Nonno's makes a handful of great slices. I'm pretty picky pizza eater now that I live in the best city in the world for 'za, but their square slices are incredible; the marinara and grandma pies always hit the spot; eggplant parm and mushroom are also both delicious, always with fresh veg and flavorful tomatoes. Their triangle slices can be hit or miss (usually rubbery mozzarella and less sauce than I'd like), but I think this might have something to do with freshness of the slices. As for their Sicilian pie, it leans toward thick and doughy, rather than crisp and light, which I prefer. I enjoy interacting with the owner(s) and the workers who are always kind and an integral part of my Bay Ridge Neighborhood Experience. As someone who prefers takeout to dine in, I also appreciate that they have an order window so I don't always have to come inside to get my food! read more

Interesting take on the NY slice. The shop looks like any typical fast-paced pizzeria and is ready to serve a hot slice. The regular slice and pepperoni and sausage was served with some sort of cornmeal or thick semolina in the crust and undercarriage of the pizza. I would assume that all their pizza is made this way. This definitely adds a particular crunch to each bite, but I can also see some people not being a fan of this. The pizza sauce is great in that it has the right amount of sweetness. The pizza has zero flop, which is my style. I usually make a run at all the good local pizzerias in Bay Ridge. Nonno's is definitely my 3rd stop. read more

Nonno's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Very good pizza always fresh, staff is friendly! The pizzeria is always clean and welcoming they take care of their appearance unlike a lot of places!!! read more

Terrible service. Cashier/ server was rude and unwelcoming. Pizza was a little better than ok. I will not be back. read more

See all

On grubhub they claim that they offer twelve inch gluten free pizzas. I spent close to thirty dollars. I received a ten inch ice cold pizza and I waited forty five minutes to almost an hour.... It's very disappointing. I will never order from them again. read more

I got the ordered through the (to good to go )app, I got 4 slices of good pizza! All the pizza had toppings, there not hot but there are edible to eat ! You ordered at the counter and one of the workers will get your pizza for you! It was closing down for the night so I had to go home to eat dinner.. it's not bad pizza read more

See all

I love this place! My go to place to order from for movie nights. The pizza is just so delicious and I think the price is very reasonable. The pies have my personally perfect ratio for a good bite of chewy cheese, tomato sauce, and soft dough, while the crust is always the right amount of crunch. I've also ordered salad from here and it was good! read more

Excellent NY pizza. The sauce on the pizza is absolutely delicious. It has a sweet touch to it and it makes their pizza one of the best I've had in all of NYC. The crust is quite soft and it's so good. Anyone who wants a scrumptious authentic NY pizza should come here. Nonno's truly has one of the top pizzas in all of NYC. Truly amazing pizza!!! read more

This place used to be our go to. They used to have reliable service and great food. Unfortunately the service has gone downhill. I don't know if they are under new management, or just have someone new in the kitchen but my order is never right anymore and it takes significantly longer to get. read more

I mean, it's Nonno's! Of course it's great. When I'm in the neighborhood, i can always count on them to make my slices the way I like and the garlic knots?! The best in bayridge. Sorry I don't have a picture, I always devour right away but take my word. The grandma slice with the green sauce & the garlic knots (get some marinara on the side) Thank me later ;) read more

My Togo place for pizza. The best. Always order grandma pizza always perfect always on time.

The best crust I've had! The cheese is stringy, gooey and the ingredients taste amazing. My kids enjoyed the pizza from here so much, they asked for pizza for breakfast the next morning. We've yet to dine in, but we live close by and my husband always orders for takeout. Pizza always comes fresh and hot. read more

What an Outstanding Pizza I had at Nonno's!! Ordered 1st time from Nonno's, and it surely won't be the last! We had the Margarita, a thin crispy crust round pie w/sauce, fresh mozzarella, and added mushrooms and bacon on it. The mushrooms were sautéed with bacon!! Such additional flavor! The semolina is evident of a well made pie! We did not go to the restaurant, but we will! We had the pie delivered (thru the Slice app), which came in a timely manner, still nice and warm despite the frigid temperatures we're experiencing. read more

