Tom's Market has the best macaroni salad, potato salad, and sandwiches in this area. We travel from Montgomery because it is just that good. The service is excellent. I place orders by phone and they are always ready on time and exactly as ordered. The catering experience is the same. We have been to several events they catered and the food and service is always very good. read more

A small deli on cozy corner of the street. All basics at fair prices. Got an Italian combo and a pasta salad, the sandwich was good and plenty of meat, unlike the salad sandwiches elsewhere . The guy behind made it perfectly and just right, since I had stuff removed and added. As for the pasta salad it was good, nothing moving the needle forward in taste. Still a great to go lunch on the move. read more

See all

Sandwiches are always great! and the Prices is real good. Tom works everyday running the place alone, He's a good guy.

Tom's Market is as genuine a small town family-owned business as they come. It's a local area convenience store that has everything that you'd need, and it offers old school deli sandwiches and salads that would make anyone come back for more. Did I mention how fair and affordable their pricing is? With all those reasons to make the visit, the real bonus is that you also get to meet and chat with Tom himself. He's the one that makes your sandwiches too! He is a wealth of information and is eager to share the store history with you. Over 40 years in business and I wish you many many more, Tom! read more

After reading the reviews, we decided to get subs for dinner as the weather is so humid.. The gentleman behind the counter (Tom?) was so friendly and pleasant. We looked around and saw the salads, potato, macaroni, pasta, beans looked extremely fresh. We also got 1/2 pound of potato salad. My turkey sub was absolutely delicious! The bread is so fresh and the amount of meat is very generous! Hubby got an Italian mixed and he said his was just as good. The potato salad was as close to my homemade as I've ever had purchased from a deli. There's also a great selection of deli meat you can purchase. It's a great little store/deli and we will definitely be making this place our go to for subs!! read more

Great pastrami sandwich on rye made to order and a bag of chips for a little over $10, great deal!

I had an American combo and it was packed with meat but at $13 I would expect that. Very small and old place but food is fresh and good

Boars Head deli meats. Homemade potato and mac salad. And Beans! Homemade baked beans! And if you're lucky, Tom himself will be there to serve you up a delicious sub and a smile read more

The BEST sandwiches in Middletown! Reminds me of the ones I used to get back in the city. Lots of thinly shaved meat piled high with just the right amount of shredded lettuce, and thinly sliced onions! The bread is always fresh, and the sandwiches never disappoint. They also take cards now, so no need to get cash first. Super friendly as well. read more

Even though I haven't been here in a long time and I'm not a huge sandwich person, I do love Tom's Market! Their sandwiches are awesome with so much meat on them! None of their food tastes like the store-bought processed stuff. It's in a great location right across the street from a family park with a pool. I used to go here a lot during summer break from school. My little cousins and I would swim for a few hours then go get a sandwich from Tom's every time.. They truly are delicious! Though I haven't been there in a while, I am going to go there one of these days to get a sandwich. You should check them out! I don't think you will be disappointed. read more

Another great little corner store! They have been around for years and are well known for their macaroni salad. They have one of the best macaroni salads I have ever had!! If you love macaroni salad try theirs. It's homemade, and made fresh daily. read more

A semi-quick and friendly deli that stacks your subs very nicely indeed. If you're needing a sandwich that won't be flat as a board, head here for lunch! I haven't tried much else here, so go read the other reviews. I don't think you'll be disappointed. read more

Tom's Market - Front of store. - Grocery Near Me - Middletown, New York

My coworker recommended I try this deli and I'm so glad I did! Small little spot but the sandwiches are amazing! Best part: Boar's Head cold cuts! If you're looking for a great sandwich minus the frills, this is it! And they sure aren't cheap with their servings! But they do NOT take credit cards. ATM right next to the register but bring cash! read more

