I've eaten at Pepe's, Sally's, and plenty of well-known Manhattan spots, and Stone's is now the top of my list. I'm a biker, and we're known for spending $25 on gas to find a great slice. Stone's is worth the ride. Outstanding food, friendly people, and a comfortable, casual atmosphere. I'm already planning my next trip for sandwiches and a pie to bring to my brother's house. If you're traveling Route 9 through Wappingers Falls, stop here. read more

I'm ready to make a bold declaration: Stone's is the best pizza shop. Not the best around. Not the best I've found in Wappingers. The best pizza shop. Period. I know. That's a ridiculous statement to make about pizza. I'm not Portnoy, and I'm not basing it on one bite and an 8.3. In fairness, I have 10+ reps here now--eating in, taking out and delivery--and at this point I'm ready to pour a little affection on this place. Stone's is just it. Want an exceptional plain slice? It's here. Want some of the best wings you've had from a pizza shop? They're here--and they're frying them in beef tallow. Want a carefully considered specialty slice that actually earns the right to be different? Pick one behind the glass. Want a sandwich? A pizza shop frankly shouldn't be making sandwiches this stupidly delicious, but apparently Stone's decided that was their lane too. The creativity isn't there for novelty. These guys clearly think about food. And that's really what separates Stone's for me: consideration. The dough gets a minimum 48-hour fermentation. The ingredients matter. The wings matter. The sandwiches matter. The sauces matter. The way a slice is constructed matters. There is a level of intention here that you can taste before you ever know any of that. But I probably wouldn't love Stone's this much if it were only about the food. I love the playful banter from behind the glass. I love asking about a slice and getting an answer from someone who is genuinely excited to tell you what they made. I love that on more than one occasion I've been sent home with a few tastes of something I hadn't ordered or hadn't gotten the chance to try. Those little interactions stick with you. The ownership loves what they're doing, they've mastered their craft, and somehow they've managed to make that enthusiasm contagious. There are plenty of places that make great pizza. Stone's feels like a great pizza shop. There's a difference. So, to the ownership of Stone's: keep going. Whatever you're trying to build here, don't stop. It feels inevitable that more people are going to discover this place. Watching that happen is going to be fun. P.S. -- Stone's may not know this yet, but they've developed a strangely loyal satellite market in Garrison, NY. It's basically two houses: mine and my neighbor's. We've figured out both how to make the Wappingers-to-Garrison run and, somehow, how to get Stone's delivered all the way down here. So if an order is making that unlikely trip south, there's a pretty safe chance it's headed to one of our houses. Consider us the unofficial Garrison chapter. Can't wait to watch this place grow. 5/5. read more

Stone’s Pizza Shop - Variety to go - Pizza Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

People on here complaining about the size of a slice are missing the point or don't have taste buds. The pizza at Stone's uses ingredients that are of such higher quality than most "slice joints" and their process is top notch. 48 hour fermentation of dough, no cheap seed oils, high quality cheese, non bleached flour, etc. The quality of ingredients and process shows in the final result, and even though it may be a little pricier for a pie than many places, the flavor and quality is light years ahead of most places. I also like that the menu is simple: make a few things and make them well, and you have my business. I've also done a number of large orders (6-8 pies) in the past few months, and they are so nice and hospitable; everyone who works there is just really great in my experience. On the inside, it's a small spot, but it's super clean with a few tables, while you watch them bustling behind the counter. I came in the other day to grab a slice and watch the World Cup action on the TV, which was extra awesome. It's in a funny location on 9D on the way into Wappingers, but the sign caught my eye - glad I pulled in as it's my new favorite pizza spot in the HV. Keep it up Stone's! read more

Stone Pizza has become one of my go-to spots. The slices are legit NYC quality but the Sicilian squares pies? Unreal. You can tell the dough is taken seriously here- it's fermented for days and always perfect. The owners are super cool, too. The menu is thoughtful and creative. My personal favorite is the cheesesteak pie from the "secret menu." Sounds insane but order it anyway. I struggle just following them on social media because this pizza has become my weakness. read more

Stone’s Pizza Shop - Pizza Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

3/26/26 - stopped in out of curiosity to see what it's like. Ordered a slice. See the photo. I thought I was in a Dollar slice place in the Bronx, kind of pathetic for this area where most slices are twice the size. It was also a bit over cooked. Frank Pepe's can get away with it. There's a few tables. My curiosity was sated, but not my appetite. read more