Fantastic! Highly recommend. I will be back. If i could give 4 1/2 i would, almost a 5. And i am a tough grader and usually go by the Bar Stool 1-10 bell curve where super premium slices are a 7-8 and a decent edible football pizza is a 5-6. I only gave Nonno's a 4.5 because the regular Sicilian was very good, but not great, no wow factor. Dont get me wrong it was very good but not a super premium top tier Square. I also had a vodka with fresh mozzarella regular style slice. This slice was near perfect, if not perfect. To start, the thin crust was uniform, perfectly crispy and chewy throughout with a uniform light caramel color and corn flower dusting. The end crust was properly dimensioned, crusty-crunchy outside and a consistent slightly chewy and warm interior. Perfect. Also the dough itself was obviously a store made proprietary recipe. Commercial purveyor supplied dough is only appropriate for football pizza. You wont find commercially supplied reddy made pizza dough at this place. The vodka sauce was robust and flavorful. The sauce had a buttery olive oil undertone with a fresh basil and quality parmigiana finish. The slice was topped w fresh mozzarella slices of just the right thickness covering most of the slice. This speciality slice is premium pizza. A yelp 5 plus, off the scale. The other slice i tried was a zucchini bacon Sicilian slice. The zucchini was thinly sliced and generously covering the whole square. The bacon was not overpowering but quite flavorful and not overcooked. The crust was airy, light, and crunchy. A great speciality slice. Both specialty slices were assembled with care using high quality hand made components. The typical pizza shop specality slice consists of some type of pre made or supplied toppings thrown on top of doctored commercial sauce set upon bland mass produced purveyor supplied pizza dough. The toppings are usually an after thought. At Nonno's, the specialty slices are artisan created Assemblies of high quality home made and selected ingredients. This is the place for speciality slices. Next time, i will go back and try a regular. Because the true measure of a NY pizza shop is the regular slice. Only a select few get measured by their speciality slice. For instance Rosa's in Queens and the famous L&B Spumoni Gardens. Oh, the owner, i had the pleasure of meeting a young gentleman at Nino's who said he was the owner. He openly engaged me in casual and pizza conversation and was polite and professional. It is obvious that he takes pride in his product and is proud to serve his customers. He seems to have s strong sense of community and puts forth great efforts in his high quality product. read more

Nonno's Pizza - Vodka with fresh mozzarella regular slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Chicken noodle soup!!! LEGENDARY... it's like he squeezes an entire bird into each serving. If you aren't feeling well and need a pick-me-up or if you just have a hankering for some damn good soup (or anything here on the menu tbh)this is where you need to go...It is truly Unmatched!!!! read more

It's Bay Ridge and there's a pizza spot practically every block. But Nonno's is a standout. Right amount of toppings. Good balance of cheese, sauce, and bread. The crust in particular is excellent if you like it a little thinner/crispier. And the staff was friendly. read more

Fabulous pizza! I tried the mozzarella with basil, the sauce and crust were perfect. Nice atmosphere, a bit of wait time, but it's a very busy place. read more

There are 2 brick oven pizza. This place is the best. Try their grandma slice super garlic and crunchy and their margarita if you want more of a mArinara sauce. The other place is not real brick oven pizza (you know the black mark you get with burned bread. You don't get that at another spot nearby. read more

Nonno's Pizza - Margarita Pizza and Grandma Pizza by the Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have been coming here since the day they opened. The prior pizzeria was not successful and the owner Tony and his family came in and redid the place over completely. In my opinion it's one of the best pizzeria's in the neighborhood. They have brick oven pizza and plenty of other dishes to choose from. I have not had a bad dish ever. The employees work very well together right down to their delivery people. It's nice when businesses remember your name and you get to know them on more of a personal level. A great sign of a business is to see the owner present. Tony who is young is there most of the time and works hard behind the counter. Gabe who I believe has been with Tony since the beginning is very loyal and represents the business well. There are only two spots in Bayridge I go to for pizza and Nonos is one of them. The restaurant is clean, has great food, extremely fair prices, and has fantastic customer service. I would highly recommend them 1/5/2019 Stopped in for some home made soup and grilled chicken and vegetables. Everything is very, very fresh! The owner Tony and is staff are great and personally take care of their customers. It's not often you see the owner working behind the counter the way Tony does. read more

See all

This a good slice with sweet tomato sauce (onions?) and thin crunchy almost fried crust. People at the counter pretty indifferent. read more

Great food and prices! One of the best if not the best tasting pizza in Brooklyn. It's the pepperoni for me :) read more

Arugula pizza. It is unlike anything I've had anywhere. One taste, you will be a believer as well. It is not something I'd EVER even think of ordering. Friends ordered it, and I'm a disciple now. Try it. Arugula Pizza. read more

Nonno's Pizza - Arugula Prosciutto & Parmesan Cheese pie.. Simply amazing. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Used to be better pizza. Pizza so so at best . People not very nice or friendly . I speak Spanish So I am ok in there . Bay Ridge tough to find great pizza . Great location , But that's it . Desafortunadamente People don't care about service like they used to . read more

