Barely three star. Pizza does not have much flavors. Tables dirty. Wont be back. Everything is just bland.

Super nice employee when we entered. Pizza was hot, fresh and amazingly delicious. Perfect ratio of bread to pizza. Ham and pineapple great flavors. Shrimp spices and sauce perfect bites. First time here and what a delight. Will certainly return. read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - Shrimp Fra Diavolo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rosendale, New York

See all

I love this pizza!! I come to the area about once a month from the city and just tried It on my last trip. Got the sausage, green pepper onion slice - yay!! It is SO awesome! Thin crunchy crust, just the right amount of cheese / sauce, not too salty. I was staying at my friends apt on Main Street, literally bolted out of bed to go back for another slice! Now I'm jonseing for my next trip back up there just for this pizza! There are many cool spots in this town which I have also reviewed. Maybe I need to relocate! Oh and the people who work there are really nice :) read more

Terrible service. Left me on hold for well over 35 minutes. Told me I'm too old to be served.

Pizza and wings are delicious. Sometimes they don't have a delivery driver. Had an issue with old meat on a sandwich a year ago. Tried other pizza places and ended up coming back. read more

I really wanted to like them. They're open when everyone else is closed. And they're friendly Traditional Margarita is my litmus test for a pizza place. Bland canned tasting sauce paste thin sliced mozzarella NO BASIL AT ALL no spices anywhere bland crust. Such a huge disappointment. Maybe some classes would help. Sad to have a friendly pizza place local but fails at one of the most classic pizzas read more

food is a hit or a miss, staff are nice but the best thing is they are the only ones open in holidays!

Was good but now they charge 3% if you use a credit card. We love their food. It's always good. Great Tosco salad but charging to use my cc all of a sudden! What??? read more

Food is not bad. Im from Brooklyn and haven't found a decent pizzeria yet. This was close but its still not good enuf. Delivery times are ridiculous more than 2 1/2 hours to wait and it comes cold read more

hey I ordered delivery from you guys tonight as I have many times in the past the deep fried raviolis were delicious but the m&m combo was very bland and soggy and the meatball parm was cold and soggy as well. I have been a loyal customer but this is the third bad or unsatisfactory order I have had in my last few meals. I don't know what has changed but it's very disappointing read more

Best pizza in the 845 I drive a half hour just to eat this pizza. Staff is always super friendly. They have awesome pizza toppings and the quality of the crust is to die for! Highly recommend read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rosendale, New York

The employees there have attitude problems I ordered a buffalo chicken wrap and the chicken was basically raw I called back and the employees had an attitude about it they just lost a costumer read more

Honest to god, WORST Italian food I have ever had. Ordered chicken marsala which was missing the marsala wine in the sauce entirely. My mom ordered chicken sorrentino which was supposed to have prosciutto but had sliced deli ham instead. All of our bread was burnt AF. (Like so burnt and hard that it hurt your teeth to bite into). We both ate like 3 bites and threw everything in the trash. Everything tasted like it came from the bottom of an oven or was freezer burnt? I've never written a bad review before!!!!. Complete waste of 50$. DISGUSTING!!!! read more

The food was horrible ! Cold , tasted like the bottom of the oven ! The sausage parm had cut rings of pizza sausage tasted frozen ! The delivery promised in 45 mins to an hour tops was an hour late , no compensation from the restaurant offered ! Owner called to tell me they were outside and hung up on me !! ???? Seriously! read more

The food here is absolutely disgusting except maybe the pizza. Ordered a buffalo chicken wrap and it was barely even edible. The fries were not cooked all the way through and the chicken tasted like rubber. Never ordering from there again. read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - Buffalo chicken wrap. - Pizza Near Me - Rosendale, New York

This place sucks! Everytime we order it takes hours to get our order and it's ice cold. We literally live a mile away. Even when you call and complain nothing changes, except to get worse. I'm done ordering from here. I'll go to Kings instead. read more

Great when it opened, fell off a cliff in recent times. Deliveries can take up to 2 hours or NEVER COME. Even if you call they can't guarantee if you're ever gonna get it. For an order that was gonna be 3 hours late they were going to give me a discount on my NEXT ORDER... NOT the one that took 3 HOURS..LMAO. Not even an apology for wasting our time. Have been going for years, and recently this has become the norm. Never again. read more

