My gluten free mom: "That was the best gluten free pizza I've ever had... if you told me it had gluten I would've believed you! I would give it 6 stars out of 5" We got the vegetarian pizza and it was phenomenal - will be back! read more

Really good pizza but I would pass on the brussel sprouts. Make a reservation bc this place gets busy! Thankfully I came there were seats at the bar open, which is first come first serve. Service was very friendly and quick. We didn't wait long to be helped and served. The place is so cute inside. It's very casual but also elevated. The brussel sprouts were really burnt so I'm not sure if I would recommend them. Probably wouldn't order them again. The pizza was so good tho!! Delicious flavors and combinations. They have a great menu that everyone would be able to find what they would enjoy! read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - BRUSSELS SPROUTS - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

See all

This was our 2nd time here. Fun little spot with great pizza and cool vibe. We had the Lil Gal pizza and Caesar Salad. The pizza is perfectly 2 people as was the salad. read more

See all

Nicest staff. Especially bartender but each time I order a pie, it's burnt more than the last time. It's a shame because all you taste is burnt crust instead of the ingredients you chose to top the pie. They are damaging their rep, which discourages repeat purchases. read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Burnt underside of pie - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

What a great spot!! It's bigger than I expected and tons of outdoor seating as well for nice days! I went there for lunch and I had the JJ which is basically like a meat lovers pizza and it was really good. A little pricey but worth it. The pizza was amazing and the drink Sierra made me was perfect. She was very friendly and helpful and provided awesome service. I will definitely come back again to try other things on the menu. read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

See all

Wish I lived closer because I enjoy this place a lot! Wine list is terrific, cocktails great, food amazing! Aside from delicious Neapolitan style pizza, their other food choices are on point. I live the creative toppings on several pies, we had the El Pastor pizza and a margarita. Each was delicious. I started with the arugula salad with shredded chicken which was abundant and satisfying as a main for myself. This is not New Haven style apizza and I am happy about that. Glad someone is doing their own thing and not succumbing to the Barstool one bite bullsh*t that every pizza place has gone in the direction of chasing points and approval from. read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Bar area - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

See all

Magic 5 Pie Co was nothing short of five star appetizer and pizza quality! We were weary ordering as their pizza menu offerings were so unique. At first we were leaning toward building our own as the menu listed pizzas that are typically not our style, but we were so happy that we trusted the restaurant recommendations and branched out!! The pie that stood out to us most was the Elote- we particularly loved the unique lime mayo drizzle to top off the pie! The magic five pie was good but definitely only for Gorgonzola lovers. The Belgian Caesar was another stand out dish... the dressing was creamy and had great flavor. We loved the low key but also vibrant atmosphere... it was a great spot to catch up with friends! read more

See all

Stopped in with a larger group for an early Saturday night dinner. Cool new place in the East Norwalk area. Lots of different indoor and outdoor seating options and family friendly! We had some specialty cocktails which were good and nicely presented. Service was prompt and friendly. Had a variety of pizzas for the table. The favorite was the potato pie and the cheese one. My kids gave the cheese pizza two thumbs up- they are picky so that was a plus! Clam pie had more garlic than clams so that was a miss. The Diavola was alittle too oily for our liking. Pork belly appetizer and avocado salad were great! I would say this is a slightly upscale pizza place in Norwalk which has a cool vibe and one you can bring the whole family too. As the weather gets nicer, I could see it being a place people will want to go given its vicinity to the water. The East Norwalk area is really get some new cool places to visit! Definitely worth checking out! read more

See all

Not my first time trying them out but it is my first time dining there. The ambiance was Halloween themed & nicely decorated. Unfortunately I can't say too much about the server because I didn't get her name & she only came to the table to take my order. I ordered the Brussels sprouts & the lil guy pizza. The Brussels sprouts smelled great & tasted great but was a bit on the extra charred side. I didn't eat all of it. The pizza was delicious! The li guy comes with pepperoni & hot oil. It didn't disappoint. I also had a mocktail called Wino spritz, not something to get if you don't like grapefruit. I would definitely go back. read more

