We very rarely order from here its always a bad experience but We ordered from here tonight for dinner. We got ranch wings and mild buffalo. They were supposed to be well done extra crispy they were not. They were rubbery and cold. My son had a meatball parm on toasted bread he said it was good. We ordered a calzone with meatballs, onions and black olives. There was nothing in it! Zero and I mean zero mozzarella cheese and just a bit of cold ricotta. Toppings were sparse at best! This meal cost a whopping $56.00! I am so tired of paying hard earned money on sub par food and small portions! Never again! read more

During our spontaneous weekend drive to New Hampshire, I decided we gotta try New York style pizza. We just happened to be in Hyde Park getting gas and Joe Cristiano's might be the only place opened on this Sunday. I had a slice of cheese (around $2), my husband had a slice of bbq chicken pizza (around $3), we got a bottle of water ($2!) and a single meatball slider because why not. While the servers were all very nice, the food was very mediocre. Not surprisingly when you order by the slice it is just reheated- which is usually ok when reheated properly. However our slices of pizza were maybe warm (questionably), and while the meatball was hot, the garlic knot that it was placed in was so cold that I questioned if it was refrigerated and just served. The three stars was for the basic qualifications that i have for any diner - the food satisfied my hunger, service was good to decent (and fast), and prices were all reasonable, but nothing outstanding that leaves me desiring more. PS. Google may tell you to go behind the building which is a hair salon, it's located in front of the building! read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

See all

Cold food, VERY small kid portions, and poor customer service. Had my order delivered today, which contained a cold pizza, cold and soggy meatball sliders, and three spaghetti kids meals with the smallest portion of spaghetti I have ever seen. I joined Yelp to write this review after the poor customer service I experienced. I called the restaurant as soon as the delivery person left and was passed along to someone named Atlantic. I explained my issue with the small portions for the kids meals and was told that everything was pre-portioned and he did not offer up an apology or any sort of resolution. I expected a smaller portion when ordering a kids meal, but clearly there was a mistake made with our order. I don't know what ages these kids meals are for (I asked Atlantic and he didn't know either), but in my experience it's usually 8 or 10 and under. All I know is that we cooked a different meal for two of our children, and my three year old ate the combination of the 3 kids meals. read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - Kids pasta exactly as received - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

See all

Zero stars.. just ordered pizza and wings the meat lovers pizza was $15.99 wings said $8.99 for 15 wing .. total cost should have been $ 24.94. When delivered price was $19.00 for 15 wings total came to $44.94.....never again will I order from them price was on there web site.. very unhappy with this business... delivery young man was very professional.. that's the only good thing I can say.. thumbs down.. read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

See all

This is the only pizza my family will eat. It actually tastes like authentic pizza, not mass produced crap like the big chain pizzerias. Not to mention they have an online special of two large pizzas for $27. Can't beat that read more

Great pizza and wings! Sweet thai chilli are the best! The meatball sliders are also great. I order from here all the time fast delivery and acurate orders. read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

10/10 no doubt about it! They make the best pizzas near me! They ooked it perfectly and made the crust even better! They even made their own tea, which is pretty creative! read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - They make some pretty good pizza! I would give this a 10/10 because the pizzas I had were cooked perfectly! - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

So far I have ordered from here a few times and it has yet to let me down. The delivery guy has always been Courteous and nice when they show up. When on the phone making my order the person or person's on the other end have always been nice and helpful. Now to the food. I have enjoyed pretty much everything I have tried her so far, with a few Exceptions. I highly recommend there meatball sliders on garlic knots. read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - Meatball parm. It was delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

See all

Absolutely the best pizza, meatball sliders. All types of pizza and creative combinations. Great staff read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - Garlic chicken and Buffalo chicken pizza. Great! - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

If I could give no stars at all I would. I ordered 14 meatball sliders and one order fries for delivery was told 30-35 minutes an HOUR later I call and ask what's taking so long and they said the driver had left already and was on the way. 20 minutes later I call again to see where the driver is and to say I'm not paying full price (they made my $25 bill $22.63) he finally gets here as I hung up (I live 5 minutes down the road) and our food is disgustingly cold the garlic knots the for the sliders taste old and are hard the meatballs were like they were straight out of the fridge and not warmed just all together horrible. I will never get food from this location again. read more

