I don't know what has happened to this place but it is extremely poor now hugely overpriced horrible products we ordered a ribeye steak, medium rare. It came out not even pink in about a quarter inch thick which is just ridiculous. They're famous desserts are terrible three times in a row now we've ordered them or gone by and pick them up. They're all frozen for months and months thawed out. theyre very dry, dense and just terrible to try and eat. It's ruined two parties that we've had at our house and we picked up desserts from there. They were absolutely horrible. Everybody took one bite, looked at each other and said no. Very disappointing. We should have gained a clue when we went by on a Saturday night at 7 o'clock without reservations and got right in and got a table. We should've known right then the word is out and this place is now terrible do not spend any money at this restaurant you'll be ignore mostly disappointment disappointment read more

Magelby's is a Utah institution. What isn't delicious here? I love the buffet they do once( ?) A month. Just call and check the schedule. Yum. read more

Disappointing. Food was totally unexceptional. Seems like a fun family restaurant but the food was just really sad.

A fancy date night that felt intimate! Serviced was excellent and the host even brought out an appetizer on him for the long wait! Chocolate cake was one of the best we have had. 10/10 read more

We had the opportunity to experience a wedding luncheon with this great restaurant. It was for our son's wedding. The staff were so friendly in working with us planning the event. The manager, Jake, was very friendly and remembered all of our requests. When we arrived on the wedding day, it was perfect. Every single employee that was involved with our event was extremely professional and kind. The food was incredible. The venue was absolutely beautiful. We were able to enjoy our time with our guests on that very special day. Everyone loved the beautiful space and the food. It was a huge hit! I recommend this beautiful restaurant to anyone looking to celebrate a special occasion, or simply looking for a very nice meal. Thank you to everyone who helped with our special day. read more

The absolute best lunch we've ever had!! Great food, great service and very affordable!!

They are slow. They brought the salad out after we had almost finished eating, it took 3 requests to get it, we still had to pay for it. The host had the tails of his shirt untucked in the front, but tucked in the back. real professional Each time I have gone back to Magleby's the free price of cake included gets smaller and smaller. And if you don't mind your drink poured your lap without a discount on your meal this is the place to go. read more

I won a $10 gift certificate for Magleby's last year and since my husband and I had a date planned at the Springville museum we decided to use the gift certificate at the Magleby's there. We were amazed by the interior beauty of the Restaurant. There was also pretty classical music playing which was a little louder than it needed to be to create a relaxing atmosphere. We were served right away and the staff was very professional. The menu options on the cover were too high for our budget but as we looked further we both settled with $8 sandwiches. My husband ordered the Gyro which is lamb with cucumber dill sauce on a pita. He enjoyed it and was quite full after the meal. I ordered the Turkey and Avocado sandwich with sweet potato fries. The sandwich was HUGE! Much more than I expected. It was delicious! Very flavorful. Normally I prefer ketchup over fry sauce, however, the fry sauce that was served with my sweet potato fries were so so good! The food certainly deserves a five but I give this restaurant a 4 because of the music volume and the fact that we were seated next a fan which caused us to be a little on the chilly side. read more

One of the nicest restaurants in the Spanish Fork/Springville area! We love it! Love the bread rolls, love the salad and love their Halibut! The building is one of Springville's historic buildings that has been fully restored. The aged brick and stone is amazing and we love the open atmosphere. I've held business meetings in their lower dining area that had an awesome water feature and full projector etc. Definitely a place to consider for date nights, larger family dinners and corporate events. read more

My family went there for Thanksgiving this year and it was fantastic. All tables were socially distanced and I felt safe. The service was timely and the food was delicious. My dad raved about it the entire way home. Great atmosphere for fine dining. read more

Friendliest and most helpful staff! Had to grab food for son's wedding lunch. Ordered the family style blackened chicken fettuccine. Added more chicken and it stretched to feed the party with a little for later. Delicious! Thank you so much! read more

