We decided to get Italian food and this was close by. I was in the mood for eggplant rollatini, which I'd never had here. I've had it at other restaurants and it's one of my favorites. Upon receiving the food, the presentation looked very pleasing. We got take out so I wasn't expecting anything crazy. Unfortunately, the food taste itself was not as great at I'd hoped. The dish was a little saltier than I'd expected and there wasn't a ton of eggplant. The rollatini portions were stuffed with ricotta, and I never thought I'd say this but, it was too much. I wanted more eggplant and that meaty, savory element. I've had better eggplant rollatini in the area and I wasn't impressed. It wasn't bad but not my favorite. Overall, the dish was okay and I don't think I'll order this one again. read more

Antonella's - Eggplant Rollatini - Italian Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

We decided to try this pizzeria because we were in the area and needed something quick. The ambience inside is really cute, and the service was great. However, the pizza was not the best. It lacked sauce, and it was paper thin. The plain slice did not really taste good, not sure if it was the seasonings they had added to the top. The only slice that had some good flavor was the buffalo chicken slice. I just wish that they put more sauce and that it was a bit thicker. read more

See all

There's no place to wash up before eating ie no bathroom. The flavor of Hand sanitizer is off putting. Depending on who's behind the counter the service is spotty at best. It's not like I haven't been here before so I know it's been better, in the past. Maybe today was a bad day for them & me. The price is the same as the one in Fishkill or if the slice is cremated. read more

Someone ordered a couple pizza pies with different toppings, and we picked them up. Unfortunately, the wait took longer than we anticipated, which was a bit of a turnoff. Since it was the lunch rush, it's somewhat understanding, but it would be nice to see some improvements. I personally enjoyed the slices, loaded with flavor and cooked just what I expected. For me, this is the first time trying Antonella's, and I'm willing to explore more on the menu. read more

The food is really good.The service is great.I love the ambience of the place.If you're looking for good food please come here.

Went there to pick up some penne slices. Got home, reheated the slices and the center of the slices were so doughy and uncooked we couldn't even eat them. Called to complain, no apologies only rudeness. Won't be going there again. This was Antonella's Wappingers location. read more

Almost ignored me when I came in, they charged me more then what is listed on the menu and the food was average at best especially when compared to the price. I would not recommend this pizzeria as they are better options in the neighborhood where you will get better service and won't be overcharged read more

Delicious Gluten Free pizza! Seriously. They sell a 10" personal size that is perfect for two people. Doesn't taste grainy or dry! They even bake it on its own pan. Thank you, Antonella's for supporting your gluten free friends! read more

We've ordered from here regularly since moving to Dutchess nearly 5 years ago after trying many places and found this to be the best pizza in the area. Sadly, it seems that they've changed ownership within the past few months and our last two orders were disappointing. A few weeks ago, we were in the mood for a sausage pie and when my husband got home, the pizza was a sloppy mess. The cheese was sliding off all over the place like it should have been cooked more and the presentation of the pizza was awful. If we weren't so hungry, we would've brought it back. Decided to order again tonight and this time we had the opposite problem. I opened the box and said "what the heck?" My husband joked that they confused our order with someone who wanted their pizza extra crispy. The crust was visibly burned in several places and was overcooked this time. I ordered a chicken entrée which no longer comes with a salad. The employee told my husband that they lowered the prices and the salad was an additional charge. The menu that I have at home may be outdated but it shows the same $17.95 for the entrée, including a salad. I don't care about a salad necessarily and I understand food prices have gone up, but it feels dishonest. I guess our love affair with Antonellas has come to an end. read more

See all

The wife and I ordered chicken dinners.The chicken parmesan I got was so salty it was almost unedible.They used too much corn starch on the chicken fiancee.No salad, no bread just a side of pasta.$45 They have gone so down hill since the pandemic. Unfortunately, I doubt I will ever eat at this location again. read more