Love love love most of their food! YOU WILL LOVE THEIR MAC N CHEESE PIZZA! From pizza to burgers it all great except their pasta sauce on the spaghetti and meatballs dish, ordered it off the kids menu for our daughter. The sauce was runny and had no substance so she didn't like it. We also ordered some of their Mexican dishes and the tacos were not great. Will definitely keep ordering other things though! read more

Tosco's Pizzeria... Go Big or Go Home. This pizzeria has been consistently good to me for years. They have the biggest single slices around. My favorite pizza that they have is named after their business. It's called the toscos pie. This bad boy has Grilled Chicken, Roasted Peppers & Fresh Mozzarella which is just such a good combo. I thought it was kind of strange that there is a kind of black vinegar on it but once I tried it there was no going back. There is no red sauce on the pie but it really does not need it. I order from here a lot. They even have 24 inch pizzas which could feed an army. In terms of there single slices they really are huge and affordable. For two bucks u can get a cheese slice that looks like two slices forged by the fires into one. This is a great place to get a pie from. Thank you for being awesome Tosco's Pizzeria. read more

The bathrooms need to be clean the staff is nice but some people there need to be more humble everything else is good

You have to try the sweet and spicy pizza. The ingredients are fresh and the restaurant is clean. Plenty of seating and easy parking in the plaza. read more

See all

Wow this is about to get real. Fist it really sucks that I am about to destroy this place, since I do like there food. It all started about a month and a half ago, at a place called Tosco's In Rosendale NY. I ordered a pizza half sausage and half pepperoni. I was told it would be 25 minutes, I got there in 15 minutes to find the pizza sitting on top of the oven, when I got it home it was not hot. Next about a week latter I ordered 2 sandwiches, one philly steak and cheese sandwich, just steak and cheese no onions, peppers, or mushrooms, and a turkey B.L.T wrap with fries, again I was told 25 minutes, so I got there early. This time they messed up the philly steak and cheese, and had to make another one, mean while the turkey B.L.T. and fries were sitting under a warming light the whole time, so when I got it home the fries were cold and mushy. Third time I ordered a turkey B.L.T. with fries and a philly stake and cheese roll not a sandwich this time. This time I get there the steak and cheese is not done so, I was waiting and was asked what the order was for. I told them a philly steak and cheese roll and a turkey B.L.T. They told me that the order was not read rite by the person in the kitchen and they never made my turkey B.L.T. Now I have to wait while they make my turkey B.L.T., in the mean time the philly wrap gets done and put on top of the oven, when it gets home it's cold. I said something to them while waiting about this being the third time my order was messed up, and if it happens again I may never order from them again. They never even addressed the issue, not even to say they were sorry. Well here is were it gets real. Saturday Feb. 25th, 2017. I ordered a philly steak and cheese wrap. Got there early to make sure it would not be sitting out waiting for me. While waiting there was a server thunder storm. The person I was with was buying, so I went to get my truck and park next to the door so she would not get soaked getting in. The power went out, and it was raining very hard with strong winds. I went out the door and went to my right, then I fell. There were bricks stacked up 2 or 3 high rite outside the door. I never saw them and fell hard. I tore the knee out of my jeans, cut my knee and hand, my knee was bleeding pretty bad as was my hand. I went back in and told them, and told the person I was with I was leaving, even if the order was not ready. She said it was done and she was paying and would be rite out. The owner nor any of the staff asked nor checked to see how bad I was bleeding. They never even asked if I was ok, they never even said a word to me. When the person I was with got in to my truck, she asked how I was and I showed her my knee and hand. She told me after I asked, that no-one inside acted concerned at what just happened. They made sure to not only charge her for the food, but since the power was out they could not open the cash register, so they owe her $2.50 change from the price of the order. So I will never go there again, due to there incompetence and lack of concern. The best part is a free meal cost me $30.00 for a pair of jeans, $75.00 for a pair of sneakers, and $15.00 for stuff at the pharmacy for the cuts. $120.00 and not as much as an are you ok. I guess they can be lucky that my injuries were not server enough for me to sue the hell out of them. Instead I'll just go down the street to some place else from now on for my food. Great place to go if you want poor service, and lack of concern. Makes me glad that I was a loyal customer for years, ordering at least 4 or 5 times a month. read more

