Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Magic 5 Pie Co.

    4.5 (88 reviews)
    Closed 3:00 pm - 9:00 PM
    Updated 2 months ago

    Order Magic 5 Pie Co. Takeout or Delivery

    Magic 5 Pie Co. Photos

    MAGIC 5 PIE CO. ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Hipster
    Casual
    Outdoor seating
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Magic 5 Pie Co.

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Bar area
    Wine O.

    Wish I lived closer because I enjoy this place a lot! Wine list is terrific, cocktails great, food amazing! Aside from delicious Neapolitan style pizza, their other food choices are on point. I live the creative toppings on several pies, we had the El Pastor pizza and a margarita. Each was delicious. I started with the arugula salad with shredded chicken which was abundant and satisfying as a main for myself. This is not New Haven style apizza and I am happy about that. Glad someone is doing their own thing and not succumbing to the Barstool one bite bullsh*t that every pizza place has gone in the direction of chasing points and approval from.

    Belgian Caesar
    Leah S.

    Magic 5 Pie Co was nothing short of five star appetizer and pizza quality! We were weary ordering as their pizza menu offerings were so unique. At first we were leaning toward building our own as the menu listed pizzas that are typically not our style, but we were so happy that we trusted the restaurant recommendations and branched out!! The pie that stood out to us most was the Elote- we particularly loved the unique lime mayo drizzle to top off the pie! The magic five pie was good but definitely only for Gorgonzola lovers. The Belgian Caesar was another stand out dish... the dressing was creamy and had great flavor. We loved the low key but also vibrant atmosphere... it was a great spot to catch up with friends!

    Wino Spritz
    Tae P.

    Not my first time trying them out but it is my first time dining there. The ambiance was Halloween themed & nicely decorated. Unfortunately I can't say too much about the server because I didn't get her name & she only came to the table to take my order. I ordered the Brussels sprouts & the lil guy pizza. The Brussels sprouts smelled great & tasted great but was a bit on the extra charred side. I didn't eat all of it. The pizza was delicious! The li guy comes with pepperoni & hot oil. It didn't disappoint. I also had a mocktail called Wino spritz, not something to get if you don't like grapefruit. I would definitely go back.

    Pork Belly Appetizer
    Kelly Y.

    Stopped in with a larger group for an early Saturday night dinner. Cool new place in the East Norwalk area. Lots of different indoor and outdoor seating options and family friendly! We had some specialty cocktails which were good and nicely presented. Service was prompt and friendly. Had a variety of pizzas for the table. The favorite was the potato pie and the cheese one. My kids gave the cheese pizza two thumbs up- they are picky so that was a plus! Clam pie had more garlic than clams so that was a miss. The Diavola was alittle too oily for our liking. Pork belly appetizer and avocado salad were great! I would say this is a slightly upscale pizza place in Norwalk which has a cool vibe and one you can bring the whole family too. As the weather gets nicer, I could see it being a place people will want to go given its vicinity to the water. The East Norwalk area is really get some new cool places to visit! Definitely worth checking out!

    Mediterranean Pie (vegan cheese). Manero's Style Garlic Bread (without cheese).
    Geena S.

    Great food and positive vibes are two things that come to mind when I think of Magic 5 Pie Co. This hidden gem is located in East Norwalk, Ct. The first time visiting, I tried the Veggie Pie with vegan cheese. After a very positive experience, I returned that week for a Mediterranean Pie. The garlic salt and red pepper flakes made it *chef's kiss*. Plus, the staff were so welcoming. Their mindfulness regarding me being vegan was much appreciated. Highly recommend checking this spot out over the summer!

    Stuffed Avocado
    Paola C.

    Hidden Gem- it's tucked away outside of an apartment complex in East Norwalk with live music and a projector screen for movies and trivia. The food was delicious, but I do wish they had more choices for appetizers. Service was quick, although packed I received my plate in like 10 mins. Definitely do stop by! It's walking distance from the East Norwalk train station and there's plenty of parking in the lot or street.

    Lil Guy
    Srinithi R.

    My friend recommended I try this place in Norwalk. I got some drinks, a Lil Guy pie and baked scallops. The drinks were strong and I liked the truffle honey on my pizza. The staff were really friendly and let us try samples of the drinks if we wanted to try them out before ordering them. The place got packed late afternoon and they had seating outside and live music.

    Lauren O.

    I've been meaning to get back here! We sat at the bar, so cute and comfortable. Lots of good drink options. There's a juke box you can have play songs from your cell, very cool. I love the ambiance. I got the wedge salad and it was one of the best I've had and the pizza we got was also very good. The bar staff was very friendly and welcoming. I believe I made a reservation but we ended up wanting to sit at the bar I instead. I want to get back soon to try more, was really impressed.

