Stumbled upon this gem while trying to find a spot to sit a party of 9. Without a reservation we waited an hour and a half. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Vibe is "stay a while, eat, sip your wine and enjoy conversation" which is exactly what we wanted.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Food were excellent! Highly recommend this place. read more

See all

What a little gem not to far of of the NY Thruway. All are drinks and food was delicious. Our waiter and helper was excellent. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Cute little place.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

Rack of Lamb dish is something to talk about. The service is a polite and indulging atmosphere. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The ambiance sets the mood for good dining.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Tried the Chicken Marsala and Clams Linguine ala Vongole. The service was good, but the food was lacking Italian gusto. Not sure what the sauce on the chicken was, but definitely not marsala which should be creamy and rich with flavor. Ugh! A failure. The Clams dish was below average in flavor. Definitely needed more garlic, better white wine, just pretty blah. Usually one of my favorites. Sorry, won't be returning. read more

My favorite Italian restaurant in New Windsor! Such great flavorful food! Wonderful staff! [[HIGHLIGHT]]The ambiance is mellow and peaceful even on the busiest nights![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I love their desserts! They even have a nice event hall should you chose to throw a party! read more

Their penne vodka hands down had the best vodka sauce I've ever tasted. Waitress was really nice, and the guy who refilled our water and gave us bread was amazing and fast. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The environment was well-thought out to every detail to make restaurant-goer's feel at home.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

This place- it ruins you for all other places. It's that phenomenal. And the server Cricket- she treated us as if we were guests in her own home. Everything was exceptionally prepared. Whatever you order will be the best version of that dish you've ever had. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Everything was great the food, service and ambiance.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We had the lamb chops, ChickenParmigiana, fried calamari paired with a red wine. We had toasted almond cake with an espresso for dessert so good. Will definitely go again. read more

Not our first time at this restaurant but always appreciate the service and food. Because it's not on our usual routes we forget how much we enjoy it here. We are always warmly greeted and seated quickly. Our waiter was accommodating and personable. He took our orders and food started coming out quickly. We had chicken specials and the saffron risotto which had a nice amount of shrimp and scallops. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Although it is a big space it's not too noisy and it feels intimate because you're not on top of each other.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Definitely will remember it for our next meal out. read more

I came here with some family for an early dinner. Service was good but food was okay, not amazing. A little pricey. I wouldn't go again but that's just my experience. read more

Great restaurant, food was very good, staff were friendly and very accommodating. Drinks were priced fair and overall a good spot for a night out. read more

Food was outstanding and service was excellent. I think anything you order off of the menu would be absolutely delicious.

When you're waiting 10min for a glass of water and the waiter gives an excuse that you accept, but then you wait another 10 min for a menu and the waiter gives the same excuse and the place is not busy.... it's time to walk out and find a much better place like " Vesuvio's Ristorante" , don't waste your time at Casa Vicina people ...... read more

We have been going here for years, their service and food is always outstanding. Bella is a wonderful waitstaff. Last evening, we had the artichoke hearts with lemon aioli, I had the ribeye, my wife had the linguini with white clam sauce. Portions were generous, salad is included and had very fresh greens and vegetables. We topped it off with a beautiful piece of pistachio/ricotta cake that was to die for. So light and airy! If you haven't yet patronized them, please do so, you will be very happy you did! read more

Plenty of parking. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Inside is relaxing.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Staff is on point. Lots of choices for drinks. Food was very good. Owner is a gentleman. Highly recommended read more

Visited in a Saturday afternoon, we had a large party. The service was excellent, the owner came to check in. Why do we love bread? We love it even more with the tomato dipping sauce served right away with our wine. Yummmmmmmmm the entrees come with salads. Most of us took the remainder of our dishes home for a midnight snack. Totally satisfied! read more

La Casa Vicina - Snapper - Italian Near Me - New Windsor, New York

Hadn't been in years but it was perfect location to meet a friend who had an appointment at Stewart Airport. I got a pasta dish that was absolutely outstanding. They had planned on only eating half their food but it was so good they just finished. Portions were nice size. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's a good date night or business location[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. They also have a catering arm if you want a private dining room. read more

