Stopped into this Little Caesars just trying to get a $6 pizza and ended up in a full on action movie. Just as grabbed my order, this furious dude barges in yelling about how I cut him off in traffic earlier. Before I can even respond, he throws a punch but then out of nowhere the guy behind the counter jumps over it like he's been waiting for this moment his whole life and just beats the living hell out of the guy. The guy ran off and the cashier just dusted himself off. I said "are you ok man" and he looked me dead in the eye and said "B*tch, this is Little Caesars. We always hot and ready." Five stars. Will absolutely return. read more

The parking is tight right in front of the store you may have to park close by. We have many cars here in America but we also have the audacity to think that we can always park right in front of a place. I have come in and I've bought pizza from here probably five or six times now. They do get busy but I always use the mobile app in order ahead, that hasn't let me down. So when I get here I normally don't have long to wait. More people should use the app I believe. But when I do come here my pizza is ready and the majority time I get exactly what I ordered. I believe once I didn't get exactly what I ordered but that happens, it's very easy for me to check it before I walk out and then that would alleviate any complaints that I would have after I get home or later when I finally check. read more

For the price, this location gets 4 stars from me! Fellow behind the counter was pleasant and food prepared to order. Most menu items are a good value, where you get a lot of decent food for the money. The value stops at the sorry chicken wings served. They're small and not meaty, definitely a pass for me next time. Looking forward to going back. read more

Little Caesars - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

See all

It's Little Caesars. You know they use cheap ingredients for their pizzas, hence the affordable (Or once affordable) pricing. You know they're cutting corners, if you know anything about how they're able to sell pizzas at the price that they do. So you're not coming in here expecting the "best pizza of your life". But, it's pizza. It's decent and it's affordable. That's why we go to Little Caesar's. It's hit or miss, so I gave it three stars but when it's on point, it's on point. I usually just order and pick it up from the deploy machine to avoid the lines. I'd use the app, as you can customize if you want things like more sauce, less sauce, more cheese, etc. read more

See all

came here to try for the first time. the people at the counter were very nice and answered my questions quickly without issue. order the batman calzoney, limited time item. i waited 15 minutes, but it was alright since it was being made fresh and i was there ordering the last hour, they were open. the calzone/pizza hybrid was amazing, cheese was hot and melty, had a ton of pepperoni, and generous with Parm cheese throughout and not overly drowned in sauce. for $8 was totally worth it. read more

Little Caesars - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

The pizza was good, and we've ordered from them before. If you pick up, I'd give it 5 stars. But be cautious if you have it delivered! This is why I'm giving 3 stars. They canceled my order, and when I went to check on it, the charge was already taken out of my bank account. When we called Little Caesars, they said to call Door Dash customer support (we called them last night and again today). They also said that their Door Dashers sometimes steal it. They said we should have an email telling us when we should expect to be reimbursed. Never got it. When we called back today, I believe we have it settled but have to wait 10-12 business days to get our money back. They, also, couldn't give us the dashers name, so no review! Disappointed. I'll revise if we get our money back! read more

It was exactly what you would expect from little Caesars. The price is right. The pizza was right the wait time was right everything as expected. read more

This review will be very quick and simple., I was in the mood all day to have pizza and little ceasers was the closet to my house. I will NEVER order from here again. I waited 10 mins for my hot & ready cheese pizza to be done, which was fine considering what I thought was going to be fresh and hot. I also ordered buffalo wings. 10 mins on the dot it was done. Rushed home (5mins away) to find out the pizza not only was it soggy and floppy but it was warm, NOT HOT! I had to microwave the little slice that I decided to try. What a turn off, it was soggy and it wasn't a good crust, nothing about it was pizza and guess what .... it went in the garbage, the wings were ok! Days like today I wish I had Brooklyn pizza! I just should've ordered Domino's. read more

