My favorite meatball parm is now crap. What is with the salt??? I could not finish my sandwich. It was so very salty. The person who took my order on the phone didn't speak enough English to understand what I wanted. They had to put someone else on the phone. In 3 months the place has gone straight to hell. I won't be back read more

All I really wanted was a good piece of pizza so I jumped on Yelp to find what was recommended nearby. I was not disappointed with the grandma slice and regular pizza at all! The grandma was definitely my favorite, so I had to go back and get a second. What really put it over the top for me was the little bit of pesto diagonally drizzled on each slice. Yes. I had three slices and I'm not ashamed to admit it. Staff is great...and its laid-back pizza joint at the end of a mostly empty shopping center. I did notice plenty of takeout orders so the locals must know it's good, too. read more

Colandrea's Pizza King - Plain slice and grandma slice - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

See all

Good food . Sauce is very good . The portions on dinners are on point. spegjetti is my favorite

So for the pizza one star 4 stars for the very nice girl behind the counter but this review is for the pizza . This is nothing like NYC pizza poor quality and I really don't believe they are using grande . Don't know why they can't make good pizza here it's only like an hour from NYC . Watch the parking lot there was a couple drinking and doing herion and some shady people hanging around outside in the parking lot . Bad experience overall , avoid . read more

Best grilled chicken salads around the area!! Highly recommend for sure. Pizza is good as well. - Anton Ego Approves read more

This pizza is truly the best pizza Used to bring the kids here years Ago when my boys were little We had take out last night It was still good !! read more

Delicious food. Best pizza we have had in a very long time We live in SC so we were looking for some great pizza so glad we found it . read more

Picked up 2 chicken parmesan heros for lunch with a client. Counter service was pleasant and sandwiches fresh, tasty, and reasonably priced. Pizza looked good and there is an extensive menu. I look forward to going back! read more

Colandrea's Pizza King - Chicken parmesan hero - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

See all

Their pizzas are fresh cooked to order They are delicious and will add whatever you like to the pie read more

New York City style pizza outside of the city! I love how the bottom is crisp and thin and how they have enough sauce under all that cheese. They usually have just plain cheese pizza when you walk in, so you will need to call in and pick up if you want any other flavors. Definitely worth it! ***no delivery*** read more

Colandrea's Pizza King - a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

Went to Colandreas tonight. Ordered 2 chicken parm meals. The sauce isn't what I remember it almost tasted like jar sauce. Lots of pasta not very much chicken. The garlic bread wasn't good either. Going to try the salad hope they didn't mess that up. Very disappointed. read more

We have been ordering pizza from Colandrea's for several decades and I have to say the last two pizzas we have ordered were the best ever. Usually the pizza needs more sauce but this time there was just the right amount. Whoever is making the pizza deserves a raise!! read more

Come here for lunch and dinner all the time, Customer service is fantastic, wraps and subs are great, salads are great, environment is always nice. Everyone is friendly, pizzas are top tier, best in town. Yktv read more

Amazing food chicken parm pizza was delicious no greasy taste so good. Only pizza place I know in Middletown New York non greasy pizza. If they can put Bread from onion rings and put on cheese sticks omg this place will be so busy. read more

Stopped in for lunch. The food was great, baked ziti and the veggie pizza were both delicious. The music was not to our liking. The constant thumping was maddening and will probably keep us from visiting again any time soon. read more

We miss the flavor from the previous owners. I can say that they have improved since the last time I went there. The pizza I ordered was tasty and well cooked. The only thing it was too much cheese. The establishment could use a mild makeover. It's a very busy pizza shop and I hope they improve and flourish over time. read more

I ordered a Cheesesteak on garlic bread and fries and that was probably the worst meal I've had in a while. The fries tasted burnt and the 'garlic bread' was just a regular roll with WAY too many chunks of garlic that I had to scoop off to be able to eat it. It was also under seasoned; I don't plan on going back. It's disappointing because I actually really liked my food on my first visit which is why I returned, but today was not good at all. read more

Great stop for quick pizza while in the area. I incorrectly ordered Sicilian not knowing what it was (very thick crust) so my kids were thrilled when we came back a second time for the regular crust pizza. We enjoyed the meat lovers, pepperoni and the white pizza. Affordable and delicious. read more

Compared to the other Pizza spots in the nearby area, mostly everything in here is about $1-2 more. Compared to other spots in the nearby area, the pizza here is very good. It definately bests the rest. However, I didn't care for their chicken fingers. read more

See all

Great New York style pizza! 2 large ( really yuge!) supreme pizzas and a medium cheese pizza... our family of 7 are easily filled up! Tastes very good. Girl who works at pizzeria, keep up learning sign language! Thanks for wonderful service! read more

Is no longer calandreas pizza. Original owners have sold. Nothing is the same

First of all, they changed the cheese. They are buying cheaper mozzarella. The pizza was the only reason I went there. However, ..... I went there last week with a friend who had a good meal there. He ordered a chicken and pasta dinner and loved it. I got a sausage and pepper sub/hero.. Undercooked peppers, stale sausage, disguised with a mountain of tomato sauce. It's what a like to call, "Trough food," you know, something you would feed animals. Went back for a slice, tonight. Typical mediocre pizza, you can get anywhere. Mostly tasteless. How do you make pizza tasteless? The original owner, sold (he's probably 80 or older). He was born in Italy. New owners? Nope. Hopefully, the new owners will drive it into the ground. read more

