As a regular delivery customer through the SLICE app, I am usually happy with their service and food. I am a good tipper. Usually don't complain however yesterday's salad was bad. It was a little bit of lettuce with olives and a LOT OF RED ONION. (the red onion wasn't even fresh, it was rotten in parts). i started a chat with the slice app and sent them a picture. SLICE reached out to Planet Pizza. Planet Pizza told them "Unfortunately, they could not authorize a credit at this time. According to their policy, they ensure the order is sent out in the best possible condition right after the food is prepared." This is the best they could do for a loyal repeat customer who received a crappy red onion salad? And NO, I did not sabotage their salad. lol. Planet Pizza did not offer to make a new salad or give a credit to a loyal repeat customer. As a loyal repeat customer, I was stuck with a salad that I paid for but could not eat. ($7.95 + tax + delivery fee + very generous tip for driver). read more

Planet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

Stopped for lunch on a business trip. I ordered the buffalo chicken wrap and my associate the grilled chicken Cesar wrap. We both enjoyed our wraps- they were absolutely loaded with chicken. That being said, the wrap had literally no other ingredients so there wasn't much choice. 30 bucks for two wraps is a little steep but they were filled to the brim so it's hard to complain. read more

Standard pizzeria with a huge dining room area in the back and seating towards the front for those who just want to sit after getting a slice or 2 before heading back out on the road. Staff was welcoming and helped navigate what to do as we were debating about grabbing a couple single slices or a full pie. I only wish the pizza had been a little more well done as it seemed on the undercooked side. However, I blame that on the fact that we were all in a rush and they knew that and we were trying to get out of there as quickly as possible and work with us. read more

See all

First timer... Food was decent, expected what I walked into. Service was actually really really good. Ambiance was faces paced, did not wait long. Well lit, parking was mid but not terrible. A little drafty. read more

Prompt service, cordial staff, nice atmosphere for In dining casual dress, Take out orders are always ready upon arrival as stated food is tasty and filling every time. read more

Ambiance is just a regular pizza joint. Most people get take out bc it's nothing special eating in there. The food is delicious tho! I got a hot hero, a beef patty, pizza and their large garlic knots! Everything has such good flavors. Would def return again for take out. read more

Penne Alla Vodka, chicken tenders and eggplant were delicious. This was a catering order and they also were very accommodating altering the amount of the chicken tenders. Delivery was on time. Would definitely recommend! read more

Really solid pizza spot in Newburgh. No complaints, their garlic knots are huge and tasty. Also like the vegetable Stromboli read more

Planet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Tried here after getting many grub hub orders here and wanted to try it after what it used to be here brother Bruno pizza. Very quick to take my order and my order to go was ready in less then 15 minutes. Order the meat and calzone, garlic knots and bacon chicken ranch pizza slice. The calzone for a personal size was gigantic, a lot cheese perfectly melted and gooey, meat filling was Alright, could been in larger chucks rather then grain size. Garlic knots were good, I like how they are not drowned in garlic like other pizzerias do, a very light amount of chopped garlic baked on top and seasoned lightly. The pizza slice was crunchy for the crust and not doughy, bacon was crispy and not black, chicken was good and not over cooked, plus pretty generous with the amount, a light drizzle of ranch was just right. Very satisfied read more

Planet Pizza - Meat and Cheese Calzone, Jumbo Garlic Knots and Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Don't. Just don't. Used to be the best, but like everything else they stop caring and uncharge. 35 dollars for a cold.pizza.

I recently went to Pizza Hut. I waiting all day for pizza and when I got it, I was very existed. I ordered two large 1-topping pizzas with bread sticks. when I got home the first thing I did was start eating. The pizza was super good and tasty. The bread sticks had so much flavor. They were even better with the sauce they came with. When I was on the phone ordering, the employee there was super nice and made sure I got what I wanted. read more

Planet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

The food was delectable and the fries was so crunchy and the service was so nice and the food came so hot and fresh and I had a nice time and it had good ambience read more

Planet Pizza - Sausage and pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

The best slice of white pizza yet in upstate NY! Didn't know this pizzeria had a restaurant in the back, I will try it next time. Everyone was super cool, they just have to sweep under the table in the front. read more

Planet Pizza - White Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Ordered a grandma's pie got a pizza with just sauce and 4 slices of cheese on it. And being told that's how they make it will never do business with them again read more

