Had an early dinner at Antonella's recently and was very impressed. The service was excellent. We had zuppa di pesce and chicken piccata. Both dishes were very good with large portions. By far the best place I've eaten in that area. read more

We arrived for a late dinner after traveling all day. Husband ordered lasagna and I ordered the angel hair pesto. Both dishes were delicious! The bread and our salads very good as well. Fresh crisp greens, red onions and tomatoes. Garlic knots and sesame crusted bread hot and delicious. Awesome service very quick and attentive. You walk through the bar where there were many locals sitting enjoying meals. We sat in the dining room which was cozy and quiet. Highly recommend this place we will be back. read more

Antonella's Restaurant - ANGEL HAIR PESTO - Italian Near Me - Hyde Park, New York

The pizza delicious, served hot with a crispy bottom. Very reminiscent of a pizza that I remember the taste from my childhood. Service was very good and quick. The ambience was fine. An pizza restaurant vibe. Casual and clean My one complaint was the bar area had FOX NEWS on and I found that disappointing. Don't want to get political but It makes me feel like I don't want to go back to support a place that does not align with my ethics and morals! read more

Great food. Fresh pizza. Really awesome ambiance if you choose to stay and eat at the restaurant. Takeout process was seamless and the food has been fresh and hot. Staff was super friendly and accommodating. read more

So had dinner on a Thursday night and only a few tables were in use. I did notice 7 orders for pickup so maybe they do a good take out business. Started with baked clams oreganato 6 smaller clams arrived but had decent flavor. Oh before I forget the bread basket had 2 garlic knots and some Italian bread which I thought was cool. Now we ordered Chicken Masala over angel hair pasta and a 16 oz ribeye special with roasted potatoes and sautéed mushrooms. OK so both mains were delicious but the steak was cooked as requested medium rare. No A1, no extra sauce nothing it was seasoned perfectly as were the roasted potato wedges. The picture doesn't show how good it was. Our server was nice and the food came out in pretty good time. The review would have gotten 5 stars but I get a little pissed when certain things happen. 1-sorry to say a pesky fruit fly buzzed around us and was disposed of in mid flight. 2- charging $4 for using a debit card? If cards are a problem then put up a sign saying cash only. Or out the $4 in the menu prices but I didn't like that after paying $113 for 2 people to eat. 3- don't be afraid to ask the prices of the specials. My ribeye steak special was $50, which is fine because the steak was awesome. Maybe it's me but these little things irk me. Anyway food was good and basically had the dining room to ourselves. read more

Antonella's Restaurant - 16 oz Ribeye steak - Italian Near Me - Hyde Park, New York

Food and service were both excellent. Unexpected surprises. Would definitely go back again.

Very disappointed in the cook on Sunday at 3:30 PM. January 15, 2023. I ordered a Lasagna. It came out Luke Warm. I called the server over and reported it was cold. They sent it back to the kitchen. It came out about five minutes later, and again it was Luke Warm. How hard is it to put in the oven and warm it up. The cheese was not bubbling. I asked to take it home. What a disappointment! read more

Antonella's Restaurant - Luke Warm Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Hyde Park, New York

The Stracciatella soup is the best . Eggplant rolotini is fantastic. Always good food there. The service is excellent. You have to go

Ordered a cold Italian sub with roasted red peppers, not a big long brown hair. Took them one hour to deliver replacement.

We love Antonella's in Hyde Park. The food is delicious and his veggie pizza with no cheese (allergy) is the best ANYWHERE. We order food for us, for the guys working on the house, we cater our parties from them. We usually eat in but even during the quarantine, we've been ordering takeout pizza. Give this place a try and say hi to Sal. read more

Antonella's Restaurant - Veggie pizza without cheese because of allergies. I bet it's super delish with cheese too! - Italian Near Me - Hyde Park, New York

Delicious food, the best in town. It's always consistent too. Great service, friendly and efficient. Good prices too.

