Order Cosimo's Takeout or Delivery
Cosimo's Photos
Business Info
Cosimo's Popular Dishes
COSIMO'S ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Cosimo's
Recommended Reviews - Cosimo's
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Still 5 Stars!! We had my mother's 70th birthday day here and they made the dinner amazing.
Stopped here on the way back from a hike bc it was a packed asf so we thought it has to be amazing but it was just fine. Service kinda lackluster, and food was alright. Got the Spicy Fennel Sausage pizza which had decent flavor but not enough cheese, good amount of meat but that made it incredibly soggy. Tried a friend's Spinach and Bacon which I enjoyed more.
Despite the parking lot being full I was seated quickly for my solo date out during dinner. The ambiance is comfortable lighting with a buzzing dinner crowd. Some people are dressed casual; some are definitely here on date night. I started with a Pellegrino which came chilled to the perfect temperature and I was given a cup sans ice (real cute), it would've been cutier in a chilled martini glass but I didn't ask either. I ordered the seafood chowder, this had more spice than I expected and was absolutely delicious a very balanced light silky soup. For dinner I had the shrimp scampi pizza, which had a phenomenal cheese pull and was pipping hot when it came out, no notes. Absolutely delicious. For dessert I got a Cannoli and espresso martini. &on Good Friday, what a Good Friday indeed. Thanks for a great dinner 10/10 everything tasted exactly or better than I imagined it would. Ps this martini is hitting
I had such a great experience at Cosimo's! The food was delicious from start to finish. The pasta was creamy, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The calamari was crispy and fresh, and those waffle fries were SO good - super crunchy with great seasoning. The cocktails were amazing too, beautifully made and really tasty, especially the pear martini and the pink cocktail. The ambiance was cozy with a nice vibe, and it was a great place to relax, enjoy good food, and have drinks with friends. Definitely a spot I'd come back to!
Nice spot with plenty of tables. Our server was wonderful. Food was delicious. I got the spinach and mushroom ravioli. The olive bread with olive oil that they initially brought us was excellent. We also ordered the waffle potatoes with Gorgonzola. These weren't my favorite but I just don't think I'm a fan of Gorgonzola. My friend really liked them!
Alert for All: Food Poisoning Risk: I would generally 100% avoid this establishment for anything beyond containerized beverages. Sun night my wife had the shrimp dish w/ kale + rice. We had scheduled an event at West Point for Mon, but she got sick at night and vommitted 2x in AM, and then health state improved markedly over the day. Mon events at USMA were ruled out, so primary purpose of the trip was never realized. In the moment, Sun night, my wife thought the shrimp and/or kale might be slightly off but attributed it to seasoning. My pizza was topped w/ uncooked diced tomato, and was substandard vs any 'Made in Italy' frozen pizza prepared in home oven...cardboard crust and Sysco vegetables. I wrote an email to Cosimos management and three hours later made an in-person visit. The on-duty Asst. Manager was dismissive out of hand, claimed it all a matter for the 'corporate office', and said it would normally take more than a day to respond to a report of food poisoning. It was a tone-deaf, brush-off effort, given that I had privately contacted the offices and showed in person to inform them of the issue. An uncaring, non-urgent, and quasi-contemptuous response to a rather serious matter. I am attaching a photo of the vommit which shows a linkage between contents of the 'meal' and my wife's sickness. I have lived a long life and understand something about food-induced illness and causation. Given the indifference of management and their cavalier attitude, I thought I should post this...and as a warning to anyone considering this establishment as a dining option.
We got 2 things to share: the Turkey Artichoke Sandwich and the Wild Mushroom Pizza. Both were fantastic and the service was amazing. The Turkey Artichoke Sandwich is more like a wrap/quesadilla, they make it with a tortilla. We got it with a side of Caesar Salad and it was a great lunch option. The Wild Mushroom Pizza was also so fragrant and I loved the pairing of the mushrooms with the cherry tomatoes! Def would come back if I were ever in the area again.
Quick take out dinner. Broccoli rabe and sausage. They make it so good. Nice crumbling sausage. A lot of juice not dried out. Wish more broccoli rabe. Asked for there olive bread omg it's so good
Usually go to the Newburgh restaurant however we came over here because they still have the broccoli rabe with sausage bowtie pasta option on the menu which isn't on the Newburgh one. This place definitely has a homier feel than the Newburgh restaurant. We were seated in the bar area which was really nice and comfortable, and the service was with us almost instantly. They have some really great bartenders and we were looked in on quite often during the appetizer portion of our meal and all through the entrees. The servings are quite massive to be honest so appetizers might be on the back burner or at least split one. Nice spot for a date night or just to meet with friends, especially in that back room off to the side. They have a couple of TVs on the wall to watch the games or you can sit at the bar as well.
