The pizzas(pies in east apparently) were great according to my friends. They looked pretty good too. I got the roasted cauliflower salad and the another salad and they were pretty new and interesting. Would've loved it if they roasted the cauliflower a little more cuz it literally felt like they threw a whole cauliflower on the plate...the sauce/hummus that it came with was yum though. Pizzas were really good. A bit pricy but service and the vibe of the place was very nice! Definitely a relaxed hangout spot. read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Roasted Cauliflower with hummus - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

Blair and Chris have a brilliant trip of restaurants going with this, Spread, and El Segundo. Blair's Berry Lemonade drink is KILLER, the salads are amazing, and the pizza is creative and delicious. They're opening the patio soon- can't wait! Blair was so helpful navigating the menu with us first time, despite the place being SLAMMED. We felt so at home! read more

See all

Short version: Awesome design, incredible staff and service, and even better food and drinks! Long version below for those who want details! Location: This is a brand new place in the Brim & Crown apartment complex. Cool modern industrial design, with a mix of bar seating, booths, and high- and low-top tables. Sitting at the bar it didn't feel crowded even when the restaurant was fully seated. Food: They have salads and a raw bar, but we skipped those and went straight for the pizza! Great menu of options including a BYO pizza. They have the classics but this menu is full of modern takes. We got the Fig Jam (goat cheese, bacon, caramelized onion, and arugula) first, which was stunning. Great balance of ingredients, thin crust with the perfect texture, and full of flavor. We somehow were still hungry after a whole pizza and got the Lenguizza (ricotta, beef tongue, arugula, garlic, and truffle vinaigrette), which was even BETTER! Drinks: Plenty of wine and beer options, with a small fully original cocktail menu; I'm sure they could make whatever standard stuff you'd like. We got a draft cider and the Ligurian Mojito, which you HAVE to try if you like a slightly sweeter cocktail (it has limoncello). Service: We went on Tuesday. The guy who greeted us (potentially the manager) was friendly and warm, and as the night went on I saw him check on tables when the waitstaff was busy. We sat at the bar, where Hyman was fantastic start to finish. Recommendations when we wanted it, checked in when we had empty plates or glasses, and gave us space throughout the night when we were obviously OK. 10/10 across the board; planning to go back ASAP! read more

Great pizza super fun environment and fantastic, friendly owners. Highly recommend this place.

Becoming one of our family's go to places for celebrations or just random night out. The service is top notch. I usually have a go to everywhere but I'm on a mission to try every pizza they've all be incredible so far. And don't forget dessert. read more

Went here with our family and another. Sat outside on a Friday night. Kids were able to run around and play with the giant connect 4. We sipped delicious cocktails and all enjoyed some really good pizza. Shout out to the Al pastor pizza which was really unique and delicious. Service was great. Great addition to Norwalk read more

Delicious pie! They seemed to provide as much of your selected toppings as will fit on the pizza. I enjoyed 2 Fresh IPA's. We arrived early about 5:00. We had reservations. No one there when we sat down. Boy did that change fast!. I would suggest reservations anytime after 5-5:30 Love the place- Two thoughts: Parking is a concern. There seems to be plenty, but you need to take care not to park in Railroad reserved areas Secondly- we had a great meal and fun being there, the bar also looked like fun. No question for me that this place will be measurably BETTER as the weather warms and outdoor seating when this restaurant goes into "open air" mode. It's apparently set up to be that way. In short- Great: Food, Service, fun atmosphere, good music. Even better soon! read more

We had dinner here last night .. honestly it was the best gluten "friendly" pizza I have ever had!!!! And to top it off they carry my favorite non-alcoholic /gluten free beer ... Athletic Brewing. Awesome job guys can't wait to come back! read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