Delicious food. And completely consistent. This is my third trip to Antonella's Hyde Park location ...this time with 6 people. Calamari - excellent... It was the breading... (Very lightly done )that made it so great. Also, the sauce was not overdone. Shrimp scampi... very good. Just the right amount of lemon. Chicken parmigiana...very good ... large portion. Rigatoni with vegetables... very good ... Grilled Chicken over salad... very good and another large portion ( of chicken). Marinade for grill was perfect Small plain pizza... crispy crust and sauce/cheese done right Meat ball sub... again, large... Looked pretty normal, but the diner wolfed down. Salad for all... fresh with fresh vegetables. Very good Service was great... when it kind of came time to be served, there were four people who brought the food so no one had to wait. Pretty sure one of them was the chef. And last, but not least very reasonably priced. Don't let the simple decor, throw you... It's simple pizza parlor decor all the way. Antonella's is worth the trip. read more

Ordered $80 worth of food and had it delivered using the slice app. One of the five items I ordered was completely wrong. Restaurant refused to do anything but refund for the one item. No offer to re-deliver the correct item stating they had no drivers and I should contact "slice". "Slice" did not package the order, Antonellas did. "Slice" is only the delivery service. Normally I am understanding about these things, however I was hung up on twice and needed to call back a third time to confirm at least the refund of the one item, and the topper...I was specifically told they didn't need me as a customer. Fine, you've lost this customer forever. I hope the owner reads these reviews. read more

Homemade Italian fare in a strip mall. We went for lunch, and the quality of the food, and the large selection of dishes made us want to come for dinner. Not much to look at either inside or outside, but as they say, you can't eat ambience. It's all about the food. And the food is five stars. read more

See all

Amazing! This place is great!! (When they don't run out of clams!) Came here on a Sunday when they first opened to place a decent order for about 8 people, but sadly they were out of clams. We ordered the shrimp scampi, zuppa di muscles, zuppa di pesce, margherita pizza, calamari pasta and some other dishes as well as garlic bread and knots*. Each dinner size portion also comes with salad to complete your meal. Food was great! We also enjoyed the food catered. The baked clams that we couldn't have were amazing and ran out in no time and the rest of the food was on par with our first experience. Eggplant rollatini/parmagiana, shrimp scampi, stuffed mushrooms, penne, chicken marsala and more. Sometimes it's hard to make larger portions of food still taste good, but Antonella's did a great job. The staff is also very friendly and helpful. Would definitely come back here again if I'm up in that area! *some garlic knots and regular italian bread come with the meal, but if you want more, they sell them 6 for $1.75. read more

Antonella's Restaurant - Restaurant front - Italian Near Me - Hyde Park, New York

I brought my Italian friend here and she said: "this has flavor. It tastes like my Mom's food." It had a zesty Italian authentic feel.

Awesome food, great workers. A nice home feeling. What ever mood you're are in. Sit at the bar or dine in.

Ordered lunch on 4/10/22 for delivery through Grubhub (note Antonella's has its own drivers and does not use Grubhub drivers. So I was unable to track via the Grubhub app. ) Got a text message saying that my order should arrive between 1:05 pm and 1:15 pm. At 1:30 pm I called the store to find out where the order was. I was then told that Antonella's canceled the order due to having no delivery drivers. However, they never let me know that the ordered had been canceled. The person I was talking to on the phone from Antonella's then out me on hold and apparently called Grubhub who then called me and finally informed me of the cancellation. read more

Antonellas has great food! I've never been disappointed. Servings are generous, service friendly, and a wide variety of delicious entrees! Eggplant rollatini and chicken Sorrentino are two of our favorites! Their meatball pizzas are delicious as well! I highly recommend Antonellas for a delicious meal!!!! read more

my favorite place! the bartender, brittany is the most competent, consistent and considerate server we've ever had. always makes everyone feel special and cared for read more

Granted it's Sunday, but this is ridiculous. Not worth going back to even show to the people there. I hope the manager was off. The wrap wasn't great, and the fries were soft and Mushy. Definitely disappointed read more

Antonella's Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Hyde Park, New York

See all

Called in a quick order and it was excellent! Chicken Pícatta and Zuppa Di Pesce both very good, quick, and abundant, thank you, love fritz

Great food! Hot, fresh and delivered in a good amount of time. Never been disappointed really.

