Service was chaotic. Several errors in timing of food to table and multiple incorrect items delivered/some items forgotten entirely even after reminders. Staff gave us a free pizza as some compensation Food was okay overall. Decent sandwiches and salads. Milkshake average. read more

They're almost always busy, but service is always good! Their pizza is always so good! It's definitely a little greasy, but that's how pizza is supposed to be! I love the eggplant pie. The little pieces of fried eggplant are so crispy and delicious. The pickled pepper relish gives it such a nice kick of flavor. And the sauce and cheese are just perfection. I love how the crust is always cooked to the perfect golden brown color. I also got a brownie since I was craving something sweet. So smooth and chocolatey, it was the perfect after dinner treat! I love coming here during the summer because they have dog friendly outdoor seating with a beautiful view of the Hudson River read more

See all

Consistently good for many years now. They do a great job on all of their items. I love the wings there.

We stopped by here because we were in the area. We ordered a pepperoni and margarita pizza and it was delicious! The garlic knots were a little dry, but edible. The booths were comfy to sit in and the staff were friendly. read more

Pizza Shop - a man sitting at a table - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

The vibe here is relaxed. Pizza Shop has good pizza. I try to hit this spot everytime I'm in the area. My order is a gluten-free personal pizza with pepperoni, extra cheese, anchovies, sausage, and a root beer to chase it all down. The restaurant is clean, and the staff is prompt and friendly. There is curbside parking, if you are lucky. If not, you have to park in the parking lot and walk, about a 1/2 block. There are two levels to this restaurant. The menu has more than just pizza for order. Do yourself a favor and look over the menu before you arrive, if possible. Cash/Credit/Debit are accepted here. read more

Pizza Shop - The entrance to the Pizza Shop on Water Street. - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

I wasn't holding out much hope. But I really like this place. The pizza is really good. And I really liked their Caesar salad. So definitely get that. read more

We had a thin crust margarita with pepperoni on top. The sauce was absolutely delicious. The pepperoni crisp up into little cups. The thin crust was crispy and delicious. We also had the arugula avocado salad, which was fresh. The dressing tasted like Italian dressing from the store nothing special, but the fact that all the ingredients were fresh made up for it. read more

Pizza Shop - Arugula and Avocado - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

One of my 3 or 4 favorite pizza places in the country. The vodka pizza is just epic. Very high quality ingredients and always cooked well. Just wish I didn't live about 300 miles away. We always stop here on our way to and from Maine (from/to the DC area). read more

Customer service! The waitress was great, the manager was a knit wit.The place was like an ice box freezing with the air conditioners blowing on the customers and the food. When asked several times to shut the A.C. down the manager said... "it's all in your minds. The building doesn't even have an air conditioner. If you can find it, good luck." All the tables in the dining room were complaining about how cold it was. Terribly rude and disrespectful to the customers. read more

I took the swirl, it's just cheese, nothing else, at some point I thought it was dough. It's bad, don't eat. Then a pesto roll, which had no pesto. Don't eat. I order 4 slices, she gave me the pizza box all packed up, missing one slice. I travelled 30 miles, so couldn't go back and ask. Overall, bad experience. read more

A pizza shop worth traveling too. Get the Grandmas pie & a chocolate chip cookie. Can't go wrong!

Ordered Uber eats and the food came hot and fresh. Perfection. The garlic knots are great and I love their pizza. It's super flavorful, and the red onions with mushrooms is a hit. Their Gorgonzola walnut salad is so good I had to replicate making this at home read more

See all

Amazing Italian food in a scenic spot by the river! Some of my personal favorites are the eggplant Parmesan, mozzarella bombs, and spinach rolls. Also the staff are friendly and helpful! Pizza Shop has both the look and tastes of NYC right in Newburgh. read more

Pizza Shop - Golden Mozzarella Bombs - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Pizza by the slice, fresh pies (the Eggplant Pie rocks), sandwiches (Meatball Parm is a standout), or salads. Everything is great. The only negative is its small size (fortunately there's a lot of outdoor seating in warmer weather) and their reduced hours since Covid. But the food and staff are great. read more

