I had read good reviews about this place and we decided to try it! There is a small parking lot area, which is convenient if you can find a spot. Upon entering, I wasn't too thrilled with how the pizza looked from the display, but we decided to try the plain slice, grandma, and the pepperoni roll. The pepperoni roll was okay. The plain slice was HUGE. It definitely didn't look that big from the display. Flavor was okay. It was very thin. Grandma was okay also. I'd go back there if I was in the area and wanted to grab a quick slice. Service was good. Interior was homey and comfortable. read more

Pizza Heaven - Plain slice and Pepperoni Roll - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

See all

Me and my aunt were there today to get the large pizza slices, they were so delicious as usual today makes my 2nd time going there, excellent pizza, the staff and owner are very friendly. I can't wait to come back read more

Been there many times Food is unbelievable The giant slice is the greatest. I like going there when I can't figure out what to eat always crowded. read more

overall good. Food/Drink: Pizza by the slice! Pretty good New York style pizza. Regular amount of options and combos. Full Italian style menu, appetizers, entrees, pizza, soups, salads, and desserts! Pizza: Needed more crunch not too much, left me wanting more of a bite. Very flavorful, not super oily though. Sauce was good not too sweet could have used a little more garlic but hey is it ever enough?! Dinning Area: Pretty large, open, area. Benches, large counter, double closed off entry way so mo breeze. Plenty of seating! Prices: Relatively cheap. 2 slice and fountain special for $11! Parking: Plenty of space, shared strip mall lot. Bathrooms: Bathrooms were clean and regular size. Atmosphere: During the weekday lunch rush, it was a huge snow storm so this would be unfair. It was empty. Staff/Attendants: great! Decent experience...idk maybe one more try! 7/10 read more

My family and I dined in and it was great. The giant slices are just that, huge. The slices were made fresh for us and the service was top tier. We got the plain, bbq chicken and bacon ranch pizza - they were delicious. The waitress was so friendly and personable. It is such a great pizza shop. We haven't even tried the entrees yet but are excited to return again and begin to enjoy other parts of the menu besides slices! read more

Giant slices AND the best pizza around. Whats not to love? The giant slices need to be eaten there to be believed. read more

Ordered two things here and the wait time was fair, the counter person took my order quickly and asked if wanted more. So for the food, the shrimp park was pretty good, not too much sauce that made the sub soggy and sauce itself was well balanced in seasoning, now the shrimp would loved some more, but at least jumbo size pieces breaded for the sub. Also just right amount of cheese in sub as well. Now the garlic bread parm, was okay, would loved more sauce under the cheese for a parmigiana bread, since it felt like it only seasoned and added cheese read more

Pizza Heaven - Shrimp parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

See all

Ordered like I have in the past delivered to the bar I was at. Second time the delivery guy didn't have a receipt and said the total was 10 to 15 more than it actually was... wanted 47 dollars for a pizza and 2 orders if garlic knots.... Either a bad delivery person is scamming, and the company does not know, or he delivery perusing is scaming because the company allows it read more

Great pizza. Good prices. Huge slices. Open late. Super nice workers. Enjoyed our meal.

Pizza Heaven is finally going to get a review from me after a long hiatus of not coming here. Walking in the space hasn't changed much still cooler in your left and right. The pizza counter in front of you with the food on display but lots of labeling which is good. Partner and I ordered up 2 giant slices, plain & pepperoni plus an order of garlic knots (6 to an order) requested it extra hot and sat down. In about 5 minutes pizza were fresh from the oven and wow were they HOT! I love a piping hot slice that burns the roof of your mouth and all your taste buds clean off your tongue! It was very good, sauce was on point, cheese was at a great ratio vs sauce and the crust was delicious. The garlic knots are tiny but I think they were like 1.99 so not horrendous. 2 drinks 2 giant slices order of garlic knots came to $13 and change. The feeling of full almost to the point of feeling sick is great especially when it's done for the love of Pizza. It is for that reason I give them 4 out 5 stars! read more

See all

I wanted to eat here a few times before giving a rating to make sure of consistency. Been here 3 times now and each time was great. The staff were friendly and the pizza was great. read more

Been going here since 1998. Pizza has always been great! Love the Giant Slice and various Pizza rolls. The only criticism that I would give is when the owners aren't there and the Spanish guys working take it over, you can tell the difference in the atmosphere and food. I use to come and eat in all the time but the one Spanish guy that seems to run the place with blonde highlights and dangling cross earring isn't as nice and constantly high pitch whistles endless. This usually leads to me leaving or having a headache. Not to mention blowing and spitting while whistling around exposed food isn't great. That's the one thing I would change. read more

Pizza Heaven - White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

Amazing Pizza and it's a family oriented place everyone knows each other but doesn't make you feel ostracized.