See all

What a great addition in East Norwalk. This is a cool restaurant right in the middle of the newly built apartment complexes and obviously draws a decent crowd from the buildings. The vibe is very cool as they have outdoor seatings as well and in summer they have bands playing music and bring out large screens for folks to watch games. The train station is also directly across, so for commuters it is also a great place to grab food. Their pizza's are awesome, my favorite being the Quattro Formaggio which is Pizza with four different kinds of cheese. Have brought several guests to the place and all have given good compliments, both on the restaurant and the food. It is kind of hidden as it is not very visible from the main road and you have to curve around to find it. I have not had trouble finding parking so far either. Keep the cool vibes going! read more

Behold, the "lil guy", a pizza that's, well, little. Small pizza at an extra large price. The house garden salad was sizable enough for two. The hostess is too busy being queen bee with the staff to actually tend to the guests walking into the restaurant. Followed by a nod and a point "yes, that's the one" Hey Chris, appreciate the reply. No, I didn't have a reservation -- just a hopeful walk-in trying to get some pizza. I did get seated, though it felt more like I was interrupting a staff meeting than being welcomed in. As for the garlic bread... nope, no peace offering came my way. I'm sure the Lil Guy is a labor of love, and I respect that it's made with top-shelf ingredients and not mass-produced. But when you name a pizza "Lil Guy" and then charge XL prices, expectations get... complicated. It was tasty, just a bit of a letdown in the "value for money" department. No hard feelings -- I always try to support local, even if this one felt more "boutique frustration" than "neighborhood gem." Maybe I just caught a weird day. read more

My friend recommended I try this place in Norwalk. I got some drinks, a Lil Guy pie and baked scallops. The drinks were strong and I liked the truffle honey on my pizza. The staff were really friendly and let us try samples of the drinks if we wanted to try them out before ordering them. The place got packed late afternoon and they had seating outside and live music. read more

See all

I have eaten here both on property and take out several times. I thought I was getting quality food esp with the prices of the food however I was terribly disappointed when I went yesterday and ordered a salad for my daughter with 8.00 add on chicken. I looked carefully at the chicken and it dawned on me that they use rotisserie chicken. To confirm my suspicions I asked the server who was very nice and got my conclusion; rotisserie chicken recooked ( barf) . Not only is rotisserie chicken one of the worst things you can consume but it's dirt cheap to buy!! I was horrified and WILL not eat this shit again! Come on restaurant owners you can do a hell of a lot better than that ; you have to cut corners that much please charge prices that reflect !! Super dissatisfied and disappointed. I get you want to make your money but use chicken breast and not cut up recooked shit!! read more

Great food and positive vibes are two things that come to mind when I think of Magic 5 Pie Co. This hidden gem is located in East Norwalk, Ct. The first time visiting, I tried the Veggie Pie with vegan cheese. After a very positive experience, I returned that week for a Mediterranean Pie. The garlic salt and red pepper flakes made it *chef's kiss*. Plus, the staff were so welcoming. Their mindfulness regarding me being vegan was much appreciated. Highly recommend checking this spot out over the summer! read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Mediterranean Pie (vegan cheese). Manero's Style Garlic Bread (without cheese). - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

The perfect trifecta: Sensational wings Sensational pizza Sensational salad We'll be back within the week read more

Great modern vibe Nice looking menu with variety and specialty drinks Good pizza great cheese and sauce Crust was too thin in the center for me. Bar tender was trying his best to strike up conversation over the live music Thank you it is a great place overall read more

Hidden Gem- it's tucked away outside of an apartment complex in East Norwalk with live music and a projector screen for movies and trivia. The food was delicious, but I do wish they had more choices for appetizers. Service was quick, although packed I received my plate in like 10 mins. Definitely do stop by! It's walking distance from the East Norwalk train station and there's plenty of parking in the lot or street. read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Stuffed Avocado - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

See all

Very good food and drink! The pizzas are solid. We had a berrata app that was to die for! The special drinks are still good too! Love their Bourbon one with Aperol (can't recall the name). Very pretty area and the outside seating is awesome. read more

Got take out...the waiter at the door was prompt with my check and food...the Iceberg Wedge Salad was delicious and the Wings were tasty.

