I had been really looking forward to this restaurant, so when we needed a restaurant for a special…read moreoccasion, it was a great opportunity to try it. It was on, but for the prices it was not great. The food was just ok. I had to swat gnats away from my wine (we were inside), had to ask for regular butter for the bread and it came out in little packets that you had to peel open. I'm not above that, but not when the bill was so high. I have never not liked the house wine at a restaurant and after trying a cab and a Merlot. Service was not the best either

Beautifully restored old building, great atmosphere…read more Creative cocktails, appetizers, and entrées. Great flavors. Nice Italian wine selection at reasonable prices. Attentive service.

This is my go to celebration spot for special occasions. Stopped in to celebrate a milestone and…read morethe food and service were exactly as I expected! Food is absolutely superb and staff is amazing. Ambience is always one of a business or romantic setting but it looks and feels upscale so it's perfect for either occasion. My occasion was a romantic celebration. God continues to bless me beyond measure.

Really great find close to legoland when looking for a great dining experience or classy bar. We've…read morebeen two years in a row and great experience each time -- accommodating total party of 9 including kids on Saturday night same week. Ambience/atmosphere: dimly light chic but still approachable. Great Halloween decor. Very chic bar area. White table cloths. Waiters in sports coats. Interior does not match the external. Very surprising. Service: very approachable and not stuffy. Tons of waitstaff assistants despite main waiters sometimes being less absence. Goods news is they'll grab them if you ask or there's a question or request they can't attend to. Drinks come quickly. Kids food came almost immediately. Love the iPad menus. Gave us a burrata salad for free without asking when a dish was slightly messed up. Food: the pasta is a must. Make sure to hear the specials. Salumi and cheese board is large. All portions are large. Quality ingredients. Many legit Italian dishes. Refined but decadent. Veal, beef, and seafood are primo. Many vegetarian dishes enjoyed. Drinks: really well done diverse cocktails. The pumpkin martini sounds like a setup for failure but was well balanced, not too sweet, and refreshing. Old fashioned spins are always a hit. Great liquor and wine selection including great bottles at every price range. Price: may be pricey for New York State but a deal for fine dining and drinks outside a metro area. We will stay return customers!

We stopped here one night after our games at The Rock with a few other families. I've looked into…read moreit ahead and had high expectations going in. Plenty of parking in a lot behind the establishment. Restaurant is in a very nice and clean "small town downtown. " We had reservations and was seated within 15 minutes upon arrival. Inside was casual, quaint and everyone went above and beyond. For an appetizer, we went with the Margherita pizza, I had to get a French Onion Soup and for dinner I got the chicken parm with angel hair. Don't ask why, I was in the mood for it. The pizza was excellent. Fresh sauce and mootz. Slight crisp to the crust. We were all pleasantly surprised. The French Onion Soup was also done correctly. Properly seasoned and the perfect amount of cheese. The chicken parm was solid. A good portion of fresh chicken breasts. Sauce was solid. Perfect way to end the weekend. Don't snooze on this place if you're in the area!

Came here as part of our date night with my boyfriend. He's never been before and I wanted him to…read moretry it. Well, he absolutely loved it. The food was amazing. It's fancy, But yet, casual. family oriented and very nicely set up. we both had the surf and turf. It was absolutely delicious. Pricing is reasonable and we didn't have to wait. The steak was cooked to perfection and so was the shrimp. This is definitely a place that we will visit again. Whether for a lunch or a dinner, if you're in the area, definitely stop by.

The quintessential diamond in the rough. A little out of the way but worth the drive. Great pizza…read moreand the rest of the menu is off the charts. I had the best penne ala vodka and Caesar salad ever. AND the garlic knots are not of this world. Make sure you stop by soon.

I've loved this place for so many years but I have to say it tastes like they've fallen off. Pizza…read moredoesn't taste as good as it used to taste for years. Something has changed, I'm thinking the sauce. Service and family that runs the business are amazing and seating in the shop is dismal at best. Time for me to re-evaluate the other shops in town and make a switch. :o(

I'm B-A-C-K! Stopped in because my local fav pizza joint has been missing the mark but Sorrentos…read morehas stepped up. Grabbed a slice with ronni and it was bussin' I'm gonna keep visiting and giving the spot a chance. Hopefully any pies I order look fresh to order and wait times aren't upwards of four hours like years ago. This place does have nice seating though, both inside and outside. I don't know if outdoor seating is setup in winter but I can totally sit in snow on bench eating a hot pizza. Looking forward to trying other stuff like their heroes and shit.

I have to share the BEST experience I had today…read more I tripped over my own shoes and accidentally dropped my pizza, and one of the workers -- who I believe may be the owner -- came running over to help me. He was so incredibly kind and genuinely went above and beyond to save the day for me. He could have easily just left me there to deal with it, but instead, he showed such compassion, kindness, and exceptional customer service. It honestly meant more to me than he probably realizes. Of course, the pizza is delicious, but exceptional service like this is what makes a business truly stand out. From now on, whenever I want pizza, this is THE pizzeria I'm going to. Thank you for turning what could have been a really embarrassing and frustrating moment into something I'll actually remember with a smile. You went above and beyond, and I truly appreciate you!

