5 Stars! Pizza Mia in Newburgh is a total gem! From the moment you walk in, you're hit with that classic pizza parlor vibe--but with a modern, Instagram-famous twist. The slices are massive and packed with plentiful toppings that actually complement each other--some seriously great combos here. The crust? Next-level. That awesome crunch hits just right every time. Service is fast and friendly, and the pizza? Absolutely delicious. You can tell they care about quality, and the prices are more than fair for what you're getting. Only minor downside: the bathroom is tiny, and it's located in a multi-store strip mall with a shared lot--but that's a small trade-off for pizza this good. Do yourself a favor and check this place out--you'll be glad you did! read more

See all

The pizza is definitely the best in this area. Loved the grandma pizza. I had the con parm sandwich. I find the sauce too sweet. No need to add sugar to a sauce.so much sauce made the bread soggy. To be fair it was a delivery service and not eaten right away. I will go back and try other items read more

The food and service is always great but I had the absolute pleasure of receiving a delivery from Collins, and I couldn't be more impressed. This is not the first time he has delivered to our business and I hope its not the last!!! From start to finish, his service was top-notch. He arrived right on time, handled the delivery with care and professionalism, and greeted me with a friendly attitude that genuinely made my day. What really stood out was his attention to detail--he followed delivery instructions perfectly and ensured everything was placed with care. It's clear they take pride in his work, and it shows in the quality of his service. In a world where rushed or careless deliveries are all too common, Collins is a shining example of how it should be done. If every driver were like this, the world would be a better place (and way more efficient)! Thank you, Collins, for being amazing at what you do! Keep up the incredible work! read more

I got my pizza coming straight out the oven, Pizza was weirdly rubbery, the crust hard as a rock, they advertise that they got a big variety of what you can pick out of but when I asked they said they needed a whole day to make a pizza. My advice don't advertise something you can't make or put a thing saying you need time in advance to make the product. Driving 2 hours to try something and you can't even make it, is disappointing. I thought this was going to be really great pizza but I personally wouldn't pay the prices again for how low quality the pizza was, didn't really have flavor. read more

Cozy little restaurant in the Target plaza. Was open during a particularly bad snow event and we were greeted cheerfully. Had some thick crust pizza that I've not been familiar with previously and it was delicious. Also had the rice balls which I probably shouldn't have gone for as they have been sitting there for a minute. Rookie move on my part I should have asked and that's probably why it's not a complete five on my rating. read more

See all

Stellar grandma slice. Flavorful sauce, tender but crispy crust. So good I took the rest available home. Next time I'll order a pie. Only negative was that other slices on display had meat on them. read more

I'm gonna be honest, I was very worried when I walked in because it looked like all they were offering was the food at the front that sits out. It wasn't even kept hot with lights. They do have a menu that shows more options but its still not the whole menu, I had to pick up a paper one to see all the options. Once I did I got more excited. I ended up ordering spaghetti and meatballs and they were good. Nothing to rave about. I would have liked to try the pizza if only it were fresh. When you walk in you need to place your order, wait at the tables, then pay as you leave. I'm sure if I was local I'd eat there again but probably by ordering a pizza delivery not going in person. I will say the guy that served is was really helpful and nice though. Whereas the girl at the counter was a little subdued, but she did her job good. read more

The pizza selection for slices is amazing! If you're are looking for options and unique selection, this is your place. You can almost always count on grandma style slices with vodka sauce, or mozz and basil and/or choices of chicken bacon ranch, Buffalo chicken etc. they even have a deep dish with garlic knot crust! Def eat there, bc it tastes so much better when it fresh and hot!! A little pricey, but you're paying for variety!! read more

So I ordered a Grandma pizza which was delicious. But I also ordered a Stromboli which was a piece of dough filled with toppings in clumps, not even spread out through out! Then just folded over. I called the restaurant and the lady on the phone was SOOOOO RUDE!!! I tried telling her it was more like a calzone, she yelled at me and said no "That's the Stromboli"!!! Absolutely not good customer service!!! read more

Pizza Mia - This is not a Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

I was just told by the employees to "have the day I deserve" after I complained about the quality of the pizza, and told them that it was like sewing through wood. The crust was burned, and the pizza had been sitting there for too long.they insisted on charging me and didn't seem to care whether I left the review or not so here it is. I wouldn't take my dog and they should be ashamed of themselves. read more