This complaint is about the delivery service, not the food which was good - not great, just good. I placed a delivery order from Antonella's through Grubhub (I've already contacted GH with this issue and they said that the driver was from Antonella's, although GH did say that they would be following up. I wanted to let Antonella's know of the issue in case they do not.) As I said, I placed a delivery order on 10/17/2021 through Grubhub. My delivery preferences include no contact delivery and I am very specific that I want my order(s) placed in front of my garage and for the driver to text me when they have done so. On this occasion, however, the driver chose to explicitly ignore my instructions and pounded on my door, insisting on handing me the food. When I reminded him of my very explicit instructions to leave the food and text me, he said that he didn't want leave it on the ground (-that's why I also request a text, so the food isn't sitting there long) Never mind that I have not one, but two sets of stairs/porch where he could have left it. Instead, he ignored my no contact delivery request. Hopefully Antonella's will teach their drivers to follow the customer's instructions. read more

We used the Slice app last week to get a pizza delivered and it was pretty good. So this week we decided to give it a try again but pasta dishes. We made our order but for some reason this week they canceled our order saying we were out of their delivery zone? Hmm we got a pizza delivered last week?? So we called Slice and they were great they called Antonella for us and asked to change it to pick up and they did. Got it and wished we hadn't. Got chicken piccata and chicken francese. The chicken was too thin as was the sauce. Too lemony. They served the pasta with red sauce?? Instead of in the chicken sauce. The bread toasted hard as a rock. Salad was decent enough but creamy balsamic was idk??? Strange. All in all not worth the $18.95 for each dish! Disappointing. Gave it 2 stars for the good pizza the week before. read more

Ordered three times just love there food always on time food is always hot and they give a lot of food.there delivery guys are so nice and courteous I recommend them. read more

Have eaten here many time. The last two times the food quality has left much to be desired. For some reason the idea of seasoning has been forsaken. The meatballs are tasteless and the eggplant parmigiana was not properly layered or seasoned!! Likely won't go back!!! read more

I went here today after a funeral, got server #69, Nicole. I ordered a pepperoni & garlic stromboli to go. It took over 45 minutes for them to make it. When I get home to eat it, I open the bag & it's some Italian sub/sandwich. Ham, salami, pepperoni, lettuce, green peppers, Italian dressing in a toasted hoagie roll. I call to tell them that they gave me the wrong thing, "well you already left with it, there's nothing we can do about it". Great customer service & way to go on making a stromboli. So much for that "authentic Italian cuisine". read more

Ordered 3 different calzones for delivery. I was told about an hour for delivery.....not a big deal, it was 5:00 in the evening on a Saturday.......20 minutes later I received my food...pleasant surprise! I ordered a calzone with spinach,mushroom, black olives, and fresh garlic.... they definitely didn't skimp on the ingredients!! And it was delish!! The other calzones were the same: delicious!!! I only have one gripe: the food wasn't as hot as I would expect. Antonella's is right down the street, so they didn't have that far to go, and my calzones should have come straight out of the oven.....(hence 4 out of 5 ) I would definitely order again, maybe try something different next time. read more

I doubt that I would ever go back. Last my wife and I went we went for pizza. We ordered 1/2 plain cheese, and 1/2 sausage. Usually there is 8 slices, so you would think that 4 slices would have sausage...not really. Only 3 slices had sausage. The garlic knots were burnt and it seemed to be an inconvenience for the wait staff to get a refill. The time before that I had ordered 3 pizzas around 5pm for pick up. I had to repeat my order a number of times. I get a call from them and when I pick up, the other end hangs up. I called back and no one seems to know who would have called (this is about 20 minutes after I originally placed my order). I go to pick them up @ 6pm and they didn't make the pizzas because there was a question. I talked to the manager who was not really caring at all. read more

Great prices, good food. For lunch, we had a (huge) egg plant parmigana hero and a pasta fiore. The first was delicious, all the ingredients good, perhaps only the bread was merely OK. The pasta fiore was reasonably sized for lunch, a fume type sauce with Artichokes and Dried tomatoes. Tasty, though missing by a little the absolute balance this sort of dish could achieve. Though we didn't have any, I think some red wine would go beautifully with the pasta. Lunch came with garlic bread and small pieces of pizza. Note: the glass showcase features grotesqe looking pizzas. Don't know if they are any good. read more

Well I can say is it is mediocre at best a tiny little Cesar salad with four tiny little shrimp was $15 ....now I don't mind paying $15 if it was a delicious salad but this was not delicious and it certainly wasn't worth $15 but what can I say it was mediocre and expensive. read more