I'll start be saying we all wanted to like this place. We ordered 3 pies and a salad. The salad was extremely spicy which was odd and not mentioned in the description at all. Not one of us liked it. 3 different pies, all soupy in the middle and flavorless. The only thing worse was the staff, when I asked the young man who brought us out our pizzas for something, he shrugged so I asked him if my request for a drizzle of hot honey on the arrival goat cheese fig pie was okay which was met with another shrug and an added eye roll. He took the pizza back to the oven and talked with 3 coworkers for my request and all three turned to stare at our table. They came back and said they had no honey, which was clearly marked in the ingredients of another pie on the menu. Our server looked miserable and her service was terrible. No wonder we were pretty much there only people in the place. Also, the pizza guy was creepy and stared at us the majority of the time. Never again, especially for $150 bill. read more

See all

Delicious food, wine and very attentive, friendly service. We shared the Belgian Caesar salad (good) and the Magic Pie (incredible!)

Great service and ambience. They really only have pizza so if you want pizza, this is a great spot! There oven looked really nice. The pizza was crispy and thin which I loved. read more

The best pizza this side of New Haven! Great crust, perfect char, excellent balance of toppings. But what sets this place apart from any competitors are the salads - they take them to the next level in freshness and innovative twists - Artesian fresh crisp greens, perfect dressing, a mix of nuts, cranberries and perfectly cut ripe pear - or - the Brussel Sprout Caesar great crunch greens and tangy dressing. Fun vibe, great staff, very involved owner-partners - everybody really cares! read more

Amazing pizza! Fun atmosphere! The hot honey was delish!! Would definitely recommend!

I loved the vibe I got when I walked in. There are 3 round couches that can easily sit 5 with a table that seats up to 3 more people. There are a dozen or so smaller tables and a bar with seating. Large clear garage doors allow daylight to come in and on warmer days they will open them and add additional outdoor seating. The staff was very friendly. It is a great place to hand out with friends. We had pizza. They have some raw bar selections and some salad selections. The pizza are all 13 inches and thin on the bottom but a nice crust around the side. One of the better crusts I have had in awhile. We ordered a regular cheese, a Phantom pie and The Bruce. The cheese was good. Nice crust, sauce was good and nice blend of cheese. Could use a little more sauce for me but most would like it the way it is. The Phantom has anchovies, garlic and EVOO. It was a little salty because of the anchovy but it was still good. The Bruce was less pizza and more like an appetizer. It had alot of parmesan on it and some clams. I love parmesan so I enjoyed it and the lemon came thru at times for a great taste. I think this pizza is very flexible. Besides the clams I think shredded chicken would be great on it too. I also had a pint of Maritime lager which I really enjoyed. It paired well with the pizzas. Overall it is a great place to hang out and grab something light to eat and wash it down with a couple of beers or wine. It would be a great place to stop on the way back from the beach. We will definitely stop back in. read more

See all

This place is a joke, called placed an order. Hard to find because of poor signage to get there. Arrive only to be told they never started the pizza. The place was dead inside, left without anything. read more

Our new favorite. A group of us try to get together there once a month. Plus I use pick-up. We've explored the innovative pizza menu and never been disappointed (my favorite remains the Lil'Guy). Try it! read more

Amazing , I mean like REALLY REALLY GOOD za! Crust was excellent! Great atmosphere, very open airy (safe) and hip vibe. Yet still cozy. Watch them make the pizza from a cozy booth with pillows and a table shaped like a pizza spatula thingy. Loved the No Worries IPA, salads were delish! Can't wait to come here during a day or night snow storm with all these huge glass walls! Our new favorite neighborhood bar/restaurant! Thank you Magic 5 Pie, we've been waiting for you! read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

See all

First visit was great! Casual atmosphere with Raw Bar, Salads and brick oven pizza. We ordered a specialty cocktail and a craft Pilsner. Both were excellent. Amazing Copps Island Oysters and an unique and excellent Brussels/ Caesar Salad came out quickly. Brick oven pizzas followed and were also great! Overall a great experience. Going back soon for that salad! read more

Love the pizza! Wish they had a better wine selection. Great vibe even in winter! Appreciate they do specials and mix things up.