Ordered a cheese pizza for pickup. When picking up, after other errands, I looked around for a rest room. Not seeing any, I asked Miss Low-Cut-Blouse-I-Hope-This-Helps-With my-Tips at the counter where it was. She said there is none. I asked, a restaurant without a bathroom? She said they're not a restaurant. I turned around and pointed to 6 to 8 tables full of people eating, looks like a restaurant. No, We're a Pizzeria! Besides that, no thank you for the purchase, choosing their location, Come visit us again, etc. BTW, if you google them, it shows up online as "Antonella's Wappingers Menu - Antonella's Restaurant & Pizzeria". Hmm. Pasta, Appetizers, Salads, Soups, Sides, Desserts, Pizza, Hero Sandwiches, Wraps, Poultry, Seafood, Italian Specialties. Sounds like a restaurant to me. If you're looking for an Italian Restaurant, from Miss Glitter Chest herself, this is not a restaurant. read more

I've been coming to Antonella's for years and it has been the best pizza in the area every single time. The atmosphere is authentic and have great service. They all welcome you like family, the lasagna is to die for. There's a reason they have been in business for all of these years. People love them and their food is delicious!! read more

We had contractors working and decided to buy some pizza for everyone for lunch. I have to say I was pleasantly surprised at how good the pizza was. There was a fair amount of sauce and also the pepperoni and cheese. The crust was good not to thin and not too thick. Overall I was very pleased. We will definitely go back. read more

I've been coming here for years. I really used to enjoy dinner in the restaurant side, which has been closed and walled off from the pizza side. The menu looks like you can get all the same dishes on the pizza side or to go, but it's just not the same. I continue to come here for the pizza, which I enjoy very much. One thing to note is that the place no longer has bathrooms,they were in the restaurant side that was walled off. How the heck can you run a B&M food establishment without bathrooms for your customers? read more

Excellent food, great staff and the owner is very personable, friendly and welcoming. Most definitely a place worth going back to. , you will not be disappointed! read more

My girlfriend and I ordered a Sicilian pie last night; half meatball, half pineapple and prosciutto. We get home and apparently ground beef is the same thing as meatballs to the pizza guys at Antonella's. Here's a tip Antonella's, have your online menu reflect the correct toppings. If you don't have meatballs, it shouldn't be an available topping for selection. And greasy ground beef on a pizza is nasty. Very disappointed. Won't be going back any time soon. read more

Antonella's - This is supposedly meatballs. - Italian Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

A friend ordered pizza from Antonella's to be delivered the other night. Pizza arrived on time, delivery guy was nice and pizza was warm. However it was not the best. The sauce looked dry and pizza was greasy. I probably wouldn't order from here again. read more

They said their mozzarella sticks were "homemade". The taste and appearance of them has determined that was a LIE. I feel deceived and robbed. Pizza toppings are also misleading as far as quality goes. read more

Antonella's - Disappointing mozzarella sticks - Italian Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

Ordered Veal Parmesan. The Veal was old an chewy. For $25 it should be much fresher. On a good note. The Angel Hair Pasta and the Garlic knots were good. read more

Got delivery (thru Grubhub)... on time (even a bit early). Nice fresh salads, with Romaine (not iceberg). Tomato sauce was nice and thick, and plenty of it. Veal parm dinner enough for 2+ meals, and delish! I highly recommend over pretty much all the other local Italian places. read more

Really solid pizza. Nice staff and always a good selection of slices. Never had a bad meal here. Settled on a chicken bacon ranch slice which is one of their better specialty slices. Also had a baked ziti slice which was really satisfying. Their regular pizza is very good and I debated buying a road slice but my wife talked me out of it. Their Sicilian is that fluffy upstate type that I'm not a huge fan of but all of their Italian food is good as well as their pizza. If you are shopping at the mall and don't want to stop at the food court it's right down route 9. read more

See all

Got a slice of lasagna Pizza. It's got a lot of toppings on it and felt like it weighs about 3 lb. Staff is really friendly, and they have a very large variety of specialty slices. Slice that I got cost $4, and is a really good deal for the money. I would recommend this pizza parlor if you are in the area. read more