Tom's Market - Amazing! - Grocery Near Me - Middletown, New York

I've been ordering subs from Tom's Market for many years. I've always been extremely happy with my order. However, last week I ordered 3 subs and when we arrived home to eat them, 2 of them were not made as ordered. My sub did not have mayo or onions as requested and hardly any oil and vinegar. My grandsons sub had tomatoes when I clearly stated no tomatoes. Our order was taken from a middle aged employee. She was friendly and courteous but didn't fill the order as she had written on the ticket. She wrote down the order as I placed it but must have rushed the order because she didn't fill the order as she written it as I ordered it. Well, it is as it is but I won't place an order over the phone again. I'll walk in and place my order face to face and only if Tom or his family members are there to fill my order. Just saying.... read more

A++++ Italian hero is huge and packed with meat. The homemade macaroni and potato salad is delicious. I have searched all over the area since moving here and they are the best out of ever deli I have ever tried. Super fast service and polite staff. read more

Potato Salad, Mac Salad, and Baked Beans are store made and delicious. The main thing to get here is the store baked roast beef on a hard roll. If you get there at lunchtime when it's still warm, it's like heaven on bread. This place has a real community feel. There's always a bunch of guys hanging around shooting the breeze with the owner. Never really tried anything but the deli, Tom's is also a convenience store. read more

Tom's market go the biggest sub out there . Boars head meat . If you haven't had one go get one

This family deli has the best subs ever. Totally worth the cost. Their chicken salad is great too. My favorite sub is their Italian sub! It's totally tasty! You can call in your order and by the time you get there, it's already done and waiting for you. Tom's Market is Middletown's best kept secret! You have to drop in or call in your order. You won't be disappointed. Their beverages are inexpensive as well. read more

All Home Made , Who Could Go Wrong Love That Place

Mention picking up a sandwich to anyone who knows Middletown and they will say it has to come from Tom's Market, and OMG the Potato Salad. Amazing! read more

I too was recommended by a coworker and kept driving pass Tom's Market, which went on for over a year-boy was I cheating myself!!! Being from Philadelphia I Know what a Proper Hoagie...oops excuse me (I live in Middletown now) Sub should taste like, and this is it, there is a good place in Port Jervis and too Chrissy's in Matamoras Pa. makes a great sandwich, but Tom's Market is the truth. Like another reviewer said, the Potato Salad is awesome as well and it will make you smack your mother... (once you taste what good potato salad should taste like! Enjoy! read more

Delicious sandwiches! They're piled high and are fresh! Hands down the best potato salad i've ever had!!!

The homely atmosphere was awesome. Upon walking into Toms Market, my nose was assaulted with the aroma of onions and other sandwich making condiments. Long time residents of Middletown have always encouraged me to go there. After 10 years, I finally did and boy have I been missing out. The stacked Turkey and Cheese sandwich was tasty and took two sittings to complete. Not to mention how delicious it was. I will definitely be eating there again. read more

Someone recommended that we try Toms for lunch and I am so glad I did. Best Hot Roast Beef Sandwich EVER!! Super friendly staff and great sandwiches!! read more

I've been going here for about 10 years and it has ALWAYS been my favorite sandwich spot. The sandwiches are always good, they don't skimp on ingredients, and the staff is always so friendly! After I gave birth to my son, a turkey sub was literally the first thing I had my husband bring me lol! I highly recommend toms! read more

Incredible family run business. Our large condominium community hired Tom's Market to cater our Labor Day party and we could not have been happier. They are a lean mean operating machine (husband and wife duo). This is my rating: Food - Great Service - Outstanding Customer Service - The best Hot fudge ice cream sundaes - scrumptious Potato salad - to die for Pricing - fits any budget Tom's Deli is perfect for any occasion, whether it be a small family reunion or a 500 person professional function. You won't be disappointed. read more

Best place to get a good deli sandwich in Middletown. They really stack their sandwiches here. Quick service.

Went here today and could not believe how expensive it has gotten at Tom's. We ordered one sub, one hard roll sandwich 2 egg salad on white and a tuna on white. We got a potato salad and a macaroni salad and drinks and it was 52 dollars. The food was good but i think the price was kinda high for sandwiches for lunch. Especially since 2 were only egg salad on white. For that price we could have gone to a nice sit down lunch not sandwiches for the park. read more