Planet Pizza - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

We had car trouble while traveling and had a few hours to wait. So we walked over to Planet Pizza in Newburgh. From the outside it looks like a strip mall pizza shop but we were pleasantly surprised upon entering. It's well appointed without being over the top. Understated but nice art work on the walls. Clean including the bathrooms and music playing. The staff were incredibly friendly and helpful. Big smiles and took time selecting items for us. We chose items that were already prepared and just needed to reheat. We chose a Sicilian cheese slice, an Italian style pepperoni pizza slice and a garlic knot. Sauce, crust and cheese were all better than average in my opinion. My husband preferred the Sicilian as the pep was very thin and kind of greasy so drooped when picking up. Again flavors were pleasant. Solid place and very happy we got to experience it. Plus like I said the staff were very helpful and friendly. That with the quality of ingredients should make more people happy to come in. read more

See all

Stopped in to grab a couple of slices to go. Asked to leave the slices in the oven a little longer so they could get a little crispy. When I brought them home they were still hot and had nice crunch. They also tasted delish. Definitely would recommend for a quick and easy lunch read more

Dropped daughter off at college and hungry for pizza before the trip back to LI. Googled closest pizza parlor and this place popped up! Wow! We each ordered a chicken bacon ranch slice and split a slice of white. Delish! Accommodating & polite staff. Great big brick pizza oven and large dining room. Classic style pizza of yesteryear even served on metal trays! We will definitely be back!! Next trip up! read more

See all

I often drive by the Mid Valley Mall and see the signs for Planet Pizza, so I finally decided to check it out. When you walk in it's a very modern decor, hard wood floors, very attractive interior. I was greeted by the gentleman at the counter and took a look at the selection of the various specialty pies. I saw bacon chicken ranch, Buffalo chicken, pepperoni, veggie, Sicilian and Jamaican beef patties. After a moment of decision making I went with a Bacon chicken ranch and a beef patty with cheese. It was out right into the oven and I grabbed a soda from the large coolers the the left of the counter. I also noticed a separate cooler filled with Italian ice. I sat down and in about 5 minutes my pizza was ready. The food was served on smaller metal pizza trays and it was hot. I am a huge fan of an extra hot slice not a mildly warm slice. The beef patty was hot cheese melted it looked and appeared most wonderful. When I took a bite I was sold. The sauce was very tasty with a bit of a roasted garlic flavor to it, the ranch was creamy/smooth, bacon was plentiful along with pieces of chicken. I enjoyed each bite as much as the last. Then I embarked on the beef patty which was a Golden isle brand (The Best) it was flaky and tasted just as it should. It was a mild flavor so those looking for spicy this is not the one. Again with each bite my satisfaction grew and after about 10 minutes of enjoyment my plate was clean. The crust on the pizza was delicious, it was a crest flaky consistency not to thick or doughy, not to thin that it lacked any flavor. If your looking for a great slice at a fair price please take a trip in and taste and see. read more

See all

the pizza was good but the service was HORRIBLE. went in to pick up our order and the lady working at the counter did not acknowledge our presence for what seemed like a looong time. she was writing stuff down and putting receipts together like a sloth ( seemed like she was being slow on purpose ), so we said "hey we are here to pick up our order" and she looked at us and lifted a "hold on" finger. then she continued to work reallllly slow shuffling things around "acting" like she was busy. FINALLY she got our box of pizza that was ready even before we walked in and basically threw it at us as she just said "$20". WTF No "Hi how's it going?" No "How can I help you?" No "Please." No "Thank you." We paid and got our box of pizza and started heading out while a guy walked in to get his pizza order and the rude lady immediately said "Hi how's it going!?" to him with such warm enthusiasm. racism at its finest at this place. read more

good pizza , and fast delivery if i say so myself would recommend to anyone who wants some good pizza.

