This rating is a four solely on the food. We were visiting friends in the area and decided to grab a pizza from Eduardos. We attempted to call the business since they don't have online ordering and were hung up on twice. We were told to hold and then dial tone. Third attempt I was able to get thru. The employee seemed very clueless on taking my order. It should have been a red flag from the start. I ordered a large cheese and large pepperoni pizza. The delivery time was way too long so I said I would pick it up.. she says ok.. I asked could you give me a time to pick it up? She says 35 minutes. Thirty minutes rolls around I send my husband to pick up said pizzas.. he gets to the restaurant and the pizzas hadn't been put in the oven yet. He had to wait another 20 minutes for them to cook. While he was there another customer had been waiting for 45 minutes and his food was put in at the same time our pizza was. That's terrible! The pizza was good. It was nice and thin. Plenty of cheese and the pepperoni was good as well. I am not sure if our experience is common with this place or just an off day but goodness that was probably the worst interaction we've ever had at a pizza place. read more

See all

Well, for like the 5th time, the calamari was very fishy. On top of that, the pizza was undercooked and overloaded with toppings. This place seems to be slipping each time we order. Going to have to find a new place. read more

Worst pizza I've ever had!!! Raw. Asked for crispy, well done. Picked up a slice and all the cheese fell off. Called the restaurant to complain and was hung up on. Brought the pizza back and the owner told me it was well done to her standards. Told her she wasn't the one eating it. They offered to make another pie. No way. They also blamed the new cook. Requested my money back, got it and left. Never again. read more

Drove 15 minutes b4 work to pick up food which was a chicken parm, and chicken franchise. When i got home it was an eggplant parm! When i called to say i would not be able to pick up the new chicken parm due to work, they stated people lie about receiving wrong items and was also hung up on. Not a big deal to mess up, but own it! Will not be returning!! read more

Always great food one of the best restaurants in a 25 mile radius!!!! Of Washingtonville ny they are the nicest people

I never thought that a place that does Italian and Mexican would be good at either but I was wrong. The shrimp burrito was delicious! However the rice and beans...meh I've had better but I would return for another meal anytime. read more

It doesn't look like much but they do serve some good food. I had the lobster ravioli with shrimp in a vodka sauce and also the chicken franchese it was pretty good! Some times you will get someone on the phone that just doesn't know the menu when you ask a question. But otherwise they do accommodate! I tried the grilled calamari and it was BOMB! read more

This is one of those Ma and Pa shops you look for when you are over the chains. Very small and much better for take out, but both experiences were great! Where else can you find a Mexican/Italian combination of food! It's great! My kids were rather confused as to why they got chips and salsa before their spaghetti but I adore it The pizzas are ginormous! If ordering for 2, a small is more like a large! This is also the BEST Alfredo sauce I have had in my life! The tortellini Alfredo is phenomenal! Super buttery and garlicy with great flavor! If you're looking for a hole-in-the-wall that could become your family favorite, this is the place! read more

Great local dining. I had been meaning to check out this little gem tucked away in Salisbury Mills. Kicked myself for not trying it sooner! Great food and exceptional service. I can see why it's a local favorite. read more

Eduardo's is very good. A mix of Italian and Mexican food either you choose your pretty much set for a good meal. Probably my favorite place locally. Best dinner dishes around being going here for years. read more

One of my favorite places! Hidden gem is an understatement. Food is delicious and very reasonably priced. The people who work there are WONDERFUL! Love coming to eat at Eduardo's! Bring your own wine/beer makes it even better (if possible). Note: their chicken francese is to die for (as is their grilled chicken and vegetables, which I can't help but get every time -- creature of habit) read more

Food was good HOWEVER TWICE my husband and young children got food borne illness from here, neighbor also got sick from here as well. So will never eat from this place again, rather drive a couple of miles out to avoid a food borne illness. read more

I used to love this place, I order delivery for my family 1 to 2 times a week for the last 3 years and the food is amazing. Yesterday I had a horrible experience that caused me to cancel my order and choose to never buy food here again. I ordered the dieter's special for delivery (add alfredo sauce), along with some other things. The person called me back to let me know that the charge would be $22 and would I still like to order it. So I asked if they were actually considering charging me $22 for a skinny slice of chicken and a half of cup of broccoli with a little sauce. She said yes, that the owner told her that's what it would be and asked if I still want it. I asked what the normal cost is and she said $15. I asked her if they seriously thought it was right to charge me $7 for a scoop of Alfredo. She said she was sorry that the owner said that's how it is. So I told her to please go tell the owner that I order from them religiously one or two times a week and that I always tip the drivers well. That if he really wants to charge me that, I will cancel my entire order and never order from there again. She went to him and I could hear her talking to the owner and he insisted that's how it was going to be, so I asked her to please cancel my order and told her they lost a customer. Someone like me you should honestly just give the sauce to no extra, but I would have been fine if they wanted to charge an extra dollar or two. But 7?! So because of a little bit of alfredo sauce you lost a customer who spends $5000 in your restaurant every year. read more

I used to eat here all the time when I lived in the area . I sure do miss it. The owners and staff are amazing . Everything on the menu is delicious. Don't let the strip mall location keep you away . I wish I could find such delicious Italian food near my new house . Priced right also read more

Really good food here. Had a "Pambazo" which I never had before. It was delicious. Enchiladas with salsa verde were good but needed heat. They gave me some additional green sauce that was much spicier and just what was needed. Will come again. read more

Eduardo's - Pambazo. Chorizo, potatoes, lettuce, cheese. Awesome - Pizza Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

See all

We love Eduardos! The nicest family and you cannot get over how good the food is. My son only eats Eduardos's pizza, penne ala vodka and wings ! The best for catering I cannot say enough! read more