Antonella's - I had to start eating before I took this picture because it just looked so tasty! - Italian Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

See all

Went for lunch today with my son , and Marisa (?) was our server and she was very friendly , helpful , and did a wonderful job. I got my son 2 slices of plain pizza which he throughly enjoyed and I got the chicken special that was like a franchisee with prosciutto and shrimp which was very good the only thing was there was a lot of shrimp in this dish I found like 2 pieces I think but over all it was excellent and plentiful . I'll stick to the fancy meals in house and only order simple things for delivery read more

Antonella's - Italian Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

Everything I've ordered from this place has been consistently good. Big fan of their pizza but their Tortellini boscaiola is phenomenal! I get a craving for the dish & it has to come from Antonella's. It's perfectly creamy & the portion size is great. The staff is also really friendly and always welcoming. Highly recommend! read more

Waiter was extremely rude. Gave us dirty glasses and had an attitude because we wanted new glasses. Was very sassy. Didn't even order We just left will not be returning! read more

My family's been eating at Antonella's since the first location opened in Fishkill in the 1990s. The veal cutlet parm here is my mom's favorite and she is always disappointed with the quality of the veal when she tries the same dish at other restaurants. For me, they have the best red sauce in the area (and we've got a lot of mom and pop Italian restaurants to choose from around here). They don't skimp on the salad that comes with your meal and the garlic knots are so good. I swear they were the first to do knots around here, nobody makes the little ones like they do. We recently went to the Wappingers location for dinner and was sad to find out that the sit-down restaurant side has closed for good. The take out side is still open, and you can sit and eat at the handful of tables so mom still got her veal parm - just with plastic forks and knives. The place was absolutely packed when we were there and lots of folks coming in for take out, lots of deliveries going out. Glad they are still in business and wish them the best. read more

Antonella's in Wappingers is really two restaurants in one. A traditional, sit-down restaurant on one side, and a neighborhood pizza joint on the other. This review is a little tricky, because it's only for the pizza place; I have been to the sit-down restaurant side, but I don't really remember it. The pizza side has a few tables (maybe 9?) and a counter; you get pizza to go or you seat yourself. They typically have several gourmet pizzas (white pizza, veggie and broccoli, etc), plain pizza, and rolls/stromboli (chicken roll etc) ready to go; they heat it up when you order. I believe Antonella's pizza doesn't get the respect it deserves. I never hear anyone talking about it, I never see advertisements for it, and it's never all that crowded when I go in. There are a lot of good pizza places in the Poughkeepsie area (Giacomos, DD's) but the gourmet pizzas at Anotnella'sare consistently excellent. I am chowing down on one chicken marsala slice and one spicy buffalo chicken slice right now and I can honestly say I can't find a better gourmet slice anywhere in Dutchess or Ulster county. Their plain slices are some of the best in the area too, but I'm a sucker for the gourmet slices. They are on the expensive side (these two slices cost me 8 bucks) but when you consider the quality of the toppings, it is worth it. View my 'about me' page to see how I rate dining establishments. This is a 2.5 star restaurant. read more

Antonella's is my new favorite Italian restaurant! We stopped there a couple of weeks ago to grab lunch. I was having a difficult time deciding between the shrimp parmesan or the eggplant parmesan meal. To solve the indecision, hubby had the eggplant and I had the shrimp. I was more than delighted with my meal. The shrimp taste and texture was perfect! The sauce was excellent and the amount of cheese was just right. I then tasted my husband's eggplant parmesan. It was delicious also. If my stomach were big enough I would have ordered both and sat there like a glutton consuming both meals. Unfortunately, I couldn't. I slowly, but surely took my time to savor every bite of my shrimp. The good thing about finding good food is that you can always go back again. So, a week later we went back. This time I had the eggplant and hubby had the shrimp. I was a very, very happy camper! The food was delicious and the service great and friendly (yes, I'm talking about you Scott). The second time around we got to meet Angelo, the owner. What a character. He made our visit even more enjoyable. Let me not forget the garlic knots and the salad. Everything was excellent! We even went home with a couple of cannolis. Will we go back there again? Of course! Just a note: Although the meals come with pasta, I chose not to have it, I had broccoli or broccoli rabe instead. read more