See all

This is the pizza shop I'll probably be loyal to while living in dutchess county at this point. I'm spoiled that it's down the street and damn man. I go 2 times a month and always happy. It put their slices up against anything in NYC, New Haven, and Jersey lol. I have yet to order a pie and typically stop over in the afternoon for 2-3 specialty slices. I love the marinara, vodka sauce, and pesto thin slice as well as the pan or Detroit style. Their crust is amazing, sauce delicious, and any meat addition sublime. Buffalo chicken slice slaps haha read more

Stone’s Pizza Shop - Marinara, pesto, vodka sauce (bottom) chicken bacon and ranch top (I think it was buffalo chicken lol mm) - Pizza Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

See all

In all my years of teaching in the city, I can't say I've ever had the chance to support any of my students' family businesses- until now. When one of the parents in my class shared that she and her husband were opening a pizza shop in Wappingers Falls, NY, I was hyped for them from the start. I've been meaning to come here, but once I'm on the west side of the Hudson River where I live, errands take over and home pulls me back before I can make the stop. So It's been tough to make a trip here to this side of the Hudson. So I found the next best way to show my support: order pizza for my class for a pre end-of-year class party made with love by my student's dad and delivered to my classroom by the child's mom. It felt great repping a family that's out here building something real. This is the pizza everyone likes to talk about- in a good way. The crust is chewy with those perfect little golden charred spots- just enough to give it flavor without burning it. The cheese is melty and rich, but it doesn't weigh down the crust. And the tomato sauce? Spot on. Tangy, fresh, slightly seasony- which I usually dislike- but theirs was so right. Honestly, it all just hits. My student's parents have a great thing going. Service? Fabulous! In the end, the student's parents gifted the class three plain cheese pies and I was genuinely moved by their generosity. And my students enjoyed the pizza! Mil gracias from the bottom of my heart! read more

Stone’s Pizza Shop - Class Party Time: (Deliciousness In Each Bite) - Pizza Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

My 2nd time here and I'm still loving it! The shop is clean and transparent - you can clearly see them making the food. The man behind the counter, whom I believe to be an owner, greeted every single customer in a most welcoming manner. He kinda makes you feel like a regular when youre not. We ordered our slices and was told to sit, they'll bring the slices out. We did, and they did. The pizza there is BOMB. They are slightly expensive compared to other pizzeria, but you can taste the better quality of the ingredients. Its worth it! I had a square sausage slice, my date had a pepperoni. They both were beyond expectation! There are so many more items on the menu I'd like to try that I have no choice but to be a repeat customer. The friendly staff, sanitary space, and delicious eats make this place stand out - stop in and try it. There wont be any regrets. The ONLY problem I had is I dont drink anything but water. I had to go next door for a bottle as they dont have water in the cooler - just a bunch of fancy sodas and what not. Hopefully this will be remedied as time passes. They are still relatively new to the area. read more

See all

Absolutely the best pizza I have found up here in the Hudson Valley since I move to the area fifteen years ago. It's in a small shopping center with plent of parking. The place itself is bright with an area of about about eight tables. I ordered two different slices, one was a square pepperoni slice with hot honey and the other was something with vodka sauce and Calabrian chiles. Both were excellent. The crusts were crispy on both and very flavorful. The people working here were friendly and kept the place clean and interacted with their customers. I was tempted to order a couple of slices to take home but I don't think they'd have made it. This place is worth checking out! This place is literally across the Hudson River but I'll make this my stop when I want delicious pizza. read more

I am sensitive to gluten and feel like I never can eat good pizza anymore, but if I get a slice from Stone's, I don't even notice--no foggy gluten headaches, no stomach aches, just feeling good! This place has been a game-changer for me, and I am super appreciative of their quick service and suggestions. The yo-yo is my absolute favorite and can lift my spirits any day of the week! Their vodka sauce pizza is also addictive. read more

Ordered cheesesteak and slice of pizza. The best part about the cheesesteak was the roll it was crunchy semolina and full of seeds perfect. The meat was just average and tasted a bit like the 80s steakums. There was just something off and sandwich wasn't full so it was more bread than anything. The vodka slice was tasty but not worth $5 just not enough there. I'd go back and try other sandwiches based on the bread though. read more

Stone’s Pizza Shop - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

This pizza is the best in Dutchess County and it's not even close. If you're looking for a tradional NY style pie you won't be disappointed. The square pies are also excellent, never doughy, always crisp and airy. Don't sleep on the heroes either! I go every week now, it's that good. Never had poor service either, staff is lovely! read more

