Local pizzeria. Hit…read moreor miss, but today is a hit! Good crunch, good sauce, a little busy during lunch, small inside, always awkward parking. Team inside is on point, nice, friendly, quick and accommodating. A little pricey but pizza is getting out of hand in general. Today I'm a fan.

Visited on 4/1/26 girl at the front very nice. However during our drive from Legoland to here we…read morelooked over the website at their specials decided as a family of 5 what we were going to order to pick up and drive home with. We called to place an order to be told they no longer do specials and the menu online prices aren't correct either....okay no big deal. Even with the specials and seeing the price I thought hmmm little over priced but it is what it is. So we ended up ordering a large meatheads pizza pepperoni, sausage, meatballs and some garlic knots for 28.00 bucks. I included some pics of the menu I picked up there. Overall the pizza was wonderful. Definitely update the WEBSITE there's plenty of competition in Newburgh for a few dollars extra will add some wings and a soda. This place is a one and done for me. Bring back the specials

We've recently just moved to the area and have been looking for a go to spot for deliciousness…read more We made the mistake of popping in last Friday (1st day of Lent) and ordered a few slices to go- that didn't go as planned... But, we've heard such great things about this place, so, we figured we'd give it another shot. Ordered a late lunch this afternoon- Clams were outstanding! Meatballs- yum! The garlic knots, though? They were spot on delicious and we literally inhaled them. Also had a couple of BYO chicken cutlet hero's- Excellent help over the phone and the delivery person was extremely pleasant and super polite. Can't wait to fall in love with this place!

After a morning of crow hunting (we got skunked), my best friend, The Missing Ink AKA the Old Crow,…read moreand I stopped at Coscarino's. Voted the best pizza in the area in 2021, 2022, and 2024 (WHAT HAPPENED IN 2023?)? What a great find! Located in a strip mall w plenty of parking. Not an abundance of seating inside, but just enough that we found a table. Order and pay up front, and someone will bring your food when ready. There were about twelve "designer" pizza varieties on display. I opted for two slices, one with spinach and ricotta (pronounced rigaught), the other w meatball and several cheeses. TMI ordered an eggplant calzone type of sandwich. My pizza was delish....one slice would have been enough. TMI's sandwich came w a side of marinara sauce, and was piping hot. We also witnessed an Italian combo sandwich ordered by the next table over. It was UGE! TMI also ordered an eggplant sandwich to-go, for his wife, the Breathtaking Maria. Not too often do you find a good pizza parlor in a town like Montgomery that also sells slices, and a large selection of the same. And with quality! Overall, as good as it gets in this area. I'd be surprised if Coscarino's didn't win for 2025 (and beyond). This pizza snob rates them 5 stars! Last, I'd be remiss if I didn't mention the bathroom. The Missing Ink never fails to visit at least once in every establishment we stop in. He said clean, and TP was 2-ply.

Food was immaculate feel me, prolly the best pizza I had before but the thing is as soon as I go to…read morewipe my face I realized they didn't give any napkins and my whole day was blown. ya. gotta do better.

Work down the road from place, always a good spot for a quick slice!…read more Pasta dinners, specialty pies, Chicken Parm heroes are all wonderful. I am a Coca Cola girly so them having Pepsi products is a little disappointing and I do think the prices of their desserts are outrageous. But Cannolis are scrumptious!

Pizza was delicious! Perfect sauce to cheese ratio...New owners, very friendly. We will definitely…read morebe back for another slice. Now called Antonella's.

Seriously great pizza! Major caveat though; their sides are awful. I've tried almost all of their…read moresides with various take orders. Garlic bread, cheesy garlic bread etc and all of them were REALLY bad. Covered in garlic from a can. So much so that all you can taste is the strange taste of canned garlic. Just seriously caked on the bread. It's annoying because their pizza is 5 stars every time. The crust is good the sauce is great and it's honestly one of my favorite pizzas. So I'm forced on minimum delivery orders to purchase a side along with my pizza and every time I regret it. All that said: their pizza is GREAT. I've had family over and ordered their pizza. Everyone of my family members said how great the pizza was. And some of them are on the picky side so I call that a win! Just stay away from the sides. I haven't tried any of the other food on the menu so I can't comment on their other items.

Best pizza in town!!! The owner is very nice, customer service is great and sauce is made from…read morescratch! You should definitely give this place a try, I'm glad we did!

went in there excited to get a hot meal!! Walked right out when I saw not one worker was wearing a…read moremask!! Literally nobody not even the cooks or the blonde lady taking orders. Unbelievable and upsetting for the times we are in!!

I find one waiter very friendly and accommodating to the Gluten needs of my cousin. A big A+ for…read moreher! The staff rushed our order to our specifications. I wholeheartedly recommend a visit!

Sadly it closed during the pandemic. Owners and staff were so wonderful. Sad to see a local fave…read morego

Wow! Clean, bright, welcoming. Food was hot and fresh, good flavor. Friendly waitress…read more My husband got the Brooklyn sandwich - pastrami, swiss, mustard. Hot, on a big sub roll. Side of fresh fries. I got the stromboli. The small was a generous size, very fresh, and I took almost half of it home. Good variety on the menu, from a well-priced lunch special up to a special dinner. We had such a nice time, felt welcome, really enjoyed ourselves. Will be back.

Update: Feb2025- liquor license and food update. Had the vodka sauce special with prosciutto...any…read morepasta type works and have had them all: ravioli, stuffed shells, manicotti! The wine selection is great and prices are great. They are still getting draft beer settled but they have a few options plus bottled beer. Adding pics of wine menu and the manicotti (I've already eaten some, sorry). But so delish. The bread is to die for and we can't stop raving about it! Our favorite pizza is to get 1/2 Crazy Chicken, 1/2 penne vodka...love that the pizza is so crispy. Last week we had 1/2 cheese and 1/2 meatball and it was amazing also. Can't go wrong here. Different from other pizzerias in the area.

The pizza shop is off of a tiny parking lot by other business on the avenue. It was very welcoming…read more When you walk in there is a deli and slices available. Staff greeted us immediately and was very cordial. We settled on a few pre made slices and garlic knots. The chicken bacon was on red sauce and had ranch on the side. I'm not familiar with the sliced made that way but none the less it was a taste sensation. The white slice was a perfect blend of cheese which can be rare to find. The margarita pizza was a fun blend of goodness. All the dough was met somewhere in the middle of too under cooked and over done. The crust was perfect. The garlic knots were very oily but still satisfied the palate in the oily, garlicky greatness. I would definitely stop by again and try other slices as well as entrees. The shop was super clean, the seating area was quaint and the restroom very updated and clean. The cost of 4 slices and 6 knots was $20 so that was a fantastic delight on my wallet. It was an overall win for a pizza night.

Terrible Food...... They should close up immediately…read more The community deserves better!! The worst I've ever had.... Sauce taste very Bitter!

Delicious food and great service!! They have anything you can want. The desert! DELICIOUS!read more

I have been getting the cheesecake tortellini and its amazing! The sauce, the Ribeye on top too…read morethe onions and peppers. Top notice dish! Nice people.

The food was really nice, the bread was warm and delicious, and everything was fresh and full of…read moreflavor. The service was friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere made the experience even better. 100% recommended -- I'll definitely come back!

Great food and great service and great price! Every dish is delicious and fresh. Very happy to be…read morehere.