Little Pops is such a hidden gem! It was recommended to me by someone volunteering at the Regional Food Bank nearby and I never looked back. For my birthday I was surprised by their amazing Teriyaki Chicken pizza. I don't know how they figured it out, I am just glad they did! Pizza pics next time, with hopefully a pic of their great garlic knots and tiramisu! Always a great time with amazing food and kind staff! read more

The Stromboli was quite the delectable taste sensation. Very quick and friendly service. Kudos.

Work down the road from place, always a good spot for a quick slice! Pasta dinners, specialty pies, Chicken Parm heroes are all wonderful. I am a Coca Cola girly so them having Pepsi products is a little disappointing and I do think the prices of their desserts are outrageous. But Cannolis are scrumptious! read more

Food was immaculate feel me, prolly the best pizza I had before but the thing is as soon as I go to wipe my face I realized they didn't give any napkins and my whole day was blown. ya. gotta do better. read more

Went to this place close to the same time as another reviewer that said they got burnt pizza. We ate there 12:45 PM, and their review was timestamped 1:45 PM the same day, though obviously I don't know how much time passed between them eating there and leaving the review. I have such a hard time believing their pizza was burned... We ate slices inside the store and they were amazing, exactly the way pizza should be made -- in a hot oven, crispy with a slight sear on the crust because if how hot the oven is. The pizza slices were some of the largest I have ever seen... One of the best places I've eaten. How can our experiences be so different? It makes me wonder if somebody who owns another pizza joint is trying to review bomb this place... read more

We have little pops delivered often. It's so friendly and convenient. Everything always arrives fresh and hot. They use quality ingredients which makes it so delicious. read more

Very good pizza and Stromboli. Growing up in New York City, I am very picky about my Pizza. This local joint passed the test with flying colors and it is good to have good pizza very close to home. I highly recommend the garlic knot crust for your pizza pies and I have to say their garlic knots rank up there amongst the best I have had. read more

really good food, got it delivered, great service, got a pizza with garlic bread crust

pizza was burnt. onions weren't completely peeled . should have brought the pizza back.......

To start off. I love the lasagna pie. Your chicken rolls are always great as well. That's where the 4 star comes from. Now for the bad. Lately you've just been slacking on service. Told us 45 minutes. Came in 50 minutes later. You got frustrated and Yelled to the cashier to tell customers it's gonna be an hour in a half for a pizza. Lol then yell out you aren't making anymore chicken rolls because you didn't feel like making any more. Which brings me to my next negative comment. We actually called today. New Year's Eve to actually order a big order and your cheap automated thing says you are closed. Happen to drive by and yea you guys were definitely open. Please, Step it up or please get someone to make more pies without complaining about working and thriving. Happy new year. Hope 2025 you can make things happen and be happy your business is doing so great! read more

Little Pops is awesome!!! The owner and his family are so sweet! The place is clean, well stocked and everything I've had there has been super delicious and super fresh!!! My favorite meal is the Italian chicken sandwich. read more

Best pizza in Orange County. Always fresh ingredients. Very friendly and they deliver! Not just the pizza, but the entire menu is great. The wings and dinners are the best around. Homemade meatballs and sausage are delicious. Go go go!!!! read more

Little Pops Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Maybrook, New York

I love this place , I'm a city girl and moved up here and this place is great . No other place comes close for upstate pizza .

We order from here all the time. The pizza slaps & delivery is quick. Highly recommend

Finally found a pizza place upstate that had descent pizza until my wife pointed out a baby roach on my plate. I was done and disgusted and would never go back unless they closed down cleaned remodeled and started over read more

"Holy Zeppoles Batman!" I have to say I'm definitely a fan of this pizza joint! I've ordered regular slices, hot heroes (meatball parm) and O-M-G zeppoles with complete satisfaction. Being from NYC it's disheartening to always order zeppoles from pizza shops in my rural home area and basically have the pizza guy/gal say, "Zeppoles? What's that?" [insert facepalm] Thankfully Little Pops has those delightful treats! Just for the zeppoles alone I'll drive out of my way to visit this pizza spot to satisfy my native NYC crave for those amazing treats that are dreadful for my waistline. Oh and be warned the pizza slices are massive in size but massively yummy! read more

seriously the best pizza upstate!!! They have a lot of options on their menu with FRESH food! They really care about what their customers are getting. Also the counter girls are always a pleasure!!! read more

I absolutely love the food here. It's always consistently good. The environment is spectacular, I always feel like family!!

Some of my faves...wings, pizza, anything with the chicken and fried ravioli! Just to name a few

The food is great, and ready when I get there to pick it up. Service is top notch and always very personable.

Mostly good someone pizza too burnt. My husband loves the chili! Everyone is sweet in there nice workers.

We LOVE little pops! I usually use slice but you can call, the people who answer are always so helpful (even suggesting specials for discounts). We LOVE the Stromboli- we get it with sausage added and it's delicious. And their pizza is top 5 for me. So good. Give it a go!! read more

I'm giving it a higher score because of the area it is in a small town . The other reason is this place can make a decent side of knots with flavor. They have an awesome staff. And excellent prices . No cell signal there but it was a neat place to relax and enjoy a slice. read more

Funny how I found them on my drive home from work and brought 2 slices and must say I LOVED IT!!! Nice large slices and the price is a little more than the large slices I get near my house in Monroe from Tasco's, but it has the right balance of cheese and sauce mix. 2 thumbs up from me and will recommend this spot. I loved it so much I stopped by 3 nights in a row for those 2 slices. Only issue I ran into was on a Friday night around 6:45pm I wanted to try one of their Calzones, but they told me it would be 45 minutes for pick and I didn't have that much time from my lunch break so I passed, but other than that I know not to order late Friday nights ((very busy)) and once again this is a place I will get my pizza from. read more

My husband adores this little pizzeria. We've had catering delivered, ordered pizza and had many other items on the menu. The food is solid and they are always reliable. read more

little pops is my favorite pizzeria!! the pizza is always great and i recommend trying the chicken parm hero and the wings!

