Buffalo Mac and Cheese it's all spots from savory to spicy. This place has many different options where you can get special Mac and cheese blends from steak, to chicken and to multi cheese blends. The service is a bit slow especially when you get there during prime time for lunch and dinner crowds. The quality of the cheese and ingredients are awesome for the area. This Buffalo Mac and cheese was delicious where I kept wanting to eat more after every bite. The topping of the bread crumbs adds a great crunch. This spot is awesome when you need a delicious soul savory meal for a quick buck. I will be going here to try multiple items on the menu. read more

Mix N Mac - Buffalo Mac and cheese- a delicious yet spicy combo with a nice crunch with the bread crumbs - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

One of the best Mac and Cheese spots by me. Insane variety. Nice portion sizes, great service.

Call me an addict at this point can't get enough of their Mac cheddar balls. I'm not ashamed to admit it but I'm a repeat offender. I tend to go here every other day during my lunch break. I should invest in their stock shares at this point, ( are they in Wall Street ?) asking for a friend. All jokes aside I did not know I would like mac and cheese this much until I tried their chicken Alfredo/ shrimp Mac and cheese. Their golden crush and crumbs on top it's chef kissed! Thank you mix N Mac for making me a believer! read more

I Don't get the fuss I make better Mac and cheese however they have tons of variation.

I'm born and raised down south and am picky about my Macaroni and Cheese so I was a little skeptical about this place. We were all really pleased with our meal. The $9 serving size was generous and I had some to go home with, while I in-laws split one. We waited maybe 15 minutes for our food. Seating is limited but we got the last table that could 4. There is a huge selection and something for everyone. We ordered the buffalo chicken, chicken bacon ranch and original American Mac n cheese. I got pull pork added to my original Mac N Cheese and next time I would order the same but add bbq sauce. In-laws loved it and said they wanted to come back when in town next time. Still not like Mac n cheese from back home But it's a good contender Service was great! read more

Worse than Kraft. Not real cheese in the mix- maybe on top. It's pretty nasty stuff from the day they opened until now, many years later. No idea how they've lasted. Good for them, though. Just goes to show that quality and REAL Mac and Cheese are simply unknown. Gross stuff. Don't eat it. read more

Vegan Mac and cheese is really good. They're always consistent and the best for comfort food when I'm in the area

I really am going to add my praise in the long list of amazing reviews. But Mix N Mac is just as good as everyone says. My husband and I were up in the area doing some errands and were starving. Instead of going to one of the million fast food chains, we decided to pull up Yelp. I am SO glad we did. This place was the top choice and looked amazing. Granted, I think a lot of mac and cheese places are well rated because it's mac and cheese. Everyone loves mac and cheese and it's hard to get it truly wrong. But this place actually does mac and cheese well. There are so many varieties and options that you could eat here every day for a month and not get bored (but probably get a heart attack....) Anyway, the cheese is high quality, the toppings are delicious and unique, and the options are amazing. This place is worth a visit if you are anywhere in a 1 hour radius. You'll be happy you took the drive. read more

Very rude staff from the time you walk in. Go somewhere else. Try to support a local business and get an attitude.

I do love my mac and cheese and this place did not disappoint!!!!!!!!!! Comfort food the whole family loved!

Awesome food, great prices, and just good comfort. The staff was great. Always a pleasure doing business with them.

I love taking a personal mac n cheese to go when I come visit Middletown. If you're a mac n cheese enthusiast you have to stop by. With over limitless combinations to choose from, you can cater your own dish to your liking. Or you can go with the combination mac n cheeses on the menu like me. I go with the buffalo chicken! read more

I had the French dip, it was very tasty , I can't wait to go back to try out a bunch more, and it's real baked Mac and chz , super delicious, Definitely recommend read more

Had the Scampi, American and chicken parm Mac and cheeses today as well as the Kung pao balls. Everything tasted amazing! The staff are all super nice too. read more

