My experience at Matchbox is one that exceeded my expectations.
I am not the one who dines at Italian/American restaurants, and especially not ones that cost more than $15 per person per meal. These kinds of restaurants, in my experience, have little to offer for vegans, and just cost way too much.
But somehow, Matchbox outdid themselves and didn't get caught into the unfortunate "I will never eat there again!" folder.
I would've never decided to eat here, but one of my co-workers is moving back to Australia after temporarily working in DC for 2 months. This was going to be our last dinner together, and a last "hoorah!" before she leaves for her home island half way across the globe.
Another person in our group suggested this restaurant, and I, not wanting to let the group down because of my dietary needs, figured I could talk to the waiter about customizing my meal and agreed on dining here.
We made a reservation for 4, but ended up bringing along another person. "No problem!," they said, and seated us at a table for 6. We were a pretty diverse group as well, 2 from Australia, 2 from California, and 1 from Connecticut.
Our waiter, Everitt, was prompt the entire night, paying close attention to our orders and needs. He got us water, he recommended beer, (I ended up getting the "Flying Dog" Lager, which was full of flavor, and delicious!), and answered all my questions. Their wine list is extensive, and they have a nice selection of local beers, as well as your usual favorites. They even break down cocktails between "girly" and "manly" which opens up the debate to the gender roles that drinks play into...BUT we understand where they're coming from and I'm gonna let them go on that one. (I love 'girly' drinks, don't judge me!)
The menu itself is not vegan friendly at all. Only 1 appetizer was vegetarian, and there was a vegetarian sandwich, and a few vegetarian pizzas. However, everything had some form of milk or cheese in it.
After long deliberation, I got the small pizza, with tomato sauce, roasted garlic sauce, and wild mushrooms (no cheese). Everitt made sure that he got my order correct, and that no mistakes would be made.
Our meal came out and it looked amazing. Even my friend's burger with onion rings, and my other friend's proschiutto pizza looked really good!
The verdict? Their woodstove ovens always give their pizzas a nice crunch and slight burnt crusts which I enjoy. The garlic sauce mixed with the tomato sauce was absolutely delicious, and you wouldn't even miss the cheese. Mushrooms were piled and were present in every bite I took. I wish the crust was a tad bit thicker, as it was almost as thin as paper, but that's a personal preference.
Everyone enjoyed their meal, and everyone devoured their pizza. I usually have to take my food home, but this pizza was so good, that even finished off the entire thing!
Of course, Everitt came around to make sure everything was going great, and our plates were picked up promptly. And of course a little dessert menu was conveniently placed at the corner of our table when we finished our meals. I usually never have dessert, but we were celebrating! So I ordered the strawberry sorbet, my Australian friend ordered the molten chocolate cake, and another friend ordered the chocolate chip bread pudding. Everything looked soo good. My sorbet was soft and creamy, and tasted like real strawberries! The molten chocolate cake was thick and oozed chocolate in every bit. The bread pudding was a generous serving, which was filling, sweet, and a bit savory.
Even when the bill came, we paid with 5 different credit cards, and not a single mistake was made. My entire experience here was great from the moment we walked in to the moment we left. I felt welcomed, and I ordered great food that worked with my dietary needs. Even though it's a lot more money than I'm use to spending, it was certainly worth it for the experience and service I received. read more