Pizza is greaaaatt! Service is good. Good music and restaurant is clean nice place to unwind

I stopped by this place a couple years ago for an ice-cream on my way to the Newburgh Vintage Warehouse, and had wanted to visit again for all the deliciousness on display. I found myself in the vintage warehouse this weekend again so searched it out for a mid-afternoon snack with my husband. We ordered the artichoke roll and the gorgonzola walnut salad. While waiting, I went downstairs to the bathroom - and felt an impulse to take a photo, coz it was so immaculate! With both high quality hand soap and hand lotion - how considerate! The cleanliness of the bathroom at an eatery is always a plus for me, in that I'd trust the cleanliness of the food that they serve. Both dishes were super delicious! The artichoke roll was huge - it fed both of us and I was too full to eat dinner that night. The salad was beautiful, creative, healthy and tasty. While we were eating, the staff also had their late lunch. How well a restaurant feeds its staff is also a good indicator of how well they feed their clients, and if the serving staff are happy to work there. Let me just say that I would be very happy to work there! read more

See all

Food is DELICIOUS and Pizza Shop staff is fantastic, HOWEVER, the once amazing ambiance of the old train station is now completely gone. The "restaurant" is pretty much a pass through and prep station for Hudson Taco now. As you see in the pictures, the servers for Hudson Taco toss out food, refill drinks, and dry trays in the Pizza Shop dining area. There is no longer any seating for Pizza Shop customers outside at all, as their had been for years prior. Only outside dining for Hudson Taco customers now. The Hudson Taco staff create A LOT of back and forth traffic in the small Pizza Shop dining room. I realize Hudson Taco definitely brings in more $$ than Pizza Shop but the atmosphere is not pleasant for the Pizza customers anymore. Maybe over the winter I'll go back to eating there again but for now I will maybe just do take out. read more

Pizza Shop - Hudson Taco prep area in Pizza Shop dining room. - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

It takes a lot for me to give poor reviews. We ordered delivery to our hotel room, starving after a long day outside. The food seemed good at first...until my husband realized, several bites in, that the eggplant he'd ordered was, in fact, chicken. Two things to note: we are vegetarians and he's allergic to chicken. As he vomited up his food, I called and got a very half-a$$ed apology from the manager. She refunded the price of his meal only but it was all ruined at that point, so a complete waste of a lot of money. Never again. read more

5/22/23 This place has definitely been dropping the ball lately. We went in to eat yesterday and first thing that upset us was they have all that outside dining on their side wrapped in their name and it's only for Hudson taco customers , then you see 5-10 workers walking back and forth from the taco side thru the pizza place to bring people food outside. It was the craziest thing I've ever seen. I ordered a pepperoni pinwheel the girl gave it to me and it was still doughy inside she's like oh it's not done I'll put it back in, like it's $7 it should be done before you take it out the first time and sit it on display. I'm like no I have no time for that I'll do it at home. This place just isn't what it used to be including the pizza. read more

Pizza Shop - Chicken Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

Loveddd. Everything was delicious. Ashley was our waitress she was awesome. We got cheeseburger, grilled chicken sandwiche and chicken BLT Everything was yummmm. Always order for delivery but never sat down. It was awesome. The mozzarella balls were everything!! Will definitely be returning read more

See all

Came here to make some to go orders. People behind the counter were quick to take my order and explained to me menu. But I sort of tell they don't seem to like dealing with customers much. I just got that vibe. So I was told my order total and how long my food would take. It took exactly the time they said, so at least they quick. So I ordered the buffalo calamari and fiery shrimp linguini. The calamari was cooked perfectly, Chewy but not rubbery like over fried seafood, the buffalo sauce they used was very tangy, would preferred it be spicier, than over board tangy, eh guess personal preferences. Hah. Fiery shrimp linguini, the pasta was Al Dante, shrimp was little over cooked and not really many in dishes, all the veggies were yummy and fresh in taste, now the vodka chili cream sauce was pretty spicy and really it was best part of dish. It's a nice upscale pizza place here, a breath of fresh air compared to standard old school place around the area. read more