Magleby's catered our wedding in November 2016. I'm now just coming around and rating all of our vendors. I was introduced to their service during one of the Bridal Conventions in SLC. They had us at their impressive set up so I scheduled a tasting appointment with one of their consultants. Their food was sooo good and their consultant gave us so many options to choose from! We ended up with their Hors d'oeuvre option which they don't offer anymore. This option was perfect for our small kinda large wedding! I did most of the setup and planning so I was able to talk with Magleby's multiple times over the week of the wedding. I mostly emailed but they responded promptly. After searching for cake options, I couldn't find a relatively affordable price. Luckily, Magleby's offered a discount on their cakes since we were going with them for catering. Their chocolate cake was AMAZING!!!! I also submitted pictures of cake designs so their baker could replicate it which they did perfectly! Our guests were alittle turn off when we told them that it was only Hors d'oeuvres but, the day of the wedding, they were impressed by their set up (the consultant had asked during the tasting what our theme was so they could match their setup with it) and the taste and how filling the food was. The meatballs and bread pudding were a crowd favorite. The only negative thing I could say is that communication wasn't the greatest at the beginning. I kind of felt forgotten because, after our tasting, the consultant told us that she would email us the price points for our order. However, I never heard from her. Two weeks later, I was the one who actually called and spoke with Keri, the supervisor, to get a hold of the consultant. Apparently, our consultant was leaving the company and had forgotten. If I wasn't impressed with the service's options and food, I probably would have gone else where because who forgets a bridal order. After that point, the communication between Magleby's and myself was much better. I'm glad I went with them! read more

Magelby's was one of the best places to eat at. We went in for a wedding tasting and it was a 10/10. The food was not just fantastic but the customer service was unmatched. Amber, who helped us, made us feel so comfortable and did everything she could to fulfill all our needs and even went above and beyond to satisfy us. The salmon, chicken marsala, and the steak were superb and i've never tasted anything that good. The mashed potatoes were unlike any mashed potatoes i've ever had. Overall eating at Magleby's was a wonderful experience and i would definitely recommend everyone to go eat there ! read more

Went for breakfast since the description says "breakfast", only to find that they don't open till 11:00 am. Kinda aggravating to drive there for nothing. Need to change that description if you're not actually serving breakfast. read more

We went to Magleby's for a family holiday celebration. It was great. Most of us got the Friday steak and seafood buffet and it didn't disappoint! Service was great. I forgot my card and they happily mailed it to me with a really nice note. We're looking forward to our next opportunity to go back! read more

Exceptional food, service and ambience. Only disappointed that will not likely get to come back.

I've been here three times now and regretted it all three times. I've had two steaks that were overcooked but I'm not the type to send food back and wait for a new meal when the rest of my party is eating. Another meal came covered in gravy that was not mentioned in the description anywhere. Again, I was with a group so did not want to make a fuss by sending food back. One positive: The creme brûlée is absolutely delicious! read more

We held a wedding luncheon here and it was perfect. We enjoyed the lovely private room with tv screens and sound system for a slide show. Everything was set up when we arrived and Darrell did a great job of taking care of us the whole time along with the servers. It was so convenient to not have to RSVP with a meal choice. Our guests had a choice of 3 entrees and picked their choice upon arrival. The food was delicious! My salmon was perfect. Highly recommended! Many of our guests commented how much they enjoyed the room and the food. They thought it was great. Rare to find a private room that doesn't require a rental fee. read more

I have not had their food, other than the cake, but it really is the best cake! Everyone that I have heard that has been there has said it is definitely worth the price, although that is the very reason I have not been. Me and my husband even found a coupon for $10 off an order of $30 or more, I guess we thought it said $40, and we didn't want to spend 20+ per plate. As soon as we can have a more elegant date night I'm sure we will be going here ;D read more

We arrived at 5:20 pm to a mostly empty restaurant on a Wednesday. The took my name and said they'd find us a table. At 5:40 they said "I'm sorry but we're not going to be able to seat you till 8. We are full with reservations." read more

They have gone downhill since moving from the Riverwoods location. The sauces were bland (their marinara used to be my favorite anywhere) & the pasta was over-cooked. I have always been a fan so it's been disappointing to see. read more

Excellent food and wine. Two restaurants in one. Upstairs more casual and downstairs more fine dining and ambiance. I need to try the downstairs. No kids allowed down there FYI. read more