The service was lacking but the food was great. We got the cherry bomb the dough alone is exceptional. However, it wasn't that busy but our pizza came out before our drinks. Also, for a smaller pizza it's quite expensive ($22) for a pizza we shared between two quite easily. We will be going back but it will be adults only! read more

I've been meaning to get back here! We sat at the bar, so cute and comfortable. Lots of good drink options. There's a juke box you can have play songs from your cell, very cool. I love the ambiance. I got the wedge salad and it was one of the best I've had and the pizza we got was also very good. The bar staff was very friendly and welcoming. I believe I made a reservation but we ended up wanting to sit at the bar I instead. I want to get back soon to try more, was really impressed. read more

See all

This place really is magic! The food is amazing and the vibes were great. I do wonder if they could improve the layout of the tables to accommodate more people though. We started with the kale salad and the Caesar salad. They were both amazing, but if you only get one salad, let it be the Caesar! Their unique take on the Caesar is one of the best I've ever had. For our pizzas, we got the Lil Guy and Phantom, but replaced the meat with mushrooms since my party doesn't eat meat. They were both great! I loved the style of the crust - thin and just slightly charred. I can't wait to return and eventually try the whole menu! read more

See all

Excellent service! Pizzas are delicious.. this is our new favorite pizza place in Norwalk! The patio has plenty of benches for outdoor seating and the ambience is great! read more

Walking distance from the East Norwalk train station, this pizza place is nestled under a vibrant apartment complex. Walls of oyster shells and tables shaped like a pizza peel - the ambiance is definitely a good vibe! My husband got the Lil Guy - pepperoni and hot honey is a new "in" flavor combination and he loves it! I got the Mediterranean - good sauce, and a nice dough with a thinner crust! I LOVED the Brussel sprout Caesar salad - shaved brussels smothered in dressing and parm, topped with fried wontons - YUM ! read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Lil Guy and Mediterranean - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

Service was terrible. We asked for water the first time our waiter came to the table, and he said of course. He didn't bring it with our drink order. A different server brought our appetizers so we didn't ask them for water thinking our waiter might be bringing it. Same when our dinners came, which was immediately after the appetizers were served (should have been spaced out). Our waiter hadn't checked on us since he brought our drink orders so I had to go up to the bar and ask for water to be brought to our table. 10 minutes went by and still no water. So I got up and asked the first server I saw if they could bring water. He was nice enough to bring it quickly. So we got our water about 45 minutes after we were seated. After finishing our dinner we waited at least another 20 minutes, still not being checked on by our waiter. Then I saw him behind the bar talking to the bartender and I went up and said "excuse me" to get his attention and asked him to bring the check. It's too bad because the atmosphere was so nice and there was live music. But it was hard to enjoy with such poor service. The food was good so I'm willing to go back and try again. read more

Me and my husband absolutely love this place! Honestly, I think I love it more than he does . For me, it was love at first bite. We've been here 4 times and every time it's amazing! I usually get the Magic 5 pie and it's so good and my husband usually gets the little guy. I think I tried another pizza or two but I need to do more exploring of their menu. We live in the Bronx so it's not exactly around the corner for us. But it is also worth the trip. I highly, highly recommend this place to anyone who just loves a great pizza pie. Now I need to find another excuse to go to Norwalk against we can visit my favorite pizza place! read more

I've had this on my list of places to try for a while. I walked in with expectations of a good meal having had them at both their other restaurants. Unfortunately, I was mistaken. The untopped crust was the best part. Dough was awesome! Sauce was great. The amount of sauce and toppings was way off. We had a few pies, the namesake magic 5 was soup in the middle. Pick up a slice and it soggily dropped from the crust down, it was mush. MUSH. The white goat cheese pizza was almost there. The buratta, arugula, and prosciutto sat beautifully on top but when you picked up a slice all toppings ended up in a pile on the tray. There was nothing on the arugula, cheese, or prosciutto that made them cohesive. They were just in an unconnected pile till you moved them. The service wasn't great. Kinda mean, actually. We're not a demanding group but the eye rolls and attitude weren't necessary. Meh. Won't go back. tried. Wanted to like it. read more

See all

Really good gluten free pizza. Highly recommend. Great service. They also have great fries.