I decided to stop here since people in the area of this shop rave about it. It's been hit or miss for the two times total that I've stopped here. The first time the pizza wasn't (a huge slice) but it was fairly decent. The second time it was an actual huge slice, but had a huge puddle of oil in the middle of the pizza. Not exactly a deal breaker, but I definitely had to sop all of it up with a napkin first. I'd give the pizza a 3/5. I believe a single "jumbo slice" is $4. read more

Best slice in the 845. Staff is friendly and pizza is delicious. My kids and I eat there weekly. read more

Straight fire best pizza in orange country. The giant slice is amazing and the Buffalo chicken sub is great,

The food is always good, but I'd say that they mess up my order at least half the time. At least twice I've ordered and paid for a specialty pie and been delivered a plain one. Prices are okay, about on par with similar places in the area. I suppose I'd recommend Pizza Heaven with the caveat that if you order delivery, ask to check your food before they go; I do think it's the best tasting slice in the immediate area. read more

We have tried this place a few times. We took a break due to the fact they messed up orders over and over. Tonight we placed an order to give them another try. But as to be expected the order was wrong. When I called I stressed to the young lady taking the order what we would like. I even repeated the order, but alas, as expected they got this order all wrong. Needless to say we will no longer making the trip over the mountain to be disappointed yet once again. I'm sorry. It's pizza. You really have to go out of your way to screw it up. If I could I would give no stars as a review. read more

I always forget this place because it's not on the main road. they have a large menu but I've only had the pizza and let me tell you it's great! I put a ruler next to the slice so you could see how large it is. Nice thin crunchy crust just the way i like it. I did think it was a bit expinsive. 2 pepperoni slices were $8.16. ! I highly recommend them. read more

Pizza Heaven - Home of the giant slice - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

Just ordered a pizza it was half cooked not eatable. I call and the person on the phone apologized didn't offer to make another one just said she was sorry. Oh well through in the garbage . Got one a few weeks ago it was good maybe because the owner mad it . read more

Raised their prices again. For the quality and taste of food not worth it. Brought lunch there because prices used to be reasonable.

Best place to get a slice of pizza in New Windsor. Always fresh and timing is always spot on. The team is very friendly!

Home of the giant slice! Pizza heaven is definitely my favorite spot for pizza. Its always consistent and fresh. This restaurant is definitely a place where everyone knows everyone and its very welcoming. If i dont get a giant slice, i get a taco slice and its amazing. read more

Great Pizza, Wings, and knots ! Always friendly atmosphere. Walk ins welcome as well .

Never again!!! The young teenager behind the counter was dealing with money, scratching her head, AND managing my food with her BARE HANDS!!! Food is very good but the workers are very unsanitary. Will not be going back ever again. read more

This place is awesome! Pizza is delicious, both the big slices and regular slice are incredible. Highly recommended.

My favorite pizza in NY for sure - maybe even the entire country. We own a home here, but live in CA - so we only get to have this two or three times a year. We look forward to it every time we come out. read more

Great People ! The Slices are HUGE ! Delicious ! Taco Salad was Great,and Service was Quick ! 4 Stars !

Just the best most consistently thin and crisp crust in the area. Pizza is a rare cheat for us, and it needs to be worth it. This is.

Living locally, I've been here a few times in the past and never got around to reviewing it. Although the food here is very good and the service is efficient, the prices are terrible. The last time I was there, I had ordered 3 Sicilian slices with pepperoni, a side order of fries, and I grabbed a can of Pepsi. It was $18 out the door. I know their regular pizza here is larger than most places, but the Sicilian slices aren't noticeably different than anywhere else. The food is good, but it's not that good to justify charging so much. read more

HUGE slices and amazing garlic knots! The pizza is pretty good and they offer delivery. I've never ordered anything else from here so I'm not sure how the rest of the items are. read more

This is the second time I've been here! They over cook there pizzas and why they may have big slices. For a small pie with one topping over $15 way over priced and over rated!! Will not return read more

Winner, winner, chicken dinner! This is place is great! Grading the pizza here. Got a large pepperoni. Excellent NY style pizza. Crust is thin and just shy of being "floppy". Cheese, sauce, etc. were perfect. In addition, they were quick. I'll be back. read more

I love the BBQ chicken wrap here among many other things. Also, the owners, counter girls and delivery guys are very nice. We will always go back. read more

By far the best pizza around. Such a nice family owned business and everyone makes you feel so welcome. They're known for their giant slice which is equivalent to almost 3 pieces! Everything is delicious from the pizza to the salads to the pene ala vodka. Yummy! read more

This place has the best pizza in New Windsor! The staff is caring and amazing. Our family has been going here for years! I highly recommend it. read more

This is the 2nd time I have gotten pizza where the woman is handling the money and the pizza with no gloves on. The pizza is good but I cannot get pizza there anymore watching her touch the money and then people's food with her bare hands. read more

Best pizza in the area! My family goes here about once per week. The White Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza are amazing. Then again, all of them are! Service is always fast. read more

Delivered Pizza needed more time in the oven...not crisp but soggy and kind of tough to chew.

The food is ok but the management and staff is extremely nasty and disrespectful to customers. I phoned in an order to pick up and the manager misunderstood my order. When I explained the order was wrong he gave me a very nasty response explaining how he is right and I was wrong and nearly refused to correct my order. I don t expect special treatment but I do expect to be treated with respect. read more