Places like this are why I am so grateful that Yelp exists. I have been taking trips into Middletown for most of my life, but if my mother and I had not turned to Yelp for a lunch suggestion today, I never would have known this existed. Mix N Mac brings a unique taste to this area, with a menu showcasing no less than 15-20 different styles of Mac and cheese. I opted for the Shrimp Scampi which was out of this world. The prices were reasonable and the portions were quite large considering the price. A pretty cool touch was the containers the Mac were served in also serves as a to-go container for the anticipated left overs. I also appreciated the kind service. The woman who helped us was super friendly, and made a point to ask every customer if they were enjoying their experience and food. Great service, delicious food, and reasonable prices, I will definitely be back. Check it out, your future self will thank you. P.S. they have a check in offer for 10% off as of 2/13/17 read more

Mix N Mac - Shrimp Scampi Mac - 9$ - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

I love that a place like this exists. Was amazing food and to be able to have a place that is successful with just max and cheese but with unique twists is great to see. I have nothing like this where I lived and if I lived nearby to this place I'd most likely eat here far too often and get way to large. read more

Mix N Mac - Photo doesn't really do this justice. This was Philly cheesesteak Mac n cheese. I didn't expect that I'd enjoy it as much as I did. - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

Great fresh food awesome service staff is friendly huge portions great value for your $$$

So many option for Mac and cheese! The food was delicious. It's been a couple months so I don't remember the exact order, but we ordered two and they were both great. The portions are definitely enough for two (or leftovers). We stopped for dinner while moving. It was easy on and off the freeway and plenty of space to park our Uhaul. read more

Really decent mac, and a dizzying amount of preset options if you don't want to BYO, but not all of them are winners. I'd heard a lot about this place from friends who live in the area, found myself free for lunch one day, and decided to stop in. I got the BBQ Pork, which ended up being very sweet. I can't say it was wrong (it was BBQ sauce flavored), but it tasted more like a dessert course. That said, the mac and the cheese themselves were quite good, and I'll have to go back and try a BYO dish. read more

The food is outstanding! I am the biggest mac n cheese fan ever..never have I been disappointed by any dish ordered. The greatest variety of America's stick to your ribs staple! read more

This place is so creative. I loved it. I think I had the Philly cheese steak and my sister had some chicken Alfredo. Ultimately it's worth the money read more

Let me start off with if you never liked Mac & Cheese you have to wait and give this place a try! Buffalo chicken mac & cheese it is so delicious! I can't say how many times I have been here and the food has truly been amazing. I am never disappointed getting food here, and it even tastes good the next day! read more

I got the Cubano max of the month and it was one of the best mac n cheese I've had. They have a large selection and gluten free options as well. read more

Mix N Mac is one of the few things I genuinely miss about Middletown. Ever since I left the area I haven't been able to find such good comfort food. Their selection and unique twists on mac is tough to find elsewhere! The staff is always hard-working and dedicated to this family business. If you're traveling through the area, hop off the highway and grab a bite here, it's only 5 minutes off the exit. The best "homemade" style mac you'll find is when you just order the base American blend. There are so many delish, more unusual options too. Crazy whitey, macho nacho, & spinach artichoke are my personal favorites. Whenever I was craving something comforting & flavorful, I couldn't go wrong with Mix N Mac. read more

I came back with even more mouths to feed hoping to be equally impressed! I've gotta give a round of applause to the people who work here. They seem super psyched about selling fried mac Balls. Just like, really into it. One may even say shockingly into it? Anyways, I ordered the Hawaiin mac and it wasn't as good as the honey sriracha but was still yummy. My sister ordered the mushroom mac which was absolutely decadent. So creamy and delicious. Despite being a Mac myself I would have never ordered mushroom mac n' cheese. Well I'm glad I didn't suffer that fate because it was gooooooddd. Overall I stand by this place as the sort of restaurant you will make yourself regret not wearing stretchy pants at. read more

The recipes Mix N Max has created of Mac n Cheese are works of art! Start out with an order of Balls, I had the Mexi Ball and it was full of taste with a little zest to spice it up. I could make a full meal of these. I went with the Cordon Bleu Mac N Cheese dish and it had a nice blend of all flavors that hit the spot! Small dining area inside as a number of people came in for their takeout order. Lots of flavors to try out for repeat visits! read more

Mix N Mac - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

Love this place! Mac & cheese balls are delicious and there are so many varieties of Mac & cheese to try! My favorite is the Buffalo chicken (: definitely recommend. read more

Service was great... food was very oily and all I could taste. The staff was very helpful, but again the food was disgusting.