Had the large plain pizza pie and it was delicious. Comparable to pizza in Manhattan which I eat a few times a week. Excellent sauce to cheese to crust to oil ratio. Crust was crisp yet chewy at the same time. Would've like a bit more char on the crust though. Friendly staff, fast service, large space and ample parking. Forgot to take a food photo since I was too busy devouring the pizza! read more

Colandrea's Pizza King - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

Cheese steak on garlic bread !!!! Hands down the best philly I have ever had !!! I'm from the Bronx and. Just moved to Middletown and I've been looking for a good pizza place that has everything good as well and this place is it !!!! Their pizza and other dishes as well are excellent !!!!! read more

Colandrea's Pizza King - a sub sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

Pizza is usually good not like original colandreas but decent except tonight pizza looked like a reheat burnt crust,burnt cheese and beyond greasy I sent private message I wasn't going to leave a negative review until I was offered a 15% discount off my next pie..thats a whole $2 25 after I paid full price for an unedible pie...I would have returned it but we live about 20 minutes away and didn't have time. I wish I could post the pictures. Good news is there are many pizza places in town. read more

Gave them a second chance after my last review. Decided to get another pizza and try them again. Nope, still not impressed. There's a pizzeria on every corner here and most suck. I do know that they aren't using real cheese because it wasn't melting or stringy and tastes horrible! Done with this place. read more

As someone who is born and raised in NYC, this is some of the best pizza I've ever had. Get it every time I'm in the area.

This is my go to pizza restaurant in Middletown. Every Pizza, Every Slice is delicious! I order through the Slice App. Every pizzas has been PERFECTION! Yeah, I've tried other restaurants and their toppings were stingy. Colandrea rocks!!!! read more

Ordered Tuesday special through Slice App. Received notification order was on it's way at 5:49 pm. Latest delivery showed 6:25 pm. Order arrived at 6:50 pm. Everything was cold and tasteless. Called restaurant at 6:40 pm and assured order was on its way and would still be hot...not true. read more

Amazing pizza! I was born and raised in New York but moved to the Pacific Northwest. Every time we're back in town we head here! Sometimes two or three times!! read more

Husband and son extremely happy with chicken parm and Philly steak subs. Great stop off route 17. Called ahead & food was ready.

Order a pizza, went to pick it up,they look baffled when I told them. They said they put the wrong toppings on it comeback in 10 minutes came back they say didn't know you still wanted it.. They so much went downhill on the last year also order a sandwich last week on door dash which was wrong.. I've tried but I'm done.. read more

Best pizza! Also calzones are pretty banging too. This place is kind of sit far back off of Route 211... But worth taking a swing by just to have their delicious pizza read more

In a recent review, I wrote Colandrea Pizza King's food wasn't as tasty, since the sale of the business. The pie crust was too large. But, would try Colandrea's one more time. Glad I did... Although, the crush may have been thin and a little burnt, the slices were acceptable. Much better than my last review... The new owner, is a very kind young man. Give him time and it will be 'His' Colandrea yumminess... They have maintained the name. But updated and changed the decor. It looks very nice... Go in and have a slice or a pepperoni pinwheel, or ... You won't be disappointed. read more

A recent transplant from Brooklyn, I have been at a loss without good pizza. Finally, I took a chance here and am beyond ecstatic. Great crunchy thin crust. Perfect amount of cheese and sauce is not acidic. Looking forward to trying everything else on the menu. read more

I ordered a medium sausage pizza and I was hoping for a nice crispy crust warm sauce and fully cooked sausage. When I got the pizza at first it looked edible, but I took a bite. The sausage was not fully cooked, it was drippy in so much oil it splashed me in my eye. I had to pat the pizza with napkins so much I thought I was drinking oil. The crust was the best thing and it was still very disappointing. The only reason I ate some was because I was starving, never in a million years would I get this again. read more

Colandrea's Pizza King - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

If I could leave zero stars I would. I came to visit my parents from Boston, thinking I'd get the family a delicious pizza from the place we'd been going to for forty years...THIS PLACE NO LONGER EXISITS. The pizza is horrible and soggy, the underage girl they have working the register can't take an order consisting of two toppings, the owner is a macho moron who thinks verbally assaulting his customers is the way to go. Besides putting an extra topping I didn't even ask for, theyforgot to put mushrooms on half, so in order to remedy it, the guy tries dumping canned mushrooms on top then handing it to me, without cooking it. The only person who actually values any kind of quality the place used to have to offer was the guy who actually made the pizzas, but again, in order to make the pizza the customer wants, the person taking the order needs to be able to read, write, and understand words, which 3 out of 4 of them dont. So, we went to Franco Di Roma....FANTASTIC substitute for the FORMERLY ONCE GREAT BUT NO LONGER Colandrea's...a sad day for Middletown, NY read more

Best pizza in Middletown! They sell pizza by the slice or a whole pie, no delivery. Everyone says their cheese slice is the best, but I like their margarita pizza. It has lots of sauce, fresh mozzarella & basil. DELICIOUS! Sorry I don't have a pic of the margarita pizza. read more

Colandrea's Pizza King - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, New York

At one time my greatest placed to order an excellent specialty pizzas, great price and Best Lunch deal. Great service, warm and friendly environment. Wonderful local Hot Family Place to truly hang out with those you love. But don't forget the appetizers. Sadly they are closed and I haven't checked the food. Best Regards and Wishes. read more

Been eating pizza there since 1984.. The pizza, calzones, subs and cannolis are outstanding. My favorite is a veal n peppers sub, Yummy A+