I went to Magic 5 for the first time this summer and it was fantastic! We ordered three pies and they were all extremely good. I have been looking for a good pizza place and have already been recommending it to a ton of people as I was impressed with their pizza selection. The vibe of the restaurant is casual, chill and great for a night out with friends or even a date night. I'm visiting from Austin TX and this spot reminded me of home. The salads were okay, nothing crazy but I highly recommend trying this spot because of their wood oven pizza & a beer! Hidden gem! read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

Went to this place for dinner on a Wednesday and it was surprisingly pretty Poppin. There was no way in my party. Also had a reservation. The owner is super super nice and the staff is also very friendly. The staff also accidentally gave us garlic bread and didn't end up charging us at the end of the night so it was very sweet. Inside is so fun. They have it all set up for Christmas. The lights are green and red and they also have all these fun Christmas decorations. The pizzas are so good. I ended up getting the little guy. My friends ended up getting the little girl and the hot and crunchy. Then my one friend ended up making his own pizza. We all ended up sharing, and still had leftovers. The pizzas are super good and super flavorful, and we loved their flavor combinations. Would totally come here again!! read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

See all

Great pizzas with high quality ingredients, good vibe to the space, nice bar. It's a great addition to the Norwalk pizza scene, and bonus points for being an easy walk to the train. read more

New spot with a good vibe! Has real potential. We ordered a few pies to try it out Saturday evening and it was pretty good; the Native Son (burrata, prosciutto, truffle ricotta, and arugula) and Pastor (tomato sauce, crumbled seasoned pork, grilled pineapple, caramelized onions, arbor sauce, fresh cilantro). They're individual pies with flavor. Could've used more prosciutto but there's still a few opening kinks so I'll give it a pass. Location is super convenient for parking being right next to the East Norwalk station, and interior looks really nice. When it gets warmer I can see a great outdoor dining area for sure! read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Interior dining area - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

See all

Love this place!! Only suggestion is to add a little honey drizzle and less arugula to the fig jam.

We picked up three pizzas from Magic 5 Pie and headed to the beach. The pizzas were exceptional! The meat eaters had the Lil Guy. They loved the hot oil and truffle honey. The combination was great. I opted for a vegetarian version of the Pastor which was absolutely wonderful. Rather than use large slices of pineapple, Magic 5 uses some diced pineapple. The flavor melded very well with the onions, arbol sauce, and cilantro. I look forward to getting this pizza again! Finally, we got the Quattro Formaggio which was also absolutely delicious. Since we did take-out, I can't comment much on the service. I can say that we were attended to right away and the staff was friendly. The overall atmosphere and ambiance of Magic 5 was also inviting. We liked the outdoor set-up and hope to stop by for more pizza, drinks, and, of course, photos sometime soon. read more

The restaurant is in a huge, fancy looking apartment building right behind the east Norwalk train station, so pretty cool location. It makes you think the restaurant will be bigger than it actually is, but I wouldn't call it "small". The vibes are pretty good, and I didn't have to wait too long for my food despite how busy it was. I got The Los pie, which is tomato sauce, buffalo mozzarella, hot capicola, cherry peppers, mushrooms, evoo. I like the tomato sauce and the crust, but I think the pie could've been baked a little longer because the slice would flop under the weight of the toppings. Still a good pizza: 7.75/10 read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - The Los - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

Great find rather hidden, but look for it in the apartment complex by the train station. Excellent pizza pie. Good drinks. Will visit again soon! read more

Great pizza, attentive staff and a fun vibe. We will be back!

Last night was our 3rd visit to Magic 5 Pie! Always an absolute blast! Staff is amazing and friendly, really awesome fun family vibe. The pizza is creative and delicious, and the salads are absolutely stellar! This is our new go-to place!!! read more

Hidden place Right Behind the East Norwalk Train Station a Excellent Pizza Place with good Drinks and Food the Service is also really good we had a Beautiful Waitress that came and took our orders I got the JJ Pizza Pie I think it was with Mozzarella Pepperoni Bacon Meatball and Sausage It was really good and they have this Delicious Rum Drink I cant think of the name of that one but It had Chocolate In it Delicious great Outdoor Dining and sometimes they have Music as well I will be back again sometime read more

The salads are all amazing: fresh and sizable, nutritious and delicious. The pizzas are also really really good, both with regular crusts and gluten free crusts. This restaurant is great with food allergies - they always provide answers about what is gluten free, even when I order for delivery. The in-person dining is also great. read more