Everything that I have tried at Eduardo's I have LOVED more and more every time we have went there to eat. I can't stop eating the DELICIOUS bread that they have there put some butter or even oil on the bread I'm in my glory. read more

Nothing but love for this place! Family friendly and cozy. Food is consistently delicious and comforting!! There is always a special menu and the regular menu is full of great choices from Italian to Mexican. Try the calamari it is always tender and you can't go wrong with the traditional chicken parmigiana! Bring your own wine there is no liquor license. read more

This place is absolutely disgusting. If I could give a negative star rating, I would. Not only did I find a dead bug in my broccoli, but I was disrespected by the staff as well. After leaving A VERY GENEROUS TIP, I was called back by the delivery guy and was told he was not delivering to me unless I gave him more money. "That tip is too little, you can come pick it up." Then when I decided to cancel my order, they harassed me and was going to charge me anyway. I WILL NEVER go to this place again. I'm disgusted. read more

Just came from Eduardo's where we had dinner. This is one of those little hidden gems every small town has that only the locals know about. It's kind of a mom and pop Italian restaurant with a few Mexican dishes as well. We started with complimentary chips and salsa (both of which are made in-house) and the salsa is quite possibly the best I've ever had. For the meal I had ravioli, again probably the best I've ever had, and a side order of meatballs in a phenomenal homemade marinara. The waitress was as skilled as the cook when it came to providing fast, caring service. She even cut my 3-year old boy's slice of pizza before bringing it out. Absolutely fantastic experience from start to finish. Definitely will be going back! It isn't "fancy" but it IS small and extremely popular so I highly recommend making reservations. read more

The only thing I don't like is the place is VERY small, if you don't make reservations on the weekend. You ant gonna get a seat it's that simple. So plan accordingly. But the food is WELL worth it! CHEERS!!! read more

Decent food, really bad pizza..the dough is not fermented like NY style pizza should be. No chew or bite to the crust, sauce is sweet.

We have been coming here for New Year's Eve for years and I have to say - once again the food was delicious and our server was so friendly, never rushing us. I ordered the Chicken Eduardo as it is one of my favorites and it was delicious. The chicken was so tender and the sauce had just the right amount of lemon. We had a large group and the seating area is small but I thought the service was great, the food was delicious - we all received our food together - and although we are the last seating of the night you were never made to feel like you were keeping them from closing. Will definitely be coming back again! read more

Great food, a hidden gem! Nice, quiet atmosphere, friendly staff. I always look what's good and see Yelp reviews and Eduardo's is right on it! It's definitely 4-5 star family oriented restaurant, consistent! Thank you my son and I enjoyed our lunch read more

If you haven't visited this hidden gem,you must! It's quaint and cozy, filled with locals. The pizza is great but the italian comfort food is my favorite. Huge portions at great prices. Equally delicious are the unexpected Mexican dishes that fly out of the same small kitchen.You even get the option of having great homemade salsa and chips,better than any exclusively Mexican restaurant in town,and great piping hot italian bread!Talk about fusion! Tables are outside as well,perfect for summer nights with friends and a bottle of wine that you can purchase from the wine store next door and enjoy with your meal.It's family owned and operated.The owners know nearly everyone by name and the staff is always friendly,going the extra mile to make you feel at home.Try the chicken Marsala or the chicken Shannon you won't be disappointed. read more

My family has been going to Eduardo's since they opened. The food is consistently delicious. Whether you choose mexican or Italian, you will always get fresh, made to order food. My favorite is Chicken Eduardo and my husband loves the chicken enchiladas. What you will get here is a family atmosphere and down to earth food. Denise and her family treat their guests like family. Always welcoming and friendly. Call and reserve a table if you want to eat here on a friday or saturday night. The locals know and love this place. Also, Stop in next door and pick up a nice bottle of wine to enjoy with your dinner. read more

We've eaten at Eduardo's at least 6 times in the past couple of years and we are always happy with everything about it. The food is always delicious. We especially like the waitress. I think her name is Denise. She makes you feel like you are her friends coming for dinner. read more

A great little restaurant with soul. A very broad menu but everything is prepared with care and tastes great. We tend to go for his Tex Mex dishes - (the tacos with fresh cilantro are fantastic) but the regular fair - burgers, pastas are of a good standard. It's a busy spot Friday and Saturday so come early or make a reservation read more

Ordered food from here three times now and it's been pleasant each time. The lady that took my order is so friendly. The food comes within a reasonable time frame and its really good. There tortellini soup is my fav and I love their nacho grande and chimichanga. They have a pretty great salmon and veggies too if you want things on the lighter side. Bottom line, love their food and it isn't a hassle to call in and order!! read more

Stopped at this place with my family and had a great time. Perfect place to stop after picking up some wine at Brotherhood winery. The food and service was excellent. Highly recommend this place. Penne a la vodka was great and even the chicken tenders were great, tasted fresh. read more

Consistently good. The food is hot AND delicious. Small place, bring your own wine. One of our favorite places in the Washingtonville area.

I have gotten pizza take out from here many many times, and it's always great. I recently ate in the small but comfortable dining area of the restaurant and was pleasantly surprised by the range of menu options (WAY more than pizza!), both Italian and Mexican... we recieved a basket of chips and salsa AND bread and butter. When I asked for a wine list (saw a bottle on the next table) I was informed by our super friendly waitress that I was welcome to purchase some from the store next door and they would open and pour free of charge, awesome! The Alfredo sauce on my tortellini was sooo creamy and delicious, and the broccoli rabe I ordered aa a side was perfectly cooked and seasoned. My dining partner ordered a veal parm dinner which was ample and very tender. Neither of us could finish what we'd ordered so we had it wrapped. Neither one of us was disappointed the next day when we'd discovered we'd taken the wrong bags home! I'll definitely be going back! read more