Served old chicken in a chicken parm but claimed its fresh, the female waitress who we are familiar with was nice but some new keebler elf they have working there was being a racist, rude disrespectful prick! Will never spend my money there after that and after Covid you need to keep your faithful customers! Black dollars matter, take them elsewhere!! read more

This place was our go to spot for pizza for a long time and unfortunately after this weeks experience we will be finding somewhere else to go. We walked in to place a takeout order. Kid at register was far from friendly (not rude but just not friendly) I showed him the "coupon" on their website to get a large pie, wings and soda for $28.50. He informs me the price went up (which is fine, everything has) and it's now $31.50. If their website is promoting that deal at 28.50 due to not being updated it should still be honored especially when I have it right in front of me. I didn't argue though. Then for my wings I asked if they can mix the Parm garlic and hot sauce. Nope they can't do that. I don't understand why but ok; asked for the hot on the side so I can just dump it on top when I get home. Asked for ranch and bleu cheese, charged me for one of them and then never gave it to us. Then we ordered the sweet Thai calamari and asked for extra sauce. When we got home we saw they barely even put a drizzle of the sauce on it and it was undercooked. Just to add, the garlic knots had very little garlic and were dry. They've been going downhill and this visit was the last straw. Spent way too much money for a half ass meal. read more

Ok. Ok. Ok. There is a lot of pizza restaurants in our area and a couple is our "go to". We wanted to try something different on a rainy afternoon. Walk in to the usual type of pizza joint. We asked to dine inside ( 2 separate areas for a more special dinner family night) Pros vs Cons Pros 1. Waitress extremely friendly 2. Menu is good for the price 3. They have Coca-Cola 4. THE PORTIONS THE PORTIONS THE PORTIONS 5. The food is some of the best around. Cons 1. The Coke was in plastic bottle 2. They don't deliver to my house. THIS IS A MUST TRY RECOMMENDED MENU the Stromboli Spaghetti with meatball Bacon chicken ranch slice Kids chicken fingers/ fries You are taking it all home anyway !!!! Refer back to PRO # 4. read more

Went in for the buffalo chicken pizza, best one around the area. Competitive price and the taste was amazing. Highly recommend. read more

Planet Pizza - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Well, I go there mainly for Pizza. The pizza is fair. But the other food? Not so good. Ordered the Calamari. I've eaten "Calama" in a lot of places. But PP's Calamari is so tough, you can barely chew it. Like rubber. Then I tried a Veal parm hero. Same thing. The Veal is tough. I order over the phone and pick the food up. Twice in the past month, the order was wrong. If you order, check the food before you leave. How I see it? Overall, the place is clean and the people friendly. But the pizza, of 1 out of 10? I give it a 5. The Sicilian slices? To doughy and too much crust. As for the rest of the food, having tried a few dishes. Not good at all and not enjoyable. I haven't tried a salad yet. But then again, how can you screw up a salad? read more

On a long drive from Ohio and my husband found this place on yelp. They are very nice- it has a really nice local feel. I got chicken with spinach. It came with pasta too. It was good. Very fresh. I would definitely come back. It was a lot of good so I might split it and get an extra salad or soup. read more

Planet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

My family and I both frequent planet pizza. Nick and his staff are very polite and professional. Always clean and organized. Food is always fresh and hot. Recently ordered from their catering menu eggplant parm which was delicious. I also ordered a tray of mozzarella sticks which come 50 to an order. I told them ik wouldnt need 50 due to guest count and they worked with me w price and quantity. You cant go wrong with the food and service here. Highly recommended!!! read more

I used to go here when I worked in Newburgh for a year. Good pizza, good salads, good price. Nothing too out of the ordinary. Would get 4/5 stars but one time I ordered a chicken Caesar salad and it wasn't ready when I got there so the girl working gave me an old one that was clearly sitting out for a while. Wilted lettuce, all lukewarm from the chicken. Gross. If I'm paying more than $10 for a salad I want it made fresh. Other than that, service was good. read more

Our first time in, the people behind the counter looked up long enough to make eye contact then looked away. It was off-puting, like, oh we don't know you so you don't register. Subsequent visits haven't been much better. All three times I've had pizza from here, the crust was really chewy. And not in a good way. Like, tough. If I can't even get a greeting when you make eye contact with me on my way in your door, why should I give my hard earned moolah to you? If your pie leaves my jaw achy, I definitely don't want to give you my business anymore. read more

The staff is very accommodating and friendly. The food is your typical Italian food-we tried the pizza which was huge slices and the calamari which was really good. read more

