I forgot how much I love Italia Pizza. Anybody who knows me knows that I love eggplant on my pizza and this is where Italia excels. It's simply out of this world. The eggplant is breaded to perfection, cheese is plentiful and high-quality and sauce has a slight sweetness to it. Crust is crispy on the outside has what I believe are sesame seeds all around the edges which just adds to the gloriousness of this pizza. What we tried for the first time tonight was the margarita pizza pie, half meatball and half eggplant. Simply amazing. read more

See all

Mediocre pizza. Had high hopes. Smelled amazing didn't taste as good. Rename it Pizza Mexicana I didn't see a single Italian working here.

Alot of variety of pizza calzone and food Great tasting pizza . I like the sauce and mozzarella pizza is my favorite , great crust too. Been having pizza here for years . Family friendly, seating available indoors . Street parking Fast serving food Makes delivery too read more

See all

Amazing local pizzeria that serves classic new york style thin crust pizza. I come here often and they just do something differently with their crust and it is delicious. They have online ordering but I usually just order over the phone since it saves on service fees on some of the ordering platforms. In addition to pizza they have classic pizzeria sides like garlic knots,pasta, and mozzarella sticks. They have a few indoor tables and their service is always done with a smile. read more

Italia Pizza - Large cheese pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I swear this place also doubles as my local pharmacy. If you're ever cold or feeling under the weather. You have to get their homemade chicken noodle soup! I've been getting it since grade school and it still slaps! I don't know what their secret ingredient is but it's hand down the best chicken noodle soup I've ever had. Kind of scared of posting this review. Cause if my mom ever stumbles on reading this she might kick my ass. read more

The good - The white slice was perfect! The bad - regular slice was horrible. Way too saucy and wayyyyyy undercooked. I asked the counter guy for a fresh slice because the ones in the display honestly looked old and dry. He pulls a slice from underneath that didn't look any better. The cheese was barely melted. Horrible slice. Took just one bite and threw the other regular slice out. The great - easily the best sausage roll I ever had! Plenty of sausage inside with onions. The crust was award winning! Service - so so. Ambiance - typical Brooklyn pizza joint look and feel. read more

Best pizza place! Been ordering from them for years. The staff is very helpful. Excellent highly recommend. read more

Italia Pizza - Large pie extra cheese OMG ITS DELICIOUS - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great pizza consistently good. I still stop in to grab slices and occasionally order pies. Their plain slices are phenomenal and borderline addictive. Thanks Italia read more

See all

Came in ready to spend money, but clearly walked into the middle of a romantic drama. The main salesperson has found their soulmate -- and together, they've reached a level of connection so deep that customers no longer exist in their world. I was completely ignored. Left empty-handed. The business lost money. But hey, who needs sales when you've got true love? Let the merchandise gather dust -- romance is clearly the new business model. read more

Ordered a half pepperoni half mushroom medium size pizza to go. Love the thin crust! It was around $20 for the pie. My go to pizzeria in the neighborhood. read more

Italia Pizza - Half pepperoni Half mushroom medium size pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The menu costs reflect food that's actually worth it. Fresh dishes at standard market prices. Every person there was receptive to our needs and performed wonderfully. Their plating is as good as their cooking. I discovered this impressive place via review sites. read more

Got a cheese pizza to go. It was Great pizza everyone enjoyed it very much. Best if you eat it very hot read more

Italia Pizza - a hand holding a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Good food very flavorful delicious fresh very tasty very satisfying my fifth time coming here but first time alone i definitely would recommend this place to all my friends and fellow yelpers as well read more

Italia Pizza - Chicken parmigiana hero with french fries with ketchup and hot sauce on top - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My go-to local pizzeria. I've been brought up on this my entire life. 10/10 would recommend but not anymore. I'm gonna tell you how the food is but ALSO the service. I always just get the plain large pie. The chocolate mousse is so smooth, it almost tasted like ice cream cake. The potato croquette was actually better than potato croquettes from a higher end restaraunt like Koku Ramen. The outside was breaded and obviously tasted like the outside of a mozzarella stick. The inside was not plain potato flavor, it had bits of a veggie piece inside to make it more flavorful. Spot on margarita pizza. It's hard to find good margarita pizzas in the local area. Delivery service: 0. My dog was barking at the delivery man and I checked the camera afterwards. The delivery man THREATENS MY DOG AND THEN dead picked up some soil from my plants and threw it in my dog's direction. Wtf???? I love some great food and all but that wasn't it. And how SANITARY is it to pick up some soil, throw it, then continue to touch the pizza box afterwards esp DURING A WHOLE PANDEMIC. Come on now... Anyways, that's why a perfect 5 went down to a 3. I made a complaint to the restaraunt and there was no disciplinary action to the deliveryman. Another staff apologized in that delivery man's place. read more