Terrible. Made a reservation for 20 on my sisters birthday. When making the reservation they did not know what a "spirits menu" was. I had to explain it was beer and wine. The said "yeah but not a lot." Should have been my first red flag. Got to the restaurant and some of our party members had dropped out and we were a smaller group. Asked if we could move some tables to accommodate a different size party. The manager walks towards us and complains that the tables will block the server walkway and they have lots of parties and cannot accommodate us. Very rude and unprofessional. Waited 30minutes for water 45 for wine and beer. Over 1 hour for food. What a horrible experience. Will not bring a group or recommend this restaurant. Ordered the salmon. Food was over priced for the Grotto Menu and the salmon was fishy and over cooked. All of our meals semi-warm and mediocre. No member of the group was impressed with the food. read more

I have LONG been a fan of Magelbys.. It seems like forever. First. I love the chocolate cake. Yesterday (dec 6, 2011) I went with a group of friends from work . I know that large groups are a pain, however! I ordered the unlimited soup and salad. Soup of the day? Creamy Chicken Noodle. Was is tasty? not bad, on the cold side, but not bad. Was it creamy?? Not even close. My food, out of all the group, came about 10-15 minutes after EVERYONE else was served. I had to eat my broth and salad in a big hurry.. So, unlimited (I would have liked some more soup) turned out to be one serving before I had to go. I love the Halibut (having had it on several previous occasions, but yesterday was 100% In their defense they did tell me that one of their servers called in sick.. but I didnt see the place as being really full, so I dont know why that would have a bearing. read more

Fantastic atmosphere, great service, incredible food, excellent dessert. Brought the whole family after a busy day. Great way to wrap it up! read more

Our department visited Maglebys in Springville on one occasion and were mostly disappointed. Service was slow and the food was only at par with local competition, which is not equivalent for the price difference we paid. A coworker ordered a medium well medallion and was corrected by the server stating "Do you want it burnt?" My Coworker agreed with a medium instead but upon delivery of the food ended up with a RARE covered in gravy to hide the issue. Our server corrected the issue but never really apologized; or communicated with the manager again putting their foot in mouth and stated, "we have a few cooks that tend to under cook things." (Again, not something one wants to hear in a restaurant of that caliber.) I ordered the Prime rib sandwich mainly for the chipotle aoili, and was disappointed at the overall dry taste of the meat and sandwich not to mention the huge pieces of fat that took up the majority of my sandwich. The highlight was probably the bread and those that ordered the chicken piccatta. I would say the staff needs to practice a little harder and the cooks need to really try their own food (under-cooked medallions, overcooked Prime rib, dry chalk Halibut) And most of all an establishment like this should not have anything called the "Blue Plate" special, that is an old term and does not send the right message anymore. read more

The food at Magleby's was great. Our server Brady made our dining experience absolutely amazing. He was polite and knowledgeable about the food items. At the end of our meal he boxed us up some delicious chocolate cake. We will definitely be returning, if for nothing else for our great server! read more

Made a reservation over a week ago for my wife and I and our two kids for Valentine's dinner, got a call tonight saying that it would be $120.00 per couple and if I wanted to keep the reservation. Quickly declined and explained that while making the reservation it didn't once state online that there would be a cover charge in place. Have never eaten at Magelby's before and due to this I never will. read more

We went here the first time for my Husband's Birthday- we signed up for their rewards & they sent him a $10 off coupon! It was amazing! Staff was very friendly & attentive, food was great, atmosphere is high end yet cozy. We got the Raspberry Lemonade (which was refilled often without even asking!) & complementary bread. Decided to try an appetizer & the Spinach artichoke dip was amazing! The side salads we had were also very good & ranch seemed home made. I got the rustic Penne Pasta & it was a hearty enough meal to save leftovers- generous with the cheese & bread on it! My Husband choose the chicken fried steak & right away commented that it's the best he's ever tried! His sides were really tasty & I kept stealing bites of his mashed potatoes. We had to get the award winning chocolate cake of course & it tasted just like my Grandma used to make! Generous serving of ice cream & a raspberry sauce on the side. We loved it & will definitely be back. read more

See all

Great experience with an incredible restaurant to work with for catering! Extensive selection of amazing food! Thank you Magleby's for exceeding my expectations! I would highly recommend!!! read more

