogs to use while you're dining there. The staff was very friendly and the bathroom was very clean. read more

Ollie's Pizza - Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - High Falls, New York

See all

Came here for my son's wedding rehearsal dinner! Sophie you were amazing from us contacting you to the minute we walked out! Food was awesome! We couldn't ask for better service our guests were very happy! Thanks for an amazing dinner party! read more

The best pizza and one of my favorite places to go in general. Extra stars for their gluten-free pizza, delicious cocktails, and festive atmosphere. I love Ollie's!!! read more

What a great spot with a very happy team. Everyone was smiling and happy to be there. Everything was delicious. Space was great and classically curated with some vintage charm. Server was superb and kind with a hint of super friendly. Drove up from Poughkeepsie and we'll be back in the spring for some outdoor seating. read more

See all

For the outrageous prices, the service is subpar at best. We ordered two pizzas, two orders of wings, and one salad. We paid 135 before tip. Pizzas were just average taste wise. Small. Soggy. 22 an order for normal, basic wings. We weren't greeted when we arrived by the host outside. We went inside and no one was at any table. And we still weren't greeted. We went to the bar to sit. We ended up at a table. The hostess was rude to us. The bartender was dismissive. We were asked to move to a different table - again, no one was seated at any table. It was odd. Like there were rules that no one knew or stated. Really not worry the price for food quality nor service. They're clearly trying to cultivate something for tourists or folks whose idea of a pizza night is 150 dollars. read more

Really love the picnic vibe sitting outside of Ollie's! Kid friendly dog friendly and busy on summer days. Counter service with a menu packed with lots of pre-suggested pizza combos or make your own option. We started with the cacio e Pepe arrancini which were delicious! We also ordered a plain cheese pie with mushrooms and the famous onion pie to share. We loved the thin crust dough and the freshness of the ingredients! The favorite was the cheese and mushroom pie and truthfully I was left a little disappointed by the onion pie. The pies are on the smaller, and pricier, side. I think I'd personally prefer Ollies more for the ambiance/ experience on a summer day than for the pizza itself. read more

See all

This place has the best pizza in the Hudson Valley. Super thin crust and perfectly done each time we visit. The salad is also amazing and always super fresh. You can choose to eat outside at the picnic tables or inside. Outside has an ordering counter but inside has waitstaff. Most of the wait staff is amazing. It's a 45 minute ride but totally worth it. read more

My friends and I were really pleasantly surprised by how good the pizza from this little spot was. The thin crust had a little bit of char and a subtle smoky and saltiness that went well with our pizza choices. Our favorite was the upside down margarita, which they recommended we get. The arancini were also a good add on and some of the biggest ones I've ever seen. (That's what she said!) Ollie's is obviously a staple in town. Do yourself a favor, and if you're doing takeout, call many hours ahead. It's very popular! read more

See all

Love!!!! The cooks, servers, and bartenders are incredibly attentive and proud of what they serve (as they should be!) the ingredients are incredibly fresh and the drinks are on point. Also it's a fun space to chill or have a date. We loved it! read more

The worst pizza I ever ate . The crust was burnt and the cheese tasted cheap . Dinner was ruined ! If you want to throw out $21, Ollie's is a place to go . I paid by credit card never left a tip even before I knew the pizza was horrible! read more

My besties live in Rosendale and whenever I come up to stay with them, it's our tradition to go to Ollies for pizza. Servvice is always been good. We've always been greeted nicely by the hostess and the waiters are across-the-board, friendly and helpful. Needless to say, I love the pizza and we love trying every different kind they have. Definitely my favorite place in High Falls. read more

See all

Fresh sauce and ingredients, tasty original pizza crust, friendly enthusiastic service and indoor/ outdoor seating is clean, comfortable and spacious. read more

The food was outstanding. I wish I wasnt from out of town, I would be at this place weekly. Try the cacio e pepe riceballs!!!