NY...do you even Pizza? In town visiting family and thought "hey let's​ order a pizza b/c its NY" well after my first bites I wish I had gotten a hot pocket from the hotel vending machine. Customer service, for while I had it (we did door dash) 10/10, guy was polite, quick service. Thats about where it ends. We got the garlic knots, fried ravioli, slice of cheesecake and the bruschetta pizza. The garlic knots were raw in the middle...fried ravioli...blander then a caucasian wedding on the cape, the pizza...unremarkable, probably the least offensive thing we ordered but I could have gotten the same experience if I opened a can of tomatoes and dumped an entire McCormick​ container of dried basil. Yelpverse, I'm a woman who has never turned away a desert, I thought, 'its cheesecake, how bad could it be? Sure it'll probably taste like a fridge but like who can screw up creamcheese an sugar?' Well...they did. I'm pretty sure I've got enough artificial vanilla in me to qualify as an aisle in stop and shop. The crust was soggy and the gelatinous mess I tasted didn't even taste like creamcheese. I threw it away. I have never in my life thrown away a dessert and I did with this one. In short, I expected better of you NY...I get its outside of the city but like don't give up on your dreams, use some salt for God's sake. If considering ordering, please save yourself the time and get your disappointment from the Mcdonalds drivethru instead. sincerely​, Salty...like your ravioli​ needed to be. read more

My girlfriend's family orders from here all the time, and I cringe everytime I stay over on their "pizza nigh." I have had a large portion of their menu so far, and they have yet to get anything right. All of their heros are dry. All of their pastas are overcooked and oily. All of their wings are overcooked by about 20 minutes. And all of their pizzas just taste cheap. Good italian food is simple, strong flavors, cooked well. It's not easy to be the best, but it's very easy to at least be good. Something needs to change, and fast. Polite staff. read more

Staff making pizza has no mask or gloves, restraunt floor and general area very dirty. Girls behind counter wearing mask on chin . One was picking at good on counter work area. read more

We were told Little Pops was the best pizza in town- both my husband and I ordered some kind of chicken pizza ( seems like all they have besides cheese by the slice)- anyway, we both got really ill. Pizza was the only thing in common we ate that day- I didn't eat anything else! We thought the pizza tasted a bit funny, but attributed it to the seasoning on the chicken or in the sauce. Still have not worked up the guts to try the other two places that are close. read more

Little pops pizza is a really solid pizzeria in maybrook. I have only had the pizza here. Prices are competitive to the other pizzerias in the area. I do think this is your best option for pizza if you are in maybrook. The staff is always nice wether eating inside or ordering to go. Little pops offers more than just pizza. There menu includes hot subs and chicken wings. It's a typical American Italian pizza place. I do not know if they deliver I forgot to ask sorry I ran into someone I knew and started talking lol. Little pops is your best option for pizza in maybrook. I do recommend getting a pie here! read more

Little Pops Pizza - The front of little pops - Pizza Near Me - Maybrook, New York

I used to come here almost every day when I'm irked in the area and I'm sad to see all the negative reviews and how much it must have changed. I loved their lasagna pizza and Sicilian slices. Not sure if prices are the same but they used to be very fair prices for large slices. read more

I was happy with the food buy my question is how does it take over an hour to get my food 2 blocks away?? That's what pissed me off!! And why you will never get more than 3 stars. Every time I order its over and hour and total bullshit!! read more

Yelp is so harsh with reviews for no reason. The reviews on google for this place are amazing, and i agree with them. As a new resident of maybrook, im psyched to have a pizza place close by with good pizza! I also enjoyed a really delicious chicken cutlet sandwich. I'm sure we will be regulars of little pops! read more

Food is generally good, but do not order the rolls, they are VERY undercooked. I tried to give it another shot but no, same thing. Half the dough was unbaked and I wasn't gonna drive back and ask for a refund so I ended up just eating only half of what I paid for unfortunately. Won't be ordering the rolls from there again, pizza is good though read more

Good pizza, good menu, fair prices. The wait is a bit long (30 to 40 min) for pickup on busy nights but if you are prepared for that, you won't go wrong here. Nice courteous staff. read more

We just bought a little house in Maybrook, and ordered food for the first time tonight and the pizza was delicious, and the crust so thin. It was done right, nice acidic sauce but balanced. We're so happy we have a great pizza shop nearby! read more

We have been going to Little Pop's for years and love the food. Increasingly though, the pizza is hastily made. The sauce does not extend to the crust and the onions are all clumped in the middle. We excused it the first time it happened, but it has been three weeks in a row. I really hope the manage/owner can address this issue as we would hate to have to get our pizza somewhere else. read more

Calzone was amazing!' Definitely worth the trip. Great sauce and good flavor. I would recommend this pizzeria

I'm disappointed in their business practices if I tip the driver four or five dollars they are only a block away from my home why are they charging me a $7 delivery fee because the girl who took the order took it wrong and turned it into the cash register wrong and then refuse to correct it so I refuse to keep the order I am a local person and my options are very limited so to take away the one Italian restaurant in the village because their business practices suck really sucks for me thanks a lot read more