Phenomenal! Food, atmosphere and service was all deserving of five stars. Our group ordered the Arugula salad, Magic Five and Potato Pie (my personal favorite). We enjoyed everything we ordered & most definitely will be returning. I recommend making a reservation in advance as our waiter said it gets very busy! Cannot wait to go back with friends and family to try more salads & pizzas! read more

Best Pizza in town by far! The chefs of this restaurant really know how to make the PERFECT pizza! My fiancé and I get the Lil Guy and The Bruce every time we come and it's never short of amazing. They are a perfect balance to each other and even our friends and families think so too! A must try place! read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Lil Guy & The Bruce - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

I have been there at least a dozen times. Its food is consistently very good. The young people working there are great; helpful, friendly and you can see how well they all get along. A very friendly energy. Definitely recommend going here. read more

Best pizza I ever had!!! Was in the area with my kids and stopped in for some pizza. We devoured our pies and still dream about this place! Can't wait to come back! read more

Extremely delicious and our new favorite in the city! Tastes just as yummy even on the next day with a quick pop in the oven

Great service and ambience. Menu reasonably priced. The crust was a 10/10. Think the bottom of pie could maybe be thicker as it might prevent some of the pies from feeling soggy. Salad pizza was a miss. Salad on top of cheese pizza. Only places I've seen do salad pizza well seem to skip the cooked cheese and I suspect put the pizza in a fridge to cool it off before adding salad. Margarita was good. Would come back to try once more and try different pies. read more

I was eager to try Magic 5. They hung up on my call before I could even order. I tried calling back but no answer. Pretty rude for a Pizza place when there are plenty of good options in Norwalk. Sorry Magic 5, you lost a customer who orders pie weekly. Those reading this, check out: Romanacci, Crust, Planet Pizza, Classica, 314 Beer Garden and Coals. read more

Came here for dinner after a very disappointing experience at another restaurant, and we were not disappointed. First off the gentlemen who greeted us as we walked in was very friendly, pleasant and fun. He asked us if the table he had was acceptable (it was) and seated us. Service was quick and attentive but now overbearing. The restaurant has what appears ot be a true Italian pizza oven. I am not sure whether it is gas, coal or wood, I didn't look but I can say it makes really good pizza. The only advice I would give is to let the pizza cook a little bit longer as while the outer part of the pie was solid, the inner section pie crust drooped. The sauce, cheese and toppings on both my pie, and my girlfriends pie were excellent and quality. They have a very nice beer, wine and cocktail selection with something for about everyone. The menu has a great selection of classic italian pizzas and some very creative ideas. And of course, you can BYOP (build your own pizza). The only really negative comment I have is that its LOUD. The music there was quite loud and made having a conversation a bit difficult. But even with that, the food and service were so good that it we will be back again. read more

The magic is real. Get here fast. The salads, the pizzas, the drinks, the ambiance, all a home run. Family friendly during the day and big time sexy time at night. Long Live the Magic 5. read more

I ordered pick up from here this week. It was nothing but amazing. I have celiac disease so when I have pizza it has to be gluten free. We called and they perfectly met expectations. I ordered a plain cheese pizza not expecting much from it. But I was wrong it was the best gluten free pizza I've had. This is a new business all the workers were very nice and trying to start a conversation. Please go support them! read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - This was about 10 min after we got the pizza. Still very warm/hot - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

Delicious pizza, comfy atmosphere and a very attentive waiter. We got the Lil guy, potato pizza, margherita and magic five. Each pizza had a perfectly cooked, thin crust pizza that didn't get soggy or fold when you picked it up read more

See all

Just the best. The Servers, managers, and owners are awesome and care about your experience. Love sitting in the booths. Have tried 4 of the pizzas and loved them all. Can't wait to try the rest. Highly recommend. read more

