Highly recommend this place. So many choices of Mac/cheese varieties. We had 3 mini orders of the Pickle, Chicken Parm & Chicken Marsala. OMG. It was so fresh and delish!!! 5star. The place was service up items in a timely matter. We waited maybe 5 min to order which the guy informed us of. Perfectly fine we were in no rush. And waited maybe 10-15 for our food. It was really fantastic. We're only in town for the Airshow this weekend but my husband travels through sometimes for work. Maybe 2x a year and he will be bringing some home to us in PA. Excellent and well done food and service. read more

For a place which is solely dedicated to making Mac and cheese, I am highly disappointed due to how lack luster the food actually was. In addition I decided to last minute to add chicken to the dish and I'm glad that I did because the steak in the Mac and cheese were basically microscopic, it wasn't until I was reaching the end of the meal where I discovered the little slither of steak the meal had in it. The store itself constricts itself as well where in the digital menu it states the meal comes along with Gouda cheese in it, however in the store front Gouda cheese is no where to be found. I realized after I ordered the food and asked the cashier about it and they stated that it did not. There's so much more I could say but this review is long enough. read more

See all

This is the third time I order and its amazing! My husband loves the cordon blue mac and cheese and Im obsessed with the mac and cheese balls they are really good! It's something different from any other food place in town. read more

What a wonderful surprise. We travelled to visit family and we found this place. Delicious food and the staff/owners were very friendly and welcoming. They happily answered any questions concerning the menu read more

See all

The place is small but it is mighty in flavor. There are a few seats but not for an extra long party. They have a bunch of sizes for serving. They had kids sizes too. They had everything you could think of in terms of combinations. They can make any msc and cheese gluten-free. read more

Fantastic comfort food! The mac and cheese balls were unreal. We had the mushroom, American, and cheesesteak. And on top, great and unique beverages. read more

Another amazing find for 2024, my only regret is that I don't live closer! This casual and small restaurant offers over 40 different items, and it was so hard for me to choose what I wanted. Thankfully, the owner was helpful, giving us a rundown of the top items and making great suggestions. They even offer gluten-free mac, which gets an A+ in my book. I went with the pesto mac, and it was absolutely incredible--you can't beat the price for the portion size. I got three meals out of it! Our small group's order took about 10-15 minutes, but since we were the only customers at the time, it wasn't an issue. Everyone was happy with their food. If you're in the area or just passing by, Mix N Mac is an absolute must! read more

See all

The food was good. Who would have thought there were so many things to mix with Mac and cheese. I had the Buffalo chicken Mac and it was spot on. Service was great. Ordered my food to go, so I can't comment on the ambiance of the place itself. read more

Thick layer of melted American cheese on top made it kind of tough to eat, peeled that off and the Mac and cheese underneath was good, but not as much of a portion. s Chop salad was very good. read more

This place is in the back of a small shopping center that I never noticed even living in town for a while. I tried it out and fell in love instantly. If you love Mac and cheese, you will love this place since you have the ability to add your favorite foods to it..eve lobster! The staff is very friendly and the prices are very reasonable. I forgot to take a pic of my lobster Mac before I devoured it. I will send a pic the next time I am there for sure though. read more

This place is a great spin on a classic of Max and cheese. We absolutely love going here when we are craving your feel good food. They even have great salads if not everyone is up for Mac and cheese. I will say that most of our experiences here have been great but the past few times it feels like they have reduced their portion sizes. I normally love the grilled chicken balsamic salad. It comes with great protein and a perfect spin on your mozzarella grape tomatoes and balsamic dressing. But coming back to smaller portions the salads have been coming with less and less grilled chicken. I don't even think it had 1/16th of a chicken breast tonight. They normally come in a tiny bite sized pieces which I enjoy but I don't even think I had more than ten little bite sized pieces which pieces. And tonight I didn't even have my fresh mozzarella that comes with the salad. Unfortunately I wasn't the only one who's meal was a lot smaller than normal. I really hope that they go back to their original sized portions with all the toppings that are in the description. They're still worth giving a try if you're a Mac and cheese lover. read more

What a great spot!! We are traveling to Legoland and this was a great stop. Very kind owner. read more