The restaurant has a typical low-light, quiet background noise set-up with both tables and booths spanning two rooms. I came with a fairly large group (8 people) and were able to get seating on a weekday night without issue. I ordered the Spicy Chicken Fusilli and an Espresso Martini and loved both. Definitely an Italian-American place, rather than straight Italian, as I tasted a hint of Frank's Red Hot in the pasta but I still enjoyed it very much.
I got to admit, I was very pleasantly surprised! Atmosphere is pleasant (choppy but pleasant,) and the service was fast. We ordered the swordfish, ravioli, and salmon, all of which were great! The prices were on the higher side, but the portions were quite generous, particularly for the fish. No complaints!
I only found out after we ate there that this is a chain restaurant, and so I'm glad I didn't let that have an impact on whether we would try it -- 'cause it was really good! They don't take reservations, but our group of 3 was seated right away, even on a Saturday night. The place was packed, and our table was in the bar, so it was a bit loud. But we weren't rushed at all by our wonderful server, whose name I wish I'd gotten! Although Cosimo's seems to be know for it's pizza, we ended up getting pasta and chicken dishes. We shared the crispy mozzarella to start, although we didn't see or taste the prosciutto that was supposed to be inside it. I had spaghetti Sicilian (eggplant, tomato sauce, mozzarella) and really enjoyed it. Light and flavorful. One person in our party got the chicken francese; also a light dish (it comes with pasta), and I thought perhaps too light. There was very little lemon flavor to it. The third person got the grilled chicken penne without the olives. We all tasted everyones; I thought the pesto was a bit bitter, but it still worked with the combination of other flavors. The bread and olive oil were all fabulous, and again, our server was super helpful. Even with a mix of reviews on what we had, we definitely plan to return, whether here or at another one of their locations.
3 months ago
The hardest part of the experience was deciding what to order because the menu had so many great options. I ended up going with the classic Chicken Francese. It's not something I usually order since I normally like to try specials or different pasta dishes, but it was the perfect choice. We started with the fried calamari, and it was easily one of my favorite appetizers. If you're like me and love the tentacle pieces, you'll be happy because there were plenty! It was fried perfectly, and the marinara sauce had just the right amount of spice to give it an extra kick. To finish the meal, I ordered the tiramisu, and it was the perfect ending. It was moist, rich, and soaked just enough to give it that classic tiramisu flavor without being overpowering. Between the delicious food, the extensive menu, and the overall experience, Cosimo's is definitely a place I'll be coming back to. There are still so many dishes I want to try! read more
5 days ago
4 months ago
Delicious. The food is delicious. The ambience is amazing. And it was a great choice for a group dinner. We started out with a bunch of appetizers. Meatballs. Calamari. Potato wedges. And a few other things. Everyone got a chance to enjoy it all. Oh..... the bread with the Olives and Oil.... Chefs Kiss. So good. I brought some bread back to my hotel along with my leftovers. That's how good it is. For my entree I got the Spicy Chicken Fusilli. It comes with Fontina cheese which I got it kind of light. I really enjoyed my pasta. The right amount of spice. Perfect. I would definitely give this place a 10/10 and hope to return one day. read more
30 days ago
Still 5 Stars!! We had my mother's 70th birthday day here and they made the dinner amazing. read more
2 months ago
Stopped here on the way back from a hike bc it was a packed asf so we thought it has to be amazing but it was just fine. Service kinda lackluster, and food was alright. Got the Spicy Fennel Sausage pizza which had decent flavor but not enough cheese, good amount of meat but that made it incredibly soggy. Tried a friend's Spinach and Bacon which I enjoyed more. read more
6 months ago
Despite the parking lot being full I was seated quickly for my solo date out during dinner. The ambiance is comfortable lighting with a buzzing dinner crowd. Some people are dressed casual; some are definitely here on date night. I started with a Pellegrino which came chilled to the perfect temperature and I was given a cup sans ice (real cute), it would've been cutier in a chilled martini glass but I didn't ask either. I ordered the seafood chowder, this had more spice than I expected and was absolutely delicious a very balanced light silky soup. For dinner I had the shrimp scampi pizza, which had a phenomenal cheese pull and was pipping hot when it came out, no notes. Absolutely delicious. For dessert I got a Cannoli and espresso martini. &on Good Friday, what a Good Friday indeed. Thanks for a great dinner 10/10 everything tasted exactly or better than I imagined it would. Ps this martini is hitting read more
I had such a great experience at Cosimo's! The food was delicious from start to finish. The pasta was creamy, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The calamari was crispy and fresh, and those waffle fries were SO good - super crunchy with great seasoning. The cocktails were amazing too, beautifully made and really tasty, especially the pear martini and the pink cocktail. The ambiance was cozy with a nice vibe, and it was a great place to relax, enjoy good food, and have drinks with friends. Definitely a spot I'd come back to! read more