Dear Joe Cristiano's, When you severely burn a chicken cutlet, make a new one. I'll wait. Don't bury it under sauce and pasta and hope I don't notice it. You can't just shove your more embarrassing trash to the bottom of the garbage can and act like it never existed. We know you had that weird porno. Did you think I'd never make it down to the actual chicken part of the "chicken parm"? While the chicken parm special was inedible because of how severely burnt it was (and unfortunately, we were too hungry to make the 10-minute drive back to the restaurant), it also incorporated this bizarrely glue-y sauce The whole thing felt like it was not fresh at all - something reheated from someone else's abandoned meal. The manacotti was just fine, and also had a completely different, less terrifying sauce. So, it was a 50/50 experience. And if you're an Italian food place, make sure you stock some linguine! read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - Chicken parm, cooked to ash. - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

Once again we are let down by the little details. The food is always great but if we get sauce on the side, there's no sauce. Want your chicken parm on garlic bread? Forgotten. The food is great if they get the order right. Update: they did not have onion rings but substituted curly fries for them. We were still charged for the onion rings even though the curly fries are cheaper. read more

Had lunch there on several occasions staff is friendly and they have a great selection of slices ready to go.

Love this place, love the desserts, staff is so accommodating and polite. try their flourless chocolate cake!!! To die for!!

I don't usually come up to Hyde park so I had no idea where to go. Took a shot at this small pizza place and i was not disappointed. Such good pizza! Nice thin crust, flavorful sauce and cheese, and every bite has a nice crunch. If I'm back in the area, this will definitely be my go to place. read more

Wonderful staff, super friendly. Great selection of slices and very reasonably priced. We go there quite a lot, always happy with it. We get the salads and slices. The Sicilian, buffalo chicken pizza. Everyone likes something different and there's always enough variety to keep the whole family happy. Garlic knots are good too. read more

Ordered a veggie gluten free pizza and it came with breaded eggplant on it. Doesn't say anything abt the eggplant being breaded on the website. Don't have to know much abt gluten free diets to get that we can't eat bread, duh. Not happy. Called them and they didn't even offer to make a new one or apologize for the oversight. Just said, "Yea, guess you've gotta order it without the eggplant." -____- UPDATE: They called back the next day and offered a refund/credit for the mistake. Thanks, guys. ;) read more

We love your Pizza order from there all the time about to order from them now lol The garlic knot meatball sliders are amazing!!!

First time ordering from them tonight (salt point location) I was told it would be 45-50 min for a pizza. After an hour and 15 minutes went by I called, and the man who answered the phone told me that my pizza was "just getting ready to come out of the oven and then his driver would be leaving". When I explained to him that I had already been waiting a long time, he cut me off and said "bye". So, never had them and now I never will. Awful customer service. read more

We love this place!!!!! We live in pleasant valley & they would deliver to us for FREE I don't know any pizza shops that do this. The pizza is delicious & I'm from the Bronx & I haven't found any place close well I have now. Also if you fold your slice it stands straight out not soggy no matter what's on your pie. We have had there wings, garlic knots, meatball sliders & chicken cutlet parmesan dinner the pasta was perfect everything is SO delicious . You can tell everything is fresh homemade. I'm Italian & really picky with Italian food & pizza I could eat here every day. They have a customer for a long time coming. Thank you for good food & quality. read more

I have stopped here many times to grab a bite/slice. Food is OK. Good basic strip mall Italian fare. However, when I stopped by yesterday to pick up a couple of slices, not one of the three people behind the counter were wearing a mask. So wrong at this point in our time. Wear a mask for the protection of your customers! Won't be going back there again. read more

I called ahead to see if they would deliver where I am and they do. I also asked if their sauce was vegetarian they said it is. And the delivery was quite quick however, most of my cheese has fallen off of my pizza. Now every slice I pull doesn't have cheese. I'd call and ask for a redo, but I don't have that kind of time, plus I'm so hungry. Like I said, it tastes good. Just wish my slices had cheese on them. read more

Joe Cristiano's Pizza - Fast delivery , but maybe a little too fast? - Pizza Near Me - Poughkeepsie, New York

The food here is excellent, the employees are courteous and they go out of their way to make the food exactly how you want it. I don't go to any other pizza place in the area ever since I found Joe Cristiano's - and the delivery guy in his mid-30s is damn sexy! I strongly recommend this place. read more