Usually really good but not today. Added chicken to the fig pie and it was a joke. Hair sized strands of dried out pulled chicken that you could hardly see and definitely couldn't be tasted. Plus the fig was less then usually and the crust was burnt. I guess the chef was new on this pie. It was actually horrible. read more

Magic 5 Pie Co. - Pizza Near Me - Norwalk, Connecticut

Just had dinner on a Friday night tonight. We had made reservations early today and there was only outdoor seating for 7pm but heard good things about this place so we decided to go. Seated promptly beautiful space got our drinks fast our salad came out with the drinks but the pizza did take one hour. I will not lie I was getting frustrated BUT it was so damn good they redeemed themselves. We had a cheese pie a pepperoni pie and a garlic and meatball. It was 2 adults 3 kids and we all enjoyed everything. The good part of the wait was the kids ran around while we waited which was nice. Definitely will go back for a date night or at a not peak dinner hour. I really was getting hangry during the wait but the food made up for it. I do suggest they get a bigger oven considering how many take out orders we saw come after we placed our order. Beautiful space for a warm night for dinner out and great drink selection! read more

Great new spot for Norwalk. Good sauce and a surprising crunch for what looked like a Neopolitan style pie.

Had a disappointing experience here tonight. We've been to Magic 5 a number of times, tonight was different. We'd made a reservation and requested a standard table instead, and were seated at a tall bar table. I, the writer of this review and maker of the reservation, am a person barely over 5 feet tall. Bar seats are pretty uncomfortable for me as my short stature leaves my legs dangling through a meal, or struggling to rest on whatever foot bar a bar chair may have. Upon my asking for a standard table I was told there were none. I asked for a booth which looked like it might work better for me, and was told they were for parties of 5 or more, which we were not. I asked if we might be permitted a booth, the man seating us asked his manger for permission to seat us at a booth, and we were denied. We sat at our bar table by the door, and ordered our meal. Throughout the meal the manager and other staff were doing something outside, they kept opening the door to go in and out, leaving it propped open a number of times. It's December in Connecticut, so having an open front door 8 feet away during a meal wasn't ideal. The food as always was great. About half way through our meal we were told a cancellation for a booth had just come in and that the manger had offered us a booth. As we were in the middle of our meal, we said thanks, but declined the offer. The in and out business continued, and there seemed to be some awkwardness, discomfort, maybe frustration between the staff and the manager. It was a strange and unpleasant vibe. I've not experienced this here before, the atmosphere is always friendly, positive, and inviting. I understand running a business, making something go, managing people, can be challenging, but I also think that discomfort should not bleed out, and be felt by the clientele which is what happen at Magic 5 for our table, tonight. read more

This is my second time here, but there won't be a third visit. Everyone loves this place, however, I am totally disappointed. The atmosphere is great, and I love their brussel sprout cesar salad. Both times I ordered the margarita pizza, and both times it was soggy and tasteless. I am not one to complain, especially when dining with others. It seems that Magic 5 Pie needs their magic wand to improve the quality of what they are supposed to be good at. read more

love loveee this place. our waitress was very polite and very attentive. the food was bomb like always! their appetizers never disappoint. favorite dessert was the waffle nachos it was amazing! definitely will return read more

I know the chef personally Carlos Baez and he did an outstanding job with the menu. The Lil guy pepperoni pizza is one of the next pizzas I've had, it's spicy, salty, a little sweet, it's just an explosion of flavor. Amazing menu, the salads are outstanding, specially the Brussels sprout cesar salad which was honestly as best of salad I've had as well. I highly recommend you try this place, drinks also on point!. read more

Loved it! High quality (bar pie sized) Pizza's. Full bar, nice atmosphere...Come on a pleasant evening and sit on the patio. No complaints!

Really great gourmet pizza. Fantastic dough - they got the recipe right. Extremely friendly and professional staff. Super cool spot for dinner and drinks. read more