Oh wow this pizza is incredible. Just delicious. I see a lot of reviews complaining about the prices. The prices that are clearly written on the menu. Nobody forced you to order anything. Shut up. Really nice outdoor seating too. This is the first place I've sat down to eat since all this craziness started and I felt very comfortable. Everything is very spaced apart. I'll definitely be back. Brett rules! read more

Ollie's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - High Falls, New York

Fantastic pizza! Cool place great music great vibe nice people who work here great drinks nice outdoor eating area

We were pleasantly surprised with this place during a trip upstate. Stopped by for lunch on a Saturday and it was pretty busy mostly with families eating outside. They have a nice set-up with a stand where you can order drinks and food. There's also a full restaurant inside with a view of the kitchen, but it was pretty quiet there then since it was so nice out. We shared the Ollie's Salad with added Chicken Cutlet and The Famous Onion Pizza between two of us and it was the perfect amount of food. The salad was light and fresh, the cutlet was a perfect addition for a full meal - juicy and crispy. I loved the pizza dough, so thin and chewy and the sesame seeds were an unexpected touch. It was really hard to decide on what to get since everything sounded so good. I'd definitely like to come back for more! read more

See all

Food and service was great!! Super close to mohonk preserve trail heads which is made it perfect post hike

I took my son and Sister here for a day trip to try out Ollies and catch Fall Foliage! We scored both successfully! I'm a fan of Best Pizza in Williamsburg and Frank is an Alma Mater of my High School St.Anthonys out in South Huntington, LI so there's that. After reading about all the Pizza Farms sprouting about all across the State and country I had to drive here from Park Slope to see and experience what this is all about. It takes a good 2 hours from Brooklyn and we arrived just at noon on a Friday. No wait l, plenty of tables for social distancing and it looked and felt like a great vibe! We went ahead and ordered a grandma style with 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 sausage and mushroom in addition to a classic round margherita pie and some beers and juice. They give you a number and bring everything out to your table. All clean all sanitized all felt safe. The pizzas came out and boy were we impressed . They both tasted delicious looked incredible and tasted phenomenal. All in the till came to about $80 so for sure not cheap but considering the quality, atmosphere it was expected and well worth it. We will come back again in the Spring and hope they are able to stay in business this Winter and eek out some profits to stay afloat! Great job and this is a real ge read more

Ollie's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - High Falls, New York

See all

Great spot to sit outside and enjoy delicious pizza and other dishes. We had the Margherita pizza, broccolini, and a salad. All good. They have a small but decent beer selection and other drinks too. Nice chill place to hang out. read more

See all

Winter getaway we found Olies. Very cool vibe in the more remote upstate NY area. Cozy & warm interior that garners a healthy gathering of people. The brick oven pizza was on point and the wait staff and bar were all great as well - Mentionable: they end the meal by giving you a cool post card. Olies looks even better to go to in the summer with the outdoor patio setup, but, in the winter it was a win as well. read more

Ollie's Pizza - two men working in a kitchen - Pizza Near Me - High Falls, New York

See all

Love this place! Fresh and tasty pizza with a side of great, friendly staff. I'll be back!

Wow!!! Amazing cacio e pepe arancini balls. Made the perfect appetizer and the marinara sauce that accompanied them was soooo flavorful! The pizzas were both amazing. Thin crust, flavorful toppings, and cheesiness made the perfect slice. read more

Ollie's Pizza - Cacio e pepe arancini - Pizza Near Me - High Falls, New York

See all

When pondering if your local pizza place is good first come and order here. What's such a mystery that they do it brilliantly and the places nearby get it so wrong? Why is this so easy for them but the local pizza places fail? Ingredients? Giving a damn? Perfect pizza is not impossible as you can see/taste from here But seems like the work needed to accomplish this isn't worth trying at some local places. I guess just keep heading to Ollie's read more

What a gem! We stumbled upon Ollie's after hiking at minnewaska and heading back to the city. We got the chicken Caesar salad and the vodka pepperoni pizza. Both were amazing! They both had such fresh ingredients. The service was also excellent; Sam was welcoming, friendly and overall had great vibes. It was a hot, busy day and still the staff all had great attitudes! We will definitely be back. read more

Ollie's Pizza - Vodka/ pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - High Falls, New York