The server was kind and we got 2 helpings of their delicious bread sticks. The waiter took our drink orders and my 10 yr old and 7 yr old wanted raspberry lemonade. He comes back with these MASSIVE glasses of lemonade for the kids. My husband and I were thinking, "Is this the drink that comes with the kids menu?" We order our kids meals from the kids menu. We got the Pasta Alfredo and the Chicken Strips with fries We were disappointed when the Chicken Strip meal was delivered - there were 2 TINY strips of chicken & LOADS of fries. My husband ordered the Petite Fillet Medallions. The sauce on top of the meat tasted like seafood - which I didn't care for - steak should not have a seafood sauce! I ordered the BBQ chicken quesadilla, it reminded me of something I would eat at Chili's. We got our bill and the Raspberry Lemonades were of course NOT part of the kids meal and were $4.00 each. Seriously? I was a bit irritated about that - the kids didn't even finish the darn things. Live and learn! We also thought the prices were a bit high for the amount of food you received (2 TINY chicken strips for $7.00). read more

I can't speak about the upstairs portion of the restaurant -- only passed through -- but I've eaten downstairs at the Grotto a few times now, and I very much enjoy it. On one visit I had a ribeye that was particularly good (not NYC dry aged good, but "best I've had in Utah valley" good). Other visits have not been quite so memorable, but the food has always been yummy. The atmosphere downstairs -- with no kids allowed -- is quite subdued, which normally suits me just fine. However, on one visit there was live music upstairs, directly above our heads, and that sort of ruined the otherwise atmospheric vibe going on down there. Service has always been friendly and adequate, but don't go for a quick meal as the pace can be pretty relaxed. (Again, my kind of place.) read more

Best food and service in Utah County! Amazing Wednesday lunch buffet. The food is always fresh and the chocolate cake can't be beat! The servers are all very friendly and accommodating. read more

I never have a bad experience here. The food is outstanding and the service is exceptional. Ask about the blue plate special for the day. The buttermilk pie is amazing, and if they have it, the strawberry shortcake is life-changing. read more

We've given this restaurant too many chances. We've had raw chicken and flavorless food. Also super overpriced for this a restaurant that looks the fine dining part, and disappoints. Springville needs a nice restaurant. As a side note, Magelbys fresh is much better. read more

We had family come in from California. We decided to go to Magleby's. We had a pretty large group. When we arrived for our reservation we had waters on the table and were promptly seated which I loved. They brought out some amazing rolls and took our orders. I had a side salad with my meal which was huge and so yummy. I also got the chicken marsala which I was so delicious with the best steamed veggies. Then the family split to of there "famous" chocolate cake. Wow its massive and so good. I get why it's famous. If you are looking for a place to give you or guest the a great dinner , it's Magleby's! ! read more

Always great service, they never hurry you and always have a smile on their face. The food is great and portions are ample .

The atmosphere is great, but the food was just okay and pretty pricy. Kneader's does much better sandwiches. The Parmesan herb bread sticks are good, like everyone says! I had a French dip sandwich. The onions on top were tasty and the cheese was nice and melty, but the bread roll was mediocre, the au jus was flavorless, and the meat tasted like it had a packaged gravy on top. My clam chowder side was good, though! My dad had a beef medallion that was overcooked. He ordered it medium well (I know, I know) and it was definitely well done. "Shoe leather," he called it. His salad was not fresh; it looked like an old bagged salad. However, my mom had a burger that she really enjoyed! "Five stars for the burger," she said. Finally, we had a slice of buttermilk pie, which I had never seen before. It was basically a vanilla cake dumped in a pie crust with raspberry and cherry sauce and whipped cream on top. The raspberry and cherry sauce was delicious and fresh, but the pie (really a cake) was nothing special. The crust (edges and bottom) had gotten burnt to a crisp in the reheating process. The cooks were clever, though; they covered the burnt crust in whipped cream to hide it! Edit: after a little bit of research, I learned that a buttermilk pie is supposed to have a custard filling. Our slice at Magleby's was so overbaked that it lost all of its moisture and was very cakey! Not custardy at all. read more

Magleby's is wonderful. Delicious gourmet food, professional genuine service, and realistic prices. Don't miss out on their delicious food AND desserts. read more

Great food great service. I haves dined here numerous times. I enjoy the chocolate cake for dessert.