What I thought was impossible to find in Orange County has now become easy...VEGAN PIZZA. Pizza Mia pulled through with this garlic knot crust deep deep vegan MEAT HATERS PIE. Great taste and it could probably fool the carnivores out there. 2 draw backs... 1) I had to eat it by myself, so I had a couple of slices a day. The garlic knot crust got a bit dry upon reheating. 2) I know it's vegan but this thing was expensive. Vegan food like this is always more expensive than regular meat prices but this seemed a bit more than I'm used to. Will either of those things stop me from eating Pizza Mia's vegan menu again and again...NOPE. All in all, I'm glad to have this pizzeria only 20 minutes from my house. read more

Pizza Mia - THE MEAT HATERS PIE - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

So I stopped in for take out and decided on these 3 slices. Vodka which was overly sauced with globs of mozzarella. All of the sauce was falling off this slice, don't recommend it. The pizza tasted like cheese and bread. The calamari was interesting; first time ever trying it and was lacking in any sauce or cheese, just tasted like calamari on bread. The star of the show was the caprese slice, I'd definitely come back for that one again! Speciality slices were about $5 each, the portion is pretty small. read more

Pizza Mia - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Pizza is awesome here always great service for pick up and to grab a slice for lunch !

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Their sauce is incredible. Eggplant parm was tasty. Highly recommend going to this shop!

This pizza place is one of the only ones in town with a VEGAN CHEESE PIZZA!! We've looked everywhere in vails gate, New Windsor, and Cornwall but we haven't found a place with a vegan cheese pizza. Pizza Mia not only has a very delicious vegan pizza but they also have a whole hidden vegan and vegetarian menu! It is a hidden menu and not advertised but when we went there they gave us a print out copy of what they offer. They are a little expensive though, around $20 for a medium vegan cheese pizza and a drink. Overall a great pizza place! read more

Pizza Mia - Vegan Menu - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

tried here after picking up a grub hub and it looked interesting, so originally, I thought to get a slice, garlic knots and a meatball sub. The flat bread pizza slices caught my interest, and I got a meatball, calamari and pepperoni slices, plus garlic knots and a desert calzone. my food was ready after I took a walk waiting on it and it was bagged and ready. first, all slices had this great vodka sauce instead of tomato sauce, different but very good. fresh mozzarella balls were yummy, again different then just shredded. All the meats were good and very generous with the portions on the slices. I never seen flat bread pizza at a pizzeria, but hey they rock it well here. Garlic knots were chewy and heavy seasoned with herbs and garlic, glad these were swimming in oil like other places do with just a pool of garlic and oil. marinara sauce was very chucky, could been smoother, since it was more like a salsa then a sauce. Dessert calzone was something I never heard of nor thought it would not exist outside maybe a fair setting. Fried dough was fluffy and had nice slight crunch, cannoli filling was creamy and sweet, very generous with the filling, it oozed out with every slice I cut. drizzle of chocolate sauce and powdered sugar was a nice touch. The calzone was 100% best for sure, glad i know it exist now. read more

Pizza Mia - dessert calzone - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

Employees are always nice and friendly. I absolutely love their penne alla vodka with shrimp.

The BEST pizza in Newburgh. I always order the same thing- a penne alla vodka grandma slice and a margherita slice. They are consistently delicious and the staff are extremely friendly. You will not find a better place for pizza so get here fast and try everything! read more

Amazing pizza. I always get a grandma style with pepperoni & pineapple. The sauce is so good. I'm from Chicago and this is about a close to home I can get flavor wise. My favorite pizza in newburgh. read more

I ordered a personal pie on line with a whole wheat crust. There was an up charge for the crust. When Uber delivered the pie, there was a regular crust. I called the shop to tell them of the mistake and the young woman who answered the phone was very hurried and explained she didn't know why that was still on there. I asked if she gave me credit for something they weren't giving me. She said I would have to contact Uber. I got no refund there either. I thought later, why didn't PizzaMia just call me and let me know before sending out a product I didn't ask for. I looked up their current menu. That crust is on there as well. All of those unrefunded dollars add up. Not fair to us consumers, our taste buds or wallets! Do better. Unfortunately their chicken cheesesteak was very unconventional. Onions and peppers were not well cooked and cheese competed with taste instead of blending in. I have had a slice of their penne al a vodka and margharita pizza on site that was excellent so decided to get a home delivery of other menu items. Those item were a mistake and I was very put off by the young lady. read more