Antonella's - Shrimp Parmesean - Italian Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

See all

Never order food from this place. Pizza came covered with oil. Pasta fagioli came covered with orange oil. Not a little. A layer of it. Pizza did not taste like the pizza served at the restaurant at all. Cheese had no flavor. Crust was burned a bit. And to top it all off, had to argue with the delivery guy since he tried to collect for the order that we had paid for online. Argued with us when he brought the order and came back later to argue again about it. I'll never order food from this place again. read more

I ordered a pizza half meatball half cheeses the sauce tasted Rancid. When I called up. And told them they said They never had a complaint. Wanted to send me another pie. Horrible. I feel so sick. It was also cold. read more

Food's OK, but there are SO many italian retaurants to choose from that are comparable. What I really don't like about this place is that they charge a "service fee" for using a credit card. That is just the cost of doing business! As we head towards a cashless society I shouldn't be charged extra for that! Why not charge me for use of the parking lot, heat, and lighting while I am there too??? If you need to charge 5% more to cover the cost, then raise your prices 5%! If you want to give a discount to people who pay in cash, then do that too! But don't charge MORE just to complete the transaction!!! read more

Best Pizza In Dutchess County. Their white pizza is the best. The owner is active behind the counter, friendly and willing to happily converse with his customers. read more

I am eating at Antonellas alone this is very rare for me. I have been greeted with warmth and attention made to feel like I am a queen. My server sweet and at tentative the manager comes over to see if I need anything. Everyone could stop treating me like I was a VIP. I look like I am a wreck I am tired and a little sad I look like u have been through hell and back this is my oasis. I am so happy here and content eating my favorite dish the shrimp cooked to perfection chicken as well the sauce makes me melt. What I love about being here is the way I am treated as if they knew I have been through hell. I most definitely recommend this place. read more

Antonella's - Love this dish - Italian Near Me - Wappingers Falls, New York

Tried to get lunch at 11:30. They have no hours posted, front door was open and someone was picking stuff up. snippy lady said they weren't open til noon. Even though we're in the plaza at noon we'll skip this place since they couldn't be bothered to get things right. I imagine them fulfilling an order would equally be hard to get right. read more

I frequently order takeout from Antonella's and they are so generous, always include bread, garlic knots, butter, salad (some places don't included salad with a meal) and even a small container of Parmesan cheese for the pasta. The penne ala vodka is always delicious and they give you enough to last three meals. read more

This was my first time at Antonella's. I had the Lasagna, kid had a pizza, and the wife had manicotti. The food was great, service was very friendly. No complaints. We'll definitely be back. read more

Great place, went with my cousin.I got a lasagna slice and he got chicken parm. Everything was on point, garlic knots at the table: super cool. All the staff is very young and pretty read more

Came here on Saturday with family. Service was a decent pace and the garlic knots were fine...That's pretty much it. Gnocchi was fine but the sauce tasted like generic canned stuff. Also could have used some mozzarella cheese. This place is just okay. No more, no less. read more

We always get the pizza and its very good. However tonights pizza was cracker crust and no bordering crust. It tasted totally different, like a different owner took over. Ill grab a picture of the 7 slices left to show what I mean. read more

I find that this location (Wappingers Falls) is more comfortable than the one in Fishkill. The pizzas by the slice are fresh and delicious. I love how the plain cheese pizza slices sometimes offer a perfect ending by the crust with a basil leaf. The chicken rolls are great because the bread has not only a wonderful taste but also has wonderful texture and buoyancy to it. The service at the front counter could be a little friendlier, but this place is about the food in the end. read more