Italia Pizza - Chocolate Mousse - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

horrible customer service definitely overpriced compare to every other place. food quality not what you see it is. Definitely don't recommend this place at all if your looking for good pizza. read more

Eating pizza from this place every week; my favorite is pepperoni New York-style style pizza.

We visited Italia Pizza on Kings Highway on a chilly afternoon in January 2024. It was one of those days where the cold goes through you. I ordered a bowl of pasta fazool to warm me up. Sitting in a booth in fixed distance to a formica covered table I was brought a bowl described by the staff as pasta fagioli. Who is to argue? It was amazing. The soup was scalding hot and accompanied by a basket of bread and butter. It hit the spot. We also ordered an arancino (singular, rice ball) and 2 slices of eggplant pizza. Fantastic! The place had a lot of take-away business but might have seen more in-store dining if they advertised their heart-warming soups. A lovely find on Kings Highway. read more

See all

I ordered beef patty, chicken pizza and a tomato slice. I asked to add cheese to the beef patty and they forgot even though they charged me. It was too late to go back. The chicken slice was bad. The chicken pieces were very dry and the tomato slice was subpar and flavorless. Very disappointed. I still like their plain slices though and I thought I should try something new. read more

See all

Ok I've come to realize that pizzerias serve hella delicious desserts and Italia Pizza is no different. Their chocolate mousse cake is out of this world. I'm not lying when I say I'm not a huge chocolate fan, but their chocolate mousse cake just kept me going. It's so fricken creamy... almost like an ice cream cake! read more

Italia Pizza - Chicken Roll - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This is not the same italia pizza I used to know who served delicious thin crust pizza, last 2 orders I got was some over cheesed sloppy greasy pizza. It's a shame such a good pizza place goes downhill that fast. I would not recommend this place anymore..owners or cooks must've changed read more

The best chicken rolls and regular slices in the world. The place is clean and the owners are always there. Good prices and very friendly. read more

This restaurant has been around for 40 years for good reason. We had Brooklyn pizza, at its best. Our pizza had a good blend of oil, cheese, sauce and a nice char because we ordered it well done and it came to us perfectly. An 18 inch pizza was only $14. The crust had a good taste. The cheese stayed on the slice, as it should. Sauce had a good taste. There was no air conditioning. The day was mild but it was a little stuffy inside. The location is convenient on a busy corner. This place has been added to our list of pizzerias that we will visit on a regular basis. read more

Years ago, my family said this place had some really good pizza. I recall I didn't care for it and that was that. Fast forward years later, I decided to give the place another chance because quite frankly, I do not remember how good/bad was the food so I ordered a pie: half plain, half sausage. Boy, was it a letdown. First off, they were skimpy on the sausage, as in they had enough to spread around for 1.5 slices of pizza and used that amount for half a pizza pie. Secondly, the pizza was floppy; I'm not a fan of burnt pizza but holy cow, this pizza had no hold and the cheese will slide off your slice if you don't fold it. And finally, there's cornmeal dusted all under the pizza and along the crust, which is a nice crunch for some, but a turnoff for me; I don't need the texture and taste of cornmeal in my pizza. Bonus what the hell moment: menu said a large round would be $15 but the pie came up to be $19; there's no indication of how much is for topping but $4 more for half a pie's scarcely there sausage is by no means worth the extra $4. Nope, this place is a big nope for me. I have better places for pizza around the area so the pie from today is just a lesson that if I do not remember it being good, then don't bother. read more

Great pizza, delicious sandwiches. Rice balls are great. Love the zeppoles and calzones.