Stone’s Pizza Shop - Regular pie - Pizza Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

See all

The food is amazingly delicious! My husband & I ordered Meatballs they are out of this world. Service was great food was hot & tasty

Stone's Pizza Shop opened at Village Squares in the former Pacini's Pizza space. They serve up traditional & signature pizzas (12"-16" pies), calzones, hot subs, wings, Caesar salad, and cooler drinks. The place is order at the counter or online with a few tables and they offer DoorDash delivery. Recently, on my way home from a long road trip with 3+ hours left, I stopped off I-84 for a food break. I decided to try out one of the specialty pizzas from Stone's Pizza Shop in Wappingers Falls and placed an online order for a 12" The Mala ($20) pizza. I headed up 9D to Stone's and my pizza was being boxed for pickup when I arrived. The Mala was topped with vodka sauce, sausage, sliced meatballs, jalapeños, & melted mozzarella cheese on a thin firm crust which had a soft light texture and thicker edge crust. I enjoyed a couple slices of pizza in the parking lot before resuming my drive. This pizza was really great. I enjoyed the rest of the pizza the next evening back at home. read more

Its been years since Ive a good pizza until I tried STONES pizza in the village of Wappingers The pizza was fantastic and the Owners/ employees are very friendly and kind Again the Pizza / food is fantastic Go to STONES for you next Pizza Its the best read more

Always enjoyed the pizza here until recently. I noticed that their slices have gotten smaller and much more greasy than in the beginning. My guess is they're using cheaper cheese than before. I hope they bring the quality back to avoid losing pizza lovers like me. read more

We love this place! We found it by accident cruising around the other day. We made a turn we normally don't make and saw their "A" sign out front and made a last second decision to go in for some Pizza. The place is on the side of a building so you can't see it from the street so the "A" sign is what you are looking for. The place has a really nice design to it not like other pizza shops. I LOVE the green they used with the black for contrast. Our house is painted with deep rich colors in each room too. When we walked in first thing we saw was the colorful display of pizza toppings in a cuisine kind of way. Not the typical slew of slices. We noticed the pepperoni was cooked til it was curled up like little suction cups the way we love so we ordered 2 slices. Turns out they also added some honey to that recipe which was the perfect mix of sweet and whatever you want to call pepperoni, spiceroni? The crust was nice and thin making it crispy the way we like too. The owner Matt even gave us a sample of a regular slice on the house which was a cherry on top. We were eating the sicilian so being able to try a regular slice sealed the deal. We can't wait to go back and try one of the other fancy slices they had out. Sorry other pizza joint we used to go to... Stone's just took your spot. read more

Amazing Grandma's pizza! Sauce was perfect with tender crust. Will definitely make this our #1 take out spot!

Food was good, pizza was decent, service was awesome, ambiance was nice and cool. Your average run of the mill place. Seems like it's a solid consistent place to grab some food on a regular basis. read more

Pizza was amazing. Was able to try the meatballs which I definitely would get again. Cheesesteak was amazing. read more

Stone’s Pizza Shop - Amazing pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

Best pizza in dutches hand down . MATS good guy never going anywhere else for a PIE...

Randomly found this pizza gem! First I'll start with the negatives. .....nothing This place is such a good pizza joint. We went after playing for hours at fun max and 12 of us, including 5 kids, were starving. We ordered three pies, meatballs and salad. Everything was delicious. The pizza is crispy and thin but not too thin, with no flop, seasoned well and the toppings are cooked to perfection. It is so rare to find a pizzeria that is so good and fresh on a regular day. It just sucks we live so far. Honestly some of the best pies I have had this year, lol, but honestly Im a long time. If you go after reading my review, and don't like it, I would be shocked. ALSO the staff is friendly and great. read more

Spectacular! The service is marvelous. The pizza is fantastic! Super simple shop, the way it should be. Great food and clean tables. The killed it with their vodka sauce and pesto slice. We will be back again... and again. Best pizza in the area. Not even close. read more

Now this is pizza! I'm born and raised in Staten Island! This tastes like home! I know where I am stopping now on my way from work!