See all

Such good pizza . The crust is thin crispy. And I like the outside seatings . Chicken wings were spicy. Great pizza I liked that the mos read more

Ollie's Pizza - Margarita pie - Pizza Near Me - High Falls, New York

See all

Delicious vegan pizza. Great service and ambiance! We've eaten here multiple times while staying at The Gray Barn at Woodstock Farm Sanctuary! read more

We were staying at a nearby Airbnb and went in on a deathly hot summer night to get some take out. We ordered all three salads and three pizzas. The Caesar salad was one of the best I've had, the wedge was equally classic and delicious. The Ollie's salad was also good but would benefit from adding fresh oranges to elevate and create a traditional Sicilian palate. Every pizza was delicious, the classic onion was the stand out. Despite the place being packed, everything came out of the kitchen pretty quickly. Can't wait to return! read more

Pizza is the real deal. Wood oven resulting in perfectly charred crust. Excellent spicy vodka sauce and pepperoni pie. Drinks are great too. The outdoor seating is a toddlerfest so beware. If you're not into kids running around making noise, this might not be your place... read more

Had a really bad experience with a waitperson. We were the only ones in the restaurant and made the mistake of bringing in an open can of seltzer. After we ordered, the waitperson came over very aggressively and demanded to know if we had poured the seltzer into one of their glasses. She was unhinged. Dissatisfied with our response, she grabbed a carafe of house seltzer and pushed her way over to pour the house seltzer into the seltzer we had brought in basically ruining the drink we had. Then she started lecturing us nonstop about bringing in outside food (which we didn't) and again when she brought the check over (she couldn't let it go). We were quite taken aback at her behavior and decided never to return again. We had been there quite a few times since the pandemic, and even though the place is drafty and cold, and the music often blares loudly, the food was generally acceptable. The waitperson told us never to return, and said she would advise the other staff to make sure we couldn't come back. We had some leftovers but dumped them in the garbage because we weren't sure if she had adulterated our food out of spite. We just couldn't be sure. We are an elderly couple and have never been treated this way anywhere, ever. I don't know what triggered the waitress, but when we brought the matter to the owner's attention, she took the waitresses side and defended her actions and attitude because we brought a can of seltzer from our car to the restaurant. There is something truly wrong with the ethic at this place. We plan to stay away and never return. I see other people have also had trouble with the staff there. I guess that is no surprise. read more

Called to place an order for pick up and they said they are not taking take out order at 5 pm! Do better for your community! And this would have been my first time eating thank u .. u just made it easier to not recommend this place ! read more

Such good pizza, drinks and other food too! We had a few different drinks - the OG Negroni was a favorite then had Caesar salad, aranchini, garlic knots and 2 pizzas. All were delicious! read more

See all

came here saturday at 5pm (came early based on other reviews that it can get hectic) and there were about half of the tables outside available. It was a beautiful sunny warm evening and all tables had the adjustable umbrellas. We ordered two of their non alcoholic drinks - the strawberry shrub and the lemon dill and mint spritzer, both were refreshing and delicious. We got the ollie salad and added chicken cutlet and also got a grandma pie with vodka sauce - did half mushrooms half fresh basil. everything was excellent and the service was great, the girls working at the ordering counter were vert friendly.. great spot to bring your dog and kids. definitely want to go back and try other items. By the time we left around 630pm, people were waiting to get a table and it was definitely packed. read more

See all

This place is a great addition to the pizza scene in Ulster County and well worth the drive from New Paltz. We had the luxury of checking this place out on a warm Sunday afternoon in December. We had a half bottle of wine from the previous night and they were gracious enough to left us drink our BYOB wine. Outdoor heaters were a nice touch to warm our heads while we enjoyed the delicious Margherita pizza and sipped our Australian Shiraz. We will certainly be back soon. read more

Ollie's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - High Falls, New York

Unfortunately, the hostess was rude and unfriendly and wouldn't let our party of 3 wait at a table for our 4th friend who arrived 5 minutes later at 5pm. Sorry to say we did not enjoy this meal at our local restaurant that we were looking forward to patronize- despite our sweet waiter. Should have been better customer service from the hostess. Doesn't take much. read more