We've ordered the Pizza Margherita & the Sicilian Pizza and they are delicious! Will definitely order these pizzas again and also try other items on their menu! read more

I talked to a really nice guy on the phone. He answered every question I had and was patent with my indecisiveness. He delivered my food to my school even tho it was under the required delivery fee. They forgot the chicken on my pizza but it was still delicious. Will defiantly be ordering again. read more

Sorry to say I didn't have a good expierence with Christian o's! First they said they don't make stromboli's! Really! So ordered calazone with 2 kinds of meat, onions,peppers. And when the delivery guy came he fogot the 2 lt of soda! And asked him if he could bring it back he replied "theres no more deliveries on the board coming this way" really! Oh ok so now I paid $2.50 for soda I didnt get but he still took his tip! And to top it sll off the calazone Didn't have any cheese in it and the onions were Raw!!! Sorry yo say that was my last order!! read more

I can honestly say that they have been consistent with their product. I highly enjoy their different variety of Wings flavors,and pizza. If you're in the area and want a quick bite,I suggest this place. read more

Stopped in for a cheese pie. Pretty impressed. Very tasty. I'll definitely come back when I'm in the area.

Joe Cristiano's on Salt Point Turnpike is the best pizza place in the area. The pizza is great, mozzarella sticks, fries, calzones. Lots of options for a vegetarian such as myself, but I must admit the pepperoni pizza smells amazing, as do most of the other foods with meat. Josh is a talented pizza maker and he makes the pizza exactly how you like it. Check this place out, it's amazing. read more

Have ordered from this salt point location several times and in the past has always been good or at least decent. Tonight we had a terrible experience. The sauce was completely different, what's usually a light tasting and (probably) homemade sauce as written on their menus was a dark lumpy fake processed sauce that ruined our pizza and everything else it was on. Why the change, I don't know but it was gross and the pizza was undercooked and mushy. I'm not sure if we are going to try again at some point but are so disappointed in what use to be our go to pizza place. read more

This is the best pizza place in the area by far. I love pizza, so I've gone to pretty much all the pizza places locally, and I have to say this is the best, with Gino's being second. The make an excellent white pizza. A lot of places tend not to season the white pizza, but being it has no sauce that already has seasonings, you really need to season it or it's bland, which they do. The cannoli's there are also really awesome, surprisingly good for a pizza place. they taste like they're from a bakery or something. They also have a gluten free pizza, so when my friend is over that doesn't eat delicious, delicious gluten, that is convenient. I would suggest Taking advantage of the coupons they have online, they save you a good amount of money. And the staff is always friendly about taking a coupon or when I order a special, unlike some places (not sure why some places put out coupons then get annoyed when you use them). They're also very accurate with the time frame when I call. I don't get told then minutes and then up waiting at the restaurant or for the delivery driver for another twenty minutes because the time frame was wrong. the drivers are always courteous. One of them, I asked for his name and he said "Bryan," was overly nice and accommodating, and I had a large, annoying order. He thanked me for the tip, something you don't always see (thank you doesn't cost anything, but some people act like it does). He went out of his way, but every driver from there has been nice. And their slices always taste fresh.. I'd bet they get made there every day, rather than reheated after the fact. So basically this place does a lot of the things most upstate New York places fail to do. In the city it isn't hard to get good pizza, but up here it can be. This is probably the closest you're going to get to real New York pizza around here. No complaints! read more

I ordered for the first time on Saturday night at 6:47, easy order of one pizza, garlic knots and mozzarella sticks, the guy told me it would take about an hour. That was fine because I've only heard good things about Joe Cristiano's Pizza. I finally got my pizza at 8:37, almost two hours later, all my food cold and they forgot the mozzarella sticks. I call the store and a girl answers and I told her they forgot my mozzarella sticks and she asks with a rude one if I'm sure I ordered them and told me to look at my receipt, I did order and pay for them. She then tells me 25 minutes and hangs up. No apology for leaving them out or that all my food is cold. 40 minutes later I finally got the mozzarella sticks. This is the worst service I've ever had and I hope no one else has to deal with this and I will never order from this place again. read more

This is for Salt Point Turnpike location. They have the best pizza's in town. We ordered a "meat lover's" and a "veggie delight" pizza and they were absolutely amazing. The price is good and place is very clean read more