6 months ago
Nice spot with plenty of tables. Our server was wonderful. Food was delicious. I got the spinach and mushroom ravioli. The olive bread with olive oil that they initially brought us was excellent. We also ordered the waffle potatoes with Gorgonzola. These weren't my favorite but I just don't think I'm a fan of Gorgonzola. My friend really liked them! read more
2 months ago
Alert for All: Food Poisoning Risk: I would generally 100% avoid this establishment for anything beyond containerized beverages. Sun night my wife had the shrimp dish w/ kale + rice. We had scheduled an event at West Point for Mon, but she got sick at night and vommitted 2x in AM, and then health state improved markedly over the day. Mon events at USMA were ruled out, so primary purpose of the trip was never realized. In the moment, Sun night, my wife thought the shrimp and/or kale might be slightly off but attributed it to seasoning. My pizza was topped w/ uncooked diced tomato, and was substandard vs any 'Made in Italy' frozen pizza prepared in home oven...cardboard crust and Sysco vegetables. I wrote an email to Cosimos management and three hours later made an in-person visit. The on-duty Asst. Manager was dismissive out of hand, claimed it all a matter for the 'corporate office', and said it would normally take more than a day to respond to a report of food poisoning. It was a tone-deaf, brush-off effort, given that I had privately contacted the offices and showed in person to inform them of the issue. An uncaring, non-urgent, and quasi-contemptuous response to a rather serious matter. I am attaching a photo of the vommit which shows a linkage between contents of the 'meal' and my wife's sickness. I have lived a long life and understand something about food-induced illness and causation. Given the indifference of management and their cavalier attitude, I thought I should post this...and as a warning to anyone considering this establishment as a dining option. read more
1 month ago
2 months ago
We got 2 things to share: the Turkey Artichoke Sandwich and the Wild Mushroom Pizza. Both were fantastic and the service was amazing. The Turkey Artichoke Sandwich is more like a wrap/quesadilla, they make it with a tortilla. We got it with a side of Caesar Salad and it was a great lunch option. The Wild Mushroom Pizza was also so fragrant and I loved the pairing of the mushrooms with the cherry tomatoes! Def would come back if I were ever in the area again. read more
4 months ago
7 months ago
2 years ago
Usually go to the Newburgh restaurant however we came over here because they still have the broccoli rabe with sausage bowtie pasta option on the menu which isn't on the Newburgh one. This place definitely has a homier feel than the Newburgh restaurant. We were seated in the bar area which was really nice and comfortable, and the service was with us almost instantly. They have some really great bartenders and we were looked in on quite often during the appetizer portion of our meal and all through the entrees. The servings are quite massive to be honest so appetizers might be on the back burner or at least split one. Nice spot for a date night or just to meet with friends, especially in that back room off to the side. They have a couple of TVs on the wall to watch the games or you can sit at the bar as well. read more
The restaurant has a typical low-light, quiet background noise set-up with both tables and booths spanning two rooms. I came with a fairly large group (8 people) and were able to get seating on a weekday night without issue. I ordered the Spicy Chicken Fusilli and an Espresso Martini and loved both. Definitely an Italian-American place, rather than straight Italian, as I tasted a hint of Frank's Red Hot in the pasta but I still enjoyed it very much. read more
I got to admit, I was very pleasantly surprised! Atmosphere is pleasant (choppy but pleasant,) and the service was fast. We ordered the swordfish, ravioli, and salmon, all of which were great! The prices were on the higher side, but the portions were quite generous, particularly for the fish. No complaints! read more
10 months ago
3 years ago
I only found out after we ate there that this is a chain restaurant, and so I'm glad I didn't let that have an impact on whether we would try it -- 'cause it was really good! They don't take reservations, but our group of 3 was seated right away, even on a Saturday night. The place was packed, and our table was in the bar, so it was a bit loud. But we weren't rushed at all by our wonderful server, whose name I wish I'd gotten! Although Cosimo's seems to be know for it's pizza, we ended up getting pasta and chicken dishes. We shared the crispy mozzarella to start, although we didn't see or taste the prosciutto that was supposed to be inside it. I had spaghetti Sicilian (eggplant, tomato sauce, mozzarella) and really enjoyed it. Light and flavorful. One person in our party got the chicken francese; also a light dish (it comes with pasta), and I thought perhaps too light. There was very little lemon flavor to it. The third person got the grilled chicken penne without the olives. We all tasted everyones; I thought the pesto was a bit bitter, but it still worked with the combination of other flavors. The bread and olive oil were all fabulous, and again, our server was super helpful. Even with a mix of reviews on what we had, we definitely plan to return, whether here or at another one of their locations. read more
