This is a takeout place and I can't believe I haven't ordered anything from here in years. Hubby frequents this place in between runs with other bus drivers. He got himself a meatball Parmesan hero and brought home some meatball sliders on a garlic knots for me to try. The sliders are amazing The meatballs and sauce are delicious which is the most important thing. We look forward to ordering more food from this place. The service is great and Joe is super nice. Can't wait to try their pizza on Sunday!!!! read more

The food is not great, service is always good and nice interior to the restaurant. Would only return if in a pinch for food

Ordered pizza here based on all of the positive reviews. The pizza was very average - not bad, but also not GREAT. Very average (and a bit expensive - $18 for a plain cheese pie) read more

Besides offering delivery, Joe Cristiano's also offers contact-free delivery, a plus currently. Their website, which is very well organized, indicates you can request it either by a phone-in order or an online order. The food is good, the customer service is great. You have a lot of options for pizza, both as specialty pizzas or create your own. You can also add or subtract from other items such as salads or wraps. There's quite a few sides too, and I really liked the mozzarella sticks. The pizza itself is pretty standard, with a fairly thick crust, so it's no surprise they offer Sicilian pizza too. My second order was even better. This time, I got what will probably become my go-to order, their Margherita Pizza - you want to specify a thin crust for this for more authenticity. The fresh tomatoes on it make it really juicy. Their zucchini fries are quite crisp and "meaty," which can be challenging for zucchini fries. It's nice to see that their focus is as much on their customers as it is on their food. read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - Large classic pie - Pizza Near Me - Hyde Park, New York

See all

Since moving to Staatsburg a couple of years ago we have been picking up a pizza from JC's once a week. It has been pretty good---crust is firm, crispy and light, sauce is decent and just the right amount of cheese. The past 3 times have not been satisfactory at all. The quality just isn't there, it's as if the person that previously made the Pizza no longer does or perhaps management has changed. Most recently, the Pizza from last night was doughy and loaded with unmelted excessive cheese. We will give this place one more chance in hopes that it can return to being one of the better Pizzerias in the area. read more

It's all about the crust...and many pizza places miss the last 30 seconds in the oven that would make this pizza over the top! This was a good dough and good toppings...but they didn't give us crushed peppers or ask if we wanted them. The Caesar is basic lettuce croutons and shaved park with a package of Ken's Caesar dressing so it was fine. Compared to the big pizza chains this was good! read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - Cheese pizza and margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hyde Park, New York

See all

I didn't eat there I had a to go order on a pick up. The service was quick and I was near the front door where the bar is which I wasn't too keen on the ambiance for more personal reasons. read more

AMAZING pizza. Not too crispy, not too soft and the sauce is delicious too. We have also gotten Buffalo Chicken Pizza (yum) and the boneless chicken wings - BBQ is top notch. Delivery is available and timely. Joe Cristiano's is our new go-to for a quick, tasty and affordable meal! read more

They have the best pizza around! They're fast and affordable. The crust is perfect, chewy without being too thick. Nothing fancy, just really good pizza. They also have awesome wings read more

I've tried quite a few of their pizzas they're all absolutely great but notable ones are sweet Thai chili chicken, Chicken Alfredo and the margarita are out top three favorite pizzas.....I travel 25 miles to get these pizzas because there is nothing close to me that has anything like it including all the ones in Rhinebeck in red Hook..... totally worth the trip read more

Great value great food best lasagna chicken wings and top notch pizza highly recommend if you have not tried

Great pizza and wings. I prefer the Salt Point location over the Hyde Park location. More consistency. But both are quality places. I Would recommend read more

Love this place, great customer service, food is always hot and fresh, 10/10 would recommend to any newcomer in the area!