Delicious Dinner , Food was fresh and big portions, would recommend. This was 2nd week in a row going. read more

See all

I came to this place once for a sweet 16 years ago and thought the food was pretty good. I don't know why I never went back because these dishes are exquisite. It's hard to find really good flavorful food in the area, but La Casa Vicina was outstanding! For New Windsor - La Casa Vicina & Citrus are the best ‼ read more

See all

My wife and I have lived in the area for about two years. We always drive by and pass the restaurant but never stop in. We made to right decision of going to dinner last night. Wow were we impressed. The service, atmosphere and food were first class. For an appetizer we had the portobello mushroom with ricotta cheese, out of this world. The flavor was outstanding. For dinner my hice had the seared salmon and I ordered the special, the Chilean sea bass. Both dishes are absolutely exquisite. The fish flakes off with just a fork, the flavors were phenomenal. I am so glad we finally decided to stop lo in. Check out the posted pictures and tell me it does not look appetizing. Highly recomm read more

See all

Delicious food and great service! I recommend the white clam sauce, the risotto, and any special of the day.

Incredible service and food! Every time I drive by this place is packed. It's definitely a bit more upscale/ fine dining than we were prepared for. I thought the prices were reasonable based on the meals and quality of ingredients. My family is from Italy and there are very few places I'd bring my parents that they would actually enjoy- they would love it here. Can't wait to bring them next time they are in town. read more

See all

I totally agree with Virginia S. post.. Sounds like that guy was having a bad day all around and was looking for someone to take it out on. I have been going there for years and love the food, the service and the presentation. The best bang for your buck. Haven't you ever had to wait to be seated on a holiday? If it's a great restaurant, that is normal. It's worth the wait. read more

I have been to this establishment many times and always felt the food was ok, but certainly not great. Some of my family have frequented this place a lot and I never understood why. Tonight I went again with a large party. Service was good. My meal was again subpar. Short rib ravioli with a butter truffle sauce. Nothing truffle flavor about it. Ravioli was thick and chewy, not much different than any frozen dinner. I had a Cesar salad with the dinner which much to my surprise was extra. The wait staff failed to inform us of that. Most restaurants give you the choice of on or the other. That really annoyed me. When I asked the waiter about it he said my sister had been here enough times that she should have known that. Then I had a cappuccino. No biscotti with it and the steamed milk tasted sour. I have never written a bad review on a restaurant but tonight just left a bad taste in my mouth, literally. Do yourself a favor and just go to Vesuvios in Newburgh. Way better food and service and they don't charge extra for their Cesar salad read more

Great food and great service! They have a wide selection of food and are very accommodating for large groups!

We heard a lot if good things about La Casa from different people. We went for Sunday dinner. It has a comfortable atmosphere though the heater made a lot of noise. I asked the person who seemed to be the owner for his suggestions and he basically had no personality and nothing to say. The waitress was very nice and friendly. The bread dip was very nice and the bread was okay. We all enjoyed the grilled octopus and the mushroom appetizer. And We liked the salad with blue cheese dressing a lot. However, the main entrees were a disappointment. We returned the two risottos because they were undercooked. My chicken parmigiana was very basic. The pasta and sauces for all dishes were bland. Overall, all of the meals lacked flavor including the rack of lamb and the short rib ravioli. read more

La Casa Vicina - Chicken parmigiana - Italian Near Me - New Windsor, New York

I highly recommend this place! I called only a few hours before I needed platters of food for a party and they took my order! And it was ready on time! I got penne vodka, chicken parm and Cesar salad trays. They were all fresh and delicious! Guests kept saying how good the food was! Prices are affordable too! I would definitely order again! Thanks! read more

La Casa Vicina - Penne vodka, chicken parm, Cesar salad - Italian Near Me - New Windsor, New York