This pizza was our go to. Our birthday pizza. Our weekend pizza. Growing up in bklyn and now 35 this was our pizza as kids and now its my husbands and I pizza. The best pizza, incredible crust, ideal service, respect and kindness. Until last night when their delivery man harassed me because he wanted cash tip instead of a THIRTY PERCENT tip on app. This was terrible and frightening. Please get back to me Italia so we dont have to push this further. read more

Review #434 None Elite Squad Awesome! Fantastic! Authentic! Classic! Delicious! Fresh! Highly Recommend! I can't find better words to describe how great this place is. The pizza was Amazing! Out of the Oven..cheesy, saucy ..truly New York Pizza at its finest. The Calzone was delicious..i would like to have had the Marinara little thicker but it was delicious. Family owned ..great atmosphere .. a must go to if you want Delicious Pie ..5 stars all the way read more

Italia Pizza - Just walked in.. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I have dined in or placed an order for delivery, always piping hot & fresh. Clean restaurant that takes pride in their menu. Grandma pizza is one of the best I ever had, Chicken Marsala to die for & nice portions. Chicken parm hero awesome...real semolina style crust on their pizza. Owner is a charming guy too. Order today food is delish!!!! read more

I loved the pizza it was really good really nice and fresh and I rate the pizza 10.99

Yum!! One of my favorite cheese pies in the area. Can't go wrong with Italia whenever I am in the area. The crust is nice and thin, not overbearing and has a nice sprinkle of garlic salt! read more

Italia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great pizza, the crust is always awesome and crunchy and the sauce is also flavorful. I usually get the plain slice or margherita slice. The one thing that I noticed which threw me off and where they lost two stars is that while handling pizza, the workers behind the counter also handle money. They did not switch their gloves. Witnessed one worker handle money and then go on to use his bare hands to pluck basil leaves and put it on a pizza pie for delivery. read more

Italia Pizza is the reason why I love pizza now! I mean, I always did but never craved for it as much as I do now. My boyfriend and I always order a vodka pie, and honestly it's probably more worth it than just getting it by the slice. Definitely fresher. My friend who lives in the neighborhood told me Italia Pizza is either a hit or miss but it's always been a hit for me! The workers there are super nice as well. I remember one time I came in and really wanted the garlic bread but the girl in the front told me it comes by the loaf only so I settled for the knots. She must've seen how much I really wanted the bread so she ended up cutting it for me.. super sweet! read more

Great pizza and chicken parmigiana!! Nice friendly staff! Always a repeat on my dial. read more

A neighborhood pizzeria that has very good Italian food and pizza. Love their pizza, calzone, chicken parmigiana, eggplant parmigiana and baked ziti. Their sauce is fabulous. Their delivery guys are friendly and deliver food carefully. If you want eat in, there are tables inside to sit or you can sit outside in their covered area. The staff is wonderful and react quickly to help you. The management is responsive and intelligently runs their business. read more

In a town where pizzerias are abundant, finding a good slice is not hard. So what does it take to stand out in Bensonhurst? Fresh, high quality ingredients! Now, we all know that don't come cheap. If you want cheap, move on to the next pizzeria that only non-Italians go to. If you want pizza done right, you go to Italia pizza! Try the old fashioned Sicilian! Light plum tomato sauce (not gravy people!), topped with FRESH real mozzarella and tomatoes! Add some fresh basil & you got yourself an authentic slice of pizza- Light, crispy with only a bit of a chew. Perfetto!! read more

Italia Pizza - Fresh Sicilian pie. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I got the round pie, is that not the order? It wasn't bad at all but that doesn't cut it in this part of Brooklyn. Grandma looks good?

Pizza's reaaaallly goood!! The servers were great too! Very accommodating! Will definitely come back!

Been ordering from this place for a little while now. Whether it's pizza, sandwiches, salads or entrees the food is always amazing and I'm a very picky eater. One of the best pizza restaurants all around! read more

Hands down the best pizza in the area. We come here every other week for a whole pie and Greek salad. Easy peasy lemon squeezy dinner.

I haven't been here in a while, but I always came here when I was in high school. The slices are always delicious and reasonably priced. The staff is nice (and not in-your-face). You could order first, eat as many slices as you care, sit with a friend for hours, and then just pay before you leave. I don't know many places that trust their customers like that anymore. This is such a great example of how Brooklyn pizzerias are and should be - no frills, just great pizza. I miss this place now that I've moved out of Brooklyn, but I definitely try to come here whenever I come home. read more

Overall good standard pizza. I think the crust is dusted with cornmeal - which is a bit unique. There are a number of pizza spot in the neighborhood - this one is one of the top ones and recommend if you're looking to satisfy your pizza craving. read more

Italia Pizza - two pizzas in a box - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York