We grab food here a couple of times a month and are rarely disappointed. The pizza is great and the wings are even better. The meatball sliders are phenomenal as well. You can't go wrong ordering from Joe C's and the online ordering system they're getting off the ground is making it that much better. read more

On a recent trip to Hyde Park, to visit my in-laws, we ordered ahead from Joe Cristiano's Pizza and picked it up on the way to the house. The order was hot and ready when we arrived and the service was pleasant. I noticed that the dining area is small but tidy, probably best not to plan on eating in with a group. We brought the food two minutes down the road and dug in. All of the food was good, not exceptional but a very good meal. The pizza wasn't overly greasy, the meatballs were well seasoned, the macaroni and cheese was very creamy, and the chicken tenders were crisp on the outside and moist on the inside. This was my first time ordering from Joe Cristiano's Pizza when visiting my in-laws but I would definitely do it again. read more

We needed a place to pick up food to take to the drive in theater and decided to try this place. We got a pie, wings and salad. The wings and pizza were good, the salad was nothing special. I will come back and try the pastas. read more

I'm so annoyed! I don't think I will ever order anything from this place ever again. Every once in a while I will order a spinach roll. The first time I had one, it was out on their display counter with the already made pizza slices. I wanted to try something new. They also had pepperoni rolls but I went for the spinach since I've never had one before. it and it was pretty good. So now and then, I will order a spinach roll. I will also add they also happen to charge me different prices every time as well, anywhere from $4-$8.... Pretty weird and annoying as you can imagine. Well we just ordered lunch a little while ago and I ordered a spinach roll and my husband goes to pick it up and there's all this burnt breaded chicken all over it???? I'm not happy. My husband calls them and they of course the same guy that took the order says it always comes with chicken. Why lie? What's the motive behind lying? I've never had a spinach roll with chicken! WTF? What is wrong with these people? I hate when places like this take no responsibility for their mistakes! So of course my husband has to now take it back. I don't even want them to make me a new one. Ugh! Well you just lost a few regular customers. I'm done. You all are lame. read more

4/5 stars, its a small pizza place, the pizza tasted good, and the traditional cajun buffalo sauced wings were really good too. I'd recommend to anyone who wants an easy meal. We went in for pick up, not delivery, for the record. read more

My Firefighter I class ordered an ungodly amount of pizza to celebrate the completion of the course. I was absolutely AMAZED by the gluten free pizza. It came with its own, plastic wrapped disposable cutter! It was the best pizza I've had since my Celiac diagnosis, and all it had was cheese and pepperoni! That, and my stomach didn't get sick. All the other pizzas looked and smelled heavenly! Everyone seemed happy: people don't go for seconds and thirds if they're not! read more

We were visiting the National Parks in the area. We are from out of state. This place had a good Yelp review, so we decided to stop in. It's small, but there was a place to sit. Based on the amount of people that called, came in and out, and just the buzzing of their computer, this place is HOPPING! It seems to be a local's favorite place. We were met with really friendly staff. The food was hot and came out quick. The food was really good. We enjoyed it very much and recommend. read more

Great selection of delicious pizza by the slice! Calzones, wings and garlic knots are excellent! Dining area is tiny, so if you go with a group hope you are the only group! read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hyde Park, New York

I ordered for my family last night and it was my girlfriends birthday. I took an hour and a half for a delivery of make you own pizza kit. I called to speak to a manager. His name is Lyle, whom was the most disrespectful and rudest person I've dealt with. I had a prior issue with a wrap being cold and I believe it was the same manager I dealt with in the past. I order from this restaurant 3 to 4 times a week. That should tell u how much I used to love this place. Unfortunately the service from the manager is to the point I'll never order there again. I spend approx. 100 to 150 weekly. I was hung up on 3 times by Lyle and finally spoke to a young woman Anna. She was so kind a receive a raise. However. I cancelled my order due to the hour and a half of waiting when I was told 45 minutes. My money didn't mean nothing to the way this manager talked to me. Unfortunately he puts out a face for the business which lost me as a customer and I will never order there again. Tried to ask to speak to the owner and was told good luck. So that told me the owner accepts this behavior. Good luck and I have to file a claim to get my money back because I never received my good. How selfish can a business be and care about the community which they live. So upset about this. read more

See all

My granddaughter was visiting when we ordered her a gluten free pizza. Imagine my surprise and thankfulness when her pie came it was baked on a disposable pan and came with a new pizza cutter, not to mention she loved it . THANK YOU for taking food allergies seriously, cross contamination is a real fear. I know now where I can take her for a safe treat read more

We order from them a lot and it's always what we're looking for. Drivers are friendly and prompt too! Thanks for my Saturday night fix!