We had our belated holiday party at Pharmacy Kitchen and Bar, and it was the perfect choice! The…read moreatmosphere was fun and inviting, and the owners were incredibly accommodating when we had to move our reservation earlier due to an incoming winter storm. Our group of eight was seated by a front window, giving us a beautiful snowy street view of the village of Goshen--such a cozy touch! The food was excellent. The appetizers were larger than expected and perfect for sharing--the kimchi on the cucumber salad was amazing, and we absolutely devoured the burrata. Our entrées were just as delicious, and a few of us were so full we had to take some home. Despite the busy night, the staff was friendly, attentive, and on top of our orders. A fantastic experience all around--we can't wait to come back!

Love the potential!…read more As we walked in, we were thinking, "this a 5 Star gem in the land of Goshen." The groove of 70's music was playing at the perfect volume, the lighting was soft but not too bark. We sat in the round table in the back corner with a view of the entire joint! Everything thing was great, UNTIL, the cook received a FaceTime call from his girl five minutes after we sat down. FaceTime, without earbuds, which means, speaker at max volume the entire time we were there. (45 minutes) At one point, the cook needed to refill his water bottle to wash down the food he was eating while cooking our aged Prime steaks. ( the bill was $190) Still on the FaceTime call with volume on max, he cluelessly walked by our table. We were thinking the bartender and server would say something to him as he got water at the bar, but they were too busy making googly eyes and playing touchy-feely with each other to notice. Then, a manly gentleman walked in liked he owned the place with an adorable little girl and we were thinking this guy put an end the cook's call. Well, we thought wrong, it appeared the little girl was the bartender's daughter. When man and little girl left, the sever and bartender went back to giggling and touching as the cook rambled on with his lady on FaceTime. (side note, as with the cook, my wife and I both speak Spanish, but it would not be appropriate for us to share with you what their conversation was about) Long story short, our hopes were dashed even though the food wasn't bad. We can only imagine the beauty 5 star we would have written if we did not have to listen to a Novela with our meal.

Brought my daughter and bestie here. We loved the food and…read morecustomer service ! I visited here a few times and everything is always good in the past . We love the cornbread especially

This place is incredible! From the food to the vibe, you feel very relaxed and welcomed. Had their…read moreAMAZING a korean broccoli tonight after thinking about it for the past 4 years! Still just as good as before. We also ordered the bone marrow and escargot appetizer which comes with bread on the side. I never tried either foods but I was blown away. The flavor was incredible on both dishes. For entrees I ordered the vodka burrata pasta with sausage and pesto. It was really good, and my husband ordered the salmon and gnocchi. The salmon was cooked perfectly. The waiter was pleasant and friendly. This place is a must visit!

We stopped here as a halfway point between NYC and Cooperstown…read more We ordered both pizzas and sandwiches. The pizzas are about 25 centimeters in size and can easily be shared, or enjoyed individually if you're hungry. The sandwiches are also generous enough to share. The pizza here is incredible, with a perfectly executed crust. The house salad is made with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and onions, served with a balsamic dressing. Everything tasted very fresh and crisp. Cosimo's does not disappoint.

Love this place! Haven't been here in a long time so it was way over due! Stopped in for date night…read morewith girlfriend and I had my absolute favorite "pasta del la Nona". Location is perfect because then after dinner you can hit the brewery just around the corner to continue a date. Perfect date night scenario. Service is awesome, ambience is perfect and I love this place. Give me pasta or give me death!

We're from NY & NJ, lived in VA, FL, NC, been to Italy... I think this is the best pizza we've ever…read morehad. We got a large sicilian- 1/2 plain, 1/2 cheese (for the picky tiny humans.) The crust was crisp, buttery, fluffy, and perfect. The sauce isn't too sweet or chunky- it's delicious. The cheese is thick and stretchy and delightful. It was the best piece of pizza we've hAd in a long time... if not ever. No joke. I don't want to over sell it, but... it was pure magic. The beef empanadas were SO good, we had to get some to go. Deliciously crispy crust and just simple seasoned beef inside. My mother-in-law makes them with veggies, ketchup, and all kinds of stuff and they're very good, but these are simple savory pockets of meat that everyone loved, even our picky kids. The meatball parm hero was devoured. I'm really particular about the texture of my meatballs (gotta be like mom made them), but the bread, cheese, and sauce were again, perfection. The other two adults loved it all. We fed five of us for like $58 with a half a pie & 4 empanadas leftover. We thought it was very reasonably priced. On top of it, it had a very local, hometown feel with nice people cooking and serving. We have a couple of kids with an egg allergy, but they knew quickly what was safe. What they didn't now off hand, they were happy to research. I doubt we'll ever have reason to be in Goshen in the future (on trip to Legoland is enough for me) but not getting to eat this food again makes me sad. So I had to tell everyone else. Bon appétit!

ordered DoorDash deliver, middle of summer. Pizza arrived cold. Dasher traveled 3/4 of a mile…read morestraight from the restaurant to me. $25 for pepperoni pizza that arrived cold with the thinnest amount of cheese possible. obviously they don't care about their product or customers.

Always delicious, always fantastic and always on point with selection, price and quickness of your…read moreorder.

We ordered from here for an office lunch. We had it delivered. They were very easy to order from…read moreand their delivery service was quick and efficient. My colleagues all had pizza I ordered their chopped Italian salad with balsamic vinaigrette since I can't eat grains. The portion was generous. It was one of the best salads that I had in a long time. I will definitely be ordering this again in the future.