Two words; Garlic knots! Oh so good. This is the place to go for lunch in town. Fresh perfectly cooked ravioli , huge subs, great sausage and juicy burgers. One more time let me say "garlic knots". Also staff is fabulous, as is the owner. Very attentive and great service. read more

See all

A nice cozy place for a good meal. I stopped in while visiting from out of town and had dinner. I had the linguini puttanesca dinner that includes salad and bread. What I really appreciated was the portion sizes. I'm not someone who expects leftovers and the salad and pasta were just right. The puttanesca sauce was a bit chunkier than I'm used to, but had good flavor and a nice kick to it. Garlic knots were yummy. They have a bar in the restaurant, so a glass of vino is in order! The place is managed by Italians, so I appreciated that! Nice friendly staff. Good meal for a good value. read more

Two words: stomach ISSUES. Not once, not twice but three times. The first two times I had ordered specials so the third time I went (yes I went back after a serious GI upset both times because my friend really likes it here) and I ordered something off the menu. Same result. Maybe it's just me but something there makes me sick. So why 3 stars you may wonder? Well the food is actually pretty good. Not super authentic and nothing especially unique but they have all the Italian basics. Good calamari and seafood. They have a full bar and the experience is nice and cozy. Very casual local Italian spot. read more

I really wanted to like Antonella's more. It's near Piersaull House and I'm a huge Italian food fan. I sat at the bar and the bartender was very nice. Several locals were there and making conversation. It's a very clean establishment and well appointed. Unfortunately, the food was not up to par. I ordered mussels marinara with linguine and a Stella Artois. I asked for the linguine al dente. The small salad served before the meal was fresh and tasty, and the blue cheese dressing was very good. A small basket of bread also arrived. The Italian bread was good, but the garlic knots lacked garlic and salt. When my main course arrived, the plate was loaded with mussels, but not very much pasta. It was cooked perfect Al dente though. I can look past the lack of linguine, but the real problem was the marinara. It lacked seasoning and was just not tasty. If there is anything that must be good in an Italian place, it's the marinara. In the closing scene of Goodfellas, Henry Hill is lamenting small town life and states, "Right after I got here I ordered some spaghetti with marinara sauce and I got egg noodles and ketchup." Now the sauce is that bad, but it's not far off. The mussels were good, but a bit on the smallish side. I did finish the plate, but doubt I will order the dish here again. I will return, as I believe every place deserves a second shot. I will try the Chicken Française next time. read more

Great Italian restaurant!!! Food is really good!! Place has a bar & always a nice atmosphere. Stop in on Fridays .... Britney usually bartends & she's top notch. Been eating here for years & they treat you like family.. 5 STARS!!!!!!! read more

Ok pizza. No ranch. But a great deal for lunch 2 slices with a topping on each and a soda for $8.

If you want to wait 3 hours on a Wednesday night for a pizza, call these guys. (PS- 3 hours and 2 phone calls later, we canceled the order as it still had NOT left the restaurant) read more

As a resident of Hyde Park for the last 30 years I have never received such horrible service. Yes it was a Saturday night but we arrived at 5:15pm and there were only 2 tables besides our table. We had a party of four ordered our appetizers, which came out very quickly. We order our meals while waiting for our apps. The apps stuffed mushrooms and fried squid were ok. Now here is where things went down hill. At 6:20pm we still did not have our main courses so I asked the server if our food was put it. He said he put it in for the third time. Finally at 7:05 our food was given to another table and then they realized it was ours. My wife, my mother, father and I are not ones to complain about food or service but this was just crazy. My wife takes a few bites of her wrap and a huge piece of plastic was in it. I then figured I would speak to the manager. When I spoke to the manager about the entire situation his answer was do you see how busy I am (points to the stack of receipts) it happens. I said well then we won't be back, his answer fine don't come back. I have been to every restaurant in Hyde Park several times and many others around and have never seen a staff that is so dysfunctional. The server we had was great but everything else was not. We did not even eat a quarter of our meals and I asked for the check. The manager then very snotty says you want your food for free I said no I just want you to know the experience we had. He says well alot of other people feel differently and I have been here for 12 years. I asked to speak to the owner and I was told that one of the cooks left and the owner was in the back cooking and was to busy. As a local business supporter and a former retail manager for 15 years I could only imagine how I would feel if one of my customers was treated like this. We will never visit this establishment again and I will be sure to spread the word. read more