Went here for dinner Friday night on a double date with friends. From the moment we walked in until we left, the service was excellent. Everyone was very pleasant and attentive. We started with the calamari and the stuffed mushrooms that were on the specials menu. Both were quite tasty but the mushrooms were amazing! The sauce was just out of this world. For entrees we had: chicken parm, saffron risotto, duck and the chicken and lobster. Everyone was quite pleased with the order. We were so full we did not get dessert. Everything was just great - food and service. Excellent experience and I would definitely go back when I'm in the area. read more

La Casa Vicina - Chicken Parm - Italian Near Me - New Windsor, New York

See all

This place is a hidden gem! It is pretty big inside. Its clean and inviting. Family owned. The staff is very friendly and comfortable. There is ample parking. There are two sides with a bar in the middle. This place does banquets and parties on one side and the regular restaurant on the other side. I had the Lobster Bisque soup, for my appetizer and a salad. The soup was good with nice flavor. My main course was the Lobster Ravioli in a truffle butter sauce. (Ravioli Aragosta). It was really good. The serving portions are just right, not too small and not too large portions. You definitely get your monies worth here. The prices aren't overly expensive, you wont break your budget eating here. I will definitely eat here again. We walked in and were promptly seated. There was not a big crowd in the restaurant, but it was not empty either. read more

See all

Excellente! Reservations are definite. The filet mignon, Chicken franchise were perfect !

Had my daughters baby shower there the owner in the staff were amazing and so was the food everybody enjoyed it what highly recommend for a party? Have in dinner there are several times and the food was always great. read more

Delicious Italian food. Great spot for date night. Our first time here was incredible definitely did not disappoint

This place is amazing, food is delicious, staff is friendly and did I say the food is delicious???!!!

My husband and I chose La Casa Vicina to host our rehearsal dinner, and we couldn't be happier with our decision! In addition to a private room with speakers/music to fill the space, the staff was incredibly accommodating and the food and drinks were beyond spectacular. Everyone had an amazing time and couldn't stop raving about how delicious everything was (my husband and I included)! read more

Went here Saturday night 12/26/2020 and was truly impressed, best filet minion we have had in some time! Service was on point, not too slow or too fast. Drinks are well made also. We go out to eat every weekend and this was by far one of the best experiences we have had in a while and looking forward to going back real soon! read more

I have never had a bad experience at LaCasa Vicina, as the owner himself is polite and professional, friendly in every respect, as is the rest of staff. These two recent negative reviews (both from the same party) are so exaggerated and could not be further from the truth. The staff did their best to accommodate this party by putting a separate table together for them and making special arrangements for them. It was Mother's Day and understandably the restaurant was very busy (a good thing). Now for this group to pull the race card? Please. Do us all a favor and stay home and order in. That negative review is totally unwarranted and undeserved. La Casa Vicina is one of the best restaurants in the Hudson Valley. Best food and unparalleled service! read more

Delicious food, cozy atmosphere and friendly service. Definitely going back soon! Highly recommended

Found this place after some googling and the reviews seemed promising so we decided to give it a try. All of the food and drinks were absolutely delicious and the service was great. All of the staff we interacted with were wonderful.. bartender, waiters, bus boys and possibly an owner/manager were extremely nice. My toddler ended up spilling his water on the floor and even though it was embarrassing for us no one made us feel as if it were a problem or inconvenience. The ambiance was wonderful as it seemed like a place where they have a lot of regulars, so it felt homelike in the best way. We will definitely be back.. (with a spill proof sippy cup!) read more

I really enjoyed my recent visit. The staff were friendly and accommodating. Waitress Samantha was an absolute sweetheart. Flood was amazing from appetizer to dessert! read more

worst restaurant for customer service and food presentation . we had to wait an hour for a table even though we had a reservation. the owner is rude for starters and the staff is as well. one of the waitresses kicked my mother's chair while she was passing by and didn't even stop to apologize . they are a disgrace. stay away. there are better restaurants in the area. read more