    Lil guy with mushrooms instead of pepperoni on top, phantom with mushrooms instead of anchovies on bottom

    See all

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Amazing Management. Pizza was the best pie I have tried in the area highly recommend for families or quick dining.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Great service. Unique pizzas. Nice and hot. Great vibe. Going back Maybe they can get music on the wknds.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Magic 5 Pie Co.

    You might also consider

    Troupe429 - Bar games and drag queen at Troupe429

    Troupe429

    4.8(55 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    $

    I've been a Trouper for the past four years, ever since moving to Connecticut, and it's truly a…read morespecial place. With gay bars rapidly disappearing across America, Troupe stands out as a vibrant hub in the Fairfield County LGBTQ+ scene. The owners pour their heart and soul into every aspect of the bar including the programming, music, and atmosphere, and it really shows. The bartenders are warm, welcoming, and genuinely seem to love what they do. From drag shows and burlesque performances to seasonal drink specials, themed parties, and go-go shows, there's always something happening. Troupe quickly became my go-to spot after discovering it one week into living in CT and I'm so grateful for its existence. Huge shoutout to Casey and Nicholas for the love and tireless work they put into making Troupe429 what it is today--and of course to Johnny, who mixes the meanest elderflower gin and tonic in town.

    My fiancée (soon to be wife) and I absolutely love this bar. We feel not only safe but loved there…read moreas a lesbian couple! We make a point to go to Troupe every time we are in town. We are from Boston. It is basically the LGBTQ+ Cheers! It feels like home but the Queer flair we love. Don't get me started on how amazing every night is whether it is a Drag Show, Lesbian Night or Karaoke! This truly is life!

    Photos
    Troupe429 - Seasonal espresso martini with bar Christmas decor.

    Seasonal espresso martini with bar Christmas decor.

    Troupe429 - Jesus

    Jesus

    Troupe429 - Summer Haze is the host of a Drag Queen show at Troupe429 Thursday nights

    See all

    Summer Haze is the host of a Drag Queen show at Troupe429 Thursday nights

    Lazy Sister

    Lazy Sister

    4.3(118 reviews)
    0.6 mi

    Talk about last minute birthday decisions! So last year on my birthday I had a friend order…read moretakeout and we had it at their house. This year for my 35th, I was on my own for dinner this time around. That being said, I think I found a winner here to celebrate my 35th birthday. Say hello to Lazy Sister, located in the heart of South Norwalk where the restaurant scene comes alive! Because I was a single coming in, I was seated right away, no reservation needed. They were even kind enough to place my bag in the atrium so that I wouldn't have it in the way. I was seated at a table set for two, but it's a good thing I guess that I came on my own. First thing I notice upon coming in is that it is a very classy restaurant, not your typical dim sum joint. It's also not a big space, but that's fine by me. Honestly, this would make a great date night spot for anyone going out on a date. Funny enough, I was actually suggested this place by my friend the night I went to Jacob's Pickles. For reasons I am about to get to, I am glad I decided not to come here until a later date. So why would I say that? Well, because tonight, my order consisted of two Junmai Genshu "Little Sumo" sakes as well as the Salt & Pepper Calamari, a medium level Dry Fry Style Szechuan Chicken, and then the Fortune Cookie Soft Serve for dessert. Not only did I pay more here, but I also got more inebriated here than I did at Jacob's Pickles. But it's my birthday, so tonight it's not in my contract to care. You only live once, and I am already in like the middle of my life, so it all evens out, right? Speaking of the food, everything I ate was immaculate! The calamari was seasoned perfectly, vegetables were cooked and crisp, the spice from that Szechuan didn't overpower. It was more like a pleasant tingle, especially when mixed with water or sake. Everything was done just right. And that soft serve cooled me down in just the right way. Delicious and well worth finishing off the night! And while there were other drinks that definitely looked good, I couldn't say no to sake. That's like THE ultimate celebratory drink far as I'm concerned, and it was awesome! If you were wondering about the service, these people are quite friendly. They help you through anything you might need. While I waited a while to tell them, I did eventually tell my waitress it was birthday while I was on dessert. Cool enough, we are both Tauri! I love it when I get to talk to another Taurus! :) The bill was also why I am glad I waited for another occasion to come here. Because I decided to splurge, the affair was about $100 once tip was factored in. It was well worth it, and tonight's outing will definitely make for a fun story to tell. But 34 was a hard year. I deserve to let loose every now and then, and hopefully 35 will be a happier age. All in all, a great restaurant and well worth the money to come here.

    Been wanting to try Lazy Sister and finally got around to it this weekend. It was the perfect day…read morefor outdoor dining which we loved. We started off with the chili oil dumplings which were super flavorful! For entrees we got the Mongolian beef and the shrimp fried rice. Fried rice was my favorite -- didn't need any soy sauce or duck sauce bc it had enough flavor on its own. For drinks I got the lychee drink which was on the sweeter side for my personal taste. Overall, loved my experience and can't wait to go back to try more menu items.