Mix N Mac - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

OMG, we love this place! Small & cute restaurant doing mostly carryout food (either hot & ready or for heating at home later!). Dozens of specialty flavors of mac & cheese, some other cool apps, cool variety of bottled and canned drinks already chilled. Service fast & with a smile. A real hole in the wall, we would never have noticed this restaurant (as visitors from out of town) if it weren't for Yelp. So glad we searched around for good local food--this place is a casual food gem. We ordered one chicken marsala and one spinach & artichoke and pulled several teas from the fridge to take back to our hotel. We happily accepted the crunchy breadcrumb topping as the order was completed. Each mac & cheese was neatly packaged in a foil container in case it needed reheating later. No reheating was necessary--our mac & cheese was still perfectly hot & gooey! We loved both. I don't know when we'll return to the area, but I'm already looking forward to getting something new at Mix N Mac! read more

Mix N Mac - Specialty mac & cheeses! - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

See all

I love it, tried it for the first time the other day, staff is amazing as well, would definitely recommend

This mac & cheese was so damn good! I got the Philly cheesesteak, mac & cheese, and boy was it delicious and filling! This is more of a takeout spot than a sit down spot. I came to pick up my food, but I believe they're on one of the food delivery apps. The food comes in an aluminum foil personal pan size tray. It was plenty big enough for me to make two meals out of it. If you are picking up, there's a 5% discount if you pay with cash. Definitely highly suggested. The mac & cheese plates Are all around $12. This place is definitely the best mac & cheese in the area. They do a good job doing well in their niche. read more

This place is AMAZING!!!! Gluten free options for my daughter were better than ANY other mac and cheese I've ever had!!! Great service, too!

Cheese balls is my favorite. Also pulled pork mac and cheese. Staff is so nice food is always fresh by order also the sauce that comes with the cheese balls is awesome. Just wish they had a bigger parking lot. read more

All I can say is yummy. Best macaroni and cheese ever. There is something for everyone. Vegan, gluten-free, vegetarian or extra cheesy. I drive 40 minutes to come here for a treat. Portions are good and the kids love it read more

I love getting mac and cheese here and heating it up in the oven when i get home from work. The bruschetta mac is my favorite with the balsamic drizzle but they also have a really good spicy steak one. The mac balls are also always great and definitely the best around. I also love how creative the owner is with creating new macs. Its definitely a to go place though as its very small. read more

I love the variety at Mix N Mac. My favorite is definitely the classic American Mac. This visit I had gotten the buffalo chicken Mac. It was delicious and I asked for extra cheese sauce. Gorgonzola cheese is not really my thing so next time so will ask for it without. I still ate it all even though I wasn't a fan of the cheese. Staff are always friendly and the food is cooked perfectly. I also got the Garlic "Nots" and they were so tasty. I always get extra Mac sauce on the side for dipping. read more

Mix N Mac - Garlic "Nots" - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

See all

Two of us walked in to dine in for lunch - about 1 pm- before we went shopping. You are able to take out too. There's only 4 or 5 tables. We were a second group to sit at the tables. Then two more groups came and filled the dining area. The place has a casual atmosphere. Even for a mac and cheese restaurant the decoration was fun. We pointed out several adornments on the walls and the wall paper. It was our first experience and was straightforward to understand. They had menus at the register. I ordered the Lobster mac and cheese and my guest ordered the Mushroom mac and cheese. The staff were patient and helpful. The kitchen area and work area are visible from the dining area. It was cool to watch them work and cook our food. Food came out in approximately 15 minutes. We picked up our food from the pick up window. The mac and cheese had a nice cheesy bready crust on top with a creamy cheesy center and base. The lobster and mushroom were perfectly distributed throughout the dish - every bite had lobster or mushroom in it. We thoroughly enjoyed the experience and would return our business. read more

I absolutely love this place! The things they come up with for their mac & cheese are insane. I tried the chicken & waffles mac and it was an incredible mix of sweet & savory. Their balls are also out of this world. Be sure to check out their specials posted up and if this is your first time (like it was mine), ask for help! Everyone is super nice and helpful. They were able to help me decide which one to start with for the first Mix & Mac experience. Seating is a little limited but if you have a small group & it isn't so busy, you'll be fine! Everything is served pretty quickly too so most people are in & out in a jiffy. I'll definitely be back to try some of their other kinds of mac! read more

Mix N Mac - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

To be honest it depends what type of food you like. I've always wanted to try mix and Mac and they make a variety of different mac and cheeses for you. Yet all of the flavors I had I just didn't like. Me and my boyfriend got literally 4 different flavors. I managed to eat one but felt blehhhh after because it just wasn't my cup of tea. The presentation and how they serve the Mac's in the little dishes are well plated and beautiful for pictures. As far as the taste just wasn't my favorite and that's just on me I'm not a huge Mac and cheese eater UNLESS it's southern baked Mac or black people Mac because I make a hella of baked Mac and cheese. I even think boxed Mac and cheese tasted better again just me. Anyone who i say this too loves the place and to me i just wasn't messing with it. The Mac and cheese bites weren't all that for me either needless to say i just don't like the places food lol. Not because its bad just not my taste in food lol. The service was fine you talk to a person in the front they ring you up and that's all. Im only giving it a 3 because again I personally just don't like the food. read more