Pizza Mia - THIS IS NOT the whole wheat crust they advertise on their on line and paper menus. - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

If you ever in Newburgh NY area you have to try this place , great pizza and the employees were wonderful people I order 2 pies one cheese only and the other one white pizza I told them im delivering this in Michigan believe me almost both pies were gone before I made it to Michigan lol yummmmm read more

Not a place you would bring a date to impress, but a friend that was really hungry for Italinan junk food would be pleased to eat there. The pizza slices are good, but the Stromboli is a real treat. You will want to go back for more. A hidden gem in the Target plaza. read more

If you want your cheese ON your pizza by the time you get it, don't order from Pizza Mia in newburgh. I wouldn't say anything if it was the first time, and if I hadn't specifically put in the "special instructions" to be careful this happened before. However it did, and when I called to discuss it with them afterwards since I was disappointed the guy on the phone sounded annoyed I even called and didn't really give a shit ‍. At least it wasn't as bad as the first time. read more

Pizza Mia - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

HORRIBLE pizza. Tasted sour and dry cardboard crust. Brought it to the owners attention Brian and he didn't want to hear it. Go somewhere else If I could give no stars, I would read more

Favorite pizza spot!! Service is always amazing.. Pizza is consistently great, what else an you ask for!!! read more

When I moved to the area I tried out many pizza places and Pizza Mia, Newburgh is my favorite. Pizza is thin and the mozzarella is incredibly fresh, not to mention the sauce is amazing. The staff is always friendly and delivery is always always fast and polite. Certainly a favorite. read more

It is a banner day!!! Another 5 star event. If you want ambience, don't come here. If you want really good pizza you have found your spot. The ingredients are fresh, the oil important, the cheese is gooey and bubbly. I have eaten the middle of my pizza and have saved the crust for last. I can't tell you about any of the other food but if it's anything like the pizza, you won't go wrong. Don't forget my father for most people's father in World War II for the Italians. I know pizza read more

I stumbled upon this pizza place by accident. NO IDEA there would be so much variety - I stopped in for a slice and stayed for 2...they have vegetarian options too which not all places do! Thank you Brian! read more

Pizza Mia - Amazing pizza. Not too salty, or oily. Which is a good thing, add as much as you want. Had an amazing chat with the owner. Thanks again! - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

What can I say, I'm really on the fence about this place. I love pizza, can eat it every day, and did while I was a pizza man in my youth. But, $22.95 for a 16" " large" pie delivered before tip? Requested well-done but got burned instead, large is only a 16", and $22 effin 95 for a plain pie? GTFO, if it was coal or wood oven with fresh mozzarella on it, yeah, ok. But an average pizza? Nah. Oh, before any moron claims that I'm broke so that's my problem? Nah, sorry, far from it, but nobody accumulates wealth spending twice what items are worth. If this was the old Randone's up here or Lombardo's or even Leotardo's, sure, I'd pay $30 for that no problem. But this? No please. read more

This pizza spot is the BOMB! The gourmet slices are amazing; my favorite is the pesto, roasted red pepper, artichoke heart, mozzarella.. that flavor combo is a game changer. My go-tos are: - antipasto salad (so so good, packed with meats and cheese) - wings are perfect - baked ziti with vodka sauce - any gourmet slice Eat here. You won't be disappointed. read more

If I didn't need to give 1 star I wouldn't. Ordered a sausage parm and eggplant sub with a rice ball. Horrible sauce similar to what I'd expect ragu to task like and burnt bread on the subs (more burnt than not). On the eggplant sub it seemed like they didn't have enough eggplant and tried to stretch out what they had for it. The rice ball was just horrible and for $8 that's very sad. I would totally tell others not to waste their money here read more

So many fun options for pizza! Loved the mozzarella sticks on the slices. The small pepperonis crisp up perfectly. This is about 30min away from our vacation home and we always make sure it's a stop on our way! read more

