Cascarino's is the real deal, and I do not use that phrase lightly. We tried three things on this visit: the grandma pie, a classic regular slice, and a custom panzerotto. Let me start with that panzerotto, because it deserves its own paragraph. This is the kind of dish you would have to fly to Italy to find, and somehow Cascarino's is making it right here. It was the single best thing I ate, and I am still thinking about it. The grandma pie was phenomenal, perfectly crisp on the bottom, pillowy inside, with that beautiful golden crust that so few places actually nail. The regular pizza held its own too, with solid sauce, great cheese pull, and a crust that had real character. But what ties it all together is the ownership. This is a true owner-operated spot, and you feel it in every detail, the care in the kitchen, the warmth at the counter, the consistency in every bite. When the owner is on site, this place is firing on all cylinders. Five star service, no question. And order the rice ball, packed with cheese and meat and hotttt out of the oven. Cascarino's is, without a doubt, the best pizza and Italian food restaurant in the area. It is worth the drive. I have made it twice in two weeks and am already thinking about a third trip. read more

Cascarino's - Panzerottio with cheese and pepperoni. No ricotta cheese!! - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

The Pizza Beast is back for another round, and Cascarino's continues to deliver. When a place earns repeat visits year after year, that's usually the best review there is. The pizza still has that solid NY-style crunch, good flavor, and plenty of topping options. Whether grabbing a quick slice or ordering from the full menu, the food is consistently well-prepared and hits the mark. What really stands out is the consistency. The owner clearly takes pride in the operation, the kitchen stays on point, and the staff keeps things moving. It's not easy to maintain quality over time, but Cascarino's has managed to do exactly that. Pizza Beast Verdict: Still one of the most reliable pizza spots in the area. Great slices, solid menu, and a place I keep coming back to for a reason. Rating: 5/5 Beast Slices read more

Cascarino's - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

See all

We've recently just moved to the area and have been looking for a go to spot for deliciousness. We made the mistake of popping in last Friday (1st day of Lent) and ordered a few slices to go- that didn't go as planned... But, we've heard such great things about this place, so, we figured we'd give it another shot. Ordered a late lunch this afternoon- Clams were outstanding! Meatballs- yum! The garlic knots, though? They were spot on delicious and we literally inhaled them. Also had a couple of BYO chicken cutlet hero's- Excellent help over the phone and the delivery person was extremely pleasant and super polite. Can't wait to fall in love with this place! read more

We ordered 6 pizzas and some garlic knots for a party. We even ordered it the day of and the place was able to accommodate the large order so quickly. Everything came out so good. Tastes perfect! NY pizza tastes so much better than anywhere else. This is a great spot! read more

Everything is delicious and the service is so friendly. I love that they sponsor local little league, etc. Great all around

After a morning of crow hunting (we got skunked), my best friend, The Missing Ink AKA the Old Crow, and I stopped at Coscarino's. Voted the best pizza in the area in 2021, 2022, and 2024 (WHAT HAPPENED IN 2023?)? What a great find! Located in a strip mall w plenty of parking. Not an abundance of seating inside, but just enough that we found a table. Order and pay up front, and someone will bring your food when ready. There were about twelve "designer" pizza varieties on display. I opted for two slices, one with spinach and ricotta (pronounced rigaught), the other w meatball and several cheeses. TMI ordered an eggplant calzone type of sandwich. My pizza was delish....one slice would have been enough. TMI's sandwich came w a side of marinara sauce, and was piping hot. We also witnessed an Italian combo sandwich ordered by the next table over. It was UGE! TMI also ordered an eggplant sandwich to-go, for his wife, the Breathtaking Maria. Not too often do you find a good pizza parlor in a town like Montgomery that also sells slices, and a large selection of the same. And with quality! Overall, as good as it gets in this area. I'd be surprised if Coscarino's didn't win for 2025 (and beyond). This pizza snob rates them 5 stars! Last, I'd be remiss if I didn't mention the bathroom. The Missing Ink never fails to visit at least once in every establishment we stop in. He said clean, and TP was 2-ply. read more

See all

Cascarino's recently catered an event for us and the food was amazing! My guests were really pleased. The whole experience was perfect. Eric helped us choose our menu and it was all set up beautifully. Definitely the best. Highly recommend! read more