Pizza Shop - Firery Fiery Shrimp Linguini - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

I have not been here in well over three years. This place was not somewhere I frequented when I first moved here but soon discored it was nothing special. Prices where high flavor was mild and it was not really anything worth the trip. Fast forward to last Tuesday and this is not the same place I once grew to ignore. An order was placed through yelp order out feature and I had garlic knots and Buffalo Chicken pizza. Yelp estimated 45-55 minutes the app refreshed told me 18 minutes. I arrived to see different staff and a different manager. Our pizza was ready the the garlic knots were not. While we waited the manager offered us any free drink we wanted from the cooler to apologize for the knots not being ready. Very nice and a good guy move. When we got home all we could summarize the experience with is "YUM" pizza was full of flavor, great crust, solid pizza that wasn't soggy or floppy. The chicken had a kick to it but nothing to put there, onions were indeed grilled, bacon was crispy and the ranch dressing complimented it all. The knots were very garlic butter heavy and hit the spot. I would say if you were like me and gave up on them long ago dare to try them again they may surprise you like they did me 5* read more

Just popped in for a dessert post-tacos. Ice cream looks great but we settled for a giant cookie and brownie. A great takeaway.

Great pizza, service and vibe. The Margarita and mushroom pizza are our favorite. The music brings us back to our younger years.

Ordered pizza & garlics knots and they were great! Different from places in the surrounding area since they serve an 8 piece rectangular pie instead of round! Service was quick, we didn't have to wait too long which was great since we were starving. I didn't sit in the restaurant seating but I did sit in the front end, it was a nice area and didn't feel too crowded even if there were a lot of people in there. read more

Took my family and friends and had the best service. They accommodated us so well on busy night. And the food was amazing.

So, ordered wings, charge more for "crispy", which, they say are bone in. The wings that were listed as "buffalo wings" taste like mushy sweet bbq. No vinegar, salt, nothing. They were also underdone. No bueno. List them as tangy BBQ, not Buffalo. There is a difference. read more

Pizza shop is one of my absolutely fav casual dining spots in the area. The views from the restaurant are amazing and you can see the entire hudson river between the newburgh beacon bridge and cornwall on hudson. The food selection is awesome. I highly recommend getting the asian wings. They are super crunchy with a tangy, spicy sauce and they come sprinkled with sesame seeds and scallions. The rice balls have amazing flavor and they come with whipped ricotta. Soo many times restaurant dont season or do anything to the rice inside but pizza shop is the exception. Surprisingly the tastiest thing they make is a gorgonzola walnut salad! Its probably not healthy at all but its creamy and wonderful to eat alongside pizza crust. The pizzas are uniquely square with cool flavor combos. recommendation is to get a bunch of things to share so you can enjoy a little bit of everything! read more

See all

Damn Pizza shop 2 food stars TODAY. This is a tough one, on one hand I usually like the sandwiches/ pizza here (didnt realize I never wrote a review ) but today I was disappointed enough to write. I've had their crispy wings ($1.45 more for crispy vs boneless)numerous times so I know they can be kind of hard. So today I online requested . not too crispy please :) and guess what, they were the hardest I've ever had from them. So hard they were dried out. Geesh, that really seemed on purpose. Now I'm thinking what else did they do to my chicken? Smh, I politely asked. It could have been due to a toothache or sharing with a child. They don't know and made them harder!? Requests shouldn't be taken as disrespect or a dig at the cooks, pple could have legit reasons. I guess the sogginess from the chicken sandwich made up for the dry chicken. BTW they had just opened for the day can't blame overcrowded, or busy for this. read more

Pizza Shop - Wish you could feel hardness / dryness - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