This is a review of Tosco's Pizzeria, 1157 Route 32, Rosendale, NY 12472. On 07/10/2021, I ordered penne alla vodka with grilled chicken, but there was NO CHICKEN in my dish. On 08/03/2021, I ordered the same dish, AND AGAIN, there was NO CHICKEN in my dish. It should be noted that the order on 08/03/2021 was phoned in 40 minutes prior to pickup. While ordering on the phone, I mentioned the prior time that the chicken was omitted from my dish, and to please ensure that chicken is included in my dish, this time. When I arrived at Tosco's, my dish was ready, but not bagged yet. So, I asked the older Spanish guy, behind the counter, if there was chicken in my dish. He looked at the container, which had a clear plastic lid, and confirmed that he saw chicken. However, when I opened the container at home, there was NO CHICKEN. I was quite annoyed, as this was the second time that they screwed up my dish. I should also mention another ongoing issue with Tosco's, Rosendale, as follows: they have delivery, but rarely have drivers, so delivery is usually not available. However, when available, delivery usually takes at least an hour or two. So, needless to say, everyone should avoid Tosco's Pizzeria, Rosendale! read more

This is some good pizza! The delivery was earlier than expected. Large pizza with eggplant and ricotta was cooked perfectly. Homemade sauce with a slight peppery kick. Excellent chicken parm sub. Think I just found my new spot! Only wish I tried them sooner. read more

I love Tosco's. It's so good my boyfriend proposed to me after we ate there. He's like I'm so glad you said yes and I'm like I didn't say yes I said "okay" lol. The pizza here is excellent - if you get meat or vegetable surprise pizza its like 500 pounds of toppings I love it. Once I got salad pizza. Also their sandwiches and salads are so good and big. They're big and good. They also have pasta dishes. I love Tosco's and so should you. They even got wings and on the back of the menu they have some Mexican selections so I'll have to eat some of that soon. read more

Disgusting. Ordered wings, a pizza and a calzone. I am home in NY for the holidays and was so excited to have NY pizza and was so disappointed. The cheese tasted like refrigerator. Called to let them know and they offered to send something else which was nice but wasn't interested in trying what else they had to offer. Go to Benny's-worth the drive. read more

This was actually a disappointment in the pizza department. We ordered mushrooms and olives - which were plentiful - but it lacked enough sauce and actually tasted a bit over cooked or burnt. Great service, would need to try other items on the menu to give a well rounded review. read more

I really did not like the pizza I had. It was supposed to have basil but they put spinach on instead...

Loved this place. Nothing fancy but really solid NY style pizza and super friendly staff. Also mention it's beyond reasonably priced!

I love the pizza and boneless chicken wings!!! Their subs are good but the pizza is the best

I'm giving Tosco's a 5 star rating based on the fact that they are awesome about accommodating dietary needs. The super huge pie that they make is ridiculously large and we love that they sub out a topping for the cheese we can't eat. read more

Had a very busy day, fasting before a doctor's appointment that afternoon and I didn't have time to make dinner before my girlfriend picked me up to go to a women's support group. Was so hungry and I was afraid I would "pig out" on the snacks at the women's support group, that I asked my girlfriend, who is familiar with the area, if she knew of an inexpensive place to eat. She and I chose Tosco's Pizzeria, and were amazed at the value of the food, freshness, friendly staff and cleanliness of the restaurant and restrooms. We had cheese pizza and small diet sodas. WE DEFINITE WILL RETURN, and I won't need to use the excuse that I am hungry! read more

My pizza slices were not cooked through; raw dough is always a downer. My dining companions' eggplant sandwich and calzone were better, and enormous. Pleasant place to sit and eat, and there's table service. read more

Um yikes I waited 2 hours for this crap! I've seen better stuff come out of a dumpster and that says a lot good lord it was as if they kept it in a freezer. As appetizing as a asshole! read more

Awful salty processed almost inedible Stromboli. This was their second chance and they blew it! Won't waste my money here again.

unfortunately this place has really gone downhill. There are many people that cook there, so it really depends on who is working. the inconsistency is annoying. The waitstaff turns over often and is always poor service. The WORST waitress is unfortunately a family member of the place...I think the daughter. She is so rude and comes to the table every time and says "what do you want?" We used to love this place, but will not be returning after the horrible meals we have had several times now. read more

I have only had their cheese pizza, which is delicious, big slices for only $2 total. A perfect lunch for anyone, especially a cheap lunch for a college student or a quick lunch for someone taking a lunch break while on the job. The service is friendly and there is plenty of tables and seating so dinning in is always an option. I definitely recommend this pizzeria if you looking for a slice in Rosendale, NY. read more