In the words of my fiancé, "best pizza I've had in 5 years," and this is a lot coming from him as I've learned he's one of the biggest pizza snobs I've ever met. We completely stumbled upon this place by chance in search of pizza while traveling on the road. First, it's pretty much right off the interstate so it was super quick and easy to get to for those also looking for quick food stops that aren't fast food. Side note, we called 20 min ahead and got gas right off the exit beforehand and we arrived in perfect time as our pizza had just come out of the oven (so anticipate about a 25 min ready time). Second, and I can't emphasize this enough, the gentleman we spoke to behind the counter was the friendliest, most welcoming person. We presume him to be the owner? Maybe? But I was truly enamored by the pride he took in the pizza and after asking if we'd like to see it (which how can you say no to that?) he revealed it in an almost ceremonious fashion, and boy it did not disappoint. It was a work of art (my photo does not do it justice, as in this case the phone did not eat first). Even though our plan was to eat on the road, we decided to have a slice (which turned into two, then three) in the charming, very clean, pizza parlor. And finally, the pizza? Chef's kiss out of this world. THIS is what we call amoré. One bite, everyone knows the rules, this was a very solid 9.3. My biggest complaint with pizza is that they're typically too oily and give me the worst heart burn but this wasn't even close to oily, and thirty minutes later, this is settling very well--no heart burn, upset stomach, or feeling gross. The owner said it's all fresh ingredients and my body is feeling the difference. Could not recommend this place enough and we will most certainly add this as a regular stop when passing through! read more

Cascarino's - Half buffalo chicken, half margherita with prosciutto added - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

I once found a hair in my pizza. When I complained the guy tells me no one here has black hair!!! I said did I say black hair? Btw it was a black hair and the cooks in the back all had black hair. Most horrible food in the area. I've never returned nor any family members or friends read more

Really clean and organized display cases here, made it so easy to decide on what I wanted to order, I swear you eat with eyes first and I was hungry. Hah. So service here was pretty chill and friendly, plus very thorough my order was exact. Buffalo chicken and grandma slice pizza were delicious, buffalo was spicy and not overly tangy and for the grandma slice, the crust so good, not burnt or rough and just right if amount of sauce and cheese with little basil. Mussels marinara was best of what ordered, definitely felt like more than a pound of fresh mussels bathed in that rich savory tomato sauce, not overcooked and enjoyed the bits of roasted garlic in the sauce. Italian combo sandwich was great, overfilled with meats and will dressed with oil and vinegar. Wish the fresh mozzarella was slices rather than crumble. Otherwise all food here was top class read more

See all

Good food, very clean, and friendly staff. The sub sandwiches are ginormous!! Their pizza is really good too. Last time I was there I had chicken Marsala and that was good too. read more

Nice comforting environment with amazing pizza! Owner greeted us and made conversation and was really cool. Food came out as soon as I sat down and I had to get another slice. I'm a big pizza lover and this place really is high on my ranks read more

Cascarino's - Chicken parm pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

Excellent service, pizza was very good, would recommend anyone in the area to stop by and give it a try! We came from Vegas and enjoyed their pizza! read more

True authentic New York pizza, coming down from far away in Las Vegas NV and this has to be the best pizza I've had in all of New York. Including our New York City trip, this tops it all. Great service and vibe to the place, everyone very friendly. Highly read more

Cascarino's - Chicken Parm Slice - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

Excellent pizza, the mozz sticks & knots were so good too. We got a pesto and plain pie also, were excellent. read more

Cascarino's - Excellent tasting sauce and cheese with super loaded pepperoni! - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

This is a very nice lunch spot and affordable as well. We ordered at the counter, but still received high quality service. The inside tables were nice and we enjoyed ourselves. Overall a great food experience well worth the price.! read more

Very friendly and helpful service. We ordered the rice balls. Fantastic, Stromboli with everything. And then we went back the next day and got Stromboli with chicken and ranch. All of it was super good. I only wish they had beer in tap. read more

See all

The food and service was fabulous! Can't wait to go back ! I was so pleasantly surprised to find this restaurant!

Went here, hungry, wanting pizza. I was unfortunately disappointed to be met by thin, hard pizza. I would not recommend trying this food regardless of the establishments record and or notoriety. If you value the quality of your food more than requiring it to be edible, spare yourself now. In light of the food however, my rating rests at 2 stars for the amazing service. Every employ I heard and or interacted with was beyond kind and welcoming. Unfortunately, the quality of food was so sub-par that I cannot bring myself to muster more than two stars, regardless of the amazing service. read more

Just ordered the family size calzone with bacon chicken cutlet and pepperoni. It was huge and delicious! The crust was soooo good! We will have leftovers for days! read more

Cascarino's - Family size calzone - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

Amazing pizza and service. Nice atmosphere too very clean. And food came in a timely manner !

We moved up here a year ago and they family is hooked pizza has a great taste crust is great feels like I'm in the city having a slice

Food is delishhhh! The garlic knots pizza and mozz sticks do NOT disappoint!!!! Service top notch! Love it and will return again and again!