I love this neighborhood pizza place. It has been my family's savior during quarantine. Not only is it around the corner, delicious and fast. Customer service at the store is friendly and helpful. Extra sauce? "You got it! " Free pizza slicer for my pie? "You got it!" Large pie with Two slices without cheese - can you put the cheese from the two slices in a separate cup?? "You got it!" read more

Pizza fantasticico! The best vegetarian pizza I have ever eaten! Speedy friendly service. We'll be back!! read more

Exceptional Thin Crust, combined with the freshest ingredients!!!! Heats well the next day, not soggy and still the same crispness and fresh flavor!!! read more

Delivery is fast and always on point. Pizza and sandwiches are good. I like anything on the focaccia and the margherita with sausage is really tasty read more

pizza is great here , they are always so fresh . kitchen food is even better I love the variety they give on the menu, great guys and always down to chat with customers read more

With Covid driving people mad, sometimes delivery is the answer, other times learning to cook does one better. There are times something in the middle works out best. I've ordered pizzas from here and they've been a solid pick. The way their crusts are done it's just special. But we've also ordered just the dough from this place for cheap and was able to make our own concoctions. So if you want to change things up at home but don't want to make your own pizza dough, they've been good about hooking us up! read more

Amazing pizza. We had a piece of regular pizza, loved the dough, real brick oven. And the price is $2.75 per slice read more

Nonno's Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

one of the best slices we've had, their crust is so good, just different, it has a garlic crispy crunch, sauce and cheese were perfect

Best pizza in Bay Ridge. Their pies are huge and always FULL of cheese. A large pie is $14- you can't beat that. We always ask for sesame seeds on the crust- it's freaking heaven. Side note- Their buffalo chicken pizza is also amazing, they do not skimp on the chicken. Great pizza. read more

Nonno's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The zucchini and bacon square is the best concoction I have tasted on pizza! I really enjoy picking a slice up from here. The service is great and the tables are clean to eat on. read more

best pizza bar none. don't be a clueless foodie lemming that stands in line at Di Faras on ave J 45 minutes just to eat a burnt sorry excuse of a once great slice and pay $5. been there done that, fooled me once! Try the eggplant grandma and become woke! Krispy's pizza on 13th also exceptional but they've lost their way through the years imo. Nonno's is sparkling clean so no worries about food prep contamination. yes, the are customers that look for any issues and indicators of sloppy work. I will happily be a patron for a long time. highly recommended!!! read more

Great pizza, awesome staff! Their pizza has a buttery crispy crust that I haven't tasted any where else!

Long overdue revised review here. I ordered on Slice to save the pizza(ria) and give them a bigger portion of the profits. Help out the little guy... Yada-Yada. Well you know what? Don't! They prep your food better when you order on seamless /Grubhub because they fear the negative review. But when you order from Slice, they clearly can give a rat's ass and failed on getting my order correct 3x. That's right, 0-3 or a.000 batting average. Can you not read directions? They ignored the toppings despite me already paying for them. WTF? Its like seriously, I tried to help... but you guys don't deserve it. read more

Love this place. Food is great. Fresh and tasty. The men working there are sweet. Try the eggplant parm, chicken parm., meatballs, pasta, salad with grilled chicken or shrimp. read more

Very good pizza, sauce is perfect and the crust in crispy. Fast delivery as well! Excellent choice for pizza in NYC! read more

There's no pizza on earth quite like NYC pizza. Nonno's in Brooklyn delivered exactly what I was craving. We chose them over places nearby so my gluten free partner-in-crime could partake. Sadly, he didn't love his GF pizza. I tried a bite and thought the crust tasted like chicken pot pie crust... not a bad thing, but not what you'd expect with pizza. Thankfully, my slices warrant five stars. I loved every bite of the cheese, and margherita. The guys at the counter were very friendly, and fast! I would love to eat at Nonno's more often, but sadly, I have to wait till my next trip up north. read more

Nonno's Pizza - Margherita and Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I love this place for pasta and individual slices and decided to order a square pie for my friends. Square pies that are 16 dollars are usually the size of the whole box around here so I didn't think anything of the price. I got 8 slices, that didn't fill the entire box. The pizza was very good but for the amount of money I paid, I expected the box to be full. I'm honestly not sure if it's supposed to be so small but I'm not taking my chances with the square pie again unfortunately. read more

Nonno's Pizza - Square pie with 1/2 pepperoni ($18) really good but felt it was missing slices for the price. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York