I've been to Pizza Shop a bunch of times over the years. Never had a bad meal. But this time I ordered something I never tried. Country bacon Mac & cheese. HOLY CRAP ! What a meal !! DELICIOUS ! I recommend you try it. And while you're there, try their pizza, it's outstanding too ! Great place. Simple, no hassle, and good food. (Great atmosphere too!) In addition to this review, I'll add that this picture of the meal does not do it justice. We were forced to have "take out" due to the Coronavirus pandemic. Once I stirred the food, it looked the way it should. Wetter. Whatever. Everything is great there ! And it's built out of an historic train station in Newburgh, NY, a few hundred yards from Washington's Headquarters. Beautiful! Now go!! read more

Pizza Shop - Country Bacon Mac and Cheese. WOW! - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

The VIEW!!!! the food! The friendly staff and hustle n bustled of the service. Great selection and the Hudson Taco neighbors share the same kitchen and building. Unfortunately the taco place has exclusive rights to the outside seating, BUT!!! You can still share and walk around, delicious food and company. Pizzas are huge and delicious! read more

I've been having serious issues with getting delivery from Pizza Shop for about 6 months. They have a note attached to my phone number that says to call a different number when outside that I didn't write, which means that my driver can't get in touch with me when my pizza arrives. After an hour I call and give them the correct number, I've spoken to both the person working the counter and the driver and they assure me it'll be updated every time, but it hasn't happened yet. I really like the pizza from this place, but every time because of this issue I get a pizza that's been sitting in someone's car for 45 minutes. They've also given me a completely different order several times, which wouldn't be an issue if the delivery fees weren't so high ($25 and up for a single pizza driven less than a mile). I still recommend it for pick up and eating in but the delivery is a mess. read more

I've yet to have a terrible experience or even subpar one at this joint. I like to stay pretty simple with my pizza but I will get adventurous when I'm here. My newest must-try is there meatster pizza with the wheat crust paired with the Asian Szechuan type wings. Actually they probably have some of the best wings for my buck, they don't give the normal dozen you get 10 wings but it's plenty. the pizza roll ups are also pretty damn good and they give you a generous helping of side sauce. If you're sitting in the ambiance isn't bad at all and in the summer you have a little patio that you can sit at. if you're in a rush there's definitely pizza by the slice that you can go check out. read more

They have excellent pizza. The staff is pleasant. The chicken /bacon hero us truly delicious

Awesome interior, food and location. The pizza was great. But the Staff alone dropped it down to 3 stars. They were rude, impatient and made it obvious they didn't want to be at work. More than likely I won't go back. On the quest to find a better pizza place with great service. read more

See all

Place is off the hook!!! Great service, food, and atmosphere. I didn't order a pizza, but they looked so good. The sandwich I ordered was excellent! I only got through half of it and saved the rest for later. WARNING: a train rides by frequently and can be very loud if you're sitting outside (so close I could spit on it when it goes by). There is also an ice cream section located inside. Throughout the restaurant there are newspaper clippings and photos about the history of the town. Very cool! read more

See all

Pizza is very good. Service was slow as I placed a take out order. But they were very apologetic. I also got the fried dough which was nothing special. Wouldn't get that again. I think this place is the superior to Hudson Taco. read more

The pizza shoppe Pizza Love. Love the Eggplant Pizza. Excellent Can't go wrong with the Walnut cranberry salad Also the spinach w mozzarella Put more spinach less cheese I reAlly love that too everyone Is very freindly I love that they Always greet you when you walk In the door. Nice you got the river View the train passing by inside Or out great place read more

I love this place ! I've only ever had delivery . & I have NEVER been disappointed . From the Nonna's pie to the chicken Marsala dinner . Even the salad that comes as a side with the dinner !!! Incredible ... fresh shredded carrots , sliced red peppers , romaine , and this creamy spicy "house" dressing . I need the recipe to that dressing. The chicken parm / eggplant parm subs are slamming . & their variety of pizzas is just mental (in the best way). Also - delivery is always fast ! Yesterday I received my meal in under 40 minutes . read more

The pizza here is great! It is one of my favorites in the area. The dough is thin and tasty and the wide selections of toppings are a perfect addition to your pie. Lots of great appetizers and sandwiches are also available if you prefer. There is limited seating available. read more