See all

Planet pizza is a family owned pizza place in Newburgh. It is also known as barile's planet pizza. planet pizza has been open for the last 6 months. I still consider it new. Due to all of my traveling i had no idea this place opened until a friend told me about planet pizza. When I heard the name at first I thought of toy story. The place in the movie was pizza planet. Food. planet pizzahas just about every thing an Italian American pizza spot has. They have regular pizza and a list of specialty pies. From what I read all of there pies are thin crust. There pizza reminds me of NYC it is super thin crust nice and Chrispy. They also have parm sandwiches. Wraps. But the thing that struck me the most was a Jamaican beef patty. They have soups and salads. I saw a gentleman reading a paper. eating a Italian wedding soup that looked good. Planet pizza is located in the north plank strip mall. Next to dollar tree. On the corner. Experience. I have eaten here two times so far and I will defiantly be back for more. I have had there plain pizza as well as a specialty slice. The sign outside isn't very big they do have a chalk board specials menu outside listing there specials of the day. Definatly check there board for the daily specials. When I arrived I went up to the counter and I was greeted by a man who asked if he could help me. I told him I had never eaten here before and I was wondering if you could recommend a few things I could try. He told me a few things and mentioned a special on the board and then he pointed to this pizza in the display and said this was there best seller. Naturally being a yelper I had to try it. It was breaded chicken tomato sauce and cheese with a hint of ranch. I thought at first it was a béchamel sauce which it could be I didn't ask the guy. While I was waiting for my slice a friend I haven't seen in months walked in and we talked for a long time we sat down and ate together. This was completely un expected. He had a chicken ranch wrap that looked really good I might try that next time. I told the guy and who I think was the owner. Thank you for the food I also told them I am going to write a yelp review for the business and that they were really nice and everything tasted great. I will def be back to planet pizza next time I'm back home Overall. Planet pizza is a great place to grab a slice or order a pie. I highly recommend eating at planet pizza. The staff is nice and accommodating the food is good and they have Jamaican beef patty's in a Italian place. I do recommend eating here. PROS: - friendly accommodating staff - pizza is good - great daily specials - inexpensive for lunch CONS: -don't have any read more

Planet Pizza - Large plain pie - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

Food is good and fresh. Delivery is fast. Customer service is good too! Would definitely recommend.

Planet Pizza was pretty good. I had a pepperoni pizza and enjoyed it. I also had some garlic knots but didn't like those. I'll be back but only for the pizza read more

Always order from here because I love their chicken a la Felicia however it wasn't as appetizing as it has always been. I asked for extra sauce and got the complete opposite ... it tasted so much different and the chicken was dry. Was fairly disappointed. It's been consistent enough over the years that I'll give them another chance read more

Used to frequent Planet Pizza often when I lived in Monroe, and I now stop in from time to time since they have opened here in Newburgh. They did a really nice job on the dining room and seating area, very spacious and inviting, and they generally have a nice selection of gourmet pie selections and slices at the counter at all times. Get the chicken marsala pie, which is great, or the chicken bacon ranch slice, which is what they are known for. I find some of their regular Neapolitan to be slightly average compared to some other pizzerias in the area, but for the most part, entrees, heroes, and gourmet pizzas are quite good and tasty. They also get my vote for the friendliest staff in the area! read more

Best pepperoni pizza I have ever had, wings are great and they just do it spot on every time. If you want good pizza, come here.

Get off I84 and get some good food. We had Chicken over Spinach and Broccoli Rabe with Sausage. The portions are very generous and very tasty. Everyone is super friendly. Clean bathrooms. What more do you want. It's so worth the trip off the exit. We will be back next time we are driving through. read more

Lived in Newburgh for awhile and just decided to try this place. Very glad I did! Pies are the best around. Their calzones are huge and delicious! Delivery or pick up. Excellent local pizzeria read more

We were visiting from out of town for a get-together on Sunday. We ordered three large pizzas (and by large, they really mean LARGE!) and a chicken caesar salad for take out. They deliver, but it was right on the way for us. Everything was hot and fresh. The dough and sauce were very good! The plain cheese and meat-lovers' pizzas were the biggest hits; the pepperoni had plenty of pepperoni on it, but it just wasn't as popular. The chicken caesar had a good amount of chicken, and it was deliciously grilled. The salad container was large--easily enough for two lunch-sized entrees--and it came with some very good italian bread on the side. Servings are really generous--we had almost a whole pizza left over. Service was fast and friendly and prices were very reasonable. If we were local, this would definitely be a go-to pizza place. read more

Awful service, bad attitudes and they can't get a delivery order right to save their lives.