This is the best pizza place in the Hyde Park and possibly Poughkeepsie too. They've gone downhill since they opened so many different stores, but still good. read more

Having moved to NY from VA about nine months ago, I figured I was in for some tasty, tasty pizza. Unfortunately, until we found Joe Cristiano's, most of the pizza we'd had was pretty ho-hum. Joe Cristiano's is solid, consistent, and always on time. All the ingredients are fresh, and after having a few pizzas with canned green peppers from T & F, this made a huuuuge difference. Comparing it to one of the big pizza chains, I'd say it's kinda like Papa John's in terms of ingredient quality and crust style. Unfortunately, all I've had from their menu is a few pizzas - it looks like there's a lot more that they make (hot subs, calzones, the usual from a good pizza joint), so I have no idea if those are good or not, but I'd be willing to give 'em a shot. read more

This is the best pizza in Tri-county area. ignore the reviews that say "ordinary" & similar comments...these are clearly sugar sauce, frozen "pizza" lovers. If you know what good pizza is, you will love Critiano's. read more

Stopped for lunch, awesome food with a lot of flavor and friendly staff. Try them!! Pizza slices were tasty and my caesar wrap yuuuummy :)) read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - pizzaslices and chicken caesar wrap - Pizza Near Me - Hyde Park, New York

The pizza here is good, not great. The delivery takes about an hour every time, sometimes if you're lucky you'll get it in 45minutes. You have to eat it all in one day though, the pizza sitting in the fridge for just a single overnight seems to mess with the cheese they use... read more

We stopped in for a couple slices, and to share an Eggplant Parm Hero. With 2 soft drinks it came to $17.00 or so. I thought the price was pretty good. The food was really good. My wife's buffalo chicken pizza was basically begging me to try it. The Sicilian slice I had was nice and fluffy. The eggplant parm was good. All in all, I'm going back. Also, check in w them on Yelp and get 10% off your order. That never sucks! read more

GREAT PLACE for Take-Out. Fast service and nice people working at Joe Cristiano's Pizza Route 9G. Thanks! Lance Nealon read more

Staff is friendly and everything came out pretty quick and hot. The crust and toppings didn't really have any flavor. Not a bad place just the few times I've had it, not very consistent. read more

Was very pleased with the way a potentially unpleasant issue was handled. That alone is worth 5 stars now-a-days! Excellent customer service! read more

I have a bunch of pizza places around where i live to choose from, but I find myself ordering from this place again and again. I wish the place up the street was as good, because it's more convenient. But ya can't beat this place. Waiting on a pizza now. I highly recommend! read more

IMO. Real good pizza! Real good onion rings and what got me hooked? Meatball sliders are fire!

Delivery came on time despite being Super Bowl Sunday but wings smelled like it was fried in rancid oil and fries were packed with no air filter to prevent sogginess which I specifically asked them to do and was told they did. Pizza is good and even better when reheated in the oven. Highly suggest owner or manager to check oil as often as possible. Fryer station can be the most neglected station but should be the most important since it brings in the money and can be costly when treated incorrectly due to constant oil turnover. read more

Ordered delivery last night, I didn't realize they had forgotten part of my order until the delivery guy knocked on my door a little while later with it! Thank you for being an honest business! read more

Great food! Awesome staff! Wraps could be better but pizza is rocking. Would love to see Stromboli added to the menu

When we moved here a few months back, this was the first pizzeria my husband and I tried one night. After being spoiled by Pleasant Ridge II in Beacon, we looked forward to finding a similar restaurant that would be able to make our favorite combo pies and chicken dinners. Unfortunately, we didn't find it in this restaurant. The lack of options plus the bland pizza made us never want to come back. read more

Friendly fast service but the pizza itself was really spoken too highly of on here by other yelpers, and I usually find their taste spot on. Sorry! read more