Ordered for delivery and it did not disappoint! We tried 3 because Steve told us about the lobster Mac & the spinach artichoke Mac so those were a must. Then ordered the burger one. They were sooo flavorful and lived up to Steve's hype! Lol! Thanks again! read more

Mix N Mac - Lobster Mac - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

Never disappoints! Good, fresh and hot food and fast service. Small space inside but usually still find somewhere to sit.

Hey, it's mac & cheese. Comfort food at its best, you are not going to eat it every day, so enjoy it.

This is a very special place IMO. It makes something so simple as Mac and cheese into unique and special flavors. I love their pesto Mac and cheese but it get a bit heavy when eating it by itself. Wish they provided something to go with their amazing Mac and cheese! read more

500 stars. I dream of mix n Mac nightly. Unfortunately I moved to Nyc a few years ago and I can only visit on the weekends now. This is by far my favorite place to eat, I wish I could get mail order Mac. read more

When I moved to Middletown and saw that a macaroni and cheese place had the highest ratings on Yelp, I was a little concerned. But the reviews are right, Mix N Mac has taken the soul food favorite to the next level with unique, well executed combinations of quality ingredients. The Mac and cheese balls are effing awesome. I was afraid it would just be greasy and heavy, but they were really crispy and not oily. I got the Thanksgiving cheese balls which had turkey, carrots, and green beans in them. Also I had the cheeseburger mac n cheese. Both were great flavor combinations. The employees were very friendly and they checked often that I liked the food. They have a good selection of craft sodas from Rogue, the company originally known for making craft beer. I had a really refreshing Citrus Cucumber soda and it was big enough to share. read more

See all

Sweetie loves Mac & Cheese and we do experiments in the kitchen to create our Mac & Cheese. So, when we saw this restaurant, we decided to check it out. The Fried Mac & Cheese Balls (Bacon & Cheddar) was to awesome! Served piping hot, you just gotta have the next bite. it's the perfect crunchy on the outside and gooey on the inside kinda fun! Sweetie got the Fiery Steak Mac, which can be best described as spicy-licious. I got the Lobster Mac, the chunks of lobster was a sure delight. Then we decided to mix it up, to create a lovely Surf & Turf Mac. Since I was not so keen on eating spicy on that particular evening, the blend was definitely scrumptious. I think our experiment days are over, afterall Middletown is in the middle of the long road between work and home! We will just have to experiment on something else! Besides they do Mix it up and Get Baked. You can create your own Mac by selecting the cheese sauce, regular or whole grain mac and a wide array of ingredients! read more

Mix N Mac - The fantastically delicious Bacon & Cheddar Fried Mac & Cheese Balls served with a cheesy tomato dipping sauce. - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York

See all

It was bussin. The balls were so much bigger than i thought and it was so tasty the flavors busted in my mouth so nicely. and the mac and cheese was extremely delightful. The service was really good!!! 10/10 read more

I have visited here once and was very pleased with everything. I actually had to order a second item because the first, the cheeseburger mac, had ketchup in it. For most folks that's par for the course, but for me, it's a no-go. But it didn't go to waste and my wife and I took it home for her to have later. If you have any "things" about foods, just ask and they will tell you what's in there. For my second try I went with the BHS (bacon, ham, swiss) version and was very happy! And, for what it's worth, the next day it was even better! Also, the fried mac n cheese balls that they have as appetizers are not to be missed! Yeah, I will be back for sure! read more

Amazing. Amazing. Amazing. If you love mac and cheese, this place is heaven. I have tried about 7 different flavors, every single one was great. Favorite: HBS aka Honey Bacon Sriracha. Perfect combo of salty, sweet and heat. read more

Epic! This place is fantastic! You better walk in hungry or ready to share because their portions are incredible!!!

Good stuff. They even have whole grain pasta. Nice friendly staff. Their mac balls are pretty tasty. Even their salad was pretty good with the fresh mozzarella. All in all a good place to get your cheese fill. Especially in this neck of the woods. read more

Mix N Mac - Mac ball - Gluten-Free Near Me - Middletown, New York