OMG ! THIS PLACE IS SOO GOOOD! The entire store is basically MAC n CHEESE GALORE, they do offer salads, one dessert (smores churro's), and mac balls (which are basically fried mac n cheese, that they can smother with sauces) Food: VARIETY, VARIETY, VARIETY. I honestly wished I looked at the menu before hand, because when I went into the store I had no clue what I wanted! They have a set menu (mac n cheese combos that are always available) and a specials menu. For example some of the combos they are chicken parmesan, to shrimp alfredo, to chicken n waffles, to mango habanero. They make these all fresh when you make the order. I had ordered the mango habanero, and added pulled pork to it. THIS was DELICIOUS! Not as spicy as they claimed but still had a lil kick to it. My ONLY complaint would/will be is that I wish my mac n cheese was baked a little bit more, it tasted very cheese saucy and the sauce didn't seem baked into the pasta as much, but the cheese pull is picture worthy! Service: Was great, the guy at the cash register was super helpful and made good suggestions as to what I should get based off of what I like.. Overall, this place will definitely see my again. Cant wait to go back and try a different combination. read more

Mix N Mac - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

We live an hour away yet go out of our way to come here. That is how good it is. The Breakfast Mac is absolutely incredible. Let me tell you about the price and serving size. For about $10 I can easily get 3 meals out of it. The help is always very friendly. read more

So I didn't think that you could do so much with Mac & Cheese but this place has proven me wrong! I was talked into trying 3 different dishes (which I'm not mad about at all). The Lobster Mac & cheese was good but oh my God the clear winner today was the chicken & Waffle Mac & Cheese!! It's also made with bits of bacon & why does it taste like there is maple syrup in the cheese. I know that doesn't sound appetizing but I swear to you it was the best thing I've tasted in a long time! It even comes with a cute little waffle topper. I also tried the taco fried Mac & cheese balls which were also pretty good but again, the clear winner today that will probably bring me back is the chicken & waffles! The restaurant itself is a cute little place. The staff were super friendly the second I walked in and was very willing to talk to me about their specials, ingredients and such. My order was complete in under 13 minutes and they did make everything fresh. Overall I'm very pleased I finally decided to stop in & try them out. I also had no issues using my 10% off coupon I got from checking in on Yelp! read more

Mix N Mac - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

See all

Love this place! I was traveling through the area and was worried about finding a place to eat. I have gluten allergies and usually prefer bringing my own food since a lot of places have cross contamination or no seperate prep sites. I chose this location because of their gluten-free options. We got the scampi gf mac, the spinach artichoke gf mac, the coconut cheesecake, and the flourless chocolate cake. Everything was delicious and I did not get sick after eating. 11/10 would come back to next time I drive through! read more

See all

First of all this is the best Mac and cheese I've ever had. I got the Swiss burger Mac and added frizzled onions YUM. The ricotta Mac balls were to die for. Seriously I might commit a few crimes to get a location closer to my house. This place is worth the hour trip and more. Staff was very kind and service was fast and efficient. read more

The food is outstanding! I am the biggest mac n cheese fan ever..never have I been disappointed by any dish ordered. The greatest variety of America's stick to your ribs staple! read more

After waiting 25 mins for an order ( in person, that doesn't matter) just started to eat and my food is ice cold. The Mac & cheese ball is freezing in the middle and the ricotta cheese it's smothered in is cold! I just hope there isn't egg in the mix (like lasagna) Absolutely disgusting: doesn't matter how busy ur store is! U don't serve cold food!!! read more

Mix N Mac - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

Best Mac n cheese ever! There is so much variety in each plate from texture to flavor.

I have been here on multiple occasions now and every single time, they do not disappoint. Let me tell you why! The first time.. I was driving by and saw their sign and assumed it had to be Mac and cheese (which it is). I stopped in and got the Mexi Mac and Cheese. Absolutely outstanding. Not only was it creamy and cheesy.. it also contained pepperjack cheese and was topped with fresh taco ingredients like ground beef, chorizo and pico de Gallo. Filled with flavor and packed with ingredients! The price is perfectly right and you get an enormous portion for one person. The second time I decided to try their fried and smothered Mac and cheese balls. Again, I was dumbfounded by how good these things were! They were fried to perfection. A perfect amount of crunch with creamy and cheesy Mac in the middle. And all around them was the smothering part.. which included fresh ingredients that will make your mouth water. And don't even get me started on their layered cheesecake cups. Wow! Beyond creamy and tastes like heaven in your mouth. The cups may be a tad bit pricy for the size but they are beyond worth it. Overall, I highly recommend anyone who is a Mac and cheese lover to try Mix N Mac. They have a plethora of choices and flavors to choose from and none of them disappoint. Go now!! read more

Good food, friendly staff. Not a lot of seating inside, and can have a bit of a wait. Overall, very yummy!