See all

Wow wow wow. First of all Brian was extremely kind to me over the phone while I described a convoluted order and he explained to me exactly why my weird request wouldn't exactly work. And I appreciate that! Cause the choice he recommended was magnificent. The pizza is top notch, the presentation... don't get me started. This is art. And Collin! The delivery driver! Thank you for coming straight to me you didn't have to! Appreciate your kindness and customer service. Pizza Mia is THAT place to visit or order from read more

Pizza Mia - One of the greatest pies I've ever witnessed - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

I was in the area and figured to grab a couple of quick slices to bring home for dinner. I had two buffalo slices and they had to be the worst I've ever had. The crust you burnt so bad you couldn't even eat it! Not even sure what ingredients were used but it looked like something you'd find in a dumpster! Absolute crap. Please do yourself a favor and stay away from this place. Lesson learned, stick with planet pizza in Newburgh. That place is a real pizza shop not like these wannabes. read more

Wish I could give this a zero, I placed an order over the phone it was my first time ordering and the lady was rude. I was not able to pick up my order due to the fact that I got into an accident and I kindly called back and canceled my order the same lady asked why I was canceling and why I wasn't able to pick up my food with a rude tone I proceeded to inform her that I had gotten into and accident and and she said uh ok and hung up. I will not be ordering from this place they need to learn customer service. read more

My Husband and I usually get the Gourmet Slices from Pizza Mia we Love getting them that we would usually order 4, 5, or 6 different Gourmet Slices.It became such a habit. Wednesday, February 10th. 2021. We decided that we would have a pie instead of the Gourmet Slices NEVER AGAIN ARE WE GETTING A PIE AGAIN! We will stick with the Gourmet Slices Because we Love getting them. My husband ordered a Medium Pizza Pie It cost him $21.00 $16.00 for the pie and the rest for a tip. We go home he opens up the box the look on his face said it all VERY DISAPPOINTED in the way that the pizza looked. He had to cut the pizza because only one slice was cut both of us were VERY DISAPPOINTED in the way that the pizza looked and tasted. It was the WORST that we've ever had. We are wondering if the girl in Pizza Mia even listened to my husband when he first went in and ordered I stayed in the car and I also stayed in the car when he went in to get the pie. If only we had known he wouldn't of had to waste his money! I gave Pizza Mia a very nice review regarding the Gourmet Slices that we got that I was even saying Mama Mia We Love Pizza Mia but definitely not today we don't! read more

Pizza Mia - THE WORST PIZZA PIE!!! - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

I think their pizza was great but the salad was uneatable they obviously did not wash the lettuce. Gritty full is dirt! Don't know of I'll return because of their food prep read more

Delivered to the auto auction down the road that we were working at. Delivery guy was nice but pizza box was dented so we already knew the pizza would be a mess. Low and behold it was. Pizza was good tasting but delivery driver needs some work. read more

Pizza Mia - Messy pizza delivery - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

So, my boyfriend and I went to Pizza Mia a few times in the past, and we thought it was a great place. They even have their pizzeria named "the best pizza place in Newburgh" Well, we decided to order for them to deliver and I have to say - I and my family were not pleased by the results. The minute that I opened the pizza box, there were several things that caught my eye: 1. As indicated in the photo, the cheese was sloppy to the side and there was grease all in the corner of the box 2. The side of the crust was burnt 3. I ordered half pepperoni and half plain, but you can tell that it looks like only two slices and a small slice had bunch of pepperoni slapped on it ON ONLY THREE SLICES. Not to mention, the pie did not look even. When trying to call and tell them what happened and That I did not like the ordered received, the lady on the other end started arguing with me! She claimed to tell me that "she already saw the pizza" and that "everything was fine". I'm trying to not shout back at her even though she's doing most of the yelling and tell her that I am looking at it and that if she wants to see proof I would send it to her. It went back and fourth for a few minutes but in the end, I just hung up. I didn't need the added the stress. I ate the pizza, but it didn't seem as satisfying as when I had eaten it previously. Very disappointed by the pizza, service, and how I was treated. read more

Pizza Mia - This pizza looks a mess. . . - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Hands down the worst pizza I have ever had. Actually embarrassing considering it's a pizza parlor in NY. The girl behind the cash register needs to find a job that doesn't involve catering to customers. Maybe she should make the pizza. read more