    Photos
    Lazy Sister
    Lazy Sister - Dan Dan noodle

    Dan Dan noodle

    Lazy Sister - Lychee drink

    See all

    Lychee drink

    Bar Bushido - Bacon, Egg & Cheese Ramen

    Bar Bushido

    4.3(33 reviews)
    1.1 mi

    We went on a Sunday and chose the chef's counter in the tamaki-ya room hidden away in the back. We…read morewere fortunate enough to find Chef Taibe behind the counter on his otherwise night-off. I'm no foodie but I am Chinese/Japanese and can appreciate finer things in life when I see it. This place meet and exceeded my expectations. The wonderful speak-easy tamaki-ya room in the back is warmly lit and held at a nice volume, much quieter than the izakaya bar in the front. For small bites we had the Beet n Hijiki salad (highly recommend!), Agedashi tofu, and Torched Maine uni. For hand-rolls I had the Spanish Mackerel, Hokkaido Scallops, Ocean Trout, BBQ Eal & Foie Gras, and Cucumber ume. My wife had the Maine Uni, Hamachi, and Botan Ebi. Everything was good, but there were quite a few that were very good, and there were two that, for me, were the best that I've ever had in recent memory. For the Spanish Mackerel Chef Taibe put an interesting spin on it by topping it off with a traditional Chinese ginger and scallion garnish used in a tender chicken dish. It works, it balances out the briny taste of Spanish Mackerel... which is great... unless you LOVE the briny, savory, mineral, metallic, umami taste of fresh Spanish Mackerel :) The Hokkaido Scallops was, by quite a large margin, the best scallop dish I've ever had. The tender sweetness of the fresh scallop combined with a brown butter kewpie (how American!) and yuzu tobiko sauce swimmingly. Texture, temperature, taste, all perfect. I like eel and I love Unaju. But by far the biggest surprise was the BBQ Eal & Foie Gras (see pic). This dish alone warrants a culinary course. On the face of it, bbq, eel, foie gras all sets you up for something rich, filling, heavy. But when I bit into the unassuming hand roll, it was the lightest bite of Japanese rice/seafood/seaweed/liver/sauce combo I've ever had. Turns out Chef Taibe prepared the sauce from scratch using five+ different spices, and prepared the foie gras au torchon. I could go on, but suffice to say, this was one of the best bites I've ever had. By contrast, I thought I was going to close out with the cucumber ume roll, but compared to the eel and foie gras, the ume actually felt more overpowering. Perhaps if they cut back on the generous amount of ume paste... (Worthy mention: Chef Taibe presents the nori in a separate envelope. This seemingly simple step is crucial to the taste and mouthfeel of the hand roll. It provides a wonderful fresh crisp crunch to every bite and it does indeed make a difference. He mentioned he sources a special nori but I forgot the details, just know that it's really good) My wife loves uni, and I'll let her describe her experience (which she won't) but it was so good she had to order a second one. As if you need more convincing, we had a great experience and I think you will too. Bravo Chef, well done

    We absolutely love Bar Bushido. From the moment you walk in, you can feel the intention behind…read moreeverything -- this isn't just a restaurant, it's a full experience. The cocktail program is seriously one of the best in the area. Creative without being gimmicky, balanced, and clearly inspired by Japanese ingredients and technique. Every drink feels thoughtful and well executed -- the kind of place where you actually want to work your way through the menu. The food is where it really shines. The chef-owner's love of Japanese cuisine comes through in every detail. The yakitori program is outstanding and deeply traditional -- using all parts of the chicken the way it's done in Japan. It's respectful, intentional, and absolutely delicious. You don't often see that level of authenticity and execution locally. The bar bites are some of the best around. The fried chicken sando is one of my personal favorites -- perfectly crispy, juicy, balanced, and craveable. And the ramen? No one can hold a candle to it. The broth is deeply flavorful and layered, the noodles are spot on, and every topping feels purposeful. It's the kind of bowl you think about the next day. Perhaps the best kept secret in all of Norwalk is the back room -- the elegant Temaki-Ya. Tucked away behind an unmarked entrance, this intimate hand-roll bar feels almost like discovering a hidden Japanese speakeasy. The atmosphere is quiet and refined, the kind of place that's perfect for a special date night or a memorable evening with friends. The temaki (hand rolls) are beautifully composed, with thoughtful ingredient combinations that balance texture, flavor, and visual appeal. What makes this place special is the dual experience -- lively izakaya vibes in the front, elegant hand-roll bar in the back -- all tied together by serious culinary skill and genuine hospitality. Norwalk is lucky to have this spot.

    Photos
    Bar Bushido - Neon wall decor

    Neon wall decor

    Bar Bushido - Tofu / Asparagus Kushiyaki

    Tofu / Asparagus Kushiyaki

    Bar Bushido - Cucumber sunomono

    See all

    Cucumber sunomono

    Magic 5 Pie Co. - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...