Very good Mac and cheese. But I feel like I return here because of the ridiculous amount of choices that are well thought out and all taste good. Anything from Italian to chicken bacon ranch to Mexican Mac N Cheese. Try the Mac and cheese balls either dry or smothered they're both delicious. Gluten free and vegetarian available Definitely recommended. They have a rewards program also. read more

Mix N Mac - September 2018 specials - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

Such a unique spot! I didn't realize at first that the menu was only Mac and cheese lol... All the items like Swiss burger, nachos incorporate Mac and cheese but we were glad we tried it! The have the Mac balls which are a good deal. I recommend giving those a try. We got the shrimp scampi and loved it! Def a heavy meal but loved the vibe and this would be a cool place to bring visitors ! read more

See all

We ordered the buffalo saucy cheese balls, the lobster mac and the spinach artichoke mac , and they all had great flavors, but the quality and consistency of the mac n cheese wasn't great. We enjoyed the saucy cheese balls a lot but the actual mac n cheese dishes were too dry for me. The mac had a lot of melted shredded cheese on top, but there wasn't enough sauce in the macaroni so it was like eating globs of dry cheese, which gets old after a few bites. I love the concept of mixing in flavors and ingredients, but I think this place needs to work on their cheese sauce recipe and the consistency of the mac n cheese instead of piling on shredded cheese to make the macaroni sauce. read more

Mix N Mac - Buffalo Saucy Balls - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

See all

If you love Mac and cheese you will want to make a stop! This place does a pretty incredible job of covering every flavor profile you could want and making it work with Mac and cheese. Staff were cheery, friendly and energetic. Each gave me great tips on how to narrow down a lengthy menu. I ended up with the balls (delish and shouldn't be missed), chicken and waffle (Gouda and bread crumbs make the dish, slightly sweet with your average lego my eggo waffle) and the pumpkin pie rice pudding (weird but yummy!) Make a stop. Your tummy will be happy and you'll have a great time to boot! read more

See all

Mac & Cheese, ah how much can you really do with that? Well this place has mastered a fast food option for really good mac & cheese! The place is really small with limited seating. They have the mac & cheese toppings setup like subways where you can see them preparing the dishes. Since they are not a formal restaurant but more like a fast food style spot, your food is neatly served in a small metal tin that makes for easy take home. However, it all tastes super fresh! I had the classic American style for my first visit but was tempted to try the "Mac balls" Yelp tips mentioned but I wanted to start simple & wasn't disappointed. Macaroni is fresh and toppings really good (home style). With dishes starting at about $5 this makes for a great fast food option with a great portion for the price. 4/5/12 Update -- Normally I do an updated review to my reviews but in my eagerness to return I was met with slightly less than delightful customer service so I'm going to take this rating down a notch! The Mac & Cheese sells itself but customer service is just as important. read more

Mix N Mac - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

See all

Definitely delish! Each of us tried different macs with mix ins and all were great! We also tried the american cheddar and the bacon cheddar mac balls...do not miss ordering them! The macs are a great bargain and I could only eat half of mine but my teen boys polished off their macs. Did not have any wait and it took only a few minutes for them to make. If I lived closer I would order one to serve as a side dish for dinner frequently. Lots to try for mix ins too! read more

Mix N Mac - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

ok, well ill give it to you yelpers, there arent many types of places like this one around, but then again, i dont buy tiger insurance either. meaning, yes there are tigers in the world, im just not in a place where i would need it. I am not in need of a place that i can get overloaded on cheese. if i were, this place would be great! I liked the vibe/uniquiness of the place and people i work with raved about this place, so two arteries with one block of cheddar. Service was very cordial, the girl making my mac and pulled pork if i wanted seasoned crumbs, i mean who wouldnt? commies, thats who! I found the pork to be a bit grizzly and truthfully, how can you eat what must be a half pound of cheese on the regular sized serving? not a great idea, too rich for me brah, but you might be in the market for something like this. maybe if you were splitting this it would be better suited for prime time. i mean, you know how us connecticut people like mac & cheese. read more