7 months ago
Stopped here for a late dinner while driving upstate and I was surprised by how great everything was! Our server was super sweet and the ambiance was relaxed and family friendly. My 2 friends and I shared the CBO Burger, Grilled Chicken Pizza, and Ravioli con Mozzarella. The burger was very well cooked and juicy, the chicken pizza was extremely flavorful and the ravioli was spot on! Loved every bite! read more
Restaurant Review: I've ordered takeout from this location many times, and the food consistently impresses. Today, I ordered fried calamari, the wood fire margherita pizza, a Caesar salad, and the sun-dried tomato penne alla vodka. Among them, the penne alla vodka remains my favorite. Upon picking up the food, I noticed the restaurant was bustling, especially for a Saturday night. It's become my go-to spot for ordering food for my office staff. read more
2 years ago
Great food Great atmosphere Table bread is cold...I don't get it why not heat up the bread the oven is right there it onlytakes a minute to serve nice toasty bread...SMH read more
I was in the area so I decided to stop by and have some of their fantastic pizza. I went withNick's pie, a favorite. The pie is way too large for me to finish on my own so I took it home for lunch the next day along with a piece of tiramisu for later that evening. That was quite disappointing as it lacked much flavor. read more
3 years ago
The drink menu!! Golly it's good. I tell the kitchen to make any pasta dish gluten free and vegan and every single time I do this, the dish is frickin incredible!!! They use different veggies each time. Just to accomodate an allergy and preference read more
9 months ago
9 months ago
10 months ago
The food all tasted well. Everything was properly salted. Pizzas were great. ORDER ALL THE PIZZAS & flatbreads, the ones at the next table looked good too! NOTE, calamari is drenched in sauce, you have to tell them earlier on if you don't want it smothered, it takes away from the crispy-ness. I asked right before they brought it out but the waiter was hesitant to ask the kitchen to remake it. He instead said they already cooked it. Then about 5 mins later he brought it out and when I asked again, He asked, "do I really want to send it back?" Because of his tone I kept it, which I truly regret. My waiter was polite but seemed like till he was going through the motions. The brussel sprouts were soggy (don't order) the meat balls were ok, good enough for my kids but nothing exciting. The rooms were divided up in the restaurant so it could easily be a nice place to host a small event. Now the spicy chicken fusilli was hands down the most delicious thing ever I'd order this again 2x I wish I tried more of the pasta but I was full from dipping all the bread in my seafood bisque! read more
1 year ago
2 years ago
2 years ago
6 months ago
Omg the food is finger-licking good! We sadly skipped the appetizers and headed straight for the entrees. We ordered the Herb Baked Shrimp (with wild rice) and the Formaggi pizza. For drinks we ordered Pomango Twist () and the Cosimo Punch. The first bite of food was the pizza... and the first words were "oh my... so good." It was an explosion of flavor in my mouth. The herb shrimp was so savory and the kale was amazing!!!! We were stuffed with all the meals, we didn't even get to order dessert. However, we did order more meals to go. We had the Shrimp Risotto and the Woodfire Snapper. Both meals were great for a very late 'snack' and early meal, lol. Lastly, the service was awesome. The waitress, I believe her name was Julie (sorry if it isn't) was very friendly, kind, and patient. Do I recommend this place, umm YES. We are already planning on taking a trip up north again to visit. read more
Passed this place numerous times and ignored- all my friends told me I have to stop and ignored... we finally stopped and now I'm upset because I did not listen. Super good Italian food! One of my favorites now for Italian food in the Harriman area . read more
1 year ago
3.5 / 5.0 - We came here for an early lunch before an afternoon of outlet shopping at Woodbury Commons. The restaurant was spacious with high ceilings and our server was very attentive, but the food was subpar. We ordered the following for 2 to share: - Toscano Pear Salad ($14+) The salad was nice, with arugula, pear, pecorino toscano and prosecco vinaigrette. It had a little too much dressing for our taste, though, and we should have asked for it on the side. - Mozzarella Fresca Pizza ($16+) This wood fired pizza was underwhelming. The ratio of the ingredients was unbalanced and the pizza completely fell apart as we were trying to eat it. The crust wasn't great, but perhaps, the Margherita would have been better. read more
Page 1 of 10
More info about Cosimo's
100 State Rt 32
Woodbury, NY 10917
Directions
(845) 928-5222
Call Now
Visit Website
http://cosimosgroup.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
More Info
Health Score
Ask the Community - Cosimo's
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
25 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
2 years ago
6 years ago
9 years ago
7 years ago
15 years ago
13 years ago
11 years ago
12 years ago
11 years ago
8 years ago
7 years ago
12 years ago
2 years ago
1 year ago
16 years ago
14 years ago
9 years ago
14 years ago
13 years ago
13 years ago