Catering service is amazing! they have great portions and the food is delicious. tenants loved food from Cascarino's we will definitely be back for more. read more

Cascarino's - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

Amazing food & service! Owner is very accommodating!!! We are from WI and this is the best pizza we've had. Our party also got gluten free and they said it was by far the best gluten free crust they've ever had. read more

Cascarino's - Large bacon chicken ranch..... amazing crust! - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

I came here for lunch and I enjoyed it very much. My sister lives in Walden and this is my go to pizza place. They said they deliver and I look forward to ordering from them. I ordered two slices the white pizza and the Buffalo chicken and both were done very well. They were warm, flavorful and the right amount of dough. I look forward to trying their lunch items. I enjoyed my experience because the employees were very nice. They asked which slice I wanted. read more

Cascarino's - White pizza - Pizza Near Me - Montgomery, New York

See all

This place went from my favorite to mediocrity in the past 6 months. I recently ordered a Margarita pie that was inedible and floating in oil . The staff has changed, and I get the impression that they are not experienced. It's too bad. read more

Their pizza is fabulous! My wife and I got personal specialty pies; pickle and bbq - both did not disappoint! Besides being beyond flavorful they were also abundant with toppings. Way to represent phenomenal service and pizza! read more

The owner called me the next day to apologize. He was sorry due to new employees not knowing all the ropes. He offered a store credit. I was pleased that he called and happy to receive the store credit. It's a good thing when an establishment admits their mistake and offers some kind of compensation read more

This was always my go to pizzeria. However over the last year the quality has done down the tubes. It was always hood thin crust pizza with a fair amount of cheese, now the pies come loaded with dough bubbles and far less cheese. The dough is no longer thin and floppy, it's thicker and hard, not typical of real NY Pizza. This has been the downward spiral over the last year. Most recently, I noticed a significant size difference in what is a large pie Bs what a large pie was a few weeks ago. While I was picking up my pie. I heard the cashier on the phone with a customer who was upset with the size of their pie. The large pie you pay for is a small or medium pie, hard to tell since they stopped selling medium pies a while ago. To be honest, they are no longer quality pizza. You get more for your money at Guidos in Walden. I also tried the mozzarella sticks. They were god awful. They tasted like something you would get in a box out of the frozen section at Shoprite. Copperfields is the only place that still makes good Mozzarella sticks. What happened to Cascarinos? They were my favorite pizzeria, but in just a year they have gone completely into the toilet. read more

Came to Cascarino's on the first night of our vacation. For a Saturday night, the place was pretty busy. I was expecting more of a restaurant vibe, but I don't think they have it nailed down yet. They had a full menu, with gluten free items, but the methodology was a little haphazard. The staff was very friendly and the food was tasty. Would definitely recommend. read more

Even though it was Mother's Day, our takeout order was ready within 30 minutes. I had Chicken Francese with linquini and it was delicious. The portion size was more than I could finish at one sitting, so I'll have it for dinner tonight. It was the same with my husband's Sausage Parm hero. He had half that day and half yesterday. Thanks Cascarino's for a great meal. read more

Frequent Cascarino's pizza, it's my go to place for pizza, wings and sandwiches. Pizza is NY style with some of the best crust I have had on a pizza. I normally pickup which is fast. When I do sit down to eat the service is friendly and the food is hot (most of the time). If they are busy sometimes the pizza with a lot of toppings can come out too fast. If you don't like the temperature ask them to throw it in again Seating is limited so again if their busy you may not get a seat. They used to have limited outdoor seating which I wish they would bring back and expand as on nice days it's nicer than sitting inside The only negative is that do they charge a small service charge for using an credit card so if you want to avoid this pay cash If you're in Montgomery NY try them out read more

Great customer Service, pizza was amazing!!! You can tell they use good ingredients and are very clean. Definetly will be back

I often would get a take out meal..and were excellent..but this last year it has gone down and down..rude help taking orders ..prices charged are many times a few dollars over the menu..my last time there was for an Italian Hero Special..had ONE SLICE SWISS and ONE SLICE HAM..so I said NO MORE and that was last time.. on weekends even worse as Mgr is not there and a rude group take orders.. read more

Delicious pizza coming in almost every style possible. I'm from Massachusetts and was in a weird area of New York for my first time called ellenville. This place was about 20 minutes away from there me and my boys popped out grabbed a couple pies and they were absolutely delicious and the service was great too no complaint. I ain't from New York so the shit slapped compared to the pizza I'm used to it was my first New York pie I've really tried, and being 2 hours away from the city and most known spots I was very impressed how good the pizza was. Great place. Almost makes me wanna drive 3 and a half hours from mass again read more

They used to be so good when I first moved in this area now maybe the owner let somebody else cook the food it is not the same anymore

It is one of the best pizza spots in the hudson valley. I get pizza from here at least once a week. Their marinara sauce is outstanding, their grandma pie is outstanding. My kids love their bacon chicken ranch. read more

Amazing food and great customer service Absolutely recommend this place to anyone. The ambiance was perfect read more

food was good. Delivery was good. Everything was fine and way better than Carmella. I don't wanna add anything else. It was just good.