Went back yesterday for as usual an amazing slice and realized I did not write a review on their chicken wings that I had the other day. When I ordered them I did not think that them cooking their wings in beef tallow would be a big deal. Boy was I wrong what a big difference in flavor and crunch. They were so crispy and tasted so much better than the usual wings. They did not have that greasy taste you sometimes get with other wings. They tasted fresher and lighter and the garlic wings I had was amazing Try them out when you go you will not be sorry read more

I have nothing but positive things to say about this place. The sauce , the cheese and the dough are excellent! I always go classic cheese pie. The staff and owners are so friendly and kind. The place is very clean and welcoming. We come from Beacon and have spots that are great over here but we never turn down a trip to Stone's ! read more

The crust is sooo good! Buttery and crispy! I also ordered a Ceasar salad and added a chicken cutlet. I wish they had a grilled option but it's NOT a deal breaker. Yaaay and it's close to home! read more

Best Pizza and Philly cheesesteak in the 845 plus the owners are the best and very friendly!

I went to this restaurant on a Sunday afternoon with my kids to pick up a couple pizzas. The owners Jos and Matt were welcoming and warm. They showed genuine interest in my family and couldn't have been more hospitable. I've had some amazing pizza. Favorites include in NYC: DiFara's, Scarr's, John's of Bleecker Street, L'Industrie and Lucali. And in the Hudson Valley: Forage, Lola Pizza and Ollie's. I feel strongly that what Jos and Matt are producing deserves to be on the list of true pizza greats. The dough is perfectly chewy (no flop!), right proportion of toppings, sauce is perfectly tangy and not overly sweet. They are doing a perfectly sized menu...big enough to show variety, but not too big where you just don't feel like any of it can be executed with any level of true excellence. Run to Stone's! read more

Was there the first time today on a recommendation from a friend. Pizza was amazing. I had the hot honey slice with pepperoni and a regular slice with vodka sauce. Both excellent! The staff was very welcoming and friendly! This will definitely be my go to pizza place in the area! Glad I gave it a try. Thank you Stone's pizza.! read more

Their crust is perfect, sauce seasoning is world class, everything I've had here is fantastic. Everybody that works there is super friendly, and they've got a play pizza kitchen to keep the kids patient while they wait for greatness! Don't forget to try the Philly cheesesteak or a chicken parm vodka sub, 10/10 recommend read more

Super good pizza for this area. On par with nyc pizza! Very friendly staff especially the counter girl for the day. Would definitely recommend this spot if you're wiling to try something new. read more

My husband and I have eaten here multiple times. This place is great our favorites include the cheesesteak sub such a generous portion of ribeye on a freshly baked sub roll. The chicken cutlet (the Tessa) sub is tender and delicious. The pizza however is the star it is not like your same old pizza. It is light and airy but crisp. The toppings are unique. You will not be disappointed. Give it a try. Anonymous PS: the meatballs are delicious!! read more

Crust is amazing! Chicken wings just so crisp and tender. Excellent - will be back. Wonderful service. Nice dining area. read more

Came out piping hot with bold flavors and generous toppings.! Great value for the price.!!

Love love love these guys!! The pizza is so NYC which I missed terribly, just had the Cheesesteak Sub, real rib eye, perfect amount of cheese and onions on that beautiful seeded NYC bread!!! These guys are the real deal, and all the food comes with great personalities!! And if you really want to feel like royalty... use the bathroom ​ read more

Driving and found by accident. Walked in and the place is spotless.Everything in the food displayed looked so delicious. I opted for The Stone pizza with pepperoni, ricotta, mozzarella and hot honey. Delicious combination, perfectly cooked crust and pepperoni cooked that it curled (Yum!)Regular slice delicious again the crust perfect nice and crispy. If you love pizza make the trip you will be happy with your choices. I found my Pizza shop read more

Best pizza in area hands down. Grandma slice taste like it was made by a legit Italian grandma!! Big guy behind the counter, I think his name was Joe really knows his stuff and can tell he's passionate about his pizza craft ! Didn't try the wings but that's on the list of things to try for next time. Will def be going back ! read more

Great guys very friendly food is delicious, they gave me a free slice of pizza that wasn't on the menu and it was phenomenal as-well as the pie i ordered best pizza i've had. Will definitely be coming back read more

Amazing pizza and sandwich shop. Best cheesesteak in the Hudson Valley (Ribeye steak sliced on premises), wings are fried in beef tallow and are super crispy, best pizza in the area (square "Yoyo" slice with fresh pesto, mozzarella, and hot honey is great). Atmosphere is reminiscent of a New York pizza shop, owners are friendly and service is excellent. If in the Hudson Valley it's a must visit. read more