I'm going to stick to my original rating just because their $5 pizza I've realized taste like crap! I did however return at my own risk to try their new "Deep Dish" $8 pizza and I have to say that crap is crazy good! Granted it's not fresh pizza shop good but when you compare their deep dish to that frozen $5 pizza crap they sell you, the deep dish is really good. Ok, I've said crap like 4 times in this review so while technically they sell crap I'd recommend the deep dish crap! LOL! read more

Let's be honest as we share this experience this is Drive by, have a moment of weakness or clarity and make a purchase. Little Caesar's is by no means high culinary food, this isn't high brow, nor expensive or anything that would make you have those ideas but they make good cheap eats. I am a huge fan of the Detroit style Square pies. They cost more than a $5 special but the flavor is so on point. It's great, buttery, crispy square crust goodness! I walked in placed my order and within 10 minutes I was handed my scorching hot pie and cheese bread aka sauceless pizza and into my car I went. It was glorious with each bite and so bad for you. Not something I would recommend for the health conscious but on a day I was in a rare mood there is something just so good about cheap eats that satisfy for under $10 and leave you with leftovers. If you are new to the little Caesar flavor get the square pie and enjoy. Sounds crazy but trust me it's worth the extra cardio at the gym it earns my 5 stars for being cheap, carry out good eats and doing that one thing well. read more

first time ordering here. they made my whole order wrong and, from drink to pizza to bread. I'll never be ordering here again.

Terrible customer service!!! Older guy who was the manager was very disrespectful. Went there to pick up my food that i had placed online. I received a message telling me my food was ready and i also had a confirmation code for my order. My order came out to $51 and change! The manager told me they didnt receive my order so there was nothing he could do. He said his hands were tied. Its has now been a week of me continuously trying to contact anyone who can give me a refund and still nothing. So i never got my food and i still have no got my money back! In words i got robbed! Worst place to ever go to and will also never be returning! read more

We love the pizza from here, you can't beat some the deals and its not too far from the house to make a quick pick up after we call it in or order on-line. I only give it three stars because sometimes when I arrive they are still making the order even if I've called it in 30 minutes before. Also, I've had people pest me for loose change outside of this location but I guess you can have that happen anywhere. It doesn't appear that they have much of a choice in diet soda and I wish they offered more selections. As to the interior I cannot say it is the cleanest but it's also not the worst establishment I've ever been to. All in all its a quick pick up pizza place if you are having a craving for that deep dish, cheesy goodness & cheesy bread. read more

This is the deal to a great LC pizza. Deep Deep Dish, very light on the sauce, extra cheese with pepperoni and well done. Ask them to hit it with grated Parmesan when finished. It's really good read more

Little Caesars - Deep Deep Dish, very light on the sauce, extra cheese with pepperoni and well done. Ask them to hit it with grated Parmesan when finished. - Pizza Near Me - Newburgh, New York

I'm use to really good Pizza. Burger Boys stopped selling pizza so I stopped in here. I should have known, you get what you pay for. $5 for a whole pie and it was sitting in a warming oven. He just took the box out the oven and handed it to me. The pizza was awful. I'll never go back read more

My boyfriend was on FaceTime with me while going into little caesars to get a pizza. After he ordered his pizza he noticed a roach. He asked the worker if that was a roach and she acted nonchalant and said that it was an ant. My boyfriend said nah that's a roach and she told him to kill it. He left the establishment. How disgusting and unprofessional. read more

After submitting I complain to corporate I have still yet to hear back a month later.

The manager/cashier/pizza maker was friendly and efficient. The bacon-wrapped pizza is pretty good but overpriced at $12 since nothing at LC's should ever come close to double digits. As for the wings, you can barely see them. How do they get them to be so tiny? read more

Being from Michigan, Little Caesar's is the favorite pizza for our family and we were ecstatic to see one open so close to us ( prior to us moving to the area, the closest LC was in the Bronx and we could only get our fav pizza when we travelled "home"). My kids go CRAZY over their crazy bread. Italian Cheese bread and Deep Deep Dish Pizza is a fam fav. Hot-n-Ready is great for a cheap quick meal